The Classical Accounts of India c20.s4: 4. Incidental Notices
The Classical Accounts of India c20.s4
- Language
- English
Contents
- c20.s4.t1 A. Clemens Alexandrinus — 5 parts
- c20.s4.t2 B. St. Jerome (c. A.D. 340-420) — 2 parts
- c20.s4.t3 C. Plutarch — 1 part
- c20.s4.t4 D. Archelaos — 2 parts
- c20.s4.t5 E. Kedrenos — 2 parts
- c20.s4.t6 F. Hierokles — 3 parts
4. Incidental Notices
A. Clemens Alexandrinus
c20.s4.t1.1
Clemens was a native of Athens and was probably born about A.D. 150, but as he spent the greater part of his life in Alexandria, the capital of Egypt, he was surnamed the Alexandrian. During his residence there he became the disciple of Pantaenus, who was the head of the Christian School of Alexandria, and whom he succeeded in that office in 211 A D. His notice of the Brachmans or Brahmans is contained in his work which he called *Stromateis*, to indicate the miscellaneous nature of its contents.⁵ He probably lived till A D 220
c20.s4.t1.2
Stromateis. III. 194. The Brachmans neither eat anything having life nor drink wine, but some of them every day, like ourselves, take food, while others of them do so once in three days, as Alexander Polyhistor relates in his *Indika*. They despise death, and set no value on life; for they are persuaded that there is a new birth (*paliggenesia*), and these worship Herakles and Pan. But those Indians who are called *Semnoi* go naked all their lives.⁶ These practise truth, make predictions about futurity, and worship a kind of pyramid beneath which they think the bones of some divinity lie buried⁷. But neither the Gymnosophists nor the Semnoi use women, for they regard this as contrary to nature and unlawful; for which reason they keep themselves chaste. The *Semnai*, too, remain virgin. They observe closely the heavenly bodies, and by the indications of futurity which these offer, make some predictions.
c20.s4.t1.3
I. 305. That the Jewish race is by far the oldest of all these, and that their philosophy, which has been committed to writing, preceded the philosophy of the Greeks, Philo the Pythagorean shows by many arguments, as does also Aristoboulos the Peripatetic, and many others whose names I need not waste time in enumerating. Megasthenes, the author of a work on *India*, who lived with Seleukos Nikator, writes most clearly on this point, and his words are these⁸ :—"*All that has been said regarding nature by the ancients is asserted also by philosophers out of Greece, on the one part in India by the Brachmanes, and on the other in Syria by the people called the Jews.*"
c20.s4.t1.4
Philosophy, then, with all its blessed advantages to man, flourished long ages ago among the barbarians, diffusing its light among the Gentiles, and eventually penetrated into Greece. Its hierophants were the prophets among the Egyptians, the Chaldaeans among the Assyrians, the Druids among the Gauls, the Sarmanaeans who were the philosophers of the Baktrians and the Kelts, the Magi among the Persians, who, as you know, announced beforehand the birth of the Saviour, being led by a star till they arrived in the land of Judaea, and among the Indians the Gymnosophists, and other philosophers of barbarous nations
c20.s4.t1.5
There are two sects of these Indian philosophers—one called the Sarmânai and the other the Brachmânai. Connected with the Sarmânai are the philosophers called the Hylobioi, who neither live in cities nor even in houses. They clothe themselves with the bark of trees, and subsist upon acorns, and drink water by lifting it to their mouth with their hands. They neither marry nor beget children [like those ascetics of our own day called the Enkratêtai. Among the Indians are those *philosophers* also who follow the precepts of Boutta,⁹ whom they honour as a god on account of his extraordinary sanctity.
B. St. Jerome (c. A.D. 340-420)
c20.s4.t2.1
II. *Adv. Jovın* 14. Bardesanes, a Badylonian, divides the Indian Gymnosophists into two sects. one of which he calls Brachmans and the other Samanaeans, who are so abstemious that they subsist on the fruits of trees or a public allowance of rice or flour. And the king on coming to them worships them, and the peace of his dominions depends according to his judgement on their prayers.
c20.s4.t2.2
*Contra Jov.* Epist pt. I., Tr ii 26. Hence among the Gymnosophists there is a tradition which lends authority to this opinion (the honour of virginity), that Buddha (Buddas), the founder of their doctrine, was born from the side of a virgin.
C. Plutarch
c20.s4.t3.1
T. II. p. 36. To bewail him who enters life because of the many ills he comes to, but on the other hand to dismiss from his earthly home him whom death hath released from his miseries with gladness and expressions of felicitation.
D. Archelaos
c20.s4.t4.1
Archelaos, the Bishop of Carrha in Mesopotamia, is famous for the discussion which he held in public with the heretic Manes in A D 278
c20.s4.t4.2
*Archelat et Manetis Disputatio*, I. 97. Terebinthus proclaimed himself learned in all the wisdom of the Egyptians, and gave out that his name was no longer Terebinthus¹⁰, but that he was a new Budiha (Buddas), for such was the name he now assumed, and that he was born of a virgin, and had been brought up on the mountains by an angel
E. Kedrenos
c20.s4.t5.1
Kedrenos, a Greek monk of the eleventh century was the compiler of a *Synopsis of History* which begins with the creation of the world and goes down to the year 1057 As an author he shows himself deficient alike in historical knowledge and in judgement Of his life nothing is known.
c20.s4.t5.2
*Synop. Hist.* I. pp 516-17. Bohn’s Edition —And in this year of the Emperor Constantine, Metrodoros, a Persian by birth, on pretence of philosophy, went off to India and the Brachmans, and by leading a strictly ascetic life won their respect and reverence. He constructed for them water-mills and baths—things previously unknown in the country. This man for his piety was admitted into the most sacred recesses of their temples, and stole their precious stones and pearls. He received also from the king of the Indians presents to carry to the emperor, and those he gave to him as if they were his own.
F. Hierokles
c20.s4.t6.1
Hierokles a native of Hyllarima in Karia is supposed to have been the author of a work called *Oeconomicas*, of which Stobaeus has preserved some extracts
c20.s4.t6.2
Hierokles—from Stephanos of Byzantium, s.v. Brachmanes. —After this I thought it worth my while to go and visit the Brahman caste. These men are philosophers dear to the gods, and especially devoted to the sun. They abstain from all flesh meats and live out in the open air. and honour truth Their dress is made of the soft and skin-like fibres of stones, which they weave into a stuff that no fire burns or water cleanses. When their clothes get soiled or dirty, they are thrown into a blazing fire, and come out quite white and bright.—Priaulx's *Trans.*
c20.s4.t6.3
Hierokles—from the *Chiliads* of Tzetzes (VII. *Hist.* 144-716).—Then I came to a country very dry and burnt up by the sun. And all about this desert I saw men naked and houseless, and of these some shaded their faces with their ears, and the rest of their bodies with their feet raised in the air. Of these men Strabo has a notice, as also of the no-heads and ten-heads and four-hands-and-feet men, but none of them did I ever see, quoth Hierokles.
Cites (1)
- Ἰνδική — Λούκιος Φλάουιος Ἀρριανός, Ancient Greek