<!-- Pramāṇa, a library of Indian primary sources · https://indike.org/pramana/ins.epigraphy.mahadevan-2003.c26.s15 -->

[Pramāṇa](https://indike.org/pramana/) › [Studies](https://indike.org/pramana/ins) › [Archaeology, epigraphy and coins](https://indike.org/pramana/ins.epigraphy) › [Early Tamil Epigraphy: From the Earliest Times to the Sixth Century A.D.](https://indike.org/pramana/ins.epigraphy.mahadevan-2003) › c26.s15

# Early Tamil Epigraphy: From the Earliest Times to the Sixth Century A.D. c26.s15: 6.15 Special usage governing u- vowels in Early Tamil-Brāhmī inscriptions

Early Tamil Epigraphy: From the Earliest Times to the Sixth Century A.D. c26.s15

- **Language:** English

## Contents

- [c26.s15.t1 6.15.1 Apparent lengthening of u as ū](https://indike.org/pramana/ins.epigraphy.mahadevan-2003.c26.s15.t1) — 11 parts
- [c26.s15.t2 6.15.2 Empirical rules for the special usage of u- vowels](https://indike.org/pramana/ins.epigraphy.mahadevan-2003.c26.s15.t2) — 9 parts

### 6.15 Special usage governing u- vowels in Early Tamil-Brāhmī inscriptions

### 6.15.1 Apparent lengthening of u as ū

### [c26.s15.t1.1](https://indike.org/pramana/ins.epigraphy.mahadevan-2003.c26.s15.t1.1)

Another orthographic peculiarity of the Early Tamil-Brāhmī inscriptions is the apparently 'unnecessary lengthening' of the short vowel \*u\* (initial and medial) as \*ū\* in certain positions. The present Corpus records 16 instances of this special usage in 12 inscriptions from 8 sites, far too many to be dismissed as scribal errors. All the inscriptions except one belong to the Early Period (ca. 2nd century b.c.-1st century a.d.) and occur in association with TB-I or mixed TB-I and II notations.¹¹ All of them are clustered around the Madurai region (see Map I, detail). The frequency and distribution of this peculiar usage justify the search for a rational explanation.¹²

### [c26.s15.t1.2](https://indike.org/pramana/ins.epigraphy.mahadevan-2003.c26.s15.t1.2)

¹¹ The exception is the inscription at Anaimalai (\*No. 60\*) assigned to the Late Period (ca. 2nd century a.d.).

### [c26.s15.t1.3](https://indike.org/pramana/ins.epigraphy.mahadevan-2003.c26.s15.t1.3)

¹² I. Mahadevan 1985a: pp. 22-27. The data has been updated in the present study.

### [c26.s15.t1.4](https://indike.org/pramana/ins.epigraphy.mahadevan-2003.c26.s15.t1.4)

The following is the complete list of words in the Corpus with the special usage:¹

### [c26.s15.t1.5](https://indike.org/pramana/ins.epigraphy.mahadevan-2003.c26.s15.t1.5)

¹ The list does not include words in which the vowels \*u\* and \*ū\* occur with normal values. It also excludes obvious scribal errors (e.g., \*ur\* for \*ūr\* 'village').

### [c26.s15.t1.6](https://indike.org/pramana/ins.epigraphy.mahadevan-2003.c26.s15.t1.6)

| S.No. | Apparent reading | Actual reading | Meaning | Ref.No. |  
| 1. | \*\*a na tū vā ṉa\*\* | \*antuvaṉ\* | 'a personal name' | 53.1 |  
| 2. | \*\*a va \[v\]i r\[u\] a a ra ū ma\*\* | \*avviru-ar-um\* | 'those two persons also' | 45.3 |  
| 3. | \*\*a sū tā ṇa\*\* | \*a(s)sutaṉ\* | 'a personal name' | 3.7.b |  
| 4. | \*\*ū tā yā ṇa sa\*\* | \*utayaṇa(s)sa\* | 'of Utayaṇaṉ' | 24.5 |  
| 5. | \*\*ū pā cā a ṇa\*\* | \*upa(c)caṉ\* | 'preceptor' | 10.1, 11.3 |  
| 6. | \*\*ū pā cā ṇa\*\* | \*upa(c)caṉ\* | 'preceptor' | 9.1 |  
| 7. | \*\*ū pā ṟu vā . . .\*\* | \*u(p)paṟuva\[ṉ\]\* | 'a personal name' | 11.4 |  
| 8. | \*\*ū pu vā ṇi ka ṇa\*\* | \*u(p)pu vāṇikaṉ\* | 'salt merchant' | 39.1 |  
| 9. | \*\*ū ṟai\*\* | \*uṟai\* | 'abode (of ascetics)' | 9.3, 24.4 |  
| 10. | \*\*ku ṉa ṟa tū\*\* | \*-kuṉṟa(t)tu\* | 'of the hill' | 60.1.b |  
| 11. | \*\*ko ṭa ṭū pi ta tā a\*\* | \*koṭṭupitta-a\* | 'which was caused to be carved' | 1.8 |  
| 12. | \*\*ko ṭa ṭū pi to ṉa\*\* | \*koṭṭupi(t)tōṉ\* | 'he who caused to be carved' | 8.3, 9.4 |  
| 13. | \*\*ko ṭū pi to ṉa\*\* | \*koṭu(p)pi(t)tōṉ\* | 'he who caused to be given' | 5.2 |  
| 14. | \*\*ni kā mā tū\*\* | \*nikama(t)tu\* | 'of the merchant guild' | 3.4 |  
| 15. | \*\*pā ra a cū\*\* | \*paracu\* | 'a personal name' | 9.2 |  
| 16. | \*\*pi ṇā ū\*\* | \*piṇa(v)u\* | 'cleft?' | 3.8 |

