Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

The Classical Accounts of India c22.s2.t2: Doubtful Fragments

The Classical Accounts of India c22.s2.t2

Language
English

Doubtful Fragments

c22.s2.t2.1

| Number of fragments (McCrindle) | Source | Subjectmatter | Reference to page in this volume | Category |
| LII | Aelian (XII. 8) | Elephants | 413-4 | |
| LIII | -do- (III. 46) | White Elephant | 413 | |
| LIV | Pseudo-Origen, (2-4) | Brahmanas | 443-4 | |
| LV | Pallad (8, 20) | Kalanos and Mandanis | 444-6 | |
| LVB | Ambrosius (62. 68) | -do- | 446-7 | |
| LVI | Pliny (VI. 21. 8-23. 11) | Indian Races | 341-5 | |
| LVIB | Solin, (52. 6-17) | -do- | 457-8 | |
| LVII | Polyaenus (I. 1. 1-3) | Dionysos | 456 | |
| LVIII | -do- (I. 3. 4) | Hercules and Pandaea | 456-7 | |
| LIX | Aelian (XVI. 2-22) | Beasts of India | 419-20 | |

c22.s2.t2.2

¹ M-II, 13-4.

c22.s2.t2.3

² E. I. Robson's Translation, II, 319

c22.s2.t2.4

³ M-II, 14.

c22.s2.t2.5

³ M-II, 16. The death of Chandragupta Maurya is now generally placed about 300 B.C

c22.s2.t2.6

⁴ B. C. J. Timmer has discussed this question in her doctoral dissertation entitled "Megasthenes en de Indische Maatschappij" (Amsterdam, 1930). She has not, however, gone very deeply into this subject.

c22.s2.t2.7

⁵ "*Diodorus of Sicily*"-English translation by C. H. Oldfather (1935). See Introduction.

c22.s2.t2.8

⁶ Above, p. 234.

c22.s2.t2.9

⁷ Above, p. 262.

c22.s2.t2.10

⁸ Above, p. 232.

c22.s2.t2.11

⁹ Above, p. 216. It may be noted that both Schwanbeck and McCrindle regarded it as certain "that 16,000 stadia is the only measure Megasthenes gave of the breadth of India" (M-II, 48, footnote)

c22.s2.t2.12

¹⁰ Above, p. 232

c22.s2.t2.13

¹¹ Above, p. 217

c22.s2.t2.14

¹² M-II, 47.

c22.s2.t2.15

¹³ Above, p. 216

c22.s2.t2.16

¹⁴ M-V, 185

c22.s2.t2.17

¹⁵ M-II, 18

c22.s2.t2.18

¹⁶ Translation by H. L. Jones, I, 263

c22.s2.t2.19

¹⁷ M-II, 21

c22.s2.t2.20

¹⁸ Ibid.

c22.s2.t2.21

¹⁹ M-II, 26

c22.s2.t2.22

²⁰ Above, p. 219

c22.s2.t2.23

²¹ Above, p. 220

c22.s2.t2.24

²² Above, p. 229

c22.s2.t2.25

²³ This Appendix is based upon my paper "The Indika of Megasthenes" published in the *Journal of the American Oriental Society*, Volume 78, number 4 (1958), pp. 273-6

c22.s2.t2.26

²⁴ In the cases of some Fragments, column IV is left blank as they cannot be placed under any category. It is difficult to understand on what grounds they were regarded as based on the *Indika* of Megasthenes.

c22.s2.t2.27

FOOTNOTES

Cites (1)