Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

The Ayodhya Temple-Mosque Dispute: Focus on Muslim Sources c13: Chap. 8: Evidence of the Tradition

The Ayodhya Temple-Mosque Dispute: Focus on Muslim Sources c13

Language
English

Chap. 8: Evidence of the Tradition

c13.1

The Rāma cult or worship of the idol of Rāma is not too non-ancient to preclude the possibility of an old enough Rāma temple predating the inception of Muslim rule in Ayodhya. From the way Samudragupta remembers Rāghava, viz. Rāma, it would not be illegitimate to infer that he did not look upon Rāma as a god or an incarnation of Viṣṇu. His partly broken Eran stone inscription purports to say that in giving away gold in charity etc. he brought low Pṛthu, Rāghava, and others.¹ Yet, not long after him, in the sixth century A.D., Varāhamihira is found laying down rules for carving out images of Rāma the son of Daśaratha (*Daśaratha-tanayo Rāmaḥ*) and Viṣṇu in temples separately.² Which means that Rāma's Avatārahood or divinity was taken for granted in his time, as also that Rāma temples were already in existence then. Apart from the existing Rāma temples dating back to the 12th and 11th centuries A.D., there is at least one temple dedicated to Rāma on the Rāmagiri hill by the Vākāṭaka king of the Deccan in the fifth century A.D., known today as Rāmaṭek, near modern Nandardhan, 30 km. north-east of Nagpur.¹

c13.2

¹ . . . . . *suvarṇa-dāne* . . . . . (*nyakkāritā*) *nṛpatayaḥ pṛthu-Rāghavādyaḥ*. Eran Stone Inscription of Samudragupta, middle of the 4th century A.D. Corpus Inscriptionum Indicarum, Vol. III: Inscriptions of the Early Gupta Kings and Their Successors, by J.F. Fleet, Part I, reprinted by the authority of the Belvedere Steam Printing Works, Allahabad by E. Hall, 1914, Śloka 2. It will be seen that the whole of the first Śloka, the first two lines and almost the whole of the third line of the second Śloka quoted above, and part of its fourth line are broken away and lost.

c13.3

² *Daśaratha-tanayo Rāmo, Baliś ca Vairocaniḥ śataṁ viṁśam* *Dvādaśahānyā śeṣāḥ pravarasamanyūna-parimāṇāḥ* *Kāryo 'ṣṭabhujo bhagavāṁś caturbhujo dvibhuja eva vā Viṣṇuḥ* *Śrīvatsāṅkitavakṣāḥ kaustubhmaṇibhūṣitoraskaḥ*. Varāhamihira, *Bṛhatsaṁhitā* 58.30-31

c13.4

¹ Abhas Kumar Chatterjee, ‘Ram Janmabhoomi: More Evidence’, *History versus Casuistry*, p.114

c13.5

Now, it is usual for temples to be built on mounds and plateaux overlooking a town. On the other hand, it is a rule with mosques to be erected within easy reach from a palace inhabited as well as frequented by Muslims, such as a market-place, highway, and other such sites.² A mosque built in a desolate area or at a place unfrequented and difficult of access would be no mosque in the eye of the *Sharī'ah*.³ And the Bābarī mosque is standing on the Ramkot mound and that, too, in an area which is said to have been devoid of Muslims all along. Indeed, in his judgment dated March 18, 1886, quoted earlier, Col. Chamier, District Judge, Fyzabad, has remarked that ‘*the masjid built by the Emperor Babar stands on the border of the town of Ayodhya, that is to say to the west and south. It is clear of habitations.*’⁴ (Italics added)

c13.6

² *Fatḥu ’l-Qadīr*, Vol. I, p.377

c13.7

³ *Fatāwā-i ’Ālamgīrī*, Vol. VI, p.214. Also see Muḥammad Zafīru ’d-Dīn Pūrā-Nauḍīhāwī, *Islām ka Nizām-i Masājid*, p.181, for fuller information partaining to notes 88 and 89 both.

c13.8

⁴ See Col. F.E.A. Chamier, District Judge, Faizabad’s judgment dated March 18, 1886, in Civil Appeal No.27 of 1885, Mahant Raghubar Dass versus Secretary of State of India and Mohammed Ashgar Defendant-Respondents.

c13.9

It is indeed unthinkable that the mound was not used for building a temple, while for building a mosque it was. Again, association of Ayodhya with the birth of Rāma as an incarnation of Viṣṇu predates the advent of Islam, much more so of Bābar and earlier Muslim marauders on Indian soil. Some Vikramāditya is traditioned to have discovered and determined the present Ayodhya to be the birth-place of Rāma. It is unbelievable, therefore, that the HIndus could not have thought of erecting a suitable temple for facility of Rāma’s devotees, especially in view of the fact that regular fairs have been held from time immemorial on the occasion of his birthday celebrations every year. The fairs and their antiquity have been attested to by William Finch and Abu'l-Faḍl, as we have seen already.

c13.10

It is also to be borne in mind that Hindus have never been interested in laying claim to others' places of worship, not to speak of shedding their blood in trying to usurp them. In fact, they did not feel called upon to retrieve the temples lost to the Muslim rulers even after decline of the Mūghul power, not to speak of turning mosques into temples.

c13.11

Well, gaps in history have to be filled up with the help of the tradition, if available. Take an example. No texts were composed concerning the life of the Prophet of Islam till after about 125 years of his death. Much of what we know of him comes from tradition. Likewise, the mosque built by him at Medinah, the *Masjidu 'n-Nabiyy* as it is called, out of mud-walls, palm-leaves, and palm-trunks, is no longer visible or even discernible, thanks to the drastic overhauling and modernization it has undergone since. It is only tradition which holds the mirror up to its identity.

c13.12

Now, there is no evidence that the Bābarī mosque has not displaced the Rāma Janmabhūmī temple or that such a temple simply did not exist. That, had it existed and been demolished, Tulasīdāsa and so and so much have referred to it, is no argument. Alexander's invasion of India is a fact, yet it finds no mention in any contemporary Sanskrit, Pali, Prakrit, or Apabhraṁśa record. As for Tulasīdāsa, he does not take note of Akbar's even pro-Hindu reforms. It was not the way of Tulasīdāsa to speak of particular contemporary events. Besides, it is an open secret that the Hindus of old were bad at history, worse at geography, and worst at cartography. Hence such omissions on their part are quite understandable.

c13.13

It is malicious to ascribe the origin of the tradition of the displacement of the Rāma temple with the Bābarī mosque to British propaganda pursuant to their (more mythical than real) policy of divide-and-rule. Apart from the questionability of imputing anything and everything to such a policy, the tradition is found to pre-exist the inception of the British rule in this country. As we have seen already, the British Government hastened to proscribe Mīrzā Jān's *Ḥadīqah-ī Shuhadā* soon after its publication, whereas it would have proved a good contrivance to set the Hindus and the Muslims against each other.

c13.14

It would be interesting to conclude this chapter with an artful censure of the pro-Bābarī historians by a boy of 15, who advises them to use this argument : 'Since the Hindus were great astrologers and forecasters they knew in *Treta Yuga* itself that in *Kaliyuga* in A.D. 1528 a person named Babar, who will be believer of Islam will come to Ayodhya. He would need a place to build a mosque for Allah and for angels. Hindus well known for their religious tolerance thought which else could be a better place for this than the palace of Lord Rama (Ram Kot) and the birth place of Rama itself. Thus they kept the place reserved for Babar to build a mosque on the birth place, surrounded by Sita-ki-Rasoi, Kausalya Bhawan, Hanumangarhi etc. etc. They must have undergone tremendous trouble in keeping the place free and constantly renewing the lease of land for Babar. But their astrological calculations went wrong and they did not realize that there will be another king in the line called Aurangzeb and did not leave any land free for him to build the mosques. Thus, he ordered the destruction of thousands of temples to build the mosques thereon.'¹

c13.15

¹ K.S. Ramchandran, *Ayodhya Dispute and Prof. Irfan Habib : A Distortea Scholarship*, pp. 30-31

Cites (1)