Hindu Temples: What Happened to Them v1.c8.s7: No Easy Solution
Hindu Temples: What Happened to Them v1.c8.s7
- Language
- English
No Easy Solution
v1.c8.s7.1
The foregoing discussion shows that the problem is not that of the Rama Janmabhumi Temple of Ayodhya, or the Krishna Temple of Mathura or the Visveshvara Temple of Varanasi. In its deeper aspect, the problem relates to an aggressive theology and political ideology which created an aggressive tradition of history. Needless to say that the problem in all its huge dimensions admits of no easy solution. In an ordinary situation, one could appeal from Philip drunk to Philip sober, from a man’s passion to his reason and conscience. But in the present case when Islamic theology is on the side of its historical practice and its more aggressive aims, this option is hardly available. But even then while showing, by exercising firmness, that aggression will not pay, we must yet be patient and understanding. We must realize that the problem is not**Muslims** but **Islam** or **Islamic theology**. Therefore, this theology needs a more critical examination than has been hitherto done. We must properly study Revelatory religions, their Gods and their prophets, their theories of special covenants and favoured *ummahs*, their doctrine of **one God** and **two humanities**, their categories of believers and infidels or pagans, their theory of Prophetism, their divinely ordained mission to convert and crusade.
v1.c8.s7.2
It is a task which needs the creative labour of all seekers and articulators of truth. Closed creeds are a threat both to deeper spirituality and to deeper humanity, and they badly need some sort of *glasnost*, openness and freedom. A wider discussion will help them to open up.
v1.c8.s7.3
In this task, Muslim intellectuals can play an important role. In fact, it is expected of them. It may start a new process of rethinking among the Muslims on their fundamentals - a different and truer sort of fundamentalism than they have hitherto known.
v1.c8.s7.4
It is also a task which imposes an inescapable duty on Hindu-Buddhist thinkers with their inheritance of Yoga. In fact, India’s Yoga has a lot to contribute to the discussion. We are told that Revelations come from Gods. But from another angle, Revelations and Gods themselves come from man and his psyche, as Yoga teaches us. This psyche in turn has its various levels of purity and inwardness and every level projects its own God, Revelation and Theology. Therefore, not all Gods and Revelations have the same purity. In fact, some of them are not worthy enough and they support an equally questionable politics.
v1.c8.s7.5
Such a conclusion may disappoint many Hindu wise men who fondly cling to the belief that all religions are the same and all prophets preach and say the same things. But they must learn not to evade issues and even while seeking unities, they must yet learn to recognise differences where they exist.
v1.c8.s7.6
At the end, we again return to "Hideaway Communalism" which tells us of "evasion and concealment" and the need to "face the truth." However, the sorry fact is that in order to avoid facing truth we have built up an elaborate system of evasion and concealment which protects not merely "hideaway communalism", but also shields and even fosters more sinister forces of a "hideaway Imperialism" and a "hideaway theology" which distorts relations between man and Gods and between man and man. The need is to become aware of the problem at a deeper level and in its larger antecedents and consequences.
v1.c8.s7.7
Indian Express, June 18, 1989