Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

The Sultanate of Delhi, 711–1526 A.D. c24.s6: Justice and Peace

The Sultanate of Delhi, 711–1526 A.D. c24.s6

Language
English

Justice and Peace

c24.s6.1

The *diwan-i-qaza* (department of justice) was the weakest and most ill-organised department of administration. The Sultan, being the fountainhead of justice, was responsible for upholding and maintaining the Quranic law which, in theory, was the only law recognised by the Sultanate of Delhi. He was, therefore, the head of the department of justice, held court twice a week and decided cases in person. But, though normally the highest court of appeal, he often tried original cases also. When called upon to decide religious cases, the Sultan was assisted by the chief *sadr* (*sadr-us-sudur*) and the *mufti*; but in secular cases he had the assistance of the chief *qazi* (*qazi-ul-qazat*). Throughout our period these two high offices, namely, those of the chief *sadr* and the chief *qazi* had one and the same person as their incumbent. This person sat with the king in two capacities—as chief *sadr* in religious cases and as chief *qazi* in secular cases.

c24.s6.2

The chief *qazi* was designated as the head of the department of justice, but he was only its nominal head; for the department was, in fact, controlled by the Sultan himself. The chief *qazi* constituted himself as the highest court of appeal only when the Sultan's court was not in session. Even when he acted as the highest court of appeal, his decisions were liable to be revised by the Sultan. Nor was the chief *qazi* the real administrative head; for we are told that the Sultan appointed provincial and district *qazi* and *amir-i-dad* in important cities, may be on the chief *qazi*'s recommendation, and was the *de facto* incharge of their postings, transfer and dismissal. The chief *qazi* lived and held his court at the capital. He was assisted by a *mufti* (legal interpreter); he supervised the provincial judges and heard appeals from their decisions.

c24.s6.3

There was an *amir-i-dad* in big cities whose office seems to correspond to that of the modern city magistrate. He had two duties to discharge, that is, to apprehend criminals and to try cases with the help of the *qazi*. He was, thus, both a judge and an executive officer. In the latter capacity, he was required to enforce the *qazi*'s decisions and to co-operate with the *muhtasib* in enforcing his regulations. He had an assistant, known as the *naib-i-dadbak*.

c24.s6.4

There was a *qazi* in every province and one in every district. Important cities had *qazis* and *amir-i-dads*. The government left small towns and rural areas, which, in those days, comprised ninety per cent of the population, untouched and appointed no judicial officers of its own to administer justice. Fortunately, our villages were tiny self-sufficient commonwealths and had their own *panchayats*, which not only decided all their disputes but also enforced their decisions. The people, therefore were happy to be left undisturbed by their foreign masters whose rule over the villages existed only for the collection of revenue.

c24.s6.5

Notwithstanding Dr. I. H. Qureshi’s rhetoric, contemporary Persian chronicles yield the above picture, in brief. Their perusal reveals glaring defects in the administration of justice. There was no proper grading of the courts with clearly defined jurisdictions. The suitor could lodge a complaint or file a suit anywhere he liked. He could, for instance, go to the court of the *qazi* of his town or to that of the provincial *qazi* or even to the Sultan’s court. The highest court of appeal also tried original cases, that is, cases in the first instance. Then, the judicial procedure was not uniform all over the kingdom and was very irregular. Cases were started without due enquiries. The proceedings of the court were not recorded and the trials were summary trials. The law administered by the courts was the Quranic law. Cases between Muslims and Hindus were decided by the *qazi* on the basis of this law. Customary law which was administered in the trial of secular cases in which the parties belonged to different faiths, was not the written law and hence could be interpreted according to the individual judge’s lights and whims. Great injustice must generally have been the result in regard to a suppliant for justic whose religion differed from that of the *qazi*.

