Kathāvatthu 1.9: Satipaṭṭhānakathā
Kathāvatthu 1.9
- Language
- Pāli
Contents
- 1.9.1 — 4 parts
- 1.9.2 — 32 parts
- 1.9.3 — 11 parts
- 1.9.4 — 15 parts
- 1.9.5 — 7 parts
- 1.9.6 — 4 parts
- 1.9.7 — 7 parts
- 1.9.8 — 5 parts
- 1.9.9 — 9 parts
- 1.9.10 — 8 parts
- 1.9.11 — 11 parts
- 1.9.12 — 17 parts
Satipaṭṭhānakathā
1.9.1.1
Sabbe dhammā satipaṭṭhānāti?
Are all phenomena establishments of mindfulness?
Theravādin: Do all cognizable things constitute applications in mindfulness?
1.9.1.2
Āmantā.
Yes.
Andhaka: Yes.
1.9.1.3
Sabbe dhammā sati satindriyaṃ satibalaṃ sammāsati satisambojjhaṅgo ekāyanamaggo khayagāmī bodhagāmī apacayagāmī anāsavā asaṃyojaniyā aganthaniyā anoghaniyā ayoganiyā anīvaraṇiyā aparāmaṭṭhā anupādāniyā asaṅkilesikā, sabbe dhammā buddhānussati dhammānussati saṅghānussati sīlānussati cāgānussati devatānussati ānāpānassati maraṇānussati kāyagatāsati upasamānussatīti?
Are all phenomena mindfulness, the faculty of mindfulness, the power of mindfulness, right mindfulness, the awakening factor of mindfulness, the one-way path, leading to destruction, leading to awakening, leading to diminution, taintless, not conducive to fetters, not conducive to ties, not conducive to floods, not conducive to yokes, not conducive to hindrances, unmisapprehended, not clinging-prone, undefilable; are all phenomena recollecting the Buddha, recollecting the Dhamma, recollecting the Saṅgha, recollecting virtue, recollecting generosity, recollecting devas, mindfulness of breathing, mindfulness of death, mindfulness directed to the body, recollecting peace?
Theravādin: Then must you also admit that all cognizable things constitute mindfulness, the controlling faculty and force of mindfulness, mindfulness that is perfect, that is a factor of enlightenment, the “sole conveying” path “leading to extinction”, to “enlightenment”, to “disintegration”, are “not bound up with the intoxicants”, “not akin to the fetters, ties, floods, bonds, hindrances, contagions, graspings, corruptions”; you must admit that all cognizable things constitute the “ten recollections”, namely of the Buddha, the Norm, the Order, morals, pious liberality, the devas, “mindfulness in respiration”, “reflection on death”, “mindfulness concerning the body”, “reflection on peace”. But this you deny.
1.9.1.4
Na hevaṃ vattabbe …pe….
It should not be said thus …pe….
Theravādin: Then must you also admit that all cognizable things constitute mindfulness, the controlling faculty and force of mindfulness, mindfulness that is perfect, that is a factor of enlightenment, the “sole conveying” path “leading to extinction”, to “enlightenment”, to “disintegration”, are “not bound up with the intoxicants”, “not akin to the fetters, ties, floods, bonds, hindrances, contagions, graspings, corruptions”; you must admit that all cognizable things constitute the “ten recollections”, namely of the Buddha, the Norm, the Order, morals, pious liberality, the devas, “mindfulness in respiration”, “reflection on death”, “mindfulness concerning the body”, “reflection on peace”. But this you deny.
1.9.2.1
Sabbe dhammā satipaṭṭhānāti?
Are all phenomena establishments of mindfulness?
Again, you must equally admit, given your first affirmation, that the eye-organ constitutes an application in mindfulness. And if you are driven to admit that it does, then you must admit everything for it, which, as I claim, you must admit for all cognizable things. The same argument holds for the four other sense-organs, for the five objects of sense, for lust, hate, dullness, conceit, error, doubt, sloth, distraction, impudence, indiscretion.
1.9.2.2
Āmantā.
Yes.
Again, you must equally admit, given your first affirmation, that the eye-organ constitutes an application in mindfulness. And if you are driven to admit that it does, then you must admit everything for it, which, as I claim, you must admit for all cognizable things. The same argument holds for the four other sense-organs, for the five objects of sense, for lust, hate, dullness, conceit, error, doubt, sloth, distraction, impudence, indiscretion.
1.9.2.3
Cakkhāyatanaṃ satipaṭṭhānanti?
Is the eye base an establishment of mindfulness?
Again, you must equally admit, given your first affirmation, that the eye-organ constitutes an application in mindfulness. And if you are driven to admit that it does, then you must admit everything for it, which, as I claim, you must admit for all cognizable things. The same argument holds for the four other sense-organs, for the five objects of sense, for lust, hate, dullness, conceit, error, doubt, sloth, distraction, impudence, indiscretion.
1.9.2.4
Na hevaṃ vattabbe …pe…
It should not be said thus …pe…
Again, you must equally admit, given your first affirmation, that the eye-organ constitutes an application in mindfulness. And if you are driven to admit that it does, then you must admit everything for it, which, as I claim, you must admit for all cognizable things. The same argument holds for the four other sense-organs, for the five objects of sense, for lust, hate, dullness, conceit, error, doubt, sloth, distraction, impudence, indiscretion.