### [c26.s15.t1.7](https://indike.org/pramana/ins.epigraphy.mahadevan-2003.c26.s15.t1.7)

This special usage is also known from legends on pottery and other inscribed objects:

### [c26.s15.t1.8](https://indike.org/pramana/ins.epigraphy.mahadevan-2003.c26.s15.t1.8)

| 17. | \*\*ū ti rā ṇa\*\* | \*u(t)tiraṉ\* | 'a personal name' (coin from Sri Lanka).² |  
| 18. | \*\*ū pā ā ṇa\*\* | \*upa\[c\*\]aṉ\* | 'preceptor'(gold ring from Karur).³ |  
| 19. | \*\*ū mā ṇ(a) . . .\*\* | \*umaṇa\[ṉ\]\* | 'trader in salt' (pottery inscription from Uraiyur).⁴ |

### [c26.s15.t1.9](https://indike.org/pramana/ins.epigraphy.mahadevan-2003.c26.s15.t1.9)

² See No. 5, Table 1.6.

### [c26.s15.t1.10](https://indike.org/pramana/ins.epigraphy.mahadevan-2003.c26.s15.t1.10)

³ See No. 4, Table 1.8 and Fig. 1.24 A.

### [c26.s15.t1.11](https://indike.org/pramana/ins.epigraphy.mahadevan-2003.c26.s15.t1.11)

⁴ K.V. Raman (ed.) 1988: Fig. 24.3 and Pl. 16. (See also No. 3, Table 1.5 and Fig. 1.19C in this vol.)

### 6.15.2 Empirical rules for the special usage of u- vowels

### [c26.s15.t2.1](https://indike.org/pramana/ins.epigraphy.mahadevan-2003.c26.s15.t2.1)

The clue to the understanding of this special usage comes from the TB-I notation with which it is closely associated as may be seen from the word list above. The TB-I notation attempted to distinguish three medial vowel-lengths viz., \*-ā\*, \*-a\* and Ø, but provided for only two as it employed the same marker for both \*-ā\* and \*-a\*. On this analogy, we may formulate the following empirical rules for the special usage relating to the \*u-\* vowels:

### [c26.s15.t2.2](https://indike.org/pramana/ins.epigraphy.mahadevan-2003.c26.s15.t2.2)

(a) The symbols for \*ū\* (initial and medial) stand for the sounds \*ū\* (long) or \*u\* (short).  
(b) The symbols for \*u\* (initial and medial) stand for the sounds \*u\* (short) or \*u\* (shortened).

### [c26.s15.t2.3](https://indike.org/pramana/ins.epigraphy.mahadevan-2003.c26.s15.t2.3)

Let us examine the words in the list given above in the light of these empirical rules.

### [c26.s15.t2.4](https://indike.org/pramana/ins.epigraphy.mahadevan-2003.c26.s15.t2.4)

\*\*Rule (a): \*ū\* to be read as \*u\*\*\*

### [c26.s15.t2.5](https://indike.org/pramana/ins.epigraphy.mahadevan-2003.c26.s15.t2.5)

9 initial occurrences of \*ū-\* have to be read as \*u-\* (items 4 to 9, 17-19); 6 medial occurrences of \*-ū-\* have also to be read as \*-u-\* (items 1 to 3, 11 to 13).

### [c26.s15.t2.6](https://indike.org/pramana/ins.epigraphy.mahadevan-2003.c26.s15.t2.6)

The situation is less clear in respect of the final occurrences of \*-ū\* which have to be read as \*-u\* according to rule (a). Items 15 and 16 may be read respectively as \*paracu\* and \*piṇa(v)u\* probably with the short \*-u\* finally as required by the rule. However, as item 15 is a personal name and item 16 is not attested elsewhere, one cannot be sure about the length of the final \*-u\* in these cases. Items 10 and 14 have to be emended respectively as \*kuṉṟa(t)tu\* and \*nikama(t)tu\* as in Literary Tamil; one should then expect the shortened \*-u\* in the final position in these cases and not the short \*-u\* as required by this rule.

### [c26.s15.t2.7](https://indike.org/pramana/ins.epigraphy.mahadevan-2003.c26.s15.t2.7)

\*\*Rule (b): \*-u\* to be read as shortened \*-u\*\*\*

### [c26.s15.t2.8](https://indike.org/pramana/ins.epigraphy.mahadevan-2003.c26.s15.t2.8)

The diagnostic word in the list (item 8) is \*\*ū  pu\*\* to be read as \*u(p)pu\* (with short and shortened \*u\* at either end) according to this rule: Apparently the shifting of the long \*ū\* symbol to represent the short \*u\* was for the purpose of leaving the short \*u\* symbol to represent the shortened \*-u\* in word-final positions. There are, however, no other such clear instances in the word list to confirm this hypothesis.

### [c26.s15.t2.9](https://indike.org/pramana/ins.epigraphy.mahadevan-2003.c26.s15.t2.9)

On the whole, the evidence from the word list supports the empirical rules formulated above governing the usage of the \*u-\* vowels in the Early Tamil-Brāhmī inscriptions. But, as in the case of the TB-I notation, this system is also defective as it provides for only two symbols (\*ū\* and \*u\*) to represent three sounds (\*ū\*, \*u\* and shortened \*u\*). This is almost certainly the reason why this orthographic experiment failed. While the TB-I notation was replaced by better systems, the special usage governing the \*u-\* vowels disappeared without any replacement, thus ending an interesting, though short-lived, attempt to depict the shortened \*u\* graphically in the Tamil-Brāhmī script.

---
Source: [https://indike.org/pramana/ins.epigraphy.mahadevan-2003.c26.s15](https://indike.org/pramana/ins.epigraphy.mahadevan-2003.c26.s15) · Pramāṇa
