Buddhist Philosophy in India and Ceylon c14.s4: 4. Precursors of the Mahāyāna
Buddhist Philosophy in India and Ceylon c14.s4
- Language
- English
4. Precursors of the Mahāyāna
c14.s4.1
Different as these schools are in view and outlook, they all are classed as within the Hīnayāna, and therefore as distinct from the Mahāyāna. The suggestion, however, has been made that the apparent distinctness is illusory and that Buddhaghosa’s list at least includes sects which would by us be classed as Mahāyānist. In support of this view it is pointed out² that the Chinese pilgrims recognize along with Mahāsāṅghikas, Mahīçasakas, Sarvāstivādins, Sāmmitīyas, Sthaviras, Lokottaravādins, the Pūrva- and Aparaçaila Vihāras, the Mahāyānists and Hīnayānists so that Buddhaghosa who wrote half a century after Fa-Hian (A.D. 400) could hardly fail to take account of schools of the Mahāyāna. This abstract argument is aided by the suggestion that a Mahāyānist school is to be detected in the Vetulyakas who are represented as docetists, and described according to some manuscripts as teachers of the great emptiness (*mahāsuññatāvādins*), while an effort has been made to compare the description of the Mahāyāna Sūtras as Vaipulyas with their name.¹ The Uttarāpathakas, a vague title, ‘northerners’ must have included Mahāyānists, since they patronized the doctrine of ‘suchness’ (*tathatā*) in the sense of the existence of something unconditioned, while the Mahāsāṅghikas held views in some respects intermediate between the Mahā- and the Hīna-yāna. It can hardly be said that this reasoning is satisfactory. The Vetulyakas appear in history in the third century A.D. and later as a dissident sect in Ceylon, and there is nothing to show that the Uttarāpathaka doctrine of ‘suchness’ assumed anything like the remarkable shape which it has in the Mahāyāna.²
c14.s4.2
² *Points of Controversy*, pp. xlv. ff.
c14.s4.3
¹ SBE. XLIX. ii. 188 f; 102 f; Kern, *Vaitulya, Vetulla, Vetulyaka* (Amsterdam, 1907); Poussin, *JRAS*. 1907, pp. 432 f., on the strength of a blunder in a Kashgar fragment of the *Saddharmapuṇḍarīka* when Vaitulya replaces Vaipulya.
c14.s4.4
² Below, ch. xii. § 1.
c14.s4.5
The Mahāsāṅghikas, again, though doubtless in doctrine forming a bridge to Mahāyāna ideas were clearly distinct from the Mahāyāna. To them belonged the Lokottaravādins, of whom we have a revised and altered relic in the shape of the *Mahāvastu*,³ which purports to be the Vinaya of the Lokottaravādins, of the Āryamahāsāṅghikas; both schools are mentioned by the Chinese pilgrims, and their importance was clearly great, but the *Mahāvastu* as preserved is decidedly late, since it refers *inter alia* to Chinese and Hunnish writing and to Greek astrology.
c14.s4.6
³ ed. Senart, Paris, 1882–97.
c14.s4.7
The Sāmmitīyas have been even less fortunate, though a Çāstra was translated into Chinese between A.D. 350 and 431. They were, it is clear, closely connected with the Vātsīputrīyas, with whom the *Abhidharmakoçavyākhyā* actually identifies them.⁴
c14.s4.8
⁴ In TRD., p. 46 they as Āryasamitīya appear as Vaibhāṣikas, and believers in a person (*pudgala*). This is untrustworthy, as regards the identification. The name may be Sammitīyas or Sāmmitīyas, and the meaning is uncertain. In MKV. (p. 148, n. 1) it stands for the Hīnayāna.
c14.s4.9
The appearance of the Mahāyāna in its developed forms as distinctive schools, Madhyamaka and Vijñānavāda, did not mean the absorption of the Hīnayāna schools, which persisted side by side with them in varying strength, the Sarvāstivādins and their subdivisions being predominant in Northern India; in the second century A. D. we find the Caitikas at Amarāvatī, the Mahāsāṅghikas at Kārli, and the Bhadrāyaṇīyas at Nāsik. The eighteen sects are mentioned by King Guhasena of Valabhī (A. D. 559), and are known to the Chinese pilgrims, but Hiuen-Tsang obtained scriptures only of the seven, Sthaviras, Mahāsāṅghikas, Mahiçāsakas, Sāmmitīyas, Kāçyapīyas, Dharmaguptas, and Sarvāstivādins and knows the Lokottaravādins, while I-Tsing groups the eighteen under the four heads of Mahāsāṅghikas, Sthaviras, Sāmmitīyas, and Mūla-Sarvāstivādins. But there were other lines of division, based on the distinction of Vinaya, Sūtra and Abhidharma, and probably these may have been more important than the school divisions proper.
c14.s4.10
While the relations of the schools among themselves were complex and varied, their relation to the Mahāyāna was obviously equally complicated; there was nothing to prevent the combination of Mahāyāna and Hīnayāna views; Fa-Hian resided at Pāṭaliputra in a Mahāyānist monastery, but found there the Vinaya of the Mahāsāṅghikas and the Sarvāstivādins; in Hiuen-Tsang’s enumeration of some 183,000 monks, 32,000 only were Mahāyāna out and out, 96,000 Hīnayāna, and 54,500 lived in monasteries where both faiths were studied, and he reckons some at least of the Sthaviras of Ceylon as Mahāyānists, a term which in I-Tsing covers all who read the Mahāyāna texts and worship Bodhisattvas. Neither he nor I-Tsing seems to be hostile to the Hīnayāna, but to regard it as merely an inferior stage of knowledge and practice; Hiuen-Tsang is credited with converting Harṣa (A. D. 606-48)—a very eclectic king—to Mahāyāna from Hīnayāna beliefs. I-Tsing apparently accepted as all valid the Vinaya of the Mūla-Sarvāstivādins; the Madhyamaka and Yogācāra or Vijñānavāda systems, regarded as rather complementary than opposed; and the Mahāyāna religious and ethical precepts. Eclecticism was doubtless encouraged by the existence of such institutions as the great University of Nālandā in Magadha, not far from Gayā, which appears to have come into prominence after the time of Fa-Hian; the district of Valabhī, on the other hand, was the stronghold of the Sāmmitīyas who, if we are to judge from Hiuen-Tsang’s numbers, were at his date the strongest sect, though this was not the case in that of I-Tsing who assigns pre-eminence to the Mūla-Sarvāstivādins, a term which we may interpret as denoting the Sarvāstivādin school proper as opposed to its Vaibhāṣika and Sautrāntika developments.¹
c14.s4.11
¹ See Kern, *Ind. Buddh.*, pp. 128 ff; Rhys Davids, *JRAS.* 1891, pp. 409 ff; 1892, pp. 1 ff; Eliot, *Hinduism and Buddhism*, ch. xxiii; Poussin, *Bouddhisme* (1898) ch. ii. Buddhaghosa, the great commentator on the Canon, and author of the *Visuddhimagga*, (c. A. D. 450-500) studied first at Gayā and may have been influenced by the Mahāyāna; Walleser, *PGAB.*, pp. 116 f; *JRAS.* 1904, p. 371.
Cites (3)
- Mahāvastu — Sanskrit
- Saddharmapuṇḍarīkasūtra — Sanskrit
- Tattvasaṃgraha — Śāntarakṣita, Sanskrit