1.9.2.5
cakkhāyatanaṃ satipaṭṭhānanti?
Is the eye base an establishment of mindfulness?
Again, you must equally admit, given your first affirmation, that the eye-organ constitutes an application in mindfulness. And if you are driven to admit that it does, then you must admit everything for it, which, as I claim, you must admit for all cognizable things. The same argument holds for the four other sense-organs, for the five objects of sense, for lust, hate, dullness, conceit, error, doubt, sloth, distraction, impudence, indiscretion.
1.9.2.6
Āmantā.
Yes.
Again, you must equally admit, given your first affirmation, that the eye-organ constitutes an application in mindfulness. And if you are driven to admit that it does, then you must admit everything for it, which, as I claim, you must admit for all cognizable things. The same argument holds for the four other sense-organs, for the five objects of sense, for lust, hate, dullness, conceit, error, doubt, sloth, distraction, impudence, indiscretion.
1.9.2.7
Cakkhāyatanaṃ sati satindriyaṃ satibalaṃ sammāsati satisambojjhaṅgo ekāyanamaggo khayagāmī bodhagāmī apacayagāmī anāsavaṃ asaṃyojaniyaṃ …pe… asaṅkilesikaṃ, cakkhāyatanaṃ buddhānussati dhammānussati saṅghānussati sīlānussati cāgānussati devatānussati ānāpānassati maraṇānussati kāyagatāsati upasamānussatīti?
Is the eye base mindfulness, the faculty of mindfulness, the power of mindfulness, right mindfulness, the awakening factor of mindfulness, the one-way path, leading to destruction, leading to awakening, leading to diminution, taintless, not conducive to fetters …pe… undefilable; is the eye base recollecting the Buddha, recollecting the Dhamma, recollecting the Saṅgha, recollecting virtue, recollecting generosity, recollecting devas, mindfulness of breathing, mindfulness of death, mindfulness directed to the body, recollecting peace?
Again, you must equally admit, given your first affirmation, that the eye-organ constitutes an application in mindfulness. And if you are driven to admit that it does, then you must admit everything for it, which, as I claim, you must admit for all cognizable things. The same argument holds for the four other sense-organs, for the five objects of sense, for lust, hate, dullness, conceit, error, doubt, sloth, distraction, impudence, indiscretion.
1.9.2.8
Na hevaṃ vattabbe …pe…
It should not be said thus …pe…
Again, you must equally admit, given your first affirmation, that the eye-organ constitutes an application in mindfulness. And if you are driven to admit that it does, then you must admit everything for it, which, as I claim, you must admit for all cognizable things. The same argument holds for the four other sense-organs, for the five objects of sense, for lust, hate, dullness, conceit, error, doubt, sloth, distraction, impudence, indiscretion.
1.9.2.9
sotāyatanaṃ …
[Is] the ear base …
Again, you must equally admit, given your first affirmation, that the eye-organ constitutes an application in mindfulness. And if you are driven to admit that it does, then you must admit everything for it, which, as I claim, you must admit for all cognizable things. The same argument holds for the four other sense-organs, for the five objects of sense, for lust, hate, dullness, conceit, error, doubt, sloth, distraction, impudence, indiscretion.
1.9.2.10
ghānāyatanaṃ …
the nose base …
Again, you must equally admit, given your first affirmation, that the eye-organ constitutes an application in mindfulness. And if you are driven to admit that it does, then you must admit everything for it, which, as I claim, you must admit for all cognizable things. The same argument holds for the four other sense-organs, for the five objects of sense, for lust, hate, dullness, conceit, error, doubt, sloth, distraction, impudence, indiscretion.
1.9.2.11
jivhāyatanaṃ …
the tongue base …
Again, you must equally admit, given your first affirmation, that the eye-organ constitutes an application in mindfulness. And if you are driven to admit that it does, then you must admit everything for it, which, as I claim, you must admit for all cognizable things. The same argument holds for the four other sense-organs, for the five objects of sense, for lust, hate, dullness, conceit, error, doubt, sloth, distraction, impudence, indiscretion.
1.9.2.12
kāyāyatanaṃ …
the body base …
Again, you must equally admit, given your first affirmation, that the eye-organ constitutes an application in mindfulness. And if you are driven to admit that it does, then you must admit everything for it, which, as I claim, you must admit for all cognizable things. The same argument holds for the four other sense-organs, for the five objects of sense, for lust, hate, dullness, conceit, error, doubt, sloth, distraction, impudence, indiscretion.
1.9.2.13
rūpāyatanaṃ …
the form base …
Again, you must equally admit, given your first affirmation, that the eye-organ constitutes an application in mindfulness. And if you are driven to admit that it does, then you must admit everything for it, which, as I claim, you must admit for all cognizable things. The same argument holds for the four other sense-organs, for the five objects of sense, for lust, hate, dullness, conceit, error, doubt, sloth, distraction, impudence, indiscretion.
1.9.2.14
saddāyatanaṃ …
the sound base …
Again, you must equally admit, given your first affirmation, that the eye-organ constitutes an application in mindfulness. And if you are driven to admit that it does, then you must admit everything for it, which, as I claim, you must admit for all cognizable things. The same argument holds for the four other sense-organs, for the five objects of sense, for lust, hate, dullness, conceit, error, doubt, sloth, distraction, impudence, indiscretion.
