Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

Samnyasa Upanishads: Hindu Scriptures on Asceticism and Renunciation c5.s2.t2: 2.2 Socioeconomic Changes in Sixth-Century India

Saṃnyāsa Upaniṣads: Hindu Scriptures on Asceticism and Renunciation c5.s2.t2

Language
English

2.2 Socioeconomic Changes in Sixth-Century India

c5.s2.t2.1

In the foregoing discussion we saw a central feature of, to use Peter Berger's (1969) category, Brāhmaṇical world construction, that is, the social creation of a common conceptual framework within which individuals can understand and find meaning in their discrete experiences of themselves and of the social and physical world outside. Sacrificial and procreative theology addressed in a special way the marginal situation of death where the socially constructed world is threatened with ultimate meaninglessness. In explaining death and the means of overcoming it, moreover, this theology legitimized the central social institution of marriage and, by extension, society itself.

c5.s2.t2.2

All culturally created worlds, however, are intrinsically unstable (Berger 1969, 29). They are constantly challenged by new experiences, by changes in geography, climate, and economics, by social and political upheavals, and by individuals and groups seeking better answers and new meanings. Here I want to examine briefly the momentous social, economic, and political changes that took place along the Ganges valley roughly around the sixth century B.C.E., changes that facilitated the rise of rival worldviews and the ascetic challenge to the Brāhmaṇical definition of the ideal religious life.

c5.s2.t2.3

The Aryans who migrated into India during the second millennium B.C.E. were nomads. They lived in tribes, and their economy was based principally on cattle rearing. Their tribal organization persisted even after these people had settled down in the upper Gangetic plane and agriculture had replaced cattle as their principal economic activity. They lived in small village communities. The Vedic civilization remained village based until the sixth century B.C.E. This village culture is the social background of the Brāhmaṇical theology that we have examined. The Brāhmaṇical *dharma* is addressed to the villager.

c5.s2.t2.4

The Indus Valley Civilization boasted an urban culture centered around the two principal cities of Harappa and Mohenjo Dāro, but this ancient urban civilization came to an end toward the middle of the second millennium B.C.E., and it is unlikely that it exerted an appreciable influence on Vedic culture and religion. "For her next cities, her 'second urbanization,' India had to wait for over a thousand years after the disappearance of the Indus cities—till the middle of the sixth century B.C., which saw simultaneously the beginnings of her historical period" (Ghosh 1973, 2).

c5.s2.t2.5

We can detect five major elements in the socioeconomic changes of the sixth century: food surplus, increase in population, trade, monarchical states, and, above all, cities.¹⁷ Throughout the Vedic period we detect the movement of the Aryan population to the lower regions of the Ganges valley, where the land was very fertile and rain more abundant. Rice cultivation on wetlands became the major agricultural activity, and rice replaced barley as the staple food. Although there is disagreement among scholars regarding the cause, it is clear that wetland rice cultivation gave rise to an agricultural surplus that permitted both urbanization and an increase in population.¹⁸

c5.s2.t2.6

¹⁷ For a balanced, clear, and informative description of these changes, see Ghosh 1973, and Gombrich 1988, 49–50.

c5.s2.t2.7

¹⁸ Some scholars argue that it was the invention of the iron axe and plough that made possible the clearing of the forests and the large-scale colonization and cultivation of that fertile land. Others point to the lack of archaeological evidence for such widespread use of iron tools during this period and question their need for successful farming or for creating urban cultures. See Gombrich 1988. Regarding the effects of rice on the increase of population, see Ling 1976, 49–51, where further bibliography is also given.

c5.s2.t2.8

The last three elements—trade, monarchies, and cities—are the most significant for our study. All three ultimately depended on the agricultural bounty of the rich Gangetic soil. Gombrich (1988, 53) offers some insightful comments on the interrelationship of these elements:

c5.s2.t2.9

Towns and cities arise primarily as settlements of people whose main livelihood is not derived directly from agriculture—though to be sure they may also house absentee landlords. They are political and commercial centres. There can be no trade without an economic surplus; but though trade seems to be a necessary condition for the creation of towns, it is not a sufficient one. On the other hand, it is too easily forgotten that commerce itself depends on organization: on an infrastructure of communications and a certain level of legality and security, both products of stable political conditions. . . . It is kings who construct the roads along which vehicles can move and allow for land trade in larger quantities than a pedlar carries on his back. Moreover, security in the countryside of Bihar and neighbouring areas has rarely if ever been good; without the security provided by towns, large-scale trade is impossible.

c5.s2.t2.10

Along the Ganges valley, in a region commonly referred to as the "Middle Country," relatively large kingdoms began to be consolidated under the absolute authority of kings who were constantly