Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

The Development of Hindu Iconography c11.64

The Development of Hindu Iconography c11.64

Language
English

c11.64.1

In the foregoing survey of the devices on the early indigenous and foreign coins of India, a few points are to be noted. Some of the symbols appearing on the early punch-marked and cast coins seem undoubtedly based on the religious practices of their issuers. On the local and tribal cast and die-struck coins that are Indian in character, we find the continuation of devices already met with in the earlier series, with this difference that now their nature is more clearly understandable than in their previous presentation. It should also be borne in mind that the same device was equally available to the various sectaries of those days to illustrate their own religious faith, and a cakra, which in one place might definitely represent Buddhist dharmacakra, could in another setting stand for the Sudarśana emblem of Viṣṇu, which, as we have shown, is a symbol of the Sun god. Coomaraswamy rightly remarks, ‘The vocabulary of these symbols was equally available to all sects, Brahmans, Buddhists and Jains, each employing them in senses of their own’ (HIIA, p. 44). Cunningham was oblivious about it, and he invariably described the railing, so frequently to be found on these coins, as ‘Buddhist basement railing’, the tree as ‘Bodhi tree’, the pillar as ‘Buddhist pillar’, and so on.

c11.64.2

In these early cast and die-struck coins, however, we light upon the representations of regular icons, which were objects of worship, and various gods and goddesses make their appearance with somewhat elaborate iconographic features. In the case of the oft-reproduced deity on the coins, viz., Śiva, his various types show that varieties of Śaiva icons were being made on which these coin devices were based. Again, such observations of previous scholars, that ‘the appearance of the figure of Śiva and not a Liṅga as an object of worship on the Kushan coins clearly shows that up to the time of the Kushan king Vāsudeva, Śiva worship had not come to be identified with Liṅga worship’ will have to be set aside. D. R. Bhandarkar observes further in his Carmichael Lectures (pp. 19-21) that Śiva was certainly being worshipped in his anthropomorphic form up till the 7th century A.D., for ‘Śiva recumbent on his mount’ figures on the reverse of Śaśāṅka’s gold coins. But on the basis of evidence of much earlier coins and seals, we know for certain that Śiva was also being worshipped in his phallic form. That phallicism was a part of Śiva worship in the time of Huvishka is fully proved by the ithyphallic (urdhvaliṅga) feature of the unique figure of the composite god on one of the gold coins of this Kushan emperor already noted. Much earlier evidence in the shape of the uninscribed cast coin (provenance unknown) and the die-struck coins from Ujjayinī and Taxila has been produced.

c11.64.3

The Ujjayinī coins are specially interesting from this point of view, because some of them portray Śiva in human form, while others show his phallic form, proving that Śiva was being worshipped there in both these forms simultaneously. Another point worth noticing is that though Śiva used to be represented mostly in his bull form in the Gandhāra region (cf., Hesychius' statement quoted above), still by the time the Kushans had begun their rule, the bull was regarded as his mount, and his human form was predominant. This is proved by the many extant coins of the Śaiva Kushan emperor, Wema Kadphises. In the coins of Kanishka and Huvishka, it was not even thought necessary to associate his theriomorphic form with the anthropomorphic one. But in Vāsudeva's time, the older practice was resumed, and thenceforward Śiva, in several aspects of his representation, was never to be dissociated from his mount. In the shrines which had invariably the Liṅga enshrined in the main sanctum, the bull Nandin was always given a prominent place in front of it, in order that he may always look at his lord in the symbolic form (cf., my observations about Śiva and bull on an Ujjayinī coin). It should not also be forgotten that, by the time of Huvishka, the movement for cult amalgam and for combining the iconography of two or more different cult divinities had already begun, which was to culminate in later times in the Smārta cult of Pañcopāsanā.

c11.64.4

While assigning attributes to the deity, the Kushan die-cutters were drawing also upon earlier indigenous modes, for, as we have seen, the staff and water-vessel which are the characteristic emblems of Śiva in the Ujjayinī coins are also used by them. The three heads of Śiva are figured too after the earlier mode, and most of the features are based on indigenous mythological details. The plastic form of this deity, as well as of the other deities appearing on the Kushan money, is no doubt Hellenistic, but the subject was purely Indian. The indigenous Śiva in human form was unquestionably earlier in appearance, for all scholars assign the Ujjayinī coins to the third-second centuries B.C., which was at least a century earlier than Śiva's first appearance on the money of one of the foreign rulers of India, *viz.*, Maues. I recognised Śiva for the first time in two coin devices, hitherto unidentified, of this Indo-Scythic ruler. The staff and water-vessel carrying human figure can be traced to some of the punch-marked coins described by Allan (*op. cit.*, Introduction, xxxvi ; see Pl. I, fig. 4).¹ Vāsudeva Viṣṇu, though some of his emblems, such as *cakra*, etc., are sometimes reproduced, figures somewhat rarely on the early indigenous coins; but it must be observed that even in the Gupta period, of which extant Viṣṇu images are known, none of the coins of the devout Bhāgavata kings bear on them any effigy of Viṣṇu.

c11.64.5

The Paramabhāgavatas, however, invariably used the Garuḍa emblem on most of their coins, thus showing their cult affiliation. Of the other gods, Brahmanya-Kumāra was frequently reproduced on certain coins. The name Brahmanya was evidently the base of Subrahmaṇya, in which name this god is generally worshipped in the south. The god had several iconographic types, as the coins show, which also prove that much of the mythology about him was already in existence in the 2nd century A.D. As regards several other constituents of the Brāhmanic pantheon, the Pañcāla Mitra coins supply us with some useful data. It has rightly been observed that 'the reverses are of special interest to the student of Hindu iconography, as we have nothing similar elsewhere of so early a data' (Allan). It is regrettable that their usefulness has to a certain extent been minimised by the smallness of the size of some and the imperfect state of preservation of others. The goddess Durgā-Pārvatī is not clearly recognisable in any of the early indigenous coins, though some of the female figures appearing on their reverse, and usually identified as Lakṣmī, may represent her. On some coins of Azes I, she may be recognised if we are certain about the identity of the forepart of her lion mount beside her. But, without doubt, she figures on a few coins of Huvishka; Rapson was the first to identify her correctly.

c11.64.6

In one of the two figures, a female carrying a lotus flower in her hand, and standing by the side of a male figure (Śiva), on the reverse side of a gold coin of Huvishka in the British Museum collection, the die-cutter definitely puts down her name in four Greek letters by her side, which were correctly read by Rapson as OMMO (Umā). I read the name by the side of a female figure appearing singly on the reverse of a gold coin of the same Kushan emperor in the collection of the Lahore Museum. But this time she is made to hold a cornucopia, after the manner of an Ardochso, a Demeter or a Tyche (as represented on the money of the Indo-Greek and the Indo-Scythic rulers), showing clearly how these Indian deities were being presented in their Hellenistic garb. The reverses of some of the coins of Huvishka, thus like those of the Pañcāla Mitra coins, are of special interest to the students of Brahmanical iconography.