1.9.2.15
gandhāyatanaṃ …
the odour base …
Again, you must equally admit, given your first affirmation, that the eye-organ constitutes an application in mindfulness. And if you are driven to admit that it does, then you must admit everything for it, which, as I claim, you must admit for all cognizable things. The same argument holds for the four other sense-organs, for the five objects of sense, for lust, hate, dullness, conceit, error, doubt, sloth, distraction, impudence, indiscretion.
1.9.2.16
rasāyatanaṃ …
the taste base …
Again, you must equally admit, given your first affirmation, that the eye-organ constitutes an application in mindfulness. And if you are driven to admit that it does, then you must admit everything for it, which, as I claim, you must admit for all cognizable things. The same argument holds for the four other sense-organs, for the five objects of sense, for lust, hate, dullness, conceit, error, doubt, sloth, distraction, impudence, indiscretion.
1.9.2.17
phoṭṭhabbāyatanaṃ …
the tangible base …
Again, you must equally admit, given your first affirmation, that the eye-organ constitutes an application in mindfulness. And if you are driven to admit that it does, then you must admit everything for it, which, as I claim, you must admit for all cognizable things. The same argument holds for the four other sense-organs, for the five objects of sense, for lust, hate, dullness, conceit, error, doubt, sloth, distraction, impudence, indiscretion.
1.9.2.18
rāgo …
lust …
Again, you must equally admit, given your first affirmation, that the eye-organ constitutes an application in mindfulness. And if you are driven to admit that it does, then you must admit everything for it, which, as I claim, you must admit for all cognizable things. The same argument holds for the four other sense-organs, for the five objects of sense, for lust, hate, dullness, conceit, error, doubt, sloth, distraction, impudence, indiscretion.
1.9.2.19
doso …
hatred …
Again, you must equally admit, given your first affirmation, that the eye-organ constitutes an application in mindfulness. And if you are driven to admit that it does, then you must admit everything for it, which, as I claim, you must admit for all cognizable things. The same argument holds for the four other sense-organs, for the five objects of sense, for lust, hate, dullness, conceit, error, doubt, sloth, distraction, impudence, indiscretion.
1.9.2.20
moho …
delusion …
Again, you must equally admit, given your first affirmation, that the eye-organ constitutes an application in mindfulness. And if you are driven to admit that it does, then you must admit everything for it, which, as I claim, you must admit for all cognizable things. The same argument holds for the four other sense-organs, for the five objects of sense, for lust, hate, dullness, conceit, error, doubt, sloth, distraction, impudence, indiscretion.
1.9.2.21
māno …
conceit …
Again, you must equally admit, given your first affirmation, that the eye-organ constitutes an application in mindfulness. And if you are driven to admit that it does, then you must admit everything for it, which, as I claim, you must admit for all cognizable things. The same argument holds for the four other sense-organs, for the five objects of sense, for lust, hate, dullness, conceit, error, doubt, sloth, distraction, impudence, indiscretion.
1.9.2.22
diṭṭhi …
wrong view …
Again, you must equally admit, given your first affirmation, that the eye-organ constitutes an application in mindfulness. And if you are driven to admit that it does, then you must admit everything for it, which, as I claim, you must admit for all cognizable things. The same argument holds for the four other sense-organs, for the five objects of sense, for lust, hate, dullness, conceit, error, doubt, sloth, distraction, impudence, indiscretion.
1.9.2.23
vicikicchā …
doubt …
Again, you must equally admit, given your first affirmation, that the eye-organ constitutes an application in mindfulness. And if you are driven to admit that it does, then you must admit everything for it, which, as I claim, you must admit for all cognizable things. The same argument holds for the four other sense-organs, for the five objects of sense, for lust, hate, dullness, conceit, error, doubt, sloth, distraction, impudence, indiscretion.
1.9.2.24
thinaṃ …
sloth …
Again, you must equally admit, given your first affirmation, that the eye-organ constitutes an application in mindfulness. And if you are driven to admit that it does, then you must admit everything for it, which, as I claim, you must admit for all cognizable things. The same argument holds for the four other sense-organs, for the five objects of sense, for lust, hate, dullness, conceit, error, doubt, sloth, distraction, impudence, indiscretion.
1.9.2.25
uddhaccaṃ …
restlessness …
Again, you must equally admit, given your first affirmation, that the eye-organ constitutes an application in mindfulness. And if you are driven to admit that it does, then you must admit everything for it, which, as I claim, you must admit for all cognizable things. The same argument holds for the four other sense-organs, for the five objects of sense, for lust, hate, dullness, conceit, error, doubt, sloth, distraction, impudence, indiscretion.
1.9.2.26
ahirikaṃ …
shamelessness …
Again, you must equally admit, given your first affirmation, that the eye-organ constitutes an application in mindfulness. And if you are driven to admit that it does, then you must admit everything for it, which, as I claim, you must admit for all cognizable things. The same argument holds for the four other sense-organs, for the five objects of sense, for lust, hate, dullness, conceit, error, doubt, sloth, distraction, impudence, indiscretion.
1.9.2.27
anottappaṃ satipaṭṭhānanti?
fearlessness of wrongdoing an application of mindfulness?
Again, you must equally admit, given your first affirmation, that the eye-organ constitutes an application in mindfulness. And if you are driven to admit that it does, then you must admit everything for it, which, as I claim, you must admit for all cognizable things. The same argument holds for the four other sense-organs, for the five objects of sense, for lust, hate, dullness, conceit, error, doubt, sloth, distraction, impudence, indiscretion.
