Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

Obscure Religious Cults as Background of Bengali Literature c13.s2: (ii) Criticism from The Yoga Point of View

Obscure Religious Cults as Background of Bengali Literature c13.s2

Language
English

(ii) Criticism from The Yoga Point of View

c13.s2.1

From the above it will be clear that the view that it may be possible to attain some religious experience through an intense emotion or even through some strong sensation is not very uncommon in the field of Indian religious thought. But as this view is closely associated with the question of a state of arrest, which is so much emphasised in the Pātañjala system of yoga, it will not be unfair to make some comment on it from the yoga point of view.

c13.s2.2

The exponents of yoga have admitted the fact that it may be possible to attain a state of arrest even through some strong sensation or emotion; but that kind of arrest of mind is very transitory and as such falls far short of the final state of Samādhi. Samādhi of yoga proper does not mean a temporary arrest of mind,—it means a permanent state of arrest which removes all our afflictions and which eradicates all mental complexes and root-instincts that serve as the seed of the future recurrence of life and suffering.

c13.s2.3

In the yoga scheme of psychology there have been recognised five planes of mind, which are technically known as the five *citta-bhūmis*. These are, (1) *kṣipta*, (2) *mūḍha*, (3) *vikṣipta*, (4) *ekāgra* and (5) *niruddha*. The *kṣipta*

c13.s2.4

kṣutādyante bhaye śoke gahvare vā ranāddrute |
kutūhale kṣudhādyante brahma-sattvāmayī daśā ||

c13.s2.5

But the reading of the verse as quoted in the commentary on the *Spanda-sūtras* by Utpalācāryya is as follows :-

c13.s2.6

krodhādyante bhaye śoke gahvare vāraṇe raṇe |
kutūhale kṣudhādyante brahma-sattā samīpagā ||

c13.s2.7

state is the ordinary unsteady state of mind which is always changing from one object to another. The second state is the state in which mind under the sway of some strong sensation or emotion, lies infatuated, as it were. In this state there is the excess of the *tamas* (i.e., the gross material stuff) and under the sway of the *tamas* mind falls asleep, or, swooning, as it were. The third state is the state of *vikṣipta*, which is distinguished from the *kṣipta* state by the possibility therein of temporary arrest of the mental states. It is the momentary steadiness that the mind may have amidst its unsteady changes. The other two states are *ekāgra* (one-pointed) and *niruddha* (perfectly arrested). Of these two the *ekāgra* state has been explained by Vācaspati in his commentary as *eka-tāna*, which literally means ‘one-tuned,’ i.e., the state where all the mental states attain an oneness in deep concentration on some particular object of meditation. This *ekāgra* state leads to the next state which is the state of final arrest (*niruddha*).

c13.s2.8

Now of the five planes (*bhūmi*) of the mind only the last two are recognised as the planes of yoga proper. Temporary arrest may be possible in the *mūḍha* and *vikṣipta* planes also,—but they cannot be recognised as states of yoga as there is the possibility of their relapse to ordinary active states at any moment. The important thing in yoga proper is not therefore somehow to attain a state of arrest, but to well-prepare the planes of mind for Samādhi. If the plane be well-prepared even active states cannot disturb the mind.

c13.s2.9

If we examine the states of Samādhi described particularly by the Kāśmīra-school of Śaivism, we shall be tempted to say that many of these states can be classed as the *mūḍha* state of mind and only a few of them fall within the state of *ekāgra*. There is no denial of the fact that when we are deeply absorbed in any intense emotion, we transcend our ordinary physical, biological and psychological existence,—and even it may be admitted that such states of transcendental emotion approximate in nature deep religious experience, but the question remains, how far it will be correct to accept all such states to be identical with our supreme religious experience. In states of great hunger, anger, jealousy, fear, curiosity, sex-passions, etc., there may be a temporary sleep of the ordinary mental states and processes,—but they being outside the plane of yoga may at any time relapse into activity, and for this reason such states should never be confused with the final state of Samādhi.

c13.s2.10

To judge the state of Samarasa of the Tāntriks or of Mahā-sukha of the Buddhist Sahajiyās, or the state of supreme love of the Vaiṣṇava Sahajiyās, we should first of all examine the citta-bhūmi in which such a realisation is possible. If the realisation be in any of the first three planes of the citta, i.e., if it be a mere state of sleep of the senses, or just like a state of swoon of a temporary nature then it cannot be recognised as a state of yoga proper. Everything, therefore, depends on the plane of citta. The Tāntriks and the Sahajiyās were conscious of this truth and they laid sufficient stress on it. All the stringent conditions laid by the Tāntriks and the Sahajiyās for the esoteric practice may be viewed from the yoga point of view as conditions for a proper plane of citta where the absorption of the psychical processes may amount to a state of Samādhi. Whenever the esoteric practice is resorted to in a lower plane the result produced must be dangerous; it is for this reason that the Sahajiyās repeatedly declared that a real Sahajiyā Sādhaka is rarely found even among crores (koṭike goṭik hay).

Cites (1)