Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

Early Monastic Buddhism v1.c18.s1: (i) Khandhas

Early Monastic Buddhism v1.c18.s1

Language
English

Contents

(i) Khandhas

v1.c18.s1.1

The whole universe, according to Buddhism, is dichotomised into *saṃskṛta* (constituted) or *lokiya dhātu* and *asaṃskṛta* (unconstituted) or *lokuttara dhātu*.² The former includes the whole world of animate and inanimate objects and the latter *Ākāśa* (space) and *Nirvāṇa*, which is sub-divided into two as *Pratisamkhyānirodha* and *Apratisamkhyānirodha*.

v1.c18.s1.2

² See *Infra*, p. 259.

Saṃskṛta-dhātu

v1.c18.s1.t1.1

The world of beings and inanimate objects are described as *saṃskṛta* on account of their being constituted of some elements. These elements are usually put under two heads: *nāma* and *rūpa*, *nāma* denoting the non-material or mental states of a being while *rūpa* the material parts only. All inanimate objects therefore are included in the term *rūpa*. *Nāma* is analysed into four states known as *vedanā* (feeling), *saññā* (perception), *saṅkhārā* (impressions produced through karma) and *viññāṇa* (knowledge derived through the organs of sense). The four subdivisions of *nāma* with the fifth the *rūpa* are termed *Pañcakkhandha*. It follows from this that according to the early Buddhists every being is a composite of the five khandhas (or groups of elements), each khandha comprising a particular group of elements, without a sixth the Puggala or Attā (= soul).

v1.c18.s1.t1.2

The traditional interpretation of the five khandhas (skandhas) as given in the Dhammasaṅgaṇī (Bk. II), Vibhaṅga, Buddhaghosa's Visuddhimagga and Vasubandhu's Abhidharmakośa is as follows:

v1.c18.s1.t1.3

Rūpakkhandha denotes the four elements: earth (pathavī), water (āpo), fire (tejo) and air (vāyu), including all that is formed out of these four.¹ It comprises all the material objects whether of the past, present or future, internal or external, gross or subtle, near or distant, good or bad. By past rūpa is meant the matter that has undergone change; by future, the matter which will come into existence; and by the present, the matter which is existing at the present moment. By internal rūpa are meant the flesh, bone and such other constituents of one's body made out of the four mahābhūtas: and by external, the same of bodies other than one's own. By gross and near rūpa are meant the six organs of sense with the sense-objects² while by subtle and distant rūpa, the masculinity (purisindriya) and femininity (itthindriya), vitality (jīvitindriya: as water is to the lotus, so is vitality to the rūpa),³ the seat of mental faculties (hadaya), the faculty of intimation by means of physical and vocal signs (kāyaviññatti and vaciviññatti), the space within and circumscribing the body (ākāsadhātu), the qualities⁴ which make the body light soft and supple, growing and decaying, and nutritive food (kabalinkāro āhāro). The good and bad rūpa indicate only the good or bad nature of the sense-objects.

v1.c18.s1.t1.4

¹ Db. S. 584: Cattāro ca mahābhūtā catunnañ ca mahābhūtānaṃ upādāya rūpaṃ—idaṃ vuccati sabbaṃ rūpaṃ.

v1.c18.s1.t1.5

² Vism., p. 444: cakkhu, sotaṃ, ghānaṃ, jivhā, kāyo, rūpaṃ, saddo, gandho, and raso.

v1.c18.s1.t1.6

³ See Infra, p. 260.

v1.c18.s1.t1.7

⁴ Vism., p. 444: rūpassa lahutā, mudutā, kammaññatā, upacayo, santati, jaratā, and aniceatā.

v1.c18.s1.t1.8

Vedanākkhandha connotes all that which one feels (vedayitalakkhaṇam).¹ Though it is by nature one, it is usually treated under three aspects: kusala (good), akusala (bad), and avyākata (indifferent) and sometimes under five aspects, viz., sukham and dukkham when the object of contact is pleasant and unpleasant, somanassam and domanassam when the object of thought is pleasant and unpleasant, and lastly upekkhā when the object does not produce good or bad feeling.

v1.c18.s1.t1.9

¹ In the Vibhanga, vedanā and other khandhas have been explained like rūpa as atīta, anāgata and paccuppanna, ajjhatta and bahiddhā, oḷārika and sukhuma, hīna and paṇīta, dūra and santika, but this has been omitted in the Vism., pp. 472-6.

v1.c18.s1.t1.10

Viññāṇakkhandha² refers to that faculty by which a being becomes aware of things (vijānana-lakkhaṇa), viññāṇa is a synonym of citta or mano.³ Though it is of one nature, it is usually treated as of three kinds, kusala (good), akusala (bad) and avyākata (indifferent). Each of these three kinds of Viññāṇa again is subdivided in the Abhidhamma works according to the four spheres in which the world or mental states are divided viz., kāmāvacara, rūpāvacara, arūpāvacara and lokuttara.⁴ In the Kāmāvacara sphere, kusalaviññāṇa is analysed into eight kinds, according as it is associated with, or dissociated from, ñāṇa (knowledge), and saṅkhāra (persuasion by others, e.g. in offering gifts). In the Rūpāvacara it is of five kinds in accordance with the mental states developed by a meditator as he rises gradually from the first to the fourth form of meditation (jhāna). In the Arūpāvacara it is, as before, of four kinds, as the meditator rises from the fifth to the eighth jhāna called āruppas. And in the Lokuttara, it is said to be of four kinds as a person is in one of the four maggas, viz., sotāpatti, sakadāgāmi, anāgāmi and arahatta.¹ In all kusalaviññāṇa is of twenty-one kinds.

v1.c18.s1.t1.11

² Though in the usual enumeration of khandhas, viññāṇa is put last, it has been treated as the third, in accordance with the arrangement of the Vism., p. 477-8, the reason being that, is the most important and subtlest of the khandhas and the interpretation of all other mental khandhas follow this more or less.

v1.c18.s1.t1.12

³ Vism., 452; Saṃyutta, II, 94; see also Ante, p. 24-5.

v1.c18.s1.t1.13

⁴ See IHQ., XV: The Dhamma-saṅgaṇi.

v1.c18.s1.t1.14

¹ See above, pp. 241 ff.

v1.c18.s1.t1.15

It should be remembered that these twenty-one kusala-viññāṇas do not belong to the good mental states of an average man. These refer only to the mental states of an individual who is following the Buddhist principles of gradual purification and whose mind rises by stages to the Arūpāvacara and ultimately to the Lokuttara region.

v1.c18.s1.t1.16

In the same way Akusalaviññāṇa is explained. As a person who has practised the first form of meditation, not to speak of the higher ones, cannot have akusalaviññāṇa; it is said that akusala-viññāṇa is confined to the Kāmāvacara sphere only, and so from the standpoint of spheres (avacaras) it is of one kind only. It is of three kinds according to its source, viz., lobha (avarice), dosa (hatred) and moha (delusion). Each of them again is further subdivided into twelve in accordance with its combination with one or more of the following: lobha with or without somanassa, upekkhā, diṭṭhi (non-Buddhist beliefs) and saṅkhāra (instigation by others); dosa with domanassa, paṭigha (revenge) and saṅkhāra (instigation); and moha with upekkhā and vicikicchā (doubts).

v1.c18.s1.t1.17

The Avyākata-viññāṇa has so many subdivisions that it will be easier to comprehend it in a tabular form thus:²

v1.c18.s1.t1.18

² Vism., pp. 454 ff.

v1.c18.s1.t1.21

The *ahetukam kusalavipākam avyākata-viññāṇam* is of eight kinds, viz., the six *viññāṇas* derived through the six organs of sense (including *mano*). The function of these *viññāṇas* is to make the object just known. Besides these six *viññāṇas*, there is the receiving faculty called *mano dhātu*, located in the heart (*hadayavatthu*). Its function is to cognize the objects. As it is associated either with equanimity (*upekkhā*), or joy (*somanassa*) it is said to be of two kinds. All these are further subdivided as shown in the above Table.

v1.c18.s1.t1.22

The *sahetukam kusalavipākam avyākata-viññāṇam* is also of eight kinds. It is similar to the previously said *ahetuka-viññāṇa*, the only difference being that it is always associated with *alobhādivipāka*.¹

v1.c18.s1.t1.23

¹ *alobhādi* = *alobha*, *adosa*, *amoha* and so forth; *vipāka* = result or resultant consciousness (see Transl. of the *Vism.*, p. 531).

v1.c18.s1.t1.24

The *Rūpāvacara-avyākata-vipāka-viññāṇam* like the *rūpāvacara-kusaladhamma* is of five kinds. It occurs to those who are meditating (*samāpattivasena*)² and progressing along the path. It is manifest in reconception, life-continuum and death.

v1.c18.s1.t1.25

² *Vism.*, Transl., p. 532, by way of right attainment. See above, p. 252.

v1.c18.s1.t1.26

The *Arūpāvacara-avyākata-vipāka-viññāṇam* like the *arūpāvacara-kusala* is of four kinds and should be interpreted as above.

v1.c18.s1.t1.27

The *Lokuttara-avyākata-vipāka-viññāṇam* like the *lokuttara-vipāka* is of four kinds, i.e., connected with the four kinds of mental states of four *maggas* (see above p. 252). .

v1.c18.s1.t1.28

In all, the subdivisions of the *avyākata-vipāka-viññāṇas* of the four spheres (*avacaras*) amount to thirty-six.

v1.c18.s1.t1.29

The *Kiriya-viññāṇa*, as indicated in the above Table, is subdivided according to the three spheres (*avacaras*) and then the *Kāmāvacara* into *ahetuka* and *sahetuka*, which are subdivided into eleven kinds, and as before, the *Rūpāvacara* and *Arūpāvacara* into nine, thus making in all twenty kinds.

v1.c18.s1.t1.30

The sum total of *viññāṇas* stands thus: Kusalaviññāṇa ... ... ... 21 Akusalaviññāṇa ... ... ... 12 Vipākaviññāṇa ... ... ... 36 Kiriyaviññāṇa ... ... ... 20 --- 89

v1.c18.s1.t1.31

All these 89 *viññāṇas* act in 14 ways, viz., through reconception (*paṭisandhi*), life-continuum (*bhavaṅga*), reviving (*āvajjana*), seeing (*dassana*), hearing (*savana*), smelling (*ghāyana*), tasting (*sāyana*), touching (*phusana*), receiving (*sampaṭicchana*), examining (*santīraṇa*), deciding (*voṭṭhapana*), extending (*javana*),¹ registering (*tad-ārammaṇa*) and death (*cuti*).²

v1.c18.s1.t1.32

¹ Cf. *Atthas.* p. 270: *ubhosu tiresu kedārapūraṇaṃ viya javanaṃ*.

v1.c18.s1.t1.33

² These are functions of mano-dhātu which is treated as the sixth organ of sense.

v1.c18.s1.t1.34

Of the fourteen ways in which *viññāṇa* functions, as stated above, it is the *paṭisandhi-viññāṇa* that causes re-birth. It is said in the *Saṃyutta Nikāya* (I, 122; II, 67, 103) that only when *viññāṇa* obtains a footing (*patiṭṭhā*) on something (*ārammaṇa*), then only there is the possibility of the birth of a being, and not otherwise, and the moment the *viññāṇa* ceases (*cuti*), one is regarded as dead.³ During the span of life limited by the two *viññāṇas*, *paṭisandhi* and *cuti*, the remaining twelve *viññāṇas* function. Immediately after the *paṭisandhi-viññāṇa* has done its part, i.e., having given the form of birth according to kamma, appears the *bhavaṅga-viññāṇa*, which is the resultant of one's actions (*kammassa vipākabhūtam*). The *bhavaṅga-viññāṇa* however becomes inactive when the organs of sense grow strong enough to function in their respective spheres. Then those six *indriya-viññāṇas* (i.e. including *mano-dhātu*) function and give rise to the *ahetuka-kiriya-manoviññāṇa-dhātu*, making *bhavaṅgaviññāṇa* (sub-consciousness) passive. The *kiriyamano-viññāṇadhātu* is nothing but mind (*mano* = *citta*), the function of which is to revive (*avajjana*) the objects seen, sounds heard and so forth, and to make the organs of sense function and function again. The function of mind then is to receive things communicated to it through the organs of sense; it becomes good or bad according as the things communicated through the organs of sense are pleasant or unpleasant. When the mind ceases to function, *bhavaṅga-viññāṇa* renews its activity, ceasing at death when it is followed by *cuti-viññāṇa*, which in its turn gives rise to *paṭisandhi-viññāṇa*. In this way the continuity of *citta* is maintained, and the cycle of existence is continued.¹ It should be noted that the existence of *bhavaṅgaviññāṇa* or subconsciousness is not explicitly stated anywhere in the Sutta or Abhidhamma Piṭaka, though it is given prominence in the works of later expositors, like Anuruddha and Buddhaghosa.

v1.c18.s1.t1.35

³ Cf. *Saṃyutta*, III, p. 143: *Āyu usmā viññāṇaṃ, ca yadā kāyaṃ jahantimāṃ* *apaviddho tadā seti, parabhattam acetanaṃ*.

v1.c18.s1.t1.36

¹ This exposition of *viññāṇa* is based on the *Vism.*, pp. 452-460; Transl. *Path of Purity*, III, pp. 527 ff. See also *Atthas.*, pp. 266, 269-270. In the *Atthas.* the position of *bhavaṅga-viññāṇa* has been explained by a simile which is as follows: The course of a flowing river, if turned, by an obstruction, towards a channel (*mahāmātikā*), the water not only flows through it but floods over the two sides of the channel, and then by whatever narrow ways it finds, it moves towards the main river. The flowing river = *bhavaṅga-viññāṇa*. The obstruction turning the course of the river = *kiriyamano-dhātu* (*mind* = *citta*) The channel = *vīthicittapavatti* (mind functioning through the six organs of sense)

v1.c18.s1.t1.37

*Saññākkhandha* refers to all those characteristics which make a thing known. Though it is by nature of one kind, it is, like the *vedanākkhandha* (see above, p. 251), treated as of three kinds viz., *kusala* (good), *akusala* (bad) and *avyākata* (indifferent), according as it is associated with *viññāṇa*, good, bad or indifferent. There cannot be any *viññāṇa* without *saññā* (perception), hence it has as many subdivisions as *viññāṇa* (see above). Its function is (i) to make a thing known through its characteristics, as a piece of wood is known to a carpenter; (ii) to make the characteristics engage the attention of persons, as an elephant felt by the blind; and (iii) to draw attention to the immediate function of an object, as animals know their supplier of grains as the food-giver.

v1.c18.s1.t1.38

*Saṅkhārākkhandha*. It denotes that aspect of mental states (*cetanā*),¹ the main characteristics of which is to bring together (*rāsikaraṇa*) two or more mental activities. It has the virtue of putting forward the mind into action,² and engaging it in the immediate object, and has for its proximate cause the three other khandhas, viz., *vedanā*, *saññā* and *viññāṇa*. Apparently, then,

v1.c18.s1.t1.39

¹ In the *Vibhaṅga* (p. 7), *saṅkhāra* is equated to *cetanā*, the *cetanā* which arises out of contact of the organs of sense with their objects, as does *vedanā*, *saññā* or *viññāṇa*.

v1.c18.s1.t1.40

² In the *Expositor* (p. 540 fn. 4), it has been pointed out that the commentator on the *Vism.*, has explained *āyūhana* by *rāsikaraṇa*. This, I think, is a slip on the part of the commentator, for in the text *āyūhana* is mentioned as the second characteristic, *rāsikaraṇa* being the first

v1.c18.s1.t1.41

The flooding over two sides = *javana*
Falling into the main river = *bhavaṅgotaraṇam*.

v1.c18.s1.t1.42

*saṅkhārā* means the resultant mental states—the accumulated effect of the three other khandhas or mental functions. These three khandhas do not set the mind into action but leave it to *saṅkhārā* to do so. Like the other mental khandhas, it has also been sub-divided in various ways.

v1.c18.s1.t1.43

Buddhaghosa concludes his exposition of khandhas by the remark that the people are prone to regard the body as one single thing and mistakenly apprehend it as a self and that it is only to warn them against this misapprehension that the Teacher spoke of the khandhas. The khandhas are to be looked upon as bubbles and tempting mirage. These are nothing but a mass of evanescent objects as substanceless as the trunk of a plantain tree.¹ Buddhaghosa offers also an explanation for the order (*kama*) in which the khandhas are enumerated. *Rūpa*, he says, is mentioned first because it is easily comprehensible to an average man. As this *rūpa* (matter, object and thing) gives rise to a feeling good, bad, or indifferent, so *vedanā* is treated as the second khandha. As this *vedanā* (feeling) that directs one's attention to the form and nature of the source of the feeling and thus engenders *saññā* (perception), so *saññā* is placed next. After *saññā*, happens the accumulation of mental states, hence *saṅkhārā* is treated as the fourth. Though *viññāṇa* precedes *saṅkhārā* it is mentioned last as it is the most important of the four mental khandhas, forming, as it does, the basis of *vedanā*.²

v1.c18.s1.t1.44

¹ *Vism.*, pp. 477-480.

v1.c18.s1.t1.45

² *Vism.*, p. 477: Yam vedayati tam sañjānāti ti evam vedanā-visayassa ākāragāhikam saññam; saññāvasena abhisaṅkhārake saṅkhāre; tesam vedanādīnam nissayam adhipatibhūtañ ca nesam viññāṇan ti.

Cites (8)