Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

The Ayodhya Temple-Mosque Dispute: Focus on Muslim Sources c26.s2: Rejoinder to the AIBMAC's Reply to the Questionnaire

The Ayodhya Temple-Mosque Dispute: Focus on Muslim Sources c26.s2

Language
English

Rejoinder to the AIBMAC's Reply to the Questionnaire

c26.s2.1

1-2. The AIBMAC's reply to the first question seems to suggest that none has made the offer that, if the existence and demolition of a temple for construction of the Bābarī mosque is established, the Muslims will hand over the site to the Hindus. It is tantamount to denying the obvious. It appears that at least two important members of the AIBMAC – Mr Jawed Habib and Sayyid Ahmad Bukhari, whose offer to the same effect was published only the other day – have not seen the Committee's reply to these two questions. Let them say whether or not they made the offer referred to in the opening question. (Let others alone for the moment). A more responsible reply was expected of the AIBMAC.

c26.s2.2

3-5. The AIBMAC insist that the mosque of evil was not a mosque but a pseudo-mosque. But the Qur'ān (9.107) does call it a 'mosque' and the Prophet, too, treated it as such originally. However, from their reply it transpires that a pseudo-mosque can be destroyed. Their formula, therefore, needs to be modified like this : 'Once a mosque always a mosque', but, if a mosque is shown to be a pseudo-mosque, it should be destroyed like the '*masjidu 'ḍ-ḍirār*'. Thus, if the Bābarī mosque is a pseudo-mosque, it would deserve destruction, on their own showing.

c26.s2.3

6-9. The AIBMAC say in reply that 'The non-Muslim population in the Delhi Sultanate' was non-Dhimmī. Did the Sultāns abolish the Jizyāh ? If not, how can Jizyāh-payers be non-Dhimmī-s ?

c26.s2.4

10-11. The AIBMAC do not demur to the precedents created by certain Caliphs in restoring to the Dhimmī-s their places of worship replaced forcibly by mosques wholly or partially. These precedents go to demolish the formula 'Once a mosque always a mosque'. The AIBMAC contend in reply that the precedents 'are to be considered and discussed on the merits of each case'. Let them do so, but with what results ?

c26.s2.5

As regards Akbar and Shāh Jahān, it is to be borne in mind that the 'Bābarī mosque' was a deserted mosque and in full use of the Hindus. That is why no author from 1530 to 1706 A.D. refers to it even remotely. On the other hand, it is remembered as 'Rāma Janma Bhūmi' by Sant Lāladāsa in his *Avadhavilāsa* composed in 1675 A.D.

c26.s2.6

In fact, even William Finch (1608-11) found neither the mosque nor Muslims but only Paṇḍā-s in the Ramkot which was in ruins then.

c26.s2.7

It is also to be borne in mind that the complaint about the destruction of the Cintāmaṇī Pārśvanātha temple was made to Shāh Jahān not by non-Muslims but by Mullā Abdul Ḥakīm who argued that 'this building by reason of its being the property of another person, could not be considered a mosque according to the inviolable Islamic law'. (M.S. Commissariat, *Studies in the History of Gujarat*, p. 58). (Kindly read '*Musalmānoṅ*' for '*Hinduoṅ*' in the Hindi version of question 10.)

c26.s2.8

12-13. The *Ṣaḥīfah-i Chihal Naṣā'iḥ-i Bahādurshāhī* is not a 19th but an 18th century work. The AIBMAC's reply that the Muslim documents of the 19th and 18th centuries are not reliable is simply arbitrary. The Qur'ān alone claims that the Kā'bah was built or rebuilt by Abraham. His journey to and sojourn in Arabia are not supported by the Bible. Are the AIBMAC prepared to discard the Qur'ānic statement as unreliable for the simple reason that Abraham preceded the revelation by some 3,700 years ?

c26.s2.9

The 19th century documents refer to past records and books of history, from which they derive the information about the replacement of the Rāma temple by the Bābarī mosque. There is no reason to disbelieve them.

c26.s2.10

When they made the said statement, the case of the Hanūmāngaḍhī was pending in the Royal Court and the British Resident, too, had a hand in the matter. The Muslims’ claim was based on their contention that the place had all along been occupied by a mosque and not by a temple. If the Bairagis’ claim that there was only a temple and no mosque had been established, the Muslims would have lost their case. On the same analogy the related case of the Bābarī mosque would have been lost by the Muslims on their own showing that it had replaced a temple. Even so, they took the risk of telling the truth in their writings. How can then they be called ‘unreliable’?

c26.s2.11

14. Tieffenthaler was not the first but the second known author to speak of the demolition of the Rāma Janmabhūmi temple. He visited Ayodhya in the sixties of the 18th century. But the *Ṣaḥīfah-ī Chihal-Naṣā'iḥ-i Bahādurshāhī* in which the reference first occurs belongs to the first decade of the 18th century. The Janmabhūmi tradition is attested to by the *Avadhavilāsa* of 1675 A.D. and the *Ayodhyā-Mahātmya* of the 14th century A.D., a pre-Bābar part of the *Skanda-Purāṇa* referred to by Jīva Gosvāmin & Mitra Miśra.

c26.s2.12

15-16. These questions remain unanswered. Was the veracity of the statement by the Muslim authors ever called in question prior to the present controversy ? And is there any instance of a non-existent temple’s being described as demolished by any conqueror or emperor ? These are straight questions demanding straight answers.

c26.s2.13

OCTOBER 22, 1992

Cites (2)