1.9.2.28
Na hevaṃ vattabbe …pe…
It should not be said thus …
Again, you must equally admit, given your first affirmation, that the eye-organ constitutes an application in mindfulness. And if you are driven to admit that it does, then you must admit everything for it, which, as I claim, you must admit for all cognizable things. The same argument holds for the four other sense-organs, for the five objects of sense, for lust, hate, dullness, conceit, error, doubt, sloth, distraction, impudence, indiscretion.
1.9.2.29
anottappaṃ satipaṭṭhānanti?
[Is] fearlessness of wrongdoing an application of mindfulness?
Again, you must equally admit, given your first affirmation, that the eye-organ constitutes an application in mindfulness. And if you are driven to admit that it does, then you must admit everything for it, which, as I claim, you must admit for all cognizable things. The same argument holds for the four other sense-organs, for the five objects of sense, for lust, hate, dullness, conceit, error, doubt, sloth, distraction, impudence, indiscretion.
1.9.2.30
Āmantā.
Yes.
Again, you must equally admit, given your first affirmation, that the eye-organ constitutes an application in mindfulness. And if you are driven to admit that it does, then you must admit everything for it, which, as I claim, you must admit for all cognizable things. The same argument holds for the four other sense-organs, for the five objects of sense, for lust, hate, dullness, conceit, error, doubt, sloth, distraction, impudence, indiscretion.
1.9.2.31
Anottappaṃ sati satindriyaṃ satibalaṃ sammāsati …pe… kāyagatāsati upasamānussatīti?
Is fearlessness of wrongdoing mindfulness, the faculty of mindfulness, the power of mindfulness, right mindfulness … mindfulness directed to the body, recollection of peace?
Again, you must equally admit, given your first affirmation, that the eye-organ constitutes an application in mindfulness. And if you are driven to admit that it does, then you must admit everything for it, which, as I claim, you must admit for all cognizable things. The same argument holds for the four other sense-organs, for the five objects of sense, for lust, hate, dullness, conceit, error, doubt, sloth, distraction, impudence, indiscretion.
1.9.2.32
Na hevaṃ vattabbe …pe….
It should not be said thus …
Again, you must equally admit, given your first affirmation, that the eye-organ constitutes an application in mindfulness. And if you are driven to admit that it does, then you must admit everything for it, which, as I claim, you must admit for all cognizable things. The same argument holds for the four other sense-organs, for the five objects of sense, for lust, hate, dullness, conceit, error, doubt, sloth, distraction, impudence, indiscretion.
1.9.3.1
Sati satipaṭṭhānā, sā ca satīti?
Is mindfulness an application of mindfulness, and is it mindfulness?
Is mindfulness itself an application of mindfulness, and conversely? If you admit this, then must you also admit that each of the foregoing cognizable things is an application of mindfulness, and that application of mindfulness is each of those things.
1.9.3.2
Āmantā.
Yes.
Is mindfulness itself an application of mindfulness, and conversely? If you admit this, then must you also admit that each of the foregoing cognizable things is an application of mindfulness, and that application of mindfulness is each of those things.
1.9.3.3
Cakkhāyatanaṃ satipaṭṭhānaṃ, tañca satīti?
Is the eye base an application of mindfulness, and is it mindfulness?
Is mindfulness itself an application of mindfulness, and conversely? If you admit this, then must you also admit that each of the foregoing cognizable things is an application of mindfulness, and that application of mindfulness is each of those things.
1.9.3.4
Na hevaṃ vattabbe …pe…
It should not be said thus …
Is mindfulness itself an application of mindfulness, and conversely? If you admit this, then must you also admit that each of the foregoing cognizable things is an application of mindfulness, and that application of mindfulness is each of those things.
1.9.3.5
sati satipaṭṭhānā, sā ca satīti?
Is mindfulness an application of mindfulness, and is it mindfulness?
Is mindfulness itself an application of mindfulness, and conversely? If you admit this, then must you also admit that each of the foregoing cognizable things is an application of mindfulness, and that application of mindfulness is each of those things.
1.9.3.6
Āmantā.
Yes.
Is mindfulness itself an application of mindfulness, and conversely? If you admit this, then must you also admit that each of the foregoing cognizable things is an application of mindfulness, and that application of mindfulness is each of those things.
1.9.3.7
Sotāyatanaṃ …pe…
[Is] the ear base …
Is mindfulness itself an application of mindfulness, and conversely? If you admit this, then must you also admit that each of the foregoing cognizable things is an application of mindfulness, and that application of mindfulness is each of those things.
1.9.3.8
kāyāyatanaṃ … rūpāyatanaṃ …pe…
the body base … the form base …
Is mindfulness itself an application of mindfulness, and conversely? If you admit this, then must you also admit that each of the foregoing cognizable things is an application of mindfulness, and that application of mindfulness is each of those things.
1.9.3.9
phoṭṭhabbāyatanaṃ … rāgo … doso … moho …pe…
the tangible base … lust … hatred … delusion …
Is mindfulness itself an application of mindfulness, and conversely? If you admit this, then must you also admit that each of the foregoing cognizable things is an application of mindfulness, and that application of mindfulness is each of those things.
1.9.3.10
anottappaṃ satipaṭṭhānaṃ, tañca satīti?
fearlessness of wrongdoing an application of mindfulness, and is it mindfulness?
