The Philosophy of the Upanishads c11.s1.t2: 2. Originally only one Soul
The Philosophy of the Upanishads c11.s1.t2
- Language
- English
2. Originally only one Soul
c11.s1.t2.1
The texts of the oldest Upanishads do not recognise two souls, but only one. “It is thy soul, which is within all.”¹ He who while dwelling in the earth, the water, the fire, in space, wind, heaven, sun, etc., is distinct from them, whose body they are, who rules them all from within, “he is thy soul, the inner guide, the immortal. He sees but is not seen, hears but is not heard, comprehends but is not comprehended, knows but is not known; there is none beside him that sees or hears or comprehends or knows.”² This âtman who alone exists is the knowing subject in us, and as such sustains the whole universe of conceptions, in which is everything and beyond which nothing, and with the knowledge of the âtman therefore all is known.³ This is the point of view of pure idealism, which denies the existence of a manifold universe, and of everything outside the knowing subject. It becomes pantheism, when it concedes a relative existence to the universe, but identifies this entire universe with the âtman, the knowing subject. Such an identification however, often as it is repeated, is always very obscure, and in order to bring it within the range of empirical comprehension a return is effected to the old cosmogony, and it is taught that the âtman created the universe and then entered into it as soul:—*anena jīvena ātmanā anupraviśya*.¹ Here for the first time we meet with the word *jīva ātman*, which later denotes “the individual soul” as contrasted with the supreme. But no such contrast yet exists here. It is the ātman himself who alone exists and creates the universe, who as *jīva ātman* enters into the universe that he has created. Neither from the point of view of pure idealism, nor in its empirical varieties of pantheism and cosmogonism, does any opposition exist between the supreme and individual souls. The contrast between them is first seen at the moment in which the ātman who creates the universe and then enters into his creation becomes a duality, the parts of which are set over-against one another. We have described this further accommodation to the empirical consciousness as theism, since here the original unity of the ātman is divided into God and the soul.
c11.s1.t2.2
¹ Bṛih. 3. 4. 1, 3. 5. 1.
c11.s1.t2.3
² Bṛih. 3. 7. 3–23.
c11.s1.t2.4
³ Bṛih. 2 4. 5.
c11.s1.t2.5
¹ Chând. 6. 3. 2.
Cites (2)
- Bṛhadāraṇyakopaniṣad — Sanskrit
- Chāndogyopaniṣad — Sanskrit