Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

The Ayodhya Temple-Mosque Dispute: Focus on Muslim Sources c15: Chap. 10: Was Bābar Too Tolerant to Demolish the Rāma Temple?

The Ayodhya Temple-Mosque Dispute: Focus on Muslim Sources c15

Language
English

Chap. 10: Was Bābar Too Tolerant to Demolish the Rāma Temple?

c15.1

No, Bābar was anything but too tolerant to demolish the temple. Temple demolition had been the order of the day ever since the advent of Islam, and there is no reason to believe that Bābar struck out an opposite line for himself and thereby anticipated his grandson (Akbar). By all accounts, he continued the policy of his predecessors in an orthodox fashion, except possibly for hitting the Hindus a little harder by subjecting them to pay stamp duties (*tamaghah*) over and above the *Jizyah* and Pilgrimage Tax already imposed on them to the exclusion of the Muslims.

c15.2

An officer of Bābar, Hindū Beg, converted the Hari Mandir at Sambhal into a mosque.¹ His Sadr, Shaykh Zayn, demolished a number of temples when he occupied it.² And his destruction of Jain temples at Urwa near Gwalior?³ He was exhorted by a noble of Kabul to conquer India with the remark that 'God and Muḥammad engaged you to extinguish the idolatry of the Indians.⁴ He raised a tower of Hindu skulls at Fatehpur Sikri and Chanderi and assumed the title of Ghāzī (killer of infidels in *Jihād*). He makes no bones about it. He writes: 'After this success *Ghāzī* (Victor in a Holy-War) was written amongst the royal titles. Below the titles (*tughrā*) entered on the *Fatḥ-nāma*, I wrote the following quatrain :

c15.3

¹ *Archaeological Survey of India Report*, XII, 26-27

c15.4

² *Tārīkh-i Bābarī* (MS), 145, cited in Sri Ram Sharma, *The Religious Policy of the Mughal Emperors*, p.9

c15.5

³ *Babur-Nama*, II, p.612

c15.6

⁴ S.R.Sharma, *Mughal Empire in India*, p.16

c15.7

*For Islam's sake, I wandered in the wilds,*
*Perpared for war with pagans and Hindūs,*

c15.8

*Resolved myself to meet the martyr's death*
*Thanks be to God! a ghāzī I became.*¹

c15.9

¹ *Babur-Nama*, II, pp. 574-575

c15.10

Bābar's memoirs are full of contemptuous references to the Hindus. Ordering gold and silver goblets and cups and other utensils used for drinking parties to be dashed upon the earth and broken down, he remarked, 'They dashed them in pieces, as, God willing! soon will be dashed the gods of the idolaters'.² Why not? 'Abdu 'l-Quddūs Gaṅgohī, a Muslim divine and Ṣūfī of repute, taught him in a long letter to humble and humiliate infidels in all possible ways, and compel them to hide their infidelity and not to practise it publicly, and thereby bring the glory of Islam to perfection.³

c15.11

² *Ibid.*, pp.554-555

c15.12

³ *Maktūbāt-i 'Abdu 'l-Quddūs Gaṅgohī* (MS), No. 104 (Taṣauuf), University Collections, Maulana Azad Library, Aligarh Muslim University, Aligarh, Letter No. 169

c15.13

With a strong sense of belonging to the line of Chingīz Khān, Bābar followed his custom of setting fire to towns for good omen and did so at Lahore (*Bābar qarīn-i fatḥ-o zafar ba-bilād-i Lāhaur dar-āmadah chunāṅ-ki rasm-o ādāb-i Chingīziyān ast bāzār-hā jihat-i fāl-o shagūn ātish zad*).⁴ While condemning Bābar for his tyranny in strongest terms, the great Guru Nānak makes a clear reference to the arson and massacre, including burning of temples, carried out by him at Aimanabad thus:

c15.14

⁴ *Tārīkh-i Firishtah*, Vol.I (Persian). Cp. Urdu tr., I, p. 121

c15.15

*Thān mukām jale bij mandar muchhi muchhi kuir rulāiyā*⁵

c15.16

⁵ *Guru Nānak Racanāvalī, Bābar-Vāṇī* 3, p. 246

c15.17

As regards Bābar's attitude towards temples, enough has been said by now. One issue remains to be taken care of, however. Bābar admired the beauty of the Teli/Tilangana temple at Gwalior.⁶ On this ground it is asserted that such Bābar cannot demolish temples. But it is forgotten that even Maḥmūd of Ghaznīn was impressed by temple architecture. He was all praise for the temples of Mathura, the like of which, according to him, it would take full two centuries to build up and that, too, at the cost of one lakh gold coins per temple.¹ But, then, this did not stand in the way of his tiring out himself by smashing them all. It is rather the way of vandals and philistines to make works of art the first target of their attack.

c15.18

⁶ *Babur-Nama*, II, p.613

c15.19

¹ *Tarīkh-i Firishtah*, I, p. 588; Al-'Uṭbī, *Tarīkh-i Yamīnī*, pp. 44-45

c15.20

Well, as regards the Ayodhya temple, we have seen how, according to a certain record, Bābar was first hesitant in ordering its demolition but had to yield to the pressure exercised by Mīr Mūsā 'Ashiqān and Sayyid Jalāhu'd-Dīn.

Cites (1)