Early Chauhan Dynasties c21: Appendix D: Historicity of Saṁyogitā, the Heroine of the Pṛthvīrāja-Rāso
Early Chauhān Dynasties c21
- Language
- English
Appendix D: Historicity of Saṁyogitā, the Heroine of the Pṛthvīrāja-Rāso
c21.2
The chief arguments advanced against the historicity of Saṁyogitā can, in brief, be given as follows:
c21.3
1. Saṁyogitā is not mentioned in the *Rambhāmañjarī*, a play by Nayachandra Sūri (written c. 1403 A.D.) which has Jayachandra of Kannauj as its hero and describes his qualifications and achievements in nearly two pages.
c21.4
2. Saṁyogitā is not mentioned also in Nayachandra Sūri's poem, the *Hammīramahākāvya*, which deals with the Chauhān hero Hammīra of Raṇthambhor and his ancestors.
c21.5
3. The details of Saṁyogitā's *svayaṁvara* and marriage to Pṛthvīrāja III are too romantic to be true.¹
c21.6
¹ The above arguments were advanced by Dr. G.H. Ojha (vide the *Ojhā-nibandha-saṅgraha*, II, pp. 78-112) and have been repeated, without any attempt at their critical assessment by most of the subsequent writers on the historicity of the *Pṛthvīrājarāso*.
c21.7
But the writers who advance these arguments should first see whether their authorities are really reliable. They have to think also of the nature of the evidence they have. All that the *Rambhāmañjarī*, for instance, says about Jayachandra of Kannauj can be boiled down to this much:
c21.8
(a) That he was a scion of the Ikṣvāku family.
c21.9
(b) That his arms served as an elephant's post for Madanavarman's goddess of fortune.
c21.10
(c) That he was a son of Malladeva and Chandralekhā.
c21.11
(d) That he bore the designation *dalapaṅgula* on account of the immensity of his forces.
c21.12
Of these the first three statements cannot be substantiated. The last one may be true, because he is given a similar designation in the *Pṛthvīrājarāso*. Gāhaḍavāla records do not describe Jayachandra and his ancestors as solar Kṣatriyas. The line actually is said to have come into existence when the solar line had disappeared.² Their modern representatives in the Uttar Pradesh regard themselves as lunar Rājpūts.³ Madanavarman, the Chandel ruler of Jijhotī, passed away before 1165 A.D. How could then Jayachandra, who succeeded to the throne of Banaras and Kannauj in 1170 A.D., be described as doing anything to buttress or destroy Madanavarman's prosperity ? A way out of the difficulty would perhaps be to assume that the reference is to one of Jayachandra's exploits as a *yuvarāja*, but this too is ruled out by the fact that Jayachandra's installation as a *yuvarāja* took place on 16th June, 1168 A.D.,⁴ *i.e.*, nearly three years after Madanavarman's death. Jayachandra's father is said to have been some Malladeva. Gāhaḍavāla records, however, state that Jayachandra was the son of Govindachandra's son, Vijayachandra. If it be assumed that Malladeva was one of Vijayachandra's titles, should not one enquire why the title was known only to Nayachandra Sūri, who wrote the *Rambhāmañjarī* nearly two hundred years after Jayachandra's death, and to none of the numerous Gāhaḍavāla inscriptions incised during the reigns of Vijayachandra and his successors ?⁵
c21.13
² *Āsīdaśītadyutivaṁśajātajkṣmāpālamālāsu divaṁ gatāsu.*
c21.14
³ *Mirzāpur Gazetteer*, p. 204.
c21.15
⁴ R.S. Tripathi, *History of Kanauj*, p. 321.
c21.16
⁵ Dr. R.S. Tripathi has listed 4 inscriptions of Vijayachandra, 16 of Jayachandra and 2 of Hariśchandra.
c21.17
As regards the *Hammīramahākāvya*, it is silent not only about Saṁyogitā's *svayaṁvara* but also about Pṛthvīrāja's victories in his wars with Nāgārjuna, the Chandel ruler Paramardin, the Chaulukya king Bhīmadeva II and the Bhādānakas. It has nothing to say also about Pṛthvīrāja's many marriages, though they are mentioned even in the fragmentary *Pṛthvīrājavijaya*. If on the basis of its silence, we neither regard his wars and victories as unhistorical nor conclude that Pṛthvīrāja remained unmarried, what valid reason can we have to make that very silence the main reason to discredit an old tradition, found at least in three languages, Sanskrit, Persian and old Rājasthānī, and having, as we propose to show, its roots in the contemporary poem, *Pṛthvīrājavijaya* ? No doubt the traditional story of Saṁyogitā is extremely romantic. But romance is a part of life and can therefore be equally true and real. That the story had a romantic setting from the beginning can be inferred from the *Pṛthvīrājavijaya*, which brings earth and heaven together, as it were, before describing the romance.⁶
c21.18
⁶ See the next but one paragraph.
c21.19
Tradition is unanimous in recognising the existence of Saṁyogitā, though sometimes under names that differ from each other. The *Surjanacharita* of the Bengali poet Chandraśekhara, written to commemorate the achievements of Surjan Hāḍā, a scion of the Sapādalakṣa-Raṇthambhor line and a *mansabdār* of Akbar, has almost the same account of the *svayaṁvara* as the *Pṛthvīrājarāso*, though it gives the name of the heroine as Kāntimatī.⁷ As early as the sixteenth century and probably earlier still—because the tradition could not have sprung into existence all of a sudden—the descendants of Pṛthvīrāja III and Hammīra must thus have regarded Kāntimatī—Saṁyogitā as one of their ancestresses. Similarly, Akbar's historian, minister and friend, Abul Fazl, recounts the whole story, mentioning Jayachandra's sacrifice, Saṁyogitā's *svayaṁvara*, the installation of Pṛthvīrāja's statue in the place of a gate-keeper, the carrying away of Saṁyogitā by her lover, and the bravery of his *sāmantas* who fought a rear-guard action to cover the escape of Pṛthvīrāja.⁸ In its most popular form the story, as most historians and students of Hindī literature know, is found in the *Pṛthvīrājarāso*, which originally may have been an *Apabhraṁśa* work written in the thirteenth century of the Vikrama era.⁹
c21.20
⁷ In this connection, the following papers of mine may be consulted:
(a) The historicity of the *Pṛthvīrājarāso*, *IHQ*, 1940.
(b) *Pṛthvīrājarāso kī kathāon kā aitihāsik ādhāra*, *Rājasthānī*, Calcutta, Vol. III, part 3.
(c) *Surjanacharita-mahākāvya*, *Nāgarī Prachāriṇī Patrikā*. 1929.
c21.21
⁸ See the papers listed in the last footnote.
c21.22
⁹ See our paper, "The original *Pṛthvīrājarāso*, an Apabhraṁśa work", in the *Rājasthān Bhāratī*, I, 1, pp. 93-103.
c21.23
According to the *Pṛthvīrājavijaya*, Pṛthvīrāja III fell in love with the heavenly nymph, Tilottamā, even though he had many beautiful queens, the reason for this otherwise inexplicable behaviour being that in his previous life as Rāma, Tilottamā had won his favour by playing excellently the role of Sītā in a play staged by the gods. A little further, we are told that Tilottamā was born as a princess destined to marry Rāma's incarnation, Pṛthvīrāja III¹⁰. Can we identify her with Saṁyogitā of our tradition ? Though the printed editions of the poem do not help us in settling the issue, we are, thanks to further investigations into the manuscript material of the *Pṛthvīrājavijaya* by Dr. S.K. Belvalkar, now in a position to state that the lost verses referred to a *nāka-nadī*, *i.e.*, the Gaṅgā, to a palace or town situated on its bank (*nāka-nadī-taṭa-sthita*), and to certain circumstances in which the heroine with her heart set on her lover could be compared to a *kamalinī* (lotus-flower) thinking of the Sun alone, when faced by the Moon.¹¹ Should not we conclude from these references that she was probably the daughter of a ruler, whose capital was on the bank of the Gaṅgā and who had decided to give her in marriage to a prince who, whatever his other good qualifications may have been, did not enjoy the privilege of having the princess's love ?
c21.24
¹⁰ See the last verse of canto XI and the whole of canto XII.
c21.25
¹¹ The verses are 74-78 of canto 12.
c21.26
The above account has obvious resemblances to the story of Saṁyogitā in the *Pṛthvīrājarāso*. In the *Rāso*, Saṁyogitā is regarded as an incarnation of the heavenly nymph Rambhā. The princess of the *Pṛthvīrājavijaya* is the *apsaras* Tilottamā born in this world. Both the princesses had their residence somewhere near the Gaṅgā, and both obviously had been promised to suitors they did not love. Other resemblances also exist, What is there after all then that makes Saṁyogitā's story incredible ? Her father, Jayachandra, is said to have been on bad terms with Pṛthvīrāja III. We know from history that it was actually so.¹² His putting up of Pṛthvīrāja III's statue at the gate reminds one of an old Rājpūt custom which was calculated to humiliate one's rivals. Dantidurga Rāṣṭrakūṭa, for instance, made his rivals, the Gurjara ruler and some others, his gate-keepers in the *hiraṇyagarbhamahādāna* at Ujjain.¹³ Even *rākṣasa vivāhas* were not unknown to Indian history.¹⁴ Pṛthvīrāja merely carried off a not very unwilling princess. Even in this twentieth century, the present writer has seen a bride being carried away from a marriage *maṇḍapa*.
c21.27
¹² See our account of Pṛthvīrāja III, the last Hindu Emperor of Delhi, *Indian Culture*, 1944.
c21.28
¹³ Sanjan Plates of Amoghavarṣa, *EI*, XVIII, pp. 235-57.
c21.29
¹⁴ Rāṣṭrakūṭa Indra married the Chālukya princess Bhavanāga in this way. We are not quoting examples from the epics, for they may be dismissed as legendary and pre-historic.
c21.30
We, of course, have every right to examine the truth of an old tradition. But if the only arguments that can be advanced against it are those summed up above, the old tradition must be permitted to hold its ground. There is nothing illogical or irrational about it. Nor does it go against any known historical facts.
Cites (5)
- Hammīramahākāvya — Nayacandrasūri, Sanskrit
- Pṛthvīrāj Rāso — Cand Bardāī, Hindi
- Surjanacarita — Candraśekharakavi 1500, Sanskrit
- Pṛthvīrājavijaya — Jayānaka, Sanskrit
- Rambhāmañjarī — Nayacandrasūri, Sanskrit