Is mindfulness itself an application of mindfulness, and conversely? If you admit this, then must you also admit that each of the foregoing cognizable things is an application of mindfulness, and that application of mindfulness is each of those things.
1.9.3.11
Na hevaṃ vattabbe …pe….
It should not be said thus …
Is mindfulness itself an application of mindfulness, and conversely? If you admit this, then must you also admit that each of the foregoing cognizable things is an application of mindfulness, and that application of mindfulness is each of those things.
1.9.4.1
Cakkhāyatanaṃ satipaṭṭhānaṃ, tañca na satīti?
Is the eye base an application of mindfulness, and is it not mindfulness?
You deny; then do you hold that each of those cognizable things is an application of mindfulness, but not conversely? You assent; then you must equally admit that mindfulness itself is an application in mindfulness, but that application in mindfulness is not mindfulness.
1.9.4.2
Āmantā.
Yes.
You deny; then do you hold that each of those cognizable things is an application of mindfulness, but not conversely? You assent; then you must equally admit that mindfulness itself is an application in mindfulness, but that application in mindfulness is not mindfulness.
1.9.4.3
Sati satipaṭṭhānā, sā ca na satīti?
Is mindfulness an application of mindfulness, and is it not mindfulness?
You deny; then do you hold that each of those cognizable things is an application of mindfulness, but not conversely? You assent; then you must equally admit that mindfulness itself is an application in mindfulness, but that application in mindfulness is not mindfulness.
1.9.4.4
Na hevaṃ vattabbe …pe…
It should not be said thus …
You deny; then do you hold that each of those cognizable things is an application of mindfulness, but not conversely? You assent; then you must equally admit that mindfulness itself is an application in mindfulness, but that application in mindfulness is not mindfulness.
1.9.4.5
sotāyatanaṃ …pe…
[Is] the ear base …
You deny; then do you hold that each of those cognizable things is an application of mindfulness, but not conversely? You assent; then you must equally admit that mindfulness itself is an application in mindfulness, but that application in mindfulness is not mindfulness.
1.9.4.6
kāyāyatanaṃ …
the body base …
You deny; then do you hold that each of those cognizable things is an application of mindfulness, but not conversely? You assent; then you must equally admit that mindfulness itself is an application in mindfulness, but that application in mindfulness is not mindfulness.
1.9.4.7
rūpāyatanaṃ …pe…
the form base …
You deny; then do you hold that each of those cognizable things is an application of mindfulness, but not conversely? You assent; then you must equally admit that mindfulness itself is an application in mindfulness, but that application in mindfulness is not mindfulness.
1.9.4.8
phoṭṭhabbāyatanaṃ …
the tangible base …
You deny; then do you hold that each of those cognizable things is an application of mindfulness, but not conversely? You assent; then you must equally admit that mindfulness itself is an application in mindfulness, but that application in mindfulness is not mindfulness.
1.9.4.9
rāgo …
lust …
You deny; then do you hold that each of those cognizable things is an application of mindfulness, but not conversely? You assent; then you must equally admit that mindfulness itself is an application in mindfulness, but that application in mindfulness is not mindfulness.
1.9.4.10
doso …
hatred …
You deny; then do you hold that each of those cognizable things is an application of mindfulness, but not conversely? You assent; then you must equally admit that mindfulness itself is an application in mindfulness, but that application in mindfulness is not mindfulness.
1.9.4.11
moho …pe…
delusion …
You deny; then do you hold that each of those cognizable things is an application of mindfulness, but not conversely? You assent; then you must equally admit that mindfulness itself is an application in mindfulness, but that application in mindfulness is not mindfulness.
1.9.4.12
anottappaṃ satipaṭṭhānaṃ, tañca na satīti?
fearlessness of wrongdoing an application of mindfulness, and is it not mindfulness?
You deny; then do you hold that each of those cognizable things is an application of mindfulness, but not conversely? You assent; then you must equally admit that mindfulness itself is an application in mindfulness, but that application in mindfulness is not mindfulness.
1.9.4.13
Āmantā.
Yes.
You deny; then do you hold that each of those cognizable things is an application of mindfulness, but not conversely? You assent; then you must equally admit that mindfulness itself is an application in mindfulness, but that application in mindfulness is not mindfulness.
1.9.4.14
Sati satipaṭṭhānā, sā ca na satīti?
Is mindfulness an application of mindfulness, and is it not mindfulness?
You deny; then do you hold that each of those cognizable things is an application of mindfulness, but not conversely? You assent; then you must equally admit that mindfulness itself is an application in mindfulness, but that application in mindfulness is not mindfulness.
1.9.4.15
Na hevaṃ vattabbe …pe….
It should not be said thus …
You deny; then do you hold that each of those cognizable things is an application of mindfulness, but not conversely? You assent; then you must equally admit that mindfulness itself is an application in mindfulness, but that application in mindfulness is not mindfulness.
1.9.5.1
Na vattabbaṃ—
Should it not be said:
Andhaka: Then is it wrong to say “all things are applications in mindfulness”?
1.9.5.2
“sabbe dhammā satipaṭṭhānā”ti?
“All things are applications of mindfulness”?
Andhaka: Then is it wrong to say “all things are applications in mindfulness”?
1.9.5.3
Āmantā.
Yes.
Theravādin: Yes.
1.9.5.4
Nanu sabbe dhamme ārabbha sati santiṭṭhatīti?