c24.s6.6

The penal law was very severe. Culprits were usually punished with mutilation and death. The usual practice was to make use of force and torture to extort confession from the convicts. Although the government followed the policy of minimum interference with the social affairs of the Hindus and applied what was designated as the *ghair tashrii* law in deciding their cases, yet grave injustice must have been the result, as, in those days, there were no *vakils* to place the complainant’s point of view before the judge. The chief *qazi* was at once the chief religious officer (*sadr-us-sudur*) and the chief judge. Obviously, such a person could hardly adopt a strictly neutral and impartial attitude in a case in which the parties belonged to different religions. Moreover, the chief *qazi*, and the *qazis* in the provinces, districts and towns had many other duties of a secular as well as religious nature to perform, which must have diverted their attention from their main duty. They had, for instance, to supervise and manage the property of the orphans and the lunatics, to execute testamentary dispositions and to supervise the property given away in endowments. They had also to help destitute Muslim widows and to find suitable husbands for them. Another work entrusted to them was the prevention of encroachment on public thoroughfares and open spaces. They were required to nominate persons to take charge of contested property. Their multifarious activities, which had little to do with their judicial duties, must have greatly stood in the way of their administering even-handed justice. Above all, most of the area had no government judicial officers and the people were obliged to have recourse to devise their own means to settle their disputes.

c24.s6.7

There was no police worth the name except a *kotwal* in important cities. The term *kotwal* is derived from the Sanskrit word ‘kotpal’ which shows that he must have originally been a military officer. He had a small contingent of men under him and his main duty was to maintain peace and order in his jurisdiction. There was another officer, known as *muhtasib*, in every province and in every important town. His duties were partly secular. Besides enforcing the Islamic regulations and seeing that the Muslims said their five daily prayers and kept the fast of Ramzan and observed other religious ordinances in their daily life, he had to control the markets and to regulate weights and measures. He enforced the regulation relating to the prohibition from intoxicants, such as, liquor, *bhang*, *ganja* and other drugs of a like nature. There was no police in the villages and even in small towns. There were no well-constituted prison-houses. Old forts and castles were utilised as prisons. The prison administration was lax and corruption among jail officials was common.

c24.s6.8

Throughout the period of the Sultanate of Delhi, Islam was the religion of the State. It was considered to be the duty of the Sultan and his government to defend and to uphold the principles of this religion and to propagate them among the masses. According to the Quranic law it is the highest duty of a Muslim king to put down idolatry, to fight a holy war (*jihad*) against non-Muslims and to convert *dar-ul-harb* (non-Muslim territory) into *dar-ul-Islam* (Muslim land). In view of the clear injunctions given in their holy book, the Quran, the Sultans of Delhi were anxious to convert their Hindu subjects to Islam; but practical difficulties and political wisdom compelled them not to indulge in a perpetual war against them. Nevertheless, some of the over-zealous Sultans, such as Firoz Tughluq and Sikandar Lodi, utilised state machinery and funds for religious propaganda. But the politically-minded Sultans, like Ala-ud-din Khalji or Muhammad bin Tughluq, refrained from making use of state resources and machinery for religious propaganda and proselytisation. Yet even the most enlightened among them, like Muhammad bin Tughluq, upheld the principles of their faith and refused permission to repair Hindu or Buddhist temples. For instance, when the emperor of China sent an embassy to Delhi to request permission to repair Budhhist temples which had suffered destruction at the hands of the Sultan’s army during his Qarajal expedition, Muhammad bin Tughluq refused it on the ground that his religion forbade him from acceding to the request. Thus even during the reign of the so-called liberal-minded Sultans, the Hindus had no permission to build new temples or to repair old ones. Throughout the period, they were known as *zimmis*, that is, people living under guarantee and the guarantee was that they would enjoy restricted freedom in following their religion if they paid the *jizya*. The *zimmis* were not to celebrate their religious rites openly or offensively and never to do any propaganda on behalf of their religion. A number of disabilities were imposed upon them in matters of State employment and enjoyment of civic rights. In fact they were not treated as full-fledged citizens of the State. It was a practice with the Sultans to destroy the Hindu temples and the images therein. Firoz Tughluq and Sikandar Lodi prohibited the Hindus from bathing at the ghats in the sacred rivers and encouraged them in every possible way to embrace the Muslim religion. The converts were exempted from the *jizya* and given posts in the State service and even granted rewards in cash or by grant of land. In short, there was not only no real freedom for the Hindus to follow their religion, but the state followed a policy of intolerance and persecution. The contemporary Muslim chronicles abound in detailed descriptions of desecration of images and destruction of temples and of the conversion of hundreds and thousands of the Hindus. Our religious buildings and places bear witness to the iconoclastic zeal of the Sultans and their followers. One has only to visit Ajmer, Mathura, Ayodhya, Banaras and other holy cities to see the half broken temples and images of those times with their heads, faces, hands and feet defaced and demolished.

c24.s6.9

Some of the modern Muslim writers have made an endeavour to show that the Sultans did not follow a policy of intolerence and persecution. They maintain that temples and idols were destroyed only during war; that the Hindu temples were converted into mosques and, therefore, not shown any disrespect; and that by putting down idolatry the Sultans taught the Hindus to believe in one God and, therefore, rendered them a service. One writer (Dr. Sufi, vide his *History of Kashmir*) has gone to the extent of saying that certain sections among the Hindus, like the Arya Samajists, preach against idol worship. Medieval Muslims enforced what the Arya Samajists have been preaching now. Dr. Muhammad Nazim maintains that the Hindu temples, being store-houses of wealth, invited trouble for themselves. A scholarly theologian, Maulana Sulaiman Nadvi, advises us not to take the hyperbolic statements of the contemporary historians, like Minhaj-us-Siraj, Zia-ud-din Barani, Shams-i-Siraj Afif and Yahiya bin Ahmad and others who have given graphic descriptions of religious persecution, temple-destructions and image-breaking in their works, too seriously, as they were meant, according to him, for the perusal of the Islamic peoples outside India.

c24.s6.10

It is not necessary to examine these views at length. The arguments are palpably weak and their authors unaccustomed to see the other side of a case. To take up the first, it is easy to imagine that a fanatical Sultan could declare an unprovoked war against his independent Hindu neighbour and then carry on a campaign of destruction of temples and images and conversion of the innocent Hindu population. He would, of course, have the self-righteous satisfaction that he was doing all this during war. And his modern apologist, knowing though he may be that ninety-nine out of a hundred wars fought by the Sultans of Delhi were unprovoked wars, would justify the wanton persecution by quoting the exploded slogan that “everything is fair in love and war.” Moreover, there are numerous instances on record that in normal times of peace temple-destruction and image-breaking was often resorted to. As regards the second argument, it would be perhaps permissible to enquire as to how would the author of the argument feel if a mosque were transformed into a temple. It will, of course, remain a sacred place in-spite of its transformation. As for the plea that the much-valued unity of Godhood was impressed upon the Hindu population by destroying stone images, it will be admitted that it defeated its own object and looked like sending people to heaven by force and against their will. It is unfortunate that our Turkish and Afghan rulers could not see that the Hindus in general have believed in the unity of God through the ages and that the image-worship, according to them, is only a means to an end. The great Muslim scholar and savant, Al-Beruni, clearly realised this. Dr. Nazim seems to belong to that old fraternity which imposed 'purda' on women lest their looks should invite trouble from the vagrant males. He will perhaps appreciate the naked truth that the sin of the Hindus consisted in their failure to make an example of the fanatical brigands rather than their thrift and piling up of wealth. Maulana Sulaiman Nadvi's advice amounts to this : do not believe in the detailed account and facts and figures given by the contemporary Muslim writers for they were propagandists; have faith in the generalisations of modern writers, for propaganda has no place in the writings of the 20th century scholars. The modern reader is free to draw his own conclusions. He can easily separate the wheat from the chaff.

c24.s6.11

The Sultans of Delhi and a vast majority of the Muslim population of the Sultanate being orthodox Sunnis, were absolutely opposed to the Shias and other dissenting sects in Islam. They were animated by a firm desire to root out heresy. In fact, their policy aimed at extirpating dissent in Islam. Karmathians, Shias, Mahdavis and other sects were, therefore, mercilessly repressed and their practices put down. Sometimes their leaders were tortured and even put to death. The Shias were particularly looked down upon as heretics. Firoz Tughluq took credit for placing a ban on the practices of the Shia religion and for persecuting its followers. He ordered their religious books to be publicly burnt. As far as possible, the Shias were not given posts in the State service. No king during this period employed Persian Shias in key-posts or in places of trust and responsibility. It was inevitable that the followers of dissenting Islamic sects should be dissatisfied. The discontent of the Karmathians found expression in open rebellions and violence in the time of Iltutmish and also in that of Raziah; but they were put down with a high hand. A majority of the shaikhs, who were liberal-minded mystics, were also looked at with disfavour, because they were unorthodox in their views and had a large following. In short, the period was one of rigid and narrowminded religious orthodoxy.

Cites (1)