Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

Early Monastic Buddhism v1.c13.s1: Four ways of exposition

Early Monastic Buddhism v1.c13.s1

Language
English

Four ways of exposition

v1.c13.s1.1

Buddha, it is said, adopted the following four ways for removing the doubts of those who approached him to learn the truth:—

v1.c13.s1.2

(i) *Paṭipucchāvyākaraṇīya*;
(ii) *Ekamsavyākaraṇīya*;
(iii) *Vibhajjava-yākaraṇīya*, and
(iv) *Ṭhapanīya*.

v1.c13.s1.3

In the first method, the doubts of the interlocutor are ascertained at the outset by putting suitable questions and then removed by appropriate answers; in the second, a direct reply is given to an enquirer without entering into a discussion with him; in the third, answers are given separately to the different aspects of the question;¹ and in the fourth, it is pointed out that as the question in untenable, no reply will be given.²

v1.c13.s1.4

¹ *Majjhima*, II, p. 197

v1.c13.s1.5

² *Digha*, I, pp. 187 ff., III, p. 229.

v1.c13.s1.6

Buddha insisted that his disciples should be very discriminating in adopting one of these methods¹ for delivering their discourses.

v1.c13.s1.7

¹ Cf. *Majjhima*, III, p. 208. *Samiddhinā moghapurisena Potali-puttassa paribbājakassa vibhaṅa byākaraṇiyo pañho ekamseva byākato ti.*

Cites (4)