Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

The Ayodhya Temple-Mosque Dispute: Focus on Muslim Sources c11: Chap. 6: Architectural, Art-Historical, and Epigraphical Findings

The Ayodhya Temple-Mosque Dispute: Focus on Muslim Sources c11

Language
English

Chap. 6: Architectural, Art-Historical, and Epigraphical Findings

c11.2

The Bābarī mosque contains at least 14 pillars of 5' each and of black stone of the family of schistose stone polished to look like Kasauṭī stone/touch-stone, bearing stylized designs of *kīrtimukha* and *lahara-vallarī*. 'These pillars', writes Professor R. Nath, 'did not support the main load of the celing which was passed down to the main columns of the ground floor, but only carried the lintels of the openning extensions.'¹ Their bases (piers) are 'extra thick and massive and in fact they are taking the load of the superstructure.'² The pillars carved at the base with a sacred water-pitcher called *pūrṇa-ghaṭa* or *kalaśa*. In one example a *deva-kannyā* is standing on a lotus flower and another she is replaced with a *haṁsa*. 'From this Kalash, sometimes a decorative lotus rises upon one of the octagonal facets of a pillar a female figure, standing in tribhanga mudra, still visible, although it is found heavily multilated by the iconolcasts.'³ Again, 'On all the four corners of the base of a column we see load-carrying or bharavahaka Yakshas, sitting with hands down. These are semi-divine beings in human form shown supporting the kumbhas or vessels out of which the shaft of the pillar is shown rising.'⁴ The door-jamb is of the same stone, i.e. schistose. At its base there is a standing male figure, wearing a *Kāraṇḍa-mukuṭa* on the head and a *vanamālā* on the bare front body. The right hand is in *vyākhyāna-mudrā* and the left is carrying a *triśūla*. 'Above the niche are the two vertical bands of decoration, the right one shows the rising creeper motif. The left one contains three figures of devakanyas or apsaras, i.e., nymphs or heavenly female beings, alternating on top with gana i.e., demi-divine male in the dancing pose. These are arranged one above the other, the uppermost figure is in fact a salabhanjika i.e. a female (nymph) figure holding and bending the branch of a blossming tree. The other apsaras are also shown standing in simple niches.’¹ These pillars appear to have been carved in the 11th century A.D., in *‘late Pratihār’* or *‘Gāhaḍavāl’* style.

c11.3

¹ R. Nath, p.10

c11.4

² *Ibid.*, p. 12

c11.5

³ *Evidence for the Ram Janmabhoomi Mandir*, presented to the Government of India by the Vishwa Hindu Parishad, Annexure 28

c11.6

¹ *Loc. cit.*

c11.7

Needless to emphasize that these pillars belong to an old Hindu temple. The question of their belonging to Buddhism simply does not arise, for the simple reason that in that period no Buddhist temple was built without any clear Buddhistic motif.

c11.8

We may recall that in the Janmasthān map of 1717 A.D. (Vide Appendix II, read with Appendix III) found in Kapad-Dwar, Jaipur, there are no domes at all. The superstructure is composed of three *Śikhara-s* (pyramidal, curvilinear temple-spires) with presumably corbelled ceilings. The domes and their finials appear to belong to a period later than 1717 A.D. ‘Like the domes,’ says Prof. R.Nath, ‘their *mahāpadma* and *kalaśa* too are not original and these appears to have been restored in the 18th century or later. Musallas which have been marked in the floor of the mosque too is an 18th century addition.’² He is also of the opinion that ‘If the pier and the ceilings are opened, there is likelihood of discovery of sculptures of Hindu divinities and *devanganas*.’³

c11.9

² R.Nath, p.72

c11.10

³ *Loc. cit.*