Civil Disobedience in Indian Tradition, with Some Early Nineteenth Century Documents c5.s1.t5: Events at Bhagalpur
Civil Disobedience in Indian Tradition, with Some Early Nineteenth Century Documents c5.s1.t5
- Language
- English
Events at Bhagalpur
c5.s1.t5.1
Great opposition to the tax was however manifested in Bhagalpur at this time. On October 2, the collector of Bhagalpur reported:
c5.s1.t5.2
The day before yesterday, being Monday, the 30th September, the collection was to have commenced but on the appearance of the *tahsildar*, they one and all shut up shops and houses. Yesterday, the officers of Government were unable to make any progress in their business, and in the evening while I was driving out in my carriage, several thousands of the inhabitants were standing on either side of the road. They neither committed nor offered any violence, but poured forth complaints of the hardness of their situation, and clamorously declared their inability to pay the tax. (p. 109)
c5.s1.t5.3
This was further corroborated by the magistrate, in his letter to Government on the following day. After detailing the facts of the shutting of the shops, the magistrate stated:
c5.s1.t5.4
I consequently yesterday morning summoned the principal people before me and explained to them the impropriety of their conduct and how useless it was for them to resist the orders of Government. They however declared in a body that they would give up their houses, and leave the town, but never would consent voluntarily to pay the tax, the nature of which had not even been explained to them. (p. 112)
c5.s1.t5.5
The magistrate, however, added that notwithstanding their opposition, 'they were ready to pay it whenever the collections should commence at Moorshedabad', or any adjacent zillah and he, therefore, deemed it advisable to ask the collector to suspend the collection for a few days. The collector resenting the interference of the magistrate, and thinking that the magistrate's setting himself, 'against its operation in its very first stage, because a lawless rabble assembles, is striking at the root of that power, which the Government ought to possess over the subject', sought the guidance of the Government. The Government in its deliberations on the subject of October 11, concurred with the collector and expressing its 'disapproval' of the conduct of the magistrate felt that the steps he had taken in suspending the collection of the tax was 'naturally calculated to excite a combination among the inhabitants of Bhaugulpore, and the inhabitants of Moorshedabad, Patna and other places.' It ordered the magistrate to ‘withdraw the order forthwith’ in ‘the most public manner possible’ and ‘to afford every aid and support to the collector’ in ‘regard to the collection of the house tax.’ (pp.113-4)
c5.s1.t5.6
The order reached Bhagalpur around October 20. At 10 p.m. on the 21st, the collector informed the Government:
c5.s1.t5.7
I am sorry to acquaint you that in carrying into execution the collection of the house tax I was this evening most grossly assaulted in my carriage. Bricks, stone and every description of offensive missile was hurled at my head.
c5.s1.t5.8
I am most severely cut in my face, and in my head: and had I not affected my escape into Mr. Glass’s house, nothing on earth could have saved my life. (p.114)
c5.s1.t5.9
The account of this particular incident as reported by the magistrate and by his assistant, the later acting magistrate, was wholly different. In his letter of November 15, the magistrate stated that he had ‘every reason to believe (and this is also the opinion of the other gentlemen in the town), that had he [i.e. the collector] not irritated the mob, by flogging them, the assault never could have taken place’, and further that the collector ‘deviates from the truth’ when he stated to the Government that ‘he was assaulted in carrying into execution the collection of the house tax.’ Such statements at this stage, however, appeared to the Government ‘as taking advantage of a mere inaccuracy of expression employed in the preparation of a hurried and urgent despatch.’
c5.s1.t5.10
Even the belated recognition of ‘a mere inaccuracy of expression’ did not exist on the day the Government at Calcutta received the express communication of the collector reporting the assault on himself ‘in carrying into execution the collection of the house tax.’ It immediately adopted a detailed resolution recalling its earlier order of October 11, and suspended the magistrate, as it felt ‘that the native inhabitants of Bhagalpur would not have ventured to offer the insults and outrages, described in the foregoing letter, to the collector and in his person to the Government itself, had the magistrate’ adopted ‘necessary precautions for the maintenance of the public peace and for the due support of the collector’ with ‘regard to the collection of the house tax.’ It further decided, as it informed the directing authorities in England on October 29, 1811, ‘to depute an officer of greater firmness and activity to take charge’ of the magistrate’s office and desired the person so deputed to ‘make it an object of his particular attention to enforce payment of the tax.’ This direction, incidentally, as stated previously, had four days earlier been preceded with the Government’s view of the expediency of abrogating the tax. Finally, it requested the military authorities to arrange the sending of additional military force to Bhagalpur ‘with the view of supporting the collector and the officers of police in the discharge of their public duty’, if felt necessary by them.
c5.s1.t5.11
The resolution of the Government was of little consequence to the immediate events at Bhagalpur, as it did not reach the local authorities before the people’s protests were put down. Yet the overcoming or crumbling of ‘opposition or resistance’ had caused considerable headache and anxiety to the local authorities. Some of it arose from the divergent views held by the collector and the magistrate about how to handle the situation: the collector stood for effective and ‘vigorous effort in support of the authority of Government’, while the magistrate, who had actual responsibility for police and military action, tended to follow a quieter and somewhat less violent course.
c5.s1.t5.12
Regarding the meetings of the people on the 22nd, the magistrate reported on the 24th:
c5.s1.t5.13
[I] sent for some troops to meet me at Shahjunghy, whither I proceeded after waiting a short time to allow them to arrive. We there found about eight thousand persons assembled, but totally unarmed. The principal of them kept in the centre of the crowd so that it was impossible to apprehend them, and as I was informed on the spot were performing funeral ceremonies. They, however dispersed after having been repeatedly told that if they remained they would be fired at. They then requested permission to present a petition the next morning which I agreed to receive giving them fully to understand that the collection of the tax would not be suspended, nor the petition received unless presented to me in court in a regular and respectful manner. After the dispersions there remained a numerous rabble consisting partly of weavers and other artificers, the rest old women and children. I spoke to some of them who expressed an apprehension that if they began to disperse those who remained last would be fired upon. But on being assured that this would not be done they agreed to disperse, left the place at the same time we did, and returned respectively to their houses. (pp.122)
c5.s1.t5.14
Further, the commanding officer of the Hill Rangers stated:
c5.s1.t5.15
‘When the principal people retired last evening, the remaining part of the mob, women and their children seemed to have no dread of the consequence of firing among them, but rather sought it.’ He advised the magistrate to have ‘all the desirable force’ present when the people came to present the petition, or ‘better not to receive them’ but ‘to desire that their *arzee* may be sent to you when you can act accordingly.’ Next day, the magistrate reported to the Government that he ‘had no account of the petition mentioned the evening before.’ On the evening of the 23rd, distraint with the support of the military was resorted to and as the collector reported 24 hours later ‘last night’s transaction has indeed changed the face of things.’ Meanwhile, the magistrate had also taken other measures and further requested the magistrates of adjacent districts to prevent ‘people proceeding from your district to Bhaugulpore in bodies exceeding the number of ten and to intercept all arms which may be supposed to be intended for Bhaugulpore’, and further ‘to intercept all native communications of a suspicious tendency and forward the same’ to him. Some confusion, however, arose soon after this pacification. Following the resolution of the Government of October 22, regarding its intention of suspending the collection of the house tax, the Board of Revenue had informed the Bhagalpur collector to discontinue the collection. Such instruction to Bhagalpur evoked strong censure from the Government, and the collection of the tax was resumed.
c5.s1.t5.16
In January 1812, it was reported that the European residents of Bhagalpur declined to pay the house tax. As it was felt by Government that they were in no respect ‘implicated in the circumstances which rendered the continuance of the house tax necessary at that station’, the collector was instructed not to enforce payment of the house tax from the Europeans residing in that district. Still earlier, the European residents from the suburbs of Calcutta had also refused payment of the tax and the advocate-general opined that he was doubtful if it could be enforced on them through distraint of property. Consequently, its operation from the suburbs of Calcutta, where the Government had earlier intended to continue it even after its abrogation in other cities and towns, was also suspended. While communicating this order on January 21, 1812, the Government further informed the Board of Revenue that ‘the Governor-General-in-Council has it in contemplation to pass a Regulation for abolishing Regulation XV, 1810.’ The abolishing Regulation was passed on May 8, 1812, as Regulation VII, 1812.
c5.s1.t5.17
The first intimation of the protests arising from the imposition of the house tax was conveyed to the directing authorities in London by the Bengal Government through its Revenue letter of February 12, 1811. Its receipt and consideration led to the preparation of Draft No.218 of 1811-12 on May 23, 1812. A passage in the original draft (which was expunged by the Board of Commissioners for the Affairs of India in the final stages, only for the reason that it became redundant due to the intended abrogation of the house tax), ran as follows:
c5.s1.t5.18
Having most attentively and seriously deliberated upon the subject, as you must be convinced from the present discussion, we should have felt inclined to direct the abolition of the house tax. But from an apprehension we entertain that this measure might be mistakenly considered as originating in a disposition on the part of your Government to yield to the influence of popular clamour...we are willing therefore to hope that under the modifications which you had it in contemplation to adopt...the same has, since the date of your letter been quietly collected. (pp.170-1)
c5.s1.t5.19
This passage further stated:
c5.s1.t5.20
But if notwithstanding these modifications...it has continued to be obnoxious...we think you ought to adopt the most speedy measures for its repeal, and which you think it will be possible for you to carry into execution, without compromising in too conspicuous a manner the authority of Government. (p.171)
c5.s1.t5.21
But there was really little need for communicating such sentiments to Calcutta. The Government in Calcutta had a similar view and wholly shared the sentiment that any ‘repeal’ of the tax should only be carried ‘into execution, without compromising in too conspicuous a manner the authority of Government.’ Months before London prepared and considered the relevant dispatch, the Revenue letter from Bengal of December 14, 1811 had stated:
c5.s1.t5.22
Arguments indeed were not wanting for the continuance of the tax, founded on the necessity of supporting the authority of Government and repressing the spirit of resistance which had been manifested to the exercise of its legitimate powers. The inhabitants of Benares however had long ago yielded an unconditional submission to public authority; and exclusively of that consideration it will be observed, that we neither intended to proceed to the
c5.s1.t5.23
immediate abolition of the tax, nor to extend the benefits of that measure to any place at which (to use the terms of our instructions to the Board of Revenue) ‘commotions originating in a resistance to the operation of the tax might exist at the period of the receipt of these orders’. (p.157)