The Ayodhya Temple-Mosque Dispute: Focus on Muslim Sources c6: Chap. 1: The Dispute
The Ayodhya Temple-Mosque Dispute: Focus on Muslim Sources c6
- Language
- English
Chap. 1: The Dispute
c6.2
It was almost a rule with Muslim conquerors and rulers to strive to annihilate polytheism and idol-worship (*shirk*) and other forms of infidelity (*kufr*) by, *inter alia*, desecrating or destroying infidels’ places of worship and often converting them into mosques, monasteries, etc. or raising on their sites new mosques, monasteries, etc. The number of such desecrations, destructions, conversions, and constructios runs into tens of thousands. Taking account of some well attested vandalisms of this kind, we find that Maḥmūd the Ghaznawid (997-1030) is responsible for converting several thousands of temples into mosques (*chandīn hazār butkhānah rā masjid gardānīd*).¹ He burnt down one thousand temples of Mathura and desecrated or despoiled ten thousand temples of Qannauj.² His successor Sulṭān Abu ’l-Muzaffar Ibrāhīm bin Mas‘ūd (1059-1099) destroyed at one time one thousand temples one thousand years old each, in Ganga-Yamuna Doāb and Malwa.³ Likewise Muḥammad the Ghorid (1175-1216) converted one thousand temples of Varanasi into mosques⁴ and Quṭbu ’d-Dīn Aibak (1192-1206-1210) pulled down one thousand temples of Delhi by employing elephants.⁵ Thousands of mosques might have succumbed, in Kuch-Bihar, Ujjain, Udaipur, Jodhpur, Golkonda, Bijapur, Maharashtra, and certainly in several other parts of the Mughul empire, to the successive ordinances promulgated by Auraṅgzīb (1657-1707) from time to time.¹ And as many as over eight thousand temples are reported to have been desecrated and despoiled by as late a Sulṭān as Ṭipū (1782-1799).² Incidentally, Sita Ram Goel lists some two thousand mosques and other such Muslim monuments standing on the sites of temples demolished by Muslim rulers.³ Besides, thousands of temples were desecrated or despoiled or replaced by mosques etc. by the Khaljī-s, Tughluq-s, and other Muslim emperors on one hand and regional rulers like Sikandar Butshikan (1389-1413) and ‘Alī Shāh (1413-1420) of Kashmir, Maḥmūd Khaljī (1436-1469) of Malwa, ‘Alī ‘Ādil Shāh I (1557-1579) of Bijapur, and several other such rulers.
c6.3
¹ Minhāj Sirāj, *Ṭabaqāt-i Nāṣirī*, p.9
c6.4
² Al - ‘Uṭbī, *Kitabu’l-Yamīniyy* (Arabic), Elliot & Dowson, *History of India As Told by Its Own Historians*, Vol. II, pp. 44-46; Ghiyāthu ’d-Dīn Muḥammad bin Ḥusāmu ’d-Dīn, *Habību ’s-Siyar*, Eng. tr., pp. 179-180
c6.5
³ Khawājah Mas‘ūd bin Sa‘d bin Salmān, *Dīwān-i Salmān*, Elliot & Dowson, IV, pp. 518-519
c6.6
⁴ Ṣadru ’d-Dīn Muḥammad Ḥasan Nizāmī, *Tāju ’l-Ma‘āṣir*, *ibid*., II, pp. 216-217
c6.7
⁵ Shaykh Muḥammad Ikrām, *Chashmah-i Kawthar*, p.59
c6.8
¹ S. R. Sharma, *Mughal Empire in India*, p. 277
c6.9
² *The Mysore Gazetteer*, Vol. II, Modern, Part IV, p. 2584
c6.10
³ Arun Shourie & others, *Hindu Temples*, Vol. I
c6.11
To be sure, India under Muslim domination was India under siege, India under veritable slavery, from which it had a moment’s respite under British rule, which finds an echo in the following Hindi stanza sang by Bhāratendu Harishchandra while welcoming the Prince of Wales in 1875 :
c6.12
*Jaise ātapa-tapita ko chāyā sukhada gunāta*
*Javana-rāja ke anta tuva āgama timi darasāta*
*Masjid lakhi Bisunātha ḍhiga pare hiye jo ghāva*
*Tā kañha marham sarisa yaha tuva darsana nara-rāva*
c6.13
In English : ‘Your visit at the demise of the Muslim rule, O ruler of men ! proves to be as soothing as a shade to a sun-stricken man. Your *darśana* (appearance) here is like ointment to the wound sustained by our heart on our seeing the mosque near the Viśvanātha temple.’ Indeed, we were veritable slaves of the Muslim rulers in general but subjects of the British. Our subjection to the British had significant redeeming features. As I have said elsewhere, ‘The Muslim rulers burnt but the British built libraries, rescuing and recovering our ancient texts from extinction; the former ruined but the latter rescued ancient monuments and symbols of perennial Indian culture; the former obstructed but the latter constructed centres of Sanskrit learning; the former prevented but the latter permitted practice and propagation of as well as conversion and reconversion to Hinduism.'
c6.14
Indeed, in our earnestness to get rid of the subjection to the British, we turned a blind eye to the danger of slavery to the forces of Islam. In the result the Muslims carved a *Dār al-Islām* (later split into two) out of the Hindus' only worthwhile abode that is India, virtually emptied the Western part of the *Dār al-Islām* of the Hindus, are enacting the same drama in the eastern part, and have managed to get the upper hand in the truncated India that is Bharat.
c6.15
There was, all the same, a silver-lining in the dark cloud of the partition, viz. an opportunity to get rid of the Muslim problem, miscalled communal problem, by means of transfer of population as suggested by B.R. Ambedkar as also M.A. Jinnah. But we did not heed them. The next best course would have been to circumscribe the Muslims' choice to continue here by such conditions that the millennium-old problem could not raise its head again. At any rate, restoration of some of the usurped temples to the Hindus ought to have been secured then and there.
