Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

The Classical Accounts of India c6.s3: 3. Geography

The Classical Accounts of India c6.s3

Language
English

3. Geography

c6.s3.1

The geographical account may be broadly divided into two classes, namely the narratives of men who actually visited parts of India, and general description by people who gathered information from various sources.

c6.s3.2

As regards the first, the typical examples are the account of Nearchus (313-336) and the anonymous work called *The Periplus of the Erythraean Sea* (288-312). The first belongs to the fourth century B C, and the second nearly four hundred years later. Both describe the coastal voyage between the Persian Gulf and the mouths of the Indus, and the difference between the two accounts shows the marvellous advance in navigation in these waters, and the wonderful progress in human culture in these regions, during the interval of four centuries.

c6.s3.3

The nature of the voyage between the Suez coast and the mouth of the Ganges, along the coast, the names of ports with imports and exports and other economic data, and the detailed accounts of the trade and commerce carried on between India and the Western countries, supplied by the Periplus are of unique importance, as they are not known from any other source In particular, apart from vague and general reference in literature, this book supplies the only positive evidence that is so far known regarding the ships built in India, and the Indian traders sailing and establishing settlements in Western waters (297, 299)

c6.s3.4

A very interesting account of a voyage to Egypt by a body of Indian adventurers of whom one alone reached his destination, is told by Posidonios (283) Eratosthenes records the distances from the Caspian gates to India (286) There are also detailed accounts of Taprobane or the island of Ceylon (345-8, 436)

c6.s3.5

To the second class of geographers belong Strabo, Pliny. Arrian and Ptolemy The Greeks had been long interested in general geographical studies of the World Hecataeus (c 500 B.C.) was the first Greek geographer who knew of the continents, Europe and Asia, and regarded Africa as a part of the latter His geographical work, *Survey of the World*, is lost He referred to Indoi, Indus, Gandarii, Kaspapyros and a few other peoples on the Indus

c6.s3.6

Next came Herodotus (1) who travelled widely He rejected the theory, then current among the Greeks, that the earth was flat. But he had a very poor knowledge of India He only knew that it was one of the remotest provinces of the Persian empire towards the East Herodotus lived from c 484 to 431 B C

c6.s3.7

Nearly two hundred years later flourished Eratosthenes (c 240 B C.), the famous librarian of the great library established in Alexandria by the Ptolemies He was a mathematician, and laid the foundation of a really scientific geography He accepted the theory that the earth is spherical. It is believed by some that this theory was first propounded by Thales (640-546 B C.), but others give this credit to Pythagoras who flourished in the sixth century B C In any case, it was Eratosthenes who based his geography on this idea, and, according to Bunbury,⁵ his geographical description is not only much nearer to the truth than that of Ptolemy, who flourished four hundred years later, but it is actually a nearer approximation to truth than was reached by modern geographers till about two centuries ago. He described India on the basis of the accounts supplied by the companions of Alexander and Megasthenes He also utilized the data supplied by the Register of Stathmı or Marches.

c6.s3.8

⁵ *History of Ancient Geography*, I 635.

c6.s3.9

Strabo (244-287), who flourished about two centuries after Eratosthenes, wrote his geography in order to correct the earlier works on the subject. He had a very critical mind and had fuller information of the world on account of the extensive Roman empire. His views on the older classical writers on India and the difficulty of securing accurate data about the country would be clear from the opening paragraphs of his account (244 ff.). Strabo's account is a rich mine of information about India and is not confined to geographical details, including trade routes.

c6.s3.10

Pliny (337-50) not only describes the position, boundaries and physical characteristics of India, but gives a long list of races inhabiting India and refers briefly to the routes of voyages to and from India with reference to the western lands. His notices about India are fuller, because he flourished in the first century A D. when there was an increasing trade between the Roman Empire and the east, and the discovery of Hippalus (306, 337, 339) enabled the western sailors to go direct to India and avoid the long coastal voyage. But Pliny (A D. 23-79), though a later writer than Strabo, was less critical "His love of the marvellous disposed him to accept far too readily even the most absurd fictions "⁶

c6.s3.11

⁶ M-V, p. 102.

c6.s3.12

About a century after Pliny flourished Arrian and Ptolemy who were contemporaries, both belonging to the middle of the second century A D Arrian's geographical account of India is contained, partly in his account of Alexander's expedition (23 ff.) and partly in the *Indika* (214 ff ) Arrian has also preserved the account of the coastal voyage of Nearchus from the mouths of the Indus towards the west (313 ff ), to which reference has been made above.

c6.s3.13

Ptolemy is the most renowned among the classical scholars who wrote geographical accounts of India. For a detailed discussion of his geographical work, reference may be made to pp. 351 ff.