Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

The System of the Vedanta according to Badarayana's Brahma-Sutras and Cankara's Commentary c10.s5.t3: 3. Stages on the Path of the Gods

The System of the Vedânta according to Bâdarâyana's Brahma-Sûtras and Çankara's Commentary c10.s5.t3

Language
English

3. Stages on the Path of the Gods

c10.s5.t3.1

The Devayâna, which leads the pious after death to Brahman, has a series of stages, which are differently given in the different accounts. Thus in Chând. 8, 6, 5 (above p. 162) all that is said is that the Soul ascends from the artery to the sun by a ray (raçmi), while on the other hand Chând. 5, 10, 1 (above p. 362) as also previously Chând. 4, 15, 5 (above p. 166) the following stages are given: 1. Flame (arcis), 2. the Day, 3. the half-month in which the moon increases, 4. the half-year in which the days increase, 5. the Year, 6. the Sun, 7. the Moon, 8. Lightning, 9. Brahman.—With this agrees the parallel passage Bṛih. 6, 2, 15 (above p. 363), only that no. 5 is not "the year" but "the world of the Gods," and no. 7 "the moon" is wanting.—On the other hand we find Kaush. 1, 3, as stages of the Devayâna quite different ones named: 1. Agniloka, 2. Vâyuloka, 3. Varuṇaloka, 4. Indraloka, 5. Prajâpatiloka, 6. Brahmaloka.

c10.s5.t3.2

In view of these contradictions Çaṅkara (p. 1110 ff.) insists on the fact that there is only one Devayâna, and consequently that one must combine the different accounts. How in so doing he pictures the relation between the "ray," which in Chând. 8, 6, 5 connects the artery and the sun, and the stages 1—5, which according to Chând. 5, 10, 1 lead to the sun, is not clear from his remark p. 1112, 7, that both are not mutually exclusive; he further identifies "the Flame" Chând. 5, 10, 1 with Agniloka Kaush. 1, 3, inserts Vâyuloka Kaush. 1, 3 between "Year" and "Sun" Chând. 5, 10, 1, and then again Devaloka Bṛih. 6, 2, 15 between "Year" and Vâyuloka, and likewise finally Varuṇaloka, Indraloka, Prajâpatiloka from Kaush. 1, 3 between "Lightning" and "Brahman" Chând. 5, 10 (p. 1113 ff.). We thus get the following order of the stages of the Devayâna: 1. The Flame = Agniloka, 2. the Day, 3. the Fortnight in which the moon increases, 4. the Half-year in which the days increase, 5. the Year, 6. the World of the Gods, 7. Vâyuloka, 8. the Sun, 9. the Moon, 10. Lightning, 11. Varuṇaloka, 12. Indraloka, 13. Prajâpatiloka, 14. Brahman.

c10.s5.t3.3

Now what meaning have these stages for the ascending Soul? Are they sign-posts or places of enjoyment? To this must be answered: they are neither one nor the other, but guides who conduct the Soul to Brahman. For after the Soul has reached the Lightning, it is said (above pp. 166. 363) "there indeed is a man (spirit), who is not as a human being, “he leads it to Brahman;” whence it is to be inferred that the preceding spirits: Flame etc. are of human nature (p. 1117, 6). For the Soul, in this condition, when all its organs are drawn in, is in need of guidance, somewhat like a drunken man or one whose senses are confused; this guidance is undertaken by the Flame, the Day etc.; wherefore we must understand by them not the natural phenomena which serve as signposts, for they would be incapable of leading him, but the Gods presiding over them; and also for the reason that Flame, Day, etc., are not always present, and waiting is impossible, as we saw (above p. 440). For the same reason too the stages named are not places of enjoyment for the Soul, as the designation *Loka* (world, place of enjoyment) might seem to indicate; to other Souls which dwell in them, they may serve as such places of enjoyment, but the Soul which is ascending through them is deprived of its organs and hence not capable of enjoying (p. 1118). After the Soul has come to the Lightning, it is led onwards by the “man who is not like a human “being” into Brahman, through *Varuṇaloka*, *Indraloka*, *Prajāpatiloka*; these are in some way or other helpful, either by removing obstacles, or by some other assistance (p. 1119).

Cites (3)