The Classical Accounts of India c6.s5: 5. General Manners and Customs
The Classical Accounts of India c6.s5
- Language
- English
5. General Manners and Customs
c6.s5.1
The classical writers were naturally attracted by the peculiar social customs and institutions The division of the people into seven castes is described is some detail (236, 263). It is, however, obvious that Megasthenes, who seems to be the only source of information on this point, had no accurate idea on this subject. He evidently mistook the people, following same professions or occupations, as forming endogamous classes in society. In any case, his seven castes have little in common with the four regular, or a large number of mixed, castes which certainly flourished in India after him It has been suggested that he got his number seven from Indian informants, but this is very unlikely, for the mystic or stereotyped figure seven nowhere appears in Indian literature along with caste divisions. It is more likely that he knew of social divisions based on occupations, and also of the prevalence of endogamy, among some communities in India. He mixed these two and then evolved his 'Caste' on the basis of various professions and occupations with which he became familiar. It has been rightly observed that the seven castes or classes of Megasthenes may truly reflect the various activities which a Greek resident at Pataliputra could see going on round about him in the third century B.C.⁸ This is quite in keeping with what may be reasonably inferred from the writings of Megasthenes about his lack of critical judgment.⁹
c6.s5.2
⁸ Ibid., 409
c6.s5.3
⁹ See Appendix I
c6.s5.4
The inability of the classical writers to understand the social institutions of foreigners like Indians, and a consequent tendency towards easy generalisation from isolated facts or concrete instances, are clearly proved by many statements made by them. A notable instance is furnished by the categorical statement that there were no slaves in India (244, 271). This cannot be true, as slavery is referred to in ancient Indian Smritis or law-books and in other literary works. Smritis as well as the secular *Arthaśāstra* make classifications of slaves according to the circumstances of their origin, and describe their rights and disabilities as well as the ways by which they can be manumitted. The only rational explanation of the error into which the classical writers fell is furnished by the extremely miserable lot of the slaves in Greece and Rome. Evidently the western writers would not regard as slaves those who spent their lives more like domestic servants. They looked around for the wretched species of humanity, known as slaves in the West, who were treated more like chattels than human beings—and found none. Hence they wrote that slavery was unknown in ancient India. Some writers, however, referred to the existence of slaves in some States of India (271) but regarded it as peculiar.
c6.s5.5
Another instance in which the ignorance of the classical writers is difficult to explain is the statement, attributed to Megasthenes, that the Indians were ignorant of the art of writing. Strabo quotes this (270) as well as another statement of Megasthenes which credits the Indians with a knowledge of writing (264). Strabo also refers to a statement of Nearchus to the effect that the Indians write missives on linen cloth, immediately adding, however, that the other writers say that the Indians make no use of written characters (279). Curtius refers to the use of the barks of trees for writing (104), and though he belongs to a later period, seems to describe the state of things prevailing in Alexander’s time. There is, however, hardly any doubt that the art of writing was known to the Indians at the time of Megasthenes, and even much earlier. This is proved by the inscriptions engraved on rocks and pillars during the reign of Asoka, about half a century later. These letters are so well formed that there must have been an anterior period of development of writing extending over centuries.
c6.s5.6
The classical writers throw some light on dress and ornament (270, 281), food and manner of taking it (270, 403, 455), funeral (270, 223), rubbing of body (270), private dwelling houses (223, 388) and the urban life of India which had innumerable cities (223)
c6.s5.7
On the morals of the Indians the classical writers have expressed divergent views Curtius has condemned the court-morality in strong language (105) He even goes so far as to say that amid this corruption of morals who would expect to find the culture of philosophy (105-6)? On the other hand, Strabo gives an almost exactly opposite view (269-70)
c6.s5.8
Apart from incidental references, a great deal is said about the Brahmanas and Sramanas, the latter including both Buddhists and Jainas (Ch XIII. 187, 237, 263-4, 173 ff., 298 ff). But the Brahmanas were not all recluses or devoted to religious pursuits. Some of them took active part in politics and were great fighters (1, 81, 278). Reference is also made to religious practices (280) and to the Indian conception of immortality of soul (450).
Cites (1)
- Kauṭilīya Arthaśāstra — Kauṭilya, Sanskrit