Does not mindfulness become established regarding all things?
Andhaka: But is not mindfulness established concerning all cognizable things?
1.9.5.5
Āmantā.
Yes.
Theravādin: Yes.
1.9.5.6
Hañci sabbe dhamme ārabbha sati santiṭṭhatīti, tena vata re vattabbe—
If mindfulness becomes established regarding all things, then indeed, sir, it should be said:
Andhaka: How then, good sir, can you deny what I affirm: “All cognizable things are applications of mindfulness”?
1.9.5.7
“sabbe dhammā satipaṭṭhānā”ti.
“All things are applications of mindfulness.”
Andhaka: How then, good sir, can you deny what I affirm: “All cognizable things are applications of mindfulness”?
1.9.6.1
Sabbaṃ dhammaṃ ārabbha sati santiṭṭhatīti sabbe dhammā satipaṭṭhānāti?
Because mindfulness becomes established regarding everything, are all things applications of mindfulness?
Theravādin: We have said that mindfulness is established concerning all cognizable things: now, are all cognizable things applications of mindfulness?
1.9.6.2
Āmantā.
Yes.
Andhaka: Yes.
1.9.6.3
Sabbaṃ dhammaṃ ārabbha phasso santiṭṭhatīti sabbe dhammā phassapaṭṭhānāti?
Because contact becomes established regarding everything, are all things applications of contact?
Theravādin: Contact is established with respect to all cognizable things: are then all such things applications in contact? For this is that to which you have committed yourself. Again, feeling, perception, volition, consciousness, each of these is established with respect to all cognizable things: are then all such things applications in feeling, in perception, etc.? For this must equally be admitted.
1.9.6.4
Na hevaṃ vattabbe …pe….
It should not be said thus …
1.9.7.1
Sabbaṃ dhammaṃ ārabbha sati santiṭṭhatīti sabbe dhammā satipaṭṭhānāti?
Because mindfulness is established concerning all things, are all things establishments of mindfulness?
1.9.7.2
Āmantā.
Yes.
1.9.7.3
Sabbaṃ dhammaṃ ārabbha vedanā santiṭṭhati …
Because feeling is established concerning all things …
1.9.7.4
saññā santiṭṭhati …
perception is established …
1.9.7.5
cetanā santiṭṭhati …
volition is established …
1.9.7.6
cittaṃ santiṭṭhatīti sabbe dhammā cittapaṭṭhānāti?
mind is established concerning all things, are all things establishments of mind?
1.9.7.7
Na hevaṃ vattabbe …pe….
It should not be said thus …
1.9.8.1
Sabbe dhammā satipaṭṭhānāti?
Are all things establishments of mindfulness?
Again, if your proposition is to stand, then you equally admit for all beings that they have mindfulness at hand, are endowed and set up with mindfulness, having it ever in readiness. Moreover, was it not said by the Exalted One:
1.9.8.2
Āmantā.
Yes.
1.9.8.3
Sabbe sattā upaṭṭhitasatino satiyā samannāgatā satiyā samohitā;
Do all beings have mindfulness established, are they endowed with mindfulness, supplied with mindfulness;
1.9.8.4
sabbesaṃ sattānaṃ sati paccupaṭṭhitāti?
is mindfulness present in all beings?
1.9.8.5
Na hevaṃ vattabbe …pe….
It should not be said thus …
1.9.9.1
Sabbe dhammā satipaṭṭhānāti?
Are all things establishments of mindfulness?
1.9.9.2
Āmantā.
Yes.
1.9.9.3
Nanu vuttaṃ bhagavatā—
Was it not said by the Blessed One:
1.9.9.4
“amataṃ te, bhikkhave, na paribhuñjanti ye kāyagatāsatiṃ na paribhuñjanti.
“Monks, those who do not enjoy mindfulness directed to the body do not enjoy the deathless.
“They, bhikkhus, who do not enjoy mindfulness regarding the body, do not enjoy the Ambrosial; they, bhikkhus, who enjoy mindfulness regarding the body, enjoy the Ambrosial”?
1.9.9.5
Amataṃ te, bhikkhave, paribhuñjanti ye kāyagatāsatiṃ paribhuñjantī”ti.
Monks, those who enjoy mindfulness directed to the body do enjoy the deathless”?
“They, bhikkhus, who do not enjoy mindfulness regarding the body, do not enjoy the Ambrosial; they, bhikkhus, who enjoy mindfulness regarding the body, enjoy the Ambrosial”?
1.9.9.6
Attheva suttantoti?
Does such a sutta exist?
Is the Suttanta thus? You admit it is; but do “all beings” enjoy, obtain, practise, develop, and multiply mindfulness regarding the body? You know they do not.
1.9.9.7
Āmantā.
Yes.
Is the Suttanta thus? You admit it is; but do “all beings” enjoy, obtain, practise, develop, and multiply mindfulness regarding the body? You know they do not.
1.9.9.8
Sabbe sattā kāyagatāsatiṃ paribhuñjanti paṭilabhanti āsevanti bhāventi bahulīkarontīti?
Do all beings enjoy, obtain, cultivate, develop, and make much of mindfulness directed to the body?
Is the Suttanta thus? You admit it is; but do “all beings” enjoy, obtain, practise, develop, and multiply mindfulness regarding the body? You know they do not.
1.9.9.9
Na hevaṃ vattabbe …pe….
