The Development of Hindu Iconography c14.22
The Development of Hindu Iconography c14.22
- Language
- English
c14.22.1
Two other mudrās which are also found in the iconographic art of ancient and mediaeval India have been named by T. A. G. Rao as jñāna- and vyākhyāna-, vitarka- or cin-mudrā. Rao says that, in the former, ‘the tips of the middle finger and of the thumb are joined together and held near the heart, with the palm of the hand turned towards the heart.’ Fig. 2 in Plate III of this book illustrates this pose. The ‘front’ right hand of the figure of Nārāyaṇa in the Nara-Nārāyaṇa relief at Deogarh shows it; but it can probably be traced to a period far earlier than the Gupta age.⁴ Drawing No. 1 in Plate III is based on the figure of Ajakālaka Yakṣa in Bharhut with his right hand in the same characteristic pose; the standing male figure in the representation of a donor couple (or are they Yakṣa and Yakṣiṇī?) in a part of the Bharhut railing has his left hand shown in the same pose, but it must be observed that in both a lotus flower is placed between the tips of the thumb and the index finger.¹ We are not certain, however, whether this typical pose was known under that name as early as the 2nd century B.C.; as regards the things held by the hands, it should be noted that different objects, such as a lotus flower, a rosary, a bowl, etc., are sometimes placed in them even when they typify some particular pose (for example, in some Dhyānī Buddha figures, an alms-bowl is placed on the hands showing dhyāna-mudrā).
c14.22.2
The cinmudrā is described by Rao thus,—‘ the tips of the thumb and the forefinger are made to touch each other, so as to form a circle, the other fingers being kept open. The palm of the hand is made to face the front.’ The hand in this pose is usually raised upwards near the breast and it appears that this is the exact counterpart of jñāna-mudrā. Rao remarks about it that it is the ‘ mudrā adopted when an explanation or exposition is being given; hence it is also called vyākhyāna-mudrā and sandarśana-mudrā ’ (Pl. III, Fig. 3). The extreme right section of a large panel in the Cave temple of Rāmeśvara at Ellora depicts Subrahmanya teaching his father Śiva the significance of Om; the right hand of the polycephalous god is shown in the vyākhyāna pose, a rosary being shown in the palm.² The two-armed figure of Nara in the Deogarh relief just referred to shows his right hand in the same pose, a rosary being also placed in the hand. One of the earliest representations of a teacher expounding his lessons or doctrines is to be found at Bharhut where the sage Dīrghatapasvī is shown in the attitude of instructing his pupils; he is sitting at ease on a raised seat facing his four disciples seated below in a reverential attitude; his left hand rests on his knee while his right hand is raised towards his breast with the thumb and index fingers projecting outwards, the other fingers being bent inwards.
c14.22.3
It is true that the tips of the thumb and the forefinger are not joined together, but they also characteristically portray the expounding pose.¹ A reference now to the *dharmacakra-mudrā*, though it is usually associated with the Buddha images and not with those of any Brahmanical deity, will be of some interest. The particular pose symbolises the first preaching of the law by the Master at Sārnāth, thus, figuratively speaking, setting thenceforward the ‘Wheel of the Law’ in motion; it was also used in the representation of the Great Miracle at Śrāvastī. The Gandhāra artists were never sure about the mode in which it was to be depicted; sometimes the right hand of the Buddha was placed on the rim of a wheel on stand, at other times the hand, seemingly in the *abhaya* pose, was used to serve the purpose, while more frequently it was depicted in a manner that was not at all suggestive of any clear idea (the right hand with fingers flexed inward was placed near the breast, the left hand with its fingers drawn together touching it from below). But in the truly Indian images of the Buddha from the Gupta period onwards, the *dharmacakra-mudrā* is invariably presented in the manner shown in Fig. 4, Plate III, of this book. A glance at the drawing will at once show that this hand-pose is nothing but the combined representation of *jñāna*- and *vyākhyāna-mudrās*, the left hand being in the former and the right in the latter.
c14.22.4
The ideology here is thus characteristically expressive: Buddha in the act of expounding the true knowledge which he had himself first obtained through his efforts.²