Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

The Ayodhya Temple-Mosque Dispute: Focus on Muslim Sources c12: Chap. 7: Archaeological Finds

The Ayodhya Temple-Mosque Dispute: Focus on Muslim Sources c12

Language
English

Chap. 7: Archaeological Finds

c12.1

Alexander Cunningham conducted excavations at some Buddhist places in Ayodhya in the last century. Professor A.K.Narain excavated Ayodhya by laying three trenches at three different sites considerably away from the disputed temple-mosque in 1969 and 1970. Later, from 1975 to 1980, Professor B.B.Lal, a former Director-General, Archaeological Survey of India, laid fourteen trenches at Ayodhya including one at the disputed site as part, however, of a large Central Government project, 'Archaeology of the Ramayana Sites'. The relevant data yielded by the seventeen trenches are:

c12.2

1. There had been continuous human habitation in the area of the disputed structure from 700 B.C. to 300 A.D.

c12.3

2. In a trench in the south of the structure, parallel rows of brick-bases—short, rectangular, pillar-like structures of burnt brick, each about three feet tall — have been found and are ascribable to the fourteenth-sixteenth century A.D. The directional alignment of the bases is the same as that of the several pillars of black stone found in the mosque. The bases were found hardly half a metre below the surface and appear to be meant to support the temple-mosque pillars.

c12.4

3. A well laid thick floor, made of pinkish white chunam or like and of small kankars was found running over and across a base, and even beyond the excavated area, towards the disputed structure. This is the original, disputed structure floor level. Besides, there was a well laid chunam and kankar floor below this layer, running against the bases. Again, there was one more similarly laid floor below this, running against the base.

c12.5

4. Thus, instead of one they found the remains of two floors of this pre-temple-mosque structure, which shows that the floor of the structure was restored almost completely and at least once.
5. At least in one example the base records the facts of destruction upto the foundation, evidenced by a rectangular pit without its brick base. It seems to have been done by laying a 'robber's trench' by someone interested in demolishing it and removing its bricks for some other structure.
6. In terms of archaeological stratigraphy, the two lower floors belonged to the pre-mosque structure.
7. Below the topmost floor they found a thick deposit of Islamic Glazed Ware pottery sherds of various types and colours, belonging some to the 13th, some to the 14th, and some to the 15th centuries. The find includes a White Glazed Ware with blue paintings which were in vogue in Persia in the 15th century.

c12.6

But these findings cannot be held to be conclusive, in that Professor B.B.Lal, the hero of the archaeological drama, has relented a little and come out with the suggestion to carry out further excavations at the disputed site for sufficient light on the issue. He has remarked that 'unless further excavations are carried out, the two contending parties will continue to harp on the respective stands already taken by them.'¹ Again, disturbingly enough, Prof. Suraj Bhan reveals that, in a personal discussion with him, Professor Lal agreed on the following points:

c12.7

¹ *The Times of India*, February 12, 1991

c12.8

'That there was found no evidence in his excavations at Ayodhya which could prove that the brick pillar structure in the trenches to the south of the Babari Masjid outside its compound wall was a Hindu temple.'

c12.9

'That there was found no evidence in his excavations to prove that the stone pillars used in the Babari Masjid stood on the brick pillar "bases" found in the excavations.'

c12.10

'That the vital evidence of the Muslim glazed ware (dated between 13-15 centuries) found in the above trenches marked the above age-limit of the structure of which the brick pillar stumps were a part suggesting thereby the non-existence of the brick pillar structure after the 14th century.'¹

c12.11

¹ *The Hindustan Times*, March 18, 1991

c12.12

And Professor Suraj Bhan stands uncontradicted to this day.

c12.13

Notwithstanding the confusing situation, however, confirmation of Prof. B.B. Lal's claims comes from an unexpected but authentic quarter, which cannot be brushed aside lightly. And it is a letter from Mr. Muhammed K.K., Deputy Superintending Archaeologist, Archaeological Survey of India, Madras Circle. Writing on the archaeological evidence of the existence of a temple displaced by the Bābarī mosque, he writes: 'I can reiterate this with greater authority–for I was the only Muslim who had participated in the Ayodhya excavations in 1976-1977 under Prof. Lal as a trainee in the School of Archaeology. I was at the Hanuman Garhi site, but I have visited the excavation near the Babri Masjid and seen excavated the pillar bases. The JNU historians have highlighted only one part of our findings while suppressing the other. I often wondered why Prof. Lal is keeping quiet about it while the JNU group went on a publishing spree.'²

c12.14

² *The Indian Express*, December 15, 1990

c12.15

Incidentally, the author of the letter adds a little later: 'Ayodhya is as holy to Hindus as Mecca to Muslims. Muslims should respect the sentiments of millions of their Hindu brethren and voluntarily hand over the structure for constructing the Rāma temple.'³

c12.16

³ *Loc. cit.*

c12.17

Besides, the four historians who have authored the Historians' Report to the Nation on the temple-mosque dispute have gone to the length of pointing an accusing finger at Professor B.B.Lal with the remarks: 'Though he excavated the ground over eleven years ago and thereafter published several papers on Ayodhya diggings, he first mentioned this discovery [of the brick bases in the close vicinity of the Bābarī mosque] only towards the end of 1990 (*Manthan*, October 1990). This delay, left unexplained, is certainly strange.’ They wanted to check it against site notebook and the relevant register of antiquities as well as the relevant drawings, plans, photographs, excavated material, etc., but, they contend, the Government of India did not respond to their requests in this behalf. They add that in the original report on his findings Prof. B.B.Lal had made it clear: “Several later medieval brick-and-kankar lime floors have been met with, but the entire late period was devoid of any special interest.” *Indian Archaeology, 1976-77 - A Review*, p.53).’¹

c12.18

¹ *Ramjanmabhumi-Babari Masjid: A Historians' Report to the Nation*

c12.19

These historians have made much of the adjective ‘Islamic’ in the ‘Islamic Glazed Ware potsherds’. ‘Islamic glazed ware pottery has never been used in Hindu temples’, they assert, and draw the conclusion that ‘the site was inhabited by Muslims who also lived in other parts of Ayodhya’.² They forget that such pottery has been used by Hindus as well. Its Muslim origin has nothing to do with its use.

c12.20

² *Loc. cit.*

c12.21

Recently, however, a team of Drs. Y.D. Sharma, K.M.Srivastava and S.P.Gupta claim to have carried on some excavation on the site between June 18 and July 23, 1992, and found further evidence of an ancient Hindu temple of the 11th century there. ‘A most significant piece of sculpture is the fragmentary image of Vishnu showing “Chakrapurusha”, i.e. a youthful male figure standing gracefully in tribhanga and holding vertically in the palm of the right hand the characteristic wheel or chakra of Vishnu’. Certain other finds are reported to be typical of Nāgar style temples of northern India. The team also reports that they found several courses of huge burnt brick wall running north-south and the distinct flooring of large bricks arranged in semi-circular fashion belonging to periods between the first and the eleventh centuries. A long single piece was also found fixed as part of the entrance in the disputed structure, decorated with a fully opened lotus flower in the centre and two half lotus flowers. This also belongs to the 11th century. Dr. B.R. Grover came across the remains of a very large brick flooring at this level, not only in the whole of the acquired area by the U.P. Government, but also beyond it towards the disputed structure across the road built by the British after cutting the huge Ramkot mound into two. It is spreading over thousands of square feet.¹

c12.22

¹ *The Hindustan Times*, August 8, 1992. Also see the *Indian Express* of same date

c12.23

But here, too, there are ugly circumstances out to kill the beautiful findings. The whole of the latest archaeological exercise is being adjudged illegal, for the simple reason that it was conducted without the permission of the Archaeological Survey of India, although two former Directors of the institution are actively involved in the excavations, namely, Dr. Yagya Datt Sharma and Dr. K.M. Srivastava. Besides, in the process of the excavation, even routine formalities were not observed. All the eighteen remains found in the course of the excavation were removed overnight without caring to let them remain in full view of the public and well guarded till such time as the Archaeological Survey of India, or even the relevant department of the State for that matter, was in a position to take charge of the matter.²

c12.24

² See the *Janasattā*, August 14, 1992

c12.25

Further evidence of the replacement of the Rāma temple by the Bābarī mosque was unearthed on October 10, 1992, by the archaeologists and historians assembled at Ayodhya on the occasion of the workshop on Ayodhya. They found letter *si* inscribed on the top of the right hand outer pillar of the entrance of the Bābarī mosque facing east. The script in which it has been inscribed has been determined to be the Kuṭila script prevalent during the 10th to 12th centuries.

c12.26

Besides the so-called Varāha image on the south corner of the outer wall of the Bābarī mosque transpires, on closer examination, to be part of the remains of the plinth of the temple which was destroyed. It appears that the existing wall overrides the basal part as superimposed upon it. Obviously, the base belongs to the structure of the destroyed temple.

Cites (1)