It should not be said thus …
Is the Suttanta thus? You admit it is; but do “all beings” enjoy, obtain, practise, develop, and multiply mindfulness regarding the body? You know they do not.
1.9.10.1
Sabbe dhammā satipaṭṭhānāti?
Are all things establishments of mindfulness?
Again, was it not said by the Exalted One:
1.9.10.2
Āmantā.
Yes.
Again, was it not said by the Exalted One:
1.9.10.3
Nanu vuttaṃ bhagavatā—
Was it not said by the Blessed One:
Again, was it not said by the Exalted One:
1.9.10.4
“ekāyano ayaṃ, bhikkhave, maggo sattānaṃ visuddhiyā sokaparidevānaṃ samatikkamāya dukkhadomanassānaṃ atthaṅgamāya ñāyassa adhigamāya nibbānassa sacchikiriyāya yadidaṃ cattāro satipaṭṭhānā”ti.
“Monks, this is the one-way path for the purification of beings, for the overcoming of sorrow and lamentation, for the disappearance of pain and distress, for the attainment of the true way, for the realization of unbinding—namely, the four establishments of mindfulness”?
“There is a way, bhikkhus, that leads only to the purification of beings, to the passing beyond sorrow and grief, to the extinction of Ill and sadness, to the attainment of right method, to the realization of Nibbāna, and that way is the four applications of mindfulness”?
1.9.10.5
Attheva suttantoti?
Does such a sutta exist?
Is the Suttanta thus? You admit it is; but have “all beings” this one and only way so leading? You are bound to admit that they have not.
1.9.10.6
Āmantā?
Yes.
Is the Suttanta thus? You admit it is; but have “all beings” this one and only way so leading? You are bound to admit that they have not.
1.9.10.7
Sabbe dhammā ekāyanamaggoti?
Are all things the one-way path?
Is the Suttanta thus? You admit it is; but have “all beings” this one and only way so leading? You are bound to admit that they have not.
1.9.10.8
Na hevaṃ vattabbe …pe….
It should not be said thus …
Is the Suttanta thus? You admit it is; but have “all beings” this one and only way so leading? You are bound to admit that they have not.
1.9.11.1
Sabbe dhammā satipaṭṭhānāti?
Are all things establishments of mindfulness?
Again, was it not said by the Exalted One:
1.9.11.2
Āmantā.
Yes.
Again, was it not said by the Exalted One:
1.9.11.3
Nanu vuttaṃ bhagavatā—
Was it not said by the Blessed One:
Again, was it not said by the Exalted One:
1.9.11.4
“rañño, bhikkhave, cakkavattissa pātubhāvā sattannaṃ ratanānaṃ pātubhāvo hoti.
“Monks, with the appearance of a wheel-turning king, there is the appearance of seven treasures.
“When a Wheel-turning Monarch appears, bhikkhus, then doth there appear seven treasures. What are the seven? The treasure of the Wheel doth appear, and the treasures of the Elephant, the Horse, the Jewel, the Woman, the Householder, the Heir-apparent; yea, bhikkhus, on the appearance of a Wheel-turning Monarch do these seven treasures appear. When a Tathāgata appears, bhikkhus, Arahant Buddha Supreme, then doth there appear these seven treasures of enlightenment. What are the seven? The treasures of those factors of enlightenment: Mindfulness, Search for Truth, Energy, Zest, Serenity, Concentration, Equanimity; yea, bhikkhus, on the appearance of a Tathāgata Arahant, Buddha Supreme, do these seven treasures appear”?
1.9.11.5
Katamesaṃ sattannaṃ?
Which seven?
1.9.11.6
Cakkaratanassa pātubhāvo hoti, hatthiratanassa pātubhāvo hoti, assaratanassa …
There is the appearance of the wheel treasure, the elephant treasure, the horse treasure …
1.9.11.7
maṇiratanassa …
the gem treasure …
1.9.11.8
itthiratanassa …
the woman treasure …
1.9.11.9
gahapatiratanassa …
the householder treasure …
1.9.11.10
pariṇāyakaratanassa pātubhāvo hoti.
the counselor treasure.
1.9.11.11
Rañño, bhikkhave, cakkavattissa pātubhāvā imesaṃ sattannaṃ ratanānaṃ pātubhāvo hoti.
Monks, with the appearance of a wheel-turning king, there is the appearance of these seven treasures.
1.9.12.1
Tathāgatassa, bhikkhave, pātubhāvā arahato sammāsambuddhassa sattannaṃ bojjhaṅgaratanānaṃ pātubhāvo hoti.
Monks, with the appearance of the Tathāgata, the arahant, the Fully Awakened One, there is the appearance of the seven treasures of the factors of awakening.
1.9.12.2
Katamesaṃ sattannaṃ?
Which seven?
1.9.12.3
Satisambojjhaṅgaratanassa pātubhāvo hoti, dhammavicayasambojjhaṅgaratanassa pātubhāvo hoti, vīriyasambojjhaṅgaratanassa pātubhāvo hoti, pītisambojjhaṅgaratanassa pātubhāvo hoti, passaddhisambojjhaṅgaratanassa pātubhāvo hoti, samādhisambojjhaṅgaratanassa pātubhāvo hoti, upekkhāsambojjhaṅgaratanassa pātubhāvo hoti.
There is the appearance of the treasure of the awakening factor of mindfulness, the treasure of the awakening factor of investigation of phenomena, the treasure of the awakening factor of energy, the treasure of the awakening factor of joy, the treasure of the awakening factor of tranquility, the treasure of the awakening factor of concentration, the treasure of the awakening factor of equanimity.
1.9.12.4
Tathāgatassa, bhikkhave, pātubhāvā arahato sammāsambuddhassa imesaṃ sattannaṃ bojjhaṅgaratanānaṃ pātubhāvo hotī”ti.
Monks, with the appearance of the Tathāgata, the arahant, the Fully Awakened One, there is the appearance of these seven treasures of the factors of awakening”?
1.9.12.5
Attheva suttantoti?
Does such a sutta exist?
Is the Suttanta thus? You admit it is. But do “all things” become that treasure of Mindfulness which is a factor of enlightenment, when a Tathāgata appears? You know they do not, yet you are bound to admit they do.
1.9.12.6
Āmantā.
Yes.
Is the Suttanta thus? You admit it is. But do “all things” become that treasure of Mindfulness which is a factor of enlightenment, when a Tathāgata appears? You know they do not, yet you are bound to admit they do.
1.9.12.7
Tathāgatassa pātubhāvā arahato sammāsambuddhassa sabbe dhammā satisambojjhaṅgaratanāva hontīti?
With the appearance of the Tathāgata, the arahant, the Fully Awakened One, do all things become only the treasure of the awakening factor of mindfulness?
Is the Suttanta thus? You admit it is. But do “all things” become that treasure of Mindfulness which is a factor of enlightenment, when a Tathāgata appears? You know they do not, yet you are bound to admit they do.
1.9.12.8
Na hevaṃ vattabbe …pe…
It should not be said thus …
Is the Suttanta thus? You admit it is. But do “all things” become that treasure of Mindfulness which is a factor of enlightenment, when a Tathāgata appears? You know they do not, yet you are bound to admit they do.
1.9.12.9
sabbe dhammā satipaṭṭhānāti?
Are all things establishments of mindfulness?
Lastly, if all things are applications of mindfulness, they must be equally other of the (thirty-seven) things pertaining to enlightenment, such as the supreme efforts, the steps to magic potency, the controlling faculties and forces, the factors of enlightenment. To this admission are you committed.
1.9.12.10
Āmantā.
Yes.
Lastly, if all things are applications of mindfulness, they must be equally other of the (thirty-seven) things pertaining to enlightenment, such as the supreme efforts, the steps to magic potency, the controlling faculties and forces, the factors of enlightenment. To this admission are you committed.
1.9.12.11
Sabbe dhammā sammappadhānā …
Are all things right exertions …
Lastly, if all things are applications of mindfulness, they must be equally other of the (thirty-seven) things pertaining to enlightenment, such as the supreme efforts, the steps to magic potency, the controlling faculties and forces, the factors of enlightenment. To this admission are you committed.
1.9.12.12
iddhipādā …
bases of psychic power …
Lastly, if all things are applications of mindfulness, they must be equally other of the (thirty-seven) things pertaining to enlightenment, such as the supreme efforts, the steps to magic potency, the controlling faculties and forces, the factors of enlightenment. To this admission are you committed.
1.9.12.13
indriyā …
faculties …
Lastly, if all things are applications of mindfulness, they must be equally other of the (thirty-seven) things pertaining to enlightenment, such as the supreme efforts, the steps to magic potency, the controlling faculties and forces, the factors of enlightenment. To this admission are you committed.
1.9.12.14
balā …
powers …
Lastly, if all things are applications of mindfulness, they must be equally other of the (thirty-seven) things pertaining to enlightenment, such as the supreme efforts, the steps to magic potency, the controlling faculties and forces, the factors of enlightenment. To this admission are you committed.
1.9.12.15
bojjhaṅgāti?
factors of awakening?
Lastly, if all things are applications of mindfulness, they must be equally other of the (thirty-seven) things pertaining to enlightenment, such as the supreme efforts, the steps to magic potency, the controlling faculties and forces, the factors of enlightenment. To this admission are you committed.
1.9.12.16
Na hevaṃ vattabbe …pe….
It should not be said thus …
Lastly, if all things are applications of mindfulness, they must be equally other of the (thirty-seven) things pertaining to enlightenment, such as the supreme efforts, the steps to magic potency, the controlling faculties and forces, the factors of enlightenment. To this admission are you committed.
1.9.12.17
Satipaṭṭhānakathā niṭṭhitā.
The discussion on establishments of mindfulness is finished.
Translations (2)
- Points of Controversy, or Subjects of Discourse — Shwe Zan Aung & Caroline A. F. Rhys Davids 1915, English
- English (machine translation) — English, machine translation
Commentaries (2)
- Mūlaṭīkā — Ānanda (Vanaratana), Pāli
- Pañcappakaraṇaṭṭhakathā — Buddhaghosa, Pāli
Linked texts (9)
- 雜阿含經 — Classical Chinese
- 增壹阿含經 — Classical Chinese
- 中阿含經 — Classical Chinese
- Mahāsatipaṭṭhānasutta — Pāli
- Satipaṭṭhānasutta — Pāli
- Amatavagga — Pāli
- Ambapālisutta — Pāli
- 輪王七寶經 — Classical Chinese
- Cakkavattisutta — Pāli
Discussed in (1)
- Early Monastic Buddhism — Dutt 1941, English