The History of Bengal (Vol. I: Hindu Period; Vol. II: Muslim Period 1200–1757) v2.c47.s8: VIII. Relation with the European Trading Companies
The History of Bengal (Vol. I: Hindu Period; Vol. II: Muslim Period 1200–1757) v2.c47.s8
- Language
- English
VIII. Relation with the European Trading Companies
v2.c47.s8.1
Alivardi realised the importance of looking after the traders in his province for its economic prosperity. "He understood perfectly well", remarked M. Jean Law, "the interests of his government, favoured the poor merchants and administered justice when complaints succeeded in reaching him". The council in Calcutta observed in 1747 that it had been "customary at these darbārs (of the Nawab and the Deputy Nawabs) to allow merchants to settle their accounts in a fair manner whenever it has been required by either party".¹ Mr. Scrafton writes that "he used to compare the Europeans to a hive of bees of whose honey you might reap the benefit, but that if you disturbed their hive they would sting you to death" ². He did not harass them unnecessarily, but it was only in times of extreme need that he asked them to render him financial help. Thus, hard pressed by the Maratha invasions, he exacted contributions from the English, the French and the Dutch for the safety of the province of Bengal, where "they participated of (in) the protection of his arms" and enjoyed the profits of trade. In July 1744 A. D., he accused the English of assisting the Marathas and pointed out that "the English (who now) carried on the Trade of the whole World, used (formerly) to have 4 or 5 ships, but now brought 40 or 50 sail, which belonged not to the Company...". The English were ordered not to carry on their trade unless they supplied him with three millions of rupees to clear off two months' pay of his soldiers and some of their gumāshtas were actually arrested and military guards were posted at their gurrah aurungs (coarse cotton cloth factories). After several unsuccessful attempts to conciliate the Nawab through his friend Jagat Seth Fatehchand, his nephew Sa'id Ahmad Khan, and one of officers named Chin Rāy, Mr. Forster, chief of the English factory at Qasimbazar, paid a visit to the Nawab according to the instructions of the Council in Calcutta. He was graciously received by the Nawab was presented with a saropā, (a full khil'at or dress of honour), and was able to effect a settlement in the month of September by agreeing to pay him three lakhs and a half. The Cāsimbāzār factors had to pay an additional amount of Rs. 30,500 to the Nawab's generals and officers; the Patna factors had also to present Rs. 5,000 to the Nawab and Rs. 3,000 to his officers, besides signing a paper for the annual rent of the Chapra town at the rate of Rs. 4,537; and the Dacca factors too were obliged to pay Rs. 5,000. A fine horse was also presented to the Nawab which cost 25000 Madras rupees. The restrictions on the Company's trade were then removed and its *gumāstas* were released.
v2.c47.s8.2
¹ Hill, Vol. III, 160. Letter to Court, 22nd February, 1747, para 189.
v2.c47.s8.3
² Scrafton, Reflections on the Govt. of Indostan.
v2.c47.s8.4
But more than four years did not elapse after this when fresh troubles arose. In the year 1748 Commodore Griffin, or some men of his squadron, captured some trading vessels of the Armenian and the Mughal merchants of Bengal, who complained before the Nawab for redress. The Nawab thereupon sent a *parwānah* to Governor Barwell demanding the delivery of "all the merchants' goods and effects" and adopted various repressive measures against the English Company. This obstructed the Company's trade in the different factories and added to its pecuniary troubles. After various attempts the Company could at last persuade the Armenians to express satisfaction regarding the losses sustained by them in a public darbar held by the Nawab on the 15th October, 1749. The English had also to satisfy the Nawab by the payment of one lakh and fifty thousand rupees, which they borrowed with great difficulty from the Seths. He at last issued a *parwānah* in favour of the Company's trade on 8th October, 1752.
v2.c47.s8.5
Alivardi was always particular about exerting his authority as the *subahdār* of the province over the European traders. "He was", writes M. Jean Law, "zealous of his authority. He especially affected a great independence whenever there was question of any affair between himself and the Europeans. To speak to him of *farmāns* or of privileges obtained from the Emperor was only to anger him. He knew well how to say at the proper moment that he was both King and Wazir". In the month of July, 1745, he issued a *parwānah* asking the English, the French, and the Dutch not to carry on "any hostilities against each other in his dominions", during the war of the Austrian Succession (1740-48). Point Palmyras was fixed as the point whence neutrality should be observed. In spite of this prohibition the English and the Dutch in Bengal allied themselves against the French, and their mutual relations continued to be hostile till the suspension of their conflicts in Europe. But the Nawab always tried to maintain a strict control over them so that they might not encroach upon the field of politics in Bengal as they had already done in the Deccan. M. Jean Law writes that "he saw with equal indignation and surprise the progress of the French and the English nations on the Coromandal coast as well as in the Deccan, for by means of his spies he was informed of everything that happened there . . . He feared that sooner or later the Europeans would attempt similar enterprises in his government".
v2.c47.s8.6
Thus, he did not allow the English and the French to build fortifications in Calcutta and Chandernagore respectively, just as Murshid Quli Ja'far Khan had stopped the construction of forts by the English Company in 1718. "You are merchants", Alivardi often said to the French and the English *vakils*, "what need have you of a fortress? Being under my protection you have no enemies to fear".
v2.c47.s8.7
Thus Alivardi's attitude towards the European traders in Bengal was strict, but he was not oppressive towards them. He exacted money from them occasionally under pressing financial needs due to extraordinary circumstances, and not on "groundless pretences" as the Council at Fort St. George wrongly reported to Admiral Watson in August 1756. He did not certainly contemplate the expulsion of the Europeans from his province or the destruction of their trade in any way. A contemporary French writer observed that the Nawab "was very fond of the Europeans and they all feared the moment of his death because of the disturbances which might then take place". The Dutch at Chinsurā remarked in their petition to Sirāj-ud-daulah, dated 26th June, 1756, that previously they had "generally been befriended and countenanced by the Princes of the land and, up to the glorious Nawab Shujā'-ul-mulk Mahābat Jang (Alivardi) inclusive, always endowed with privileges". About the year 1755 the Danes were permitted by Alivardi to settle at Serampore.
v2.c47.s8.8
J. Z. Holwell's charge that in his death-bed speech Alivardi instructed his grandson Sirāj-ud-daulah to suppress the Europeans, seems to be a concoction. Holwell had the habit of inventing stories or fabricating facts to suit his motives¹. Further, his charge against Alivardi is refuted by some contemporary documents. Mr. Matthew Collet, second in the English factory at Qāsimbāzār, wrote to the Council in Calcutta on the 22nd January, 1757:— "As to Alivardi Cawn's last dying speech to his nephew (? grandson) I look upon it as a specious fable". Mr. Richard Becher, Chief of the Company's factory at Dacca, remarked in his letter to the Council in Calcutta, dated the 25th January, 1757:— "Mr. Holwell will excuse me if I do not admit Alivardi Cawn's speech as genuine till better proofs are brought to support it than I have yet seen. Such advice if really given, it is reasonable to imagine, had few or no witnesses so that it appears very improbable Mr. Holwell in his distressed situation at Muxadabad should have been able to unravel the mysteries of the Cabinet and explore a secret never yet known to any one but himself”. Mr. Watts, Chief of the English Factory at Qāsimbāzār, wrote to the Court of Directors on the 30th January, 1757 :—“The last dying speech of Mahābat Jung or Alivardi Cawn to his grandson neither he, or I believe any of the Gentlemen of the Factory, ever heard of; neither have I since heard from any of the country people; it seems an imitation of the speech of Louis XIV to his grandson, and appears, as Mr. Collet aptly terms it, only a specious fable”. Instigated by the Afghan general Mustafa Khan, Alivardi’s nephews, Shahāmat Jang and Saulat Jang, once proposed to him the expulsion of the English from Bengal. But the old Nawab did not support their proposal, and, after the departure of Mustafa Khan from his court, gave them a significant reply :—“Dear children! Mustafa Khan is a soldier of fortune, . . . He wishes that I should always have occasion to employ him and to put it in his power to ask favours for himself and his friends; but in the name of common sense, what is the matter with your own selves, that you should join issue with him, and make common cause of his opinion? What wrong have the English done, that I should wish them ill? Look at yonder plains; should you set fire to it, there would be no stopping its progress; and who is the man then who shall put out a fire that shall break forth at sea, and from thence come out upon land. Beware of lending an ear to such proposals again; for they will produce nothing but evil”¹
v2.c47.s8.9
¹ Bengal Past and Present, July-Sept., 1915. Hill, II, 129 162, iii: 336:
v2.c47.s8.10
¹ Siyar, ii. 611.