Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

Obscure Religious Cults as Background of Bengali Literature c7.s3: (iii) Origin and Development of Tāntric Buddhism

Obscure Religious Cults as Background of Bengali Literature c7.s3

Language
English

(iii) Origin and Development of Tāntric Buddhism

c7.s3.1

The phase of later Buddhism, widely and roughly known as Tāntric Buddhism, may be said to be a popular development of Mahāyāna Buddhism through a gradual process of centuries having its fullest sway during the period between the eighth and twelfth centuries A.C. Mahāyāna or the ‘Great Vehicle,’ as contrasted with the ethico-religious rigorism of Hinayāna, or the ‘Little Vehicle,’ was a religion of progress and liberalism. In the *Mahāyāna-sūtrā-laṅkāra* of Asaṅga Hinayāna has been characterised as a very narrow system of religion,—narrow in its aim of self-liberation, narrow teachings to realise that aim, narrow method applied for this realisation, insufficiency of equipment and the shortness of time within which final liberation is guaranteed.¹ On the other hand, the Mahāyāna school represents the religion of the dissenters and the protestants and was always characterised by a broadness of outlook and deep sympathy for the suffering beings of the whole universe.

c7.s3.2

¹ *Mahāyāna-sūtrā-laṅkāra*, Ch. I, Verse 10. Lévi's edition.

c7.s3.3

Mahāyāna as contrasted with Hinayāna.

c7.s3.4

Tradition says that after the death of Buddha there arose a great controversy among his followers as to the correct interpretation of the sayings of the master as well as about the rules of discipline indispensable for a monk. To settle these controversies great councils were held. It is said that in the second council held in Vesāli the controversy finally ended in a split among the Buddhists, and the dissenters convened another great assembly (Mahāsangha) to have a separate school of their own and they were known as the Mahāsānghika. In this way, as time passed, the controversy between these radicalists and the orthodox elders (thera) began to be more and more uncompromising and the points of dissension were also gradually increasing in number. This controversy between the elders and the radicalists finally resulted in the growth of the two separate schools within the province of Buddhism itself, the canonical tenets of the elders being styled as Hinayāna and the tenets of the radicalists as Mahāyāna.

c7.s3.5

Among the radical changes in thought and outlook that we find in Mahāyāna, as contrasted with Hinayāna, the most important is the change in the conception of the final goal. Whereas the summum bonum of Hinayāna is to attain Arhathood or final liberation of the self from the whirl of existence through strict ethical discipline and the processes of ‘Jhāna’ (Sk. dhyāna, meditation), the final aim of Mahāyāna was to attain Buddhahood in and through different stages of Bodhisattvahood, which is a state of perfect knowledge about the void-nature of the self and the not-self mixed up with an emotion of universal compassion for the redemption of all the suffering beings. The conception of Bodhisattvahood, very important as it is in Mahāyāna Buddhism as well as in all forms of Tāntric Buddhism, requires some elaboration. The belief of the followers of Mahāyāna is that every man, nay, every being of the world, is a potential Buddha; he has within him all the potency of becoming the perfectly enlightened one (Samyak-sambuddha), which latent possibility can be made patent only through the attainment of perfect knowledge, associated with universal compassion, which prompts one to utilise that knowledge in missionary activities for the uplift of all beings. The ideal of missionary life was consequently preferred to the ideal of the attainment of final extinction (*nirvāṇa*). Bodhisattva-hood means the attainment of the Bodhi-mind (*Bodhi-citta*), which is defined as a unified state of vacuity (*śūnyatā*) and universal compassion (*karuṇā*).¹

c7.s3.6

¹ *śūnyatā-karuṇā-bhinnam bodhi-cittam iti smṛtam* | Śrī-guhya-samāja-tantra (G.O.S.), p. 153.

c7.s3.7

The other noteworthy departure in Mahāyāna was the development of the docetic conception of the three Kāyas (bodies) of the Buddha. The Hinayānists conceived the Buddha only as a historical personage in the life and activities of Śākyamuni; but with the Mahāyānists the Buddha is no particular historical personage, he is but the ultimate principle as the totality of things and beings in an unqualified state of all-existence. This ultimate principle has three aspects, known as the three Kāyas of the Buddha, *viz.*, the Dharma-kāya (*i.e.*, primordial element, or the ‘thatness’ underlying all that exists), the Sambhoga-kāya (the body of bliss, or the effulgent body in the form of the Bodhisattvas) and the Nirmāṇa-kāya (*i.e.*, the body of transformation, or the historical personage of Buddha).² With these fundamental changes in outlook and a predominance of philosophical thought and the culture of the supreme virtues (*pāramitā*) Mahāyāna Buddhism flowed on side by side with Hinayāna for centuries. But as, on the one hand, this freedom of thought, broadness of outlook and spirit of liberalism liberated Buddhism from the walls of narrow scholasticism and raised it from the selfish hankering of personal liberation to the sublimity of a religion for suffering humanity, it, on the other hand, contained the germs of indiscipline and the revelry of wild thoughts which reduced Buddhism to a body of unintelligible mutterings and a system of practices which are definitely unconventional. It should be observed that the pledge of Mahāyāna was the redemption of suffering humanity as a whole, nay, the liberation of all beings. With this end in view the apostles of Mahāyāna had to make their religion catholic enough to make it acceptable even to the most ordinary people of the society. In other words, Mahāyāna, as a religion for all people, had to make provision within its fold for people of widely different tastes and intellectual calibre. It is for this reason that heterogeneous elements of faith and religious practices began first to creep in and then to rush into the province of Buddhism.

c7.s3.8

² Vide infra.

c7.s3.9

Degeneration by too much popularisation. For ordinary people religion consists in the belief in innumerable gods and goddesses, in time-honoured customs, muttering of mystic formulas, and in the paraphernalia of rites, ceremonies and practices; when through the zeal of liberating all the beings from the bondage of existence Mahāyāna began to be too much popularised, all these popular religious elements of heterogeneous nature began to be incorporated into Buddhism. Though the general custom is to style this composite religious system of heterogeneous faiths and practices as Tāntric Buddhism, the raison d’être of Tāntric Buddhism is not to be sought in this popular phase of the religion. It seems that with the purpose of attaining the final state of Buddhahood a new school developed within the province of Buddhism itself with a more forward policy. This forward school introduced elements like the Mantras and the Dhāraṇīs into the province of this religion. It is for this reason that in the Tattva-ratnāvalī collected in the Advaya-vajra-saṃgraha (edited by MM. H. P. Śāstrī, G. O. S., No. XL), we find Mahāyāna sub-divided into two schools, viz., Pāramitā-naya and Mantra-naya. The principles of Mantra-naya are said to

c7.s3.10

Rise of Tāntric Buddhism.

c7.s3.11

be very deep and subtle and inaccessible to ordinary men; and though the ultimate purpose of the Mantra-śāstra is the same as that of other Śāstras, it is said to be distinctly superior to them because of the fact that it is free from delusions and is accessible only to people with a higher intellectual calibre.¹ This Mantra-naya or Mantra-yāna seems to be the introductory stage of Tāntric Buddhism, from which all other offshoots, like Vajra-yāna, Kālacakra-yāna, Sahaja-yāna, etc., arose in later times. In the Laghu-kāla-cakra-tantra-rāja-ṭīkā, entitled Vimala-prabhā² we find that the doctrines of the Pāramitā-naya are written wholely in Sanskrit, while those of the Mantra-naya are explained in Sanskrit, Prakrit, Apabhraṃśa and even in non-Sanskritic languages like those of the Śavaras and others.

c7.s3.12

¹ Tattva-ratnāvali in Advaya-vajra-samgraha, p. 21.

c7.s3.13

² MS., R. A. S. B., No. 4727.

c7.s3.14

Tradition holds Asaṅga, the great exponent of the Yogācāra school, to be responsible for the introduction of Tāntricism in Buddhism; he again, in his turn, is believed to have been initiated into this mystic cult by Maitreya in the Tuṣita-heaven. Others, on the other hand, hold that Nāgārjuna, the renowned exponent of the Mādhyamika school, was the real founder of the esoteric school, and that he, in his turn, received the doctrines from the Celestial Buddha Vairocana through the divine Bodhisattva Vajra-sattva in the "iron tower" in South India.

c7.s3.15

Apart from these traditions, some scholars are disposed to think that the Mahāyāna-sūtrā-laṅkāra of Asaṅga there are clear references to the sexo-yogic practice of the Tāntric Buddhists. In the Sūtrā-laṅkāra the word "parāvṛtti" occurs several times in connection with acts which constitute the supreme greatness of the Buddha. One of these verses runs thus, " In the *parāvṛtti* of sexual union supreme greatness is obtained, (namely) in the enjoyment of Buddha-happiness and in looking without impure thoughts at a wife."¹ Sylvain Lévi in translating this verse suggests that " *parāvṛtti* of sexual act " alludes to " the mystic couples of Buddhas and Bodhisattvas which have so much importance in Tāntricism." But Winternitz in his notes on the " Guhyasamāja Tantra and the Age of Tantra "² doubts this interpretation of Lévi and suggests that " *parāvṛtti* " means nothing but " turning aside, discard." The phrase " *maithunasya parāvṛtti* " may really refer to the Tāntric sexo-yogic practice through which there is the enjoyment of bliss similar to that arising from the sexual act,—and the significance of this mystic union and the consequent enjoyment of blissful union is given in the *Sūtrā-laṅkāra* itself.³ If this interpretation of the word " *parāvṛtti* " in the present context be accepted, it may be inferred that the Tāntric ideas were already prevalent in Mahāyāna Buddhism in the time of Asaṅga (4th-5th centuries A.D.), and the tradition of Tāntricism being introduced in Buddhism by Asaṅga himself becomes to a great extent significant.

c7.s3.16

¹ *maithunasya parāvṛttau vibhutvam labhyate param | buddha-saukhya-vihāre' tha dārā' saṃkleśa-darśane ||*

c7.s3.17

² *Indian Historical Quarterly*, IX. 1.

c7.s3.18

³ *Studies in the Tantras*, Dr. P. C. Bagchi, p. 92.

c7.s3.19

Some scholars are again of the opinion that the Tāntric elements were introduced into Buddhism by Lord Buddha himself as a mere provision for the laities whose intellectual calibre and moral equipment would not allow them to follow the path chalked out by him. Thus Dr. B. Bhaṭṭācārya says,—" Though Buddha was antagonistic to all sorts of sacrifices, necromancy, sorcery or magic, he is credited nevertheless with having given instructions concerning Mudras, Maṇḍalas and Tantras, etc., so that, by virtue of these, prosperity in this world could be attained by his less advanced disciples, who seemed to care more for this world than for the Nirvāṇa preached by him. India in Buddha's time was so steeped in superstitions that any religion which dared forbid all kinds of magic, sorcery and necromancy could hardly hope to withstand popular opposition. A clever¹ organiser as Buddha was, he did not fail to notice the importance of incorporating magical practices in his religion to make it popular from all points of view and attract more adherents thereby."' As a conclusive evidence of this inference Dr. Bhaṭṭācārya refers to Buddha's belief in the four "iddhis" (rddhi) or miraculous power obtained by the advanced disciples and also to a verse in the Tattva-saṃgraha of Śāntarakṣita and its commentary by Kamalaśīla, where Buddha himself is said to have prescribed Mantra, Mudrā, Maṇḍala, etc., for his lay disciples. But this view of Dr. Bhaṭṭācārya cannot be credited historically because of the fact that he has not demonstrated his view with sufficient evidence. The mere belief in the "rddhi" is no convincing proof of Buddha's sanction of Tāntricism, and the evidence of Śāntarakṣita and Kamalaśīla (which too is extremely insufficient by itself) cannot be credited much on the ground that they flourished about fourteen hundred years after the advent of Buddha. Of course, we find occasional references to Tāntric practices including the sex-element even in the time of Buddha,² but we find no conclusive evidence in any early record of Buddha's sanction to Tāntricism as the mere policy of a clever organiser. On the whole, we are loath to believe that Buddha, whose life and teachings were a direct revolution against the prevalent religious system of rites and ceremonies, should have himself made provision for Tāntric practices in his religion only to popularise it among the uncultured, superstitious laity though he himself never believed in the efficacy of any of these practices.

c7.s3.20

¹ An Introduction to Buddhist Esoterism, by Dr. B. Bhaṭṭācārya, p. 48. See also the introduction to the Sādhana-mālā (Vol. II), by Dr. Bhaṭṭācārya, pp. xvi-xvii.

c7.s3.21

² Dīgha-nikāya, Brahma-jāla-sutta; Kathāvatthu, XVII, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, XXIII. 2; Majjhima-nikāya, Pali Text-book Society's Edition, I, p. 305.

c7.s3.22

A popular tendency is manifest among some of the scholars to determine the priority either of the Hindu Tantras or of the Buddhist Tantras. We have pointed out in the Introduction the truth, which we shall have many other occasions to repeat, that Tāntricism with its heterogeneous nature is neither exclusively Hindu, nor exclusively Buddhist in origin. It is an ancient religious cult of India manifesting itself sometimes as Hindu being associated with Hindu theology, thoughts and ideas and sometimes as Buddhist in association with later Buddhist theology, thoughts and ideas. In view of this fact it will not be sound to say, as has actually been said by some scholars, that the Hindu Tantras are later in origin and are derived from the Buddhist Tantras. We have seen that Asanga has traditionally been held to be the introducer of Tāntricism in Buddhism; but the tradition of the existence of a vast array of Āgamas during the days of Asanga or even in earlier times cannot altogether be neglected. These ancient Āgamic texts seem to be the source of all Tāntric texts. That an extensive Tāntric literature existed in the days of Somānanda and Utpala is well-known. Internal evidences show that most of these works, even as they were then known, were very old. Abhinava Gupta's (10 A.C.) compilation of *Tantra-loka* is based on many ancient Āgamas, which were accessible to him personally. A study of these will show that between the so-called Buddhist Tantras and Hindu Tantras there are numerous points of contact implying thereby that they had a common cultural background in the past.

c7.s3.23

It will be very interesting to note that, apart from the theological speculations, which differ in details from one another in different religious spheres, the fundamentals of the Hindu Tantras and the Buddhist Tantras are the same. It is only the colour and tone that are sometimes different. As we shall have more occasions to refer to these points of similarity later on we do not propose to illustrate them here.

c7.s3.24

The Mantra-element seems to have been introduced in Mahāyāna Buddhism first in the form of the Dhāraṇī, which literally means that by which something is sustained or kept up (dhāryate anayā iti), i.e., the mystic syllables that have got the capacity of keeping up the religious life of a man. In the Bodhisattva-bhūmi of Vasubandhu we find a discourse on the nature of the Dhāraṇīs and a philosophical explanation for the adoption of these unmeaning Mantras for the realisation of the ultimate truth.

c7.s3.25

According to the Bodhisattva-bhūmi the Dhāraṇīs of the Bodhisattva are of four kinds, viz., Dharma-dhāraṇī, Artha-dhāraṇī, Mantra-dhāraṇī and the Dhāraṇī for the attainment of the transcendental merit of forbearance of the Bodhisattva (Bodhisattva-kṣānti-lābhaya ca dhāraṇī). The Dharma-dhāraṇī is composed of that kind of Mantras through the hearing of which (even though they are not explained in any Śāstra or by any preacher) the follower attains memory (smṛti), perfect knowledge (prajñā) and spiritual strength (bala). Artha-dhāraṇī is that type of Mantras through the mystic power of which the correct significance (artha) of the Dharmas (which significance is never explained in any Śāstra or by any preacher) is revealed to the follower in an intuitive way. The Mantra-dhāraṇī enables a man to attain perfection. The Dhāraṇī for the attainment of forbearance (kṣānti) is the Mantra through which the ultimate nature of the Dharmas is revealed to the reciter and through this realisation of the ultimate immutable nature of the Dharmas the follower attains generosity of heart which produces in him the merit of forbearance.¹

c7.s3.26

¹ *Bodhisattva-bhūmi*. Ed. by Unrai Wogihara (Tokyo), pp. 272-74.

c7.s3.27

In this connection, however, Vasubandhu gives a philosophical explanation of how the ultimate immutable nature of the Dharmas can be realised through the Mantras of unmeaning syllables, such as "iti miṭi kiṭi bhikṣāṃti padāni svāhā." He says that these syllables, viz., "iti miṭi kiṭi, etc.," have got no meaning whatsoever,—and the follower through concentration should realise the truth that these Mantras can have no meaning at all,—this unmeaningness is their real meaning. Through this absolute negation of all possible meanings to the Mantra, the real meaning of the Mantra as pure void is intuitively revealed to a man. Thus this realisation of the meaning of the Mantras (as pure negation) helps the man to realise in pure intuition the nature of the Dharmas as essenceless. But through this negation of all meanings to the Mantras a unique transcendental, immutable meaning is revealed to the heart of the Sādhaka; this immutable nature is the real nature of all things.² Closely associated with this Mantra-element is the Mudrā-element, which in Buddhism in general is but the different signs made by the particular position of the hands and the fingers.³ This Mudrā-element, however, with the Mantra-element and some other esoteric practices has a deeper significance

c7.s3.28

² sa eṣāṃ mantra-padānāṃ evaṃ samyak pratipanna evam-arthuṃ svayam evāśrutvā kutaścit pratipadyati. tad yathā nā'sty eṣāṃ mantra-padānāṃ kācid artha-pariniṣpattiḥ. nirarthā evaite. ayam eva caiṣāṃ artho yad uta nirarthatā. ...... sa teṣāṃ mantra-padānāṃ artham samyak pratividhya tenaivārthā-nusāraṇa sarva-dharmāṇām apy artham samyak pratividhyati svayam evāśrutvā parataḥ | . . . . . yā punar eṣāṃ nirabhilāpya-svabhāvatā. ayam eṣāṃ svabhāvārthaḥ. Bodhisattva-bhūmi, p. 273.

c7.s3.29

³ It should be noted here that the word Mudrā in the Tāntric and the Yogic literature has got different meanings. In the Tantras it often means the woman to

c7.s3.30

Mudrā, Maṇḍala.

c7.s3.31

in the Yogic Sādhanā of the Tāntrics, and as the Mantra-element contains all the secrecy of the potency of sound, the Mudrā-element contains all the secrecy of touch as associated with the potency of the physiological system. With Mantra and Mudrā the element of Maṇḍala or describing of mystic circles was also introduced.

c7.s3.32

But once the portals of Buddhism were flung open to let in elements of esoterism, all the traditional beliefs in gods, demi-gods, demons and ghosts, magic, charms and sorcery with all their details rushed in and quickly changed the whole ethico-religious outlook of Buddhism. With these again were joined the elements of Yoga,—Haṭha-yoga, Laya-yoga, Mantra-yoga and Rāja-yoga. All these elements made for the growth of the elaborate system of Tāntric Buddhism.

c7.s3.33

It is to be noticed that in the earlier phase of Tāntric Buddhism emphasis was laid generally on the elements of Mantra, Mudrā, Maṇḍala, Abhiṣeka (initiation and the ceremonies associated with it), etc.; but gradually the sexo-yogic practice also began to be referred to. In course of evolution, however, the sexo-yogic practice began to be held as the most important esoteric practice for the attainment of the final state of supreme bliss, all the other practices and

c7.s3.34

be selected in the secret practice; in Haṭha-yoga it refers to practices including control of limbs, muscles, nerves and the vital breath-process. We have again different descriptions of four types of Mudrās associated with both processes of Yoga and meditation which are again associated with four types of realisation of bliss (vide Catur-mudrā of the Advaya-vajra-saṃgraha, G. O. S., XL). In the University Library of Cambridge there is a manuscript with the colophon “Śrī-mac-chākyarāja-sarva-durgati-pariśodhana-mukhā-khyāna-prathamā-diyoga-nāma samādhi” (MS. Cambridge, Add. No. 1278, available to the present writer in rotograph) with as many as one hundred and fifty-eight coloured illustrations of the different kinds of Mudrās. Of these some seem to be purely postures of the hands and fingers, some on the other hand illustrate the different manners of holding the thunderbolt (vajra), lotus, bell, sword, conch-shell, bunch of flowers, garlands, etc. Others again illustrate the manner of offering flowers, water, incense, lamp and other materials of worship. Some again illustrate the different manners of playing on the different musical instruments. All these are done with the aim of obtaining final purification and final deliverance from the miseries of life.

c7.s3.35

ceremonies being held as preparatory accessories. The six kinds of ritual intended for the good or evil of anybody (*Abhicāra*) and the five accessories of wine (*madya*), meat (*māṃsa*), fish (*matsya*), woman (?) (*mudrā*) and sexual intercourse (*maithuna*) gradually made their way into Buddhism. This composite system of Tāntricism with the introduction of the sexo-yogic practice came to be known by the general name of Vajra-yāna or the Adamantine path.² Kazi Dawa-samdup in his introduction to the *Śrī-cakra-saṃbhāra-tantra* divides this Vajra-yāna into further parts, *viz.*, Kriyā-tantra-yāna, Caryā-tantra-yāna and Yoga-tantra-yāna; the last is again sub-divided into Mahāyoga-tantra-yāna, Anuttara-yoga-tantra-yāna and Atiyoga-tantra-yāna. The general custom, however, is to divide Vajra-yāna into four classes, *viz.*, Kriyā-tantra, Caryā-tantra, Yoga-tantra, and Anuttara-tantra. The first two classes are called ‘lower Tantras’ inasmuch as they are concerned with the rites, ceremonies, worship of gods and goddesses and other practices; and the latter schools are known as ‘higher Tantras’ inasmuch as they describe yogic processes for the realisation of the ultimate truth and also contain discussions on the nature of the ultimate reality.

c7.s3.36

² The original name Mantra-yāna is also often found used in a general sense for later Buddhist Tāntric schools *Cf.* *Hevajra pañjikā*, MS. (Cambridge Add. No. 1699), p. 45(B); *Advaya-vajra-saṃgraha*, p. 54 (G. O. S.); commentary on the *Dohākoṣa* of Kānhapāda, verse No. 12.

c7.s3.37

There is still another customary way of dividing Tāntric Buddhism into three schools, *viz.*, Vajra-yāna, Kāla-cakrayāna and Sahaja-yāna.¹ This division seems to us erroneous because of the fact that Kāla cakra-yāna and Sahaja-yāna seem to us to be schools within the fold of the general name Vajra-yāna. MM. H. P. Śāstrī speaks of Nāthism as another school of Tāntric Buddhism.² As we shall have to devote separate chapters to the problems regarding the nature, origin and growth of Nāthism the question of its relation to Tāntric Buddhism will not be discussed at this stage.³ The problem of Kāla-cakra-yāna, however, appears to us perplexing. About its nature Waddell says in his *Lamaism*,—"In the tenth century A.D., the Tāntric phase developed in Northern India, Kasmir and Nepal into monstrous and polydemonist doctrine, the Kāla-cakra, with its demonical Buddhas, which incorporated the Mantrayāna practices, and called itself the Vajrayāna, or the 'Thunderbolt-vehicle,' and its followers were named Vajra-carya, or, 'followers of the Thunderbolt.'⁴ In another place he says—"The extreme development of the Tāntric phase was reached with the Kāla-cakra, which, although unworthy of being considered as a philosophy, must be referred to here as a doctrinal basis. It is merely a course of Tāntric development of the Adi-Buddha theory combined with puerile mysticism of Mantrayāna, and it attempts to explain creation and the secret powers of nature by the union of the Kali, not only with the Dhyani Buddhas, but even with Adi-Buddha himself."⁵ The account and interpretation given by Mr. Waddell seem to us to be based on confused ideas about Tibetan Buddhism. We have not yet been able to discover the reason behind the general tendency of associating the name Kāla-cakra-yāna with the terrible aspect of Tāntric Buddhism. MM. H. P. Śāstrī, however, says on this point,—" What is Kāla-cakra-yāna? The word Kāla means time,—death and destruction. Kāla-cakra is the wheel of destruction, and Kāla-cakra-yāna means the vehicle for protection against the wheel of destruction."¹ But this explanation of MM. Śāstrī is not confirmed by any textual evidence.

c7.s3.38

¹ We do not, however, find any direct mention of the “*Pañca-ma-kāras*” in the Buddhist Tantras; but we find sporadic mention of wine, fish, meat, etc., and much of Mudrā and sexual intercourse. We also find frequent reference to the Pañca-kāma-guṇa or five objects of desire through the enjoyment of which perfection can be attained.

c7.s3.39

³ In this connection compare also four divisions in the arrangement of the Vaiṣṇava-tantras (found in the *Padma-tantra*), *viz.*, Jñāna-pāda, Yoga-pāda, Kriyā-pāda and Caryā-pāda. (See J. R. A. S., 1901, p. 900.)

c7.s3.40

¹ See the introduction to *Sādhana-mālā*, Vol. II, by Dr. B. Bhaṭṭācārya.

c7.s3.41

² See the introduction to *Modern Buddhism and its Followers in Orissa* of Mr. N. Vasu by MM. H. P. Śāstrī.

c7.s3.42

³ *Vide infra*.

c7.s3.43

⁴ *Lamaism*, by Waddell, p. 15.

c7.s3.44

⁵ *Ibid*.

c7.s3.45

¹ Modern Buddhism, etc., Introduction, p. 8

c7.s3.46

The traditional view concerning the origin of Śrī-kāla-cakra-mūla-tantra, which is recorded in the Abhiniśramaṇa Sūtra² is that it was delivered by the Buddha at Śrī Dhanya Kaṭaka. Regarding this system Csoma de Körös says that it was introduced in India from Śambhala at about 965 A.C.

c7.s3.47

² Pag Sam Jon Zang., p 37

c7.s3.48

We have at our disposal a text of the Śrī-kāla-cakra-tantra³ a study of which does not substantiate the statement that Kāla-cakra-yāna is that school of Tāntric Buddhism, which introduced demonic Buddhas in it,—at least, it is not the main characteristic by which the school should be recognised. In the text at our disposal the Lord has explained how the universe with all its objects and localities are situated in the body and how time in all its divisions and sub-divisions (viz., day, night, fortnight, month, year, etc.) is within the body in the processes of the vital wind (prāṇa-vāyu). In the text Sahaja has been explained and also the details of the sexo-yogic practice for the attainment of the Sahaja. The only thing that strikes the reader is the stress laid on the control of the vital winds (prāṇa and apāna) and the results attained thereby. A study of the commentary on the text (Laghu-kāla-cakra-tantra-rāja-ṭīkā, entitled Vimala-prabhā) also reveals no fundamental difference between the tenets of Vajra-yāna Buddhism and those of Kāla-cakra-yāna. The stress on yoga seems, however, to be the special feature, if there be any at all, of Kāla-cakra-yāna.

c7.s3.49

³ MS. Cambridge Add., 1364.

c7.s3.50

It is interesting to note here that similar doctrines of Kāla-cakra are elaborately described and explained in a fairly old text like the Tantrā-loka of Abhinava Gupta. The sixth chapter of the Tantrā-loka (which is a fairly big chapter) is devoted to the exposition of the doctrine of Kāla (time) and the process of keeping oneself above the influence of the whirl of time. Time (Kāla) in all its phases (day and night, fortnight, month, year, etc.) has been explained here mainly with reference to the functions of the vital wind (mainly Prāṇa and Apāna) spread through the whole nervous system, and the process of controlling time is to control the vital wind in the nerves through yogic practices.

Cites (15)