Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

An Outline of the Religious Literature of India c12.t2: B. Reconciliation of Systems.

An Outline of the Religious Literature of India c12.t2

Language
English

B. Reconciliation of Systems.

c12.t2.1

§ 346. We noticed above⁴ the statement made in the *Prabodhachandrodaya* that the six systems of Hindu philosophy are not mutually exclusive systems but that they all celebrate from various points of view the same glorious and uncreated God. Vijñāna Bhikshu,⁵ the sixteenth-century Sāṅkhya sannyāsī, who is a theist, acknowledges that the Sāṅkhya system and the Karma Mīmāmsā are atheistic, yet he holds that all the systems are authoritative, and reconciles them by distinguishing between essential and practical truths, the latter being false or imperfect theories inculcated with a view to some practical end, and therefore to be neglected in a general survey. Similarly, Madhusūdana Sarasvatī⁶ wrote rather later:

c12.t2.2

⁴ In § 270.

c12.t2.3

⁵ See § 342.

c12.t2.4

⁶ *Prasthānabheda*: Muir, *OST*. IV. 102.

c12.t2.5

The ultimate scope of all the Munis, authors of these different systems, is to support the theory of illusion, and their only design

c12.t2.6

is to establish the existence of one Supreme God, the sole essence; for these Munis could not be mistaken since they were omniscient. But as they saw that men, addicted to the pursuit of external objects, could not all at once penetrate into the highest truths, they held out to them a variety of theories, in order that they might not fall into atheism. Misunderstanding the object which the Munis thus had in view, and representing that they even designed to propound doctrines contrary to the Vedas, men have come to regard the specific doctrines of these several schools with preference, and thus become adherents of a variety of systems.

c12.t2.7

§ 347. Most modern Hindu scholars occupy a similar standpoint. Mr. J. C. Chatterji’s statement¹ may be taken as representative. The Nyāya, Vaiśeshika, and Karma Mīmāmsā systems are all realistic; the Sāṅkhya and the Yoga are dualistic; the Vedānta monistic. From this he proceeds:

c12.t2.8

¹ HR. 5.

c12.t2.9

Thus, in reality, there are only three metaphysical systems of the Hindus. These systems again are not considered as mutually contradictory. They are regarded as forming a graduated series in which the three systems form, as it were, three great standards, suited to different types or grades of minds—different intellectual (and only intellectual) capacities and temperaments.

c12.t2.10

§ 348. The position of Kabīr,² and all his school, seems at the first glance to be still wider; for in him there is a reconciliation of Islam and Hinduism; but the truth in it is far simpler, surer, and more practical. For the reconciliation is between one school of Islam and one school of Hinduism, the latter already seriously modified by the laying aside of idolatry.

c12.t2.11

² See § 396.

c12.t2.12

§ 349. But the boldest of all is Akbar’s Divine Faith, the Dīn Ilāhī,³ which was meant to sum up all religions, a creation which died with its own imperial creator. A little later, Hindu paṇḍits at the court of Aurungzebe suggested to Bernier⁴ the idea that there might be many true religions, all proceeding from the one God.

c12.t2.13

³ V. A. Smith, Akbar, 209 ff.

c12.t2.14

⁴ Travels, 328.

c12.t2.15

§ 350. Early in the eighteenth century, Prāṇnāth taught, at Panna in Bandelkhand, that all the religions of India were reconciled in his own person, since he was at once the Christian Messiah, the Mohammedan Mahdi, and the *Nishkalaṅkāvatāra*, ‘the stainless incarnation’, of the Hindus, and expressed the dogma in his *Kulljama Saheb*.¹

c12.t2.16

¹ Wilson, 315 f.; Griswold, *Forman Christian College Magazine*, July and Nov. 1905; Growse, M. 230 ff.; *JASB*. XLVIII. 171; Russell, *TCCP*. 216 ff. Mirza Ghulam Ahmad Khan of Qadian is an exact modern parallel: see Walter’s *Ahamadīya Movement*, Calcutta, 1918.

Cites (2)