c6.16
This was not done. In 1949, however, certain idols including one of 'Rām Lalā Virājamān' as they say, made their appearance by human or superhuman design, speaking non-committally, to the accompaniment of chants and music. Later; a claim was in the air for restoration of the Rāma Janmabhūmi at Ayodhya, Kṛṣṇa Janmabhūmi at Mathura, and Kāshī Viśvanātha temple at Varanasi, said to have been replaced by mosques wholly or partially.
c6.17
The Hindu side has chosen, however, to agitate for the Rāma Janmabhūmi only, holding the other two claims in abeyance. Their case is that the Rāma Janmabhūmi temple was replaced by Bābar by what has come to be called Bābarī mosque. Muslim leaders demand proof. And with this we are concerned in this work.
c6.18
I happen to be a member of the panel of experts appointed by the Vishva Hindu Parishad to hold a dialogue on the issue with the experts of the All India Babari Masjid Action Committee under the auspices of the Home Ministry. Somehow, the first dialogue proved abortive.
c6.19
I have all along been inclined to believe that the Hindu side has unnecessarily complicated matters for itself by inviting the imbroglio of reconstruction of the Rāma temple. What is crucial in this case is repossession rather than reconstruction. And now the slogan of reconstruction has yielded place to that of (new) construction. Thus the real issue has given way to the issue as to where the construction should take place. And the Hindus' proverbial self-complacency argues: Why fight for the temple site ? Every site is Rāma's site.
c6.20
Another blunder of the Hindus has been the half-hearted manner in which they are pursuing the matter in the law-court, of which, however, the less said the better.
c6.21
Well, all relevant British government records, followed by the *U.P. District Gazetteers–Faizabad* compiled and published by the Congress government in U.P. in 1960, declare it with one voice that the Bābarī mosque at Ayodhya is standing on the debris of a Rāma Janmabhūmi temple demolished at the behest of Bābar in 935 A.H./1528 A.D. On the other hand, Muslim leaders as well as leftist historians and politicians have since the last decade been proclaiming that existence and demolition of such a temple is a myth floated by the British in pursuance of their policy of divide-and-rule.
c6.22
The Muslim scholars further contend that, being a true Muslim, Bābar could not have tampered with any temple that way, for, they argue, a mosque erected on usurped land would be no mosque in the eye of the *Sharī'ah*. On this ground, they have all along been offering to hand over the mosque to the Hindus, provided it be shown independently of British sources that it has displaced a temple. Sayyid Şabāhu 'd-Dīn 'Abdu 'r-Rahmān modifies the stand thus: 'It is also thinkable that some mosque was erected close to or at a short distance from a temple demolished for some special reason, but never was a mosque built on the site of a temple anywhere.'¹
c6.23
¹ *Loc. cit.*; Sita Ram Goel, *Hindu Temples*, Vol. II
c6.24
Well, granting for the nonce that the Bābarī mosque cannot be shown to have displaced a temple, there are thousands of mosques which can indisputably be.² Will the offer hold good for them ? And what about the Ka'bah ? Was it not converted from an idol-temple, a temple housing as many as three hundred sixty idols of gods and goddesses ?
c6.25
² *Ibid.*
c6.26
The position of the *Sharī'ah* on the issue will be explored in chapter *XIII infra*.
c6.27
In connexion with the temple-mosque dispute, the so-called secular scholars and leaders tend often to belittle or ignore the relevance, value, and power of the Hindus' indomitable faith in Rāma and his place of birth and question the historicity of Rāma, antiquity of the Rāma cult, antiquity of the existing Ayodhya, and the mosque-site's being the exact birth-place of Rāma. These are important topics for historians but not very germane to the problem in hand. Existence or non-existence of some temple, believed by millions to be the Rāma Janmabhūmi temple, followed by forcible replacement by the present mosque, is the only point at issue. Innocuous religious beliefs must be respected in a democratic spirit, even where they may be found unacceptable to others. Otherwise, similar questions will begin to be raised on the dogmas of Islam and other religions and solution of our problem will become an impossibility.
c6.28
Take the example of the Ka'bah. The Prophet passed fourteen years and a half of his twentythree-year long ministry without the Ka'bah as his *Qiblah* (towards which one turns while praying). All these years, it was Jerusalem towards which the faithful were required to bow in prayer. Then he received the revelation from on high to change the Qiblah to the Ka'bah,³ which remained the Qiblah for eight years and a half till the Prophet's death. To that end, a myth was invented, the myth of the religion of Ibrāhīm (millat-iIbrāhīm)¹ or the religion of Ḥanīf (*millat-i Ibrāhīma Ḥanīfan*)² and reconstruction of the Kaʻbah by Ibrāhīm and Ismāʻīl,³ even though there is not a trace of evidence that Ibrāhīm ever visited Mecca. Who can prove the existence of the religion of Ibrāhīm and reconstruction of the Kaʻbah by him ?
c6.29
³ *Q.*, al-Baqarah (2) 125, 144, 149, 150
c6.30
¹ Q., *ibid.* 130
c6.31
² *Ibid.* 135; Āl ʻImrān (3) 3.94; al-Anʻām (6) 162; an-Niḥal (16) 123
c6.32
³ Q., al-Baqarah (2) 127
c6.33
We accordingly leave such side-issues and proceed to consider the question of evidence of the existence of the Rāma temple and its destruction by Bābar.
Cites (3)
- Tāj al-maʾāthir — Ḥasan Niẓāmī, Persian
- Visvanatha Temple
- Ṭabaqāt-i Nāṣirī — Minhāj al-Dīn Jūzjānī, Persian