Early Chauhan Dynasties c45.s2: Section II. (i) Seats of Learning
Early Chauhān Dynasties c45.s2
- Language
- English
Contents
- c45.s2.t1 (ii) System of Studies and Examinations — 10 parts
- c45.s2.t2 (iii) Literacy — 2 parts
- c45.s2.t3 (iv) Some general remarks — 3 parts
Section II. (i) Seats of Learning
c45.s2.1
As feeding and teaching poor students has always been regarded as an act of great merit, there must have been a good many schools endowed by the public. The *Upamitibhavaprapañchakathā* refers to some of these.⁵⁵ Commenting on the word, *Vidyāmaṭha* of the *Dvyāśrayamahākāvya*, Abhayatilakagaṇi states, “*Vidyāmaṭha* is an institution where rich people provide food, garments, and other things to the teachers and the taught, with a view to acquiring merit.”⁵⁶ Jayānaka speaks of *maṭhas* or schools in every square of Ajmer (PV, IX, 24). This indicates the popularity of such institutions in Gurjaratrā, of which western Rājasthān long remained a part, and also Sapādalakṣa almost up to the end of the period with which we are dealing. But of the great colleges established by the Chauhān rulers themselves, we hear of only one. To the *Sarsvatīmandira* founded by the illustrious Vigraharāja IV probably flocked students from all the parts of the Chauhān empire. The Jaina sources describe Jinavallabha's retreat at Chitor also as a great centre of education. Bhīnmāl and Ābū probably were respectively centres of Brahmanical and Tāntric studies. Padmanābha calls Bhīnmāl the *Brahmapurī* of the Chauhāns, the Brāhmaṇas of which were famed far and wide for their learning and performance of Vedic rites.⁵⁷ Ābū was a Śākta *pīṭha*.
c45.s2.2
⁵⁵ See specially p. 624.
c45.s2.3
⁵⁶ I, 7.
c45.s2.4
⁵⁷ *Kānhaḍadeprabandha*, III, 22-29.
(ii) System of Studies and Examinations
c45.s2.t1.1
From the notices that we have in the *Upamitibhavaprapañchakathā*, the *Kharataragachchhapaṭṭāvalī*, and the *Samarāichchakahā* we learn that on an auspicious day fixed by the astrologers, the boy was taken (generally in his eighth year) to the *kalāchārya*, *guru*, or *Upādhyāya* to be taught the various subjects we have discussed in the first section of this chapter and of which a more comprehensive list is given as an Appendix to this chapter. The teacher was given the highest respect. It was a sin to sit on his *vetrāsana*, a procedure so atrocious that it was believed to reduce the transgressor's life span and bring him obloquy everywhere.⁵⁸ The boys received individual attention, even though the classes with individual teachers were sometimes bigger than they should have been according to our modern standards. For special studies, one had to move on from one station to another, for while general studies could be carried on anywhere, expert teaching needed the attention of a specialist,⁵⁹ and not every one could claim like Jinavallabha to be an adept not only in theology and philosophy, but also *sāmudrika*, grammar, *metrics*, *sāhitya* and astrology.⁶⁰
c45.s2.t1.2
⁵⁸ *Upamitibhavaprapañcha-kathā*, p. 305.
c45.s2.t1.3
⁵⁹ See the *Kharataragachchhapaṭṭāvalī* for many instances of this type.
c45.s2.t1.4
⁶⁰ See the *Charchari* of Jinadatta Sūri.
c45.s2.t1.5
The present system of examinations did not exist. But the learning of scholars did not remain untested. Vigraharāja IV convened periodical assemblies of scholars and poets. Pṛthvīrāja III had *paṇḍitas* like Janārdana and Vidyāpati Gauḍa to test the scholarship of people coming to his court and deciding the points at issue between disputants. That not every one could have been, however, satisfied with their verdict, can be seen from the caustic remarks of Jayānaka in the first canto of the *Pṛthvīrājavijaya*.⁶¹ The victor received a *jayapatra* and could be, if his followers were influential enough, carried through the city, with bands playing notes of victory and people dancing and singing. The defeated disputant, on the other hand, became subject to gibes and lampoons. The *paṇḍitasabhā*, where all sorts of "possible and impossible questions" could be asked by the opponent as wall as the *paṇḍitas*, was thus a stiffer testing ground than our examination halls. A less informal test was the *goṣṭhi* where friends vied with each other.⁶²
c45.s2.t1.6
⁶¹ Verses 6-30.
c45.s2.t1.7
⁶² See the *Upamitibhavaprapañchakathā*, pp. 560-1. A very good account is to be found also in Dhanapāla's *Tilakamañjari*.
c45.s2.t1.8
This old system of examination had its merits. It did not let a scholar rest on his laurels. He had to keep fresh his stock of knowledge and even increase it, for fear that he might any day be challenged to a debate by an outsider or by his own rivals from within the kingdom.⁶³ His study had to be intensive; he had to think deeply about questions that could be raised, and it was thus that India made some of its great advances in thought. Most of us who have studied under the old system are familiar enough with its defects also. It sometimes led to endless hair-splitting dicussion, the objective of which instead of being the advancement of truth was merely the vanquishing of the opponents; and in such a debate one naturally used *chhala* as well as *vitaṇḍā*.⁶⁴ It led also scholars sometimes to give all their time to one subject—and that sometimes not the most useful—so that one may claim to be pre-eminent in one sphere, if not more.
c45.s2.t1.9
⁶³ See the account of the disputations, Jinapati Sūri *versus* Padmaprabha and Pradyumna Suri *versus* Jinapati Sūri in the *Kharataragachchhapaṭṭāvalī*.
c45.s2.t1.10
⁶⁴ That these were well known weapons can be seen from the commentaries on the *Nyāyasūtras*.
(iii) Literacy
c45.s2.t2.1
The classes which had the greatest facilities for education and consequently the greatest amount of literacy were the Brāhmaṇas and Jaina *sādhus*. It was the proud boast of Ajayameru, though there may be some poetic exaggeration in it, that its streets resounded with the sound of the Vedas recited regularly in the early hours of the morning.⁶⁵ Vaiśyas, specially those converted to Jainism, produced good scholars like Yaśovīra. Jaina *sādhus*, from whichever community they may have been drawn, were generally literate, though among them also literacy differed from one community to the other, the least literate perhaps being those who had become owners of big religious properties and whose life consequently did not differ much from that of common people. For Kāyasthas, who had by this time grown into a caste, literacy has always been essential, and many of them figure as writers of inscriptions. The *Pāśupata* teachers, Allaṭa and Viśvarūpa, were learned, though on the basis of this scanty evidence, it would be difficult to generalise and say that most of the *Pāśupatas* were literate. In Jaina literature, it is generally the Śaiva ascetics who from the butt of ridicule. We have already spoken above of the limited amount of literacy among women and need not repeat those details.
c45.s2.t2.2
⁶⁵ *PV.*, IX, 24.
(iv) Some general remarks
c45.s2.t3.1
We had a few words to say about the ancient system of examinations. About the system of education in general we may remark that it generally established very cordial relations between the teacher and the taught. Teachers, even though not rich, felt compensated by the universal respect in which they were held by the rich and the poor alike, and had with the freedom given to them a great hand in shaping the lives of their pupils and wards. Even after more than a century of western education, we still hanker after a teacher of the type described in many of our sources and one who, in the words of Yuan Chwang, "forgetting fatigue expatiate(s) in the arts and sciences" and "count(s) not 1000 *li* too long a journey in the pursuit of wisdom".⁶⁶
c45.s2.t3.2
⁶⁶ *On Yuan Chuwang*, Vol. I, p. 161.
c45.s2.t3.3
But of serious defects also, this system had developed many by the end of our period. On the whole it was ill-devised and unpractical. While astrology, *dhātuvāda* and *nimittaśāstra* flourished, Astronomy and Mathematics declined. Bhinmāl which once had been the home of Brahmagupta and Māgha and probably of some more celebrities in the field of science and arts had by the time of Kānhaḍadeva become reduced to a home of *karmakāṇḍin* Brāhmaṇas. India of the Gupta Period made advances in every cultural field. By 800 A.D., this tide of Renaissance had largely spent its force and begun to recede. By 900 A.D. it was a spent force in the field of science, though in other directions some advances continued to be registered. Not merely Rājasthān but almost the whole of India knew in 1200 A.D. no more of pure science than it did nearly five centuries earlier. We were, it seems, suffering from a dose of over-complascence, with the result that Rājasthān of our period was largely unoriginal, uninventive and unprogressive, revelling either in hair-splitting discussions or composition of commentaries, and for this mental sterility, towards the latter part of our period, some part of the blame must assuredly go the educators of our period, who probably by their too much of insistence on other-worldliness, respect for tradition, self-complacency, and isolationist behaviour rendered backward a country which once had been a torch-bearer of culture and scientific progress.
Cites (6)
- Samarāiccakahā — Haribhadra Sūri, Māhārāṣṭrī Prakrit
- Kharataragacchapaṭṭāvalī — Sanskrit
- Upamitibhavaprapañcā Kathā — Siddharṣi, Sanskrit
- Kānhaḍade Prabandha — Padmanābha, Gujarati
- Tilakamañjarī — Dhanapāla, Sanskrit
- Pṛthvīrājavijaya — Jayānaka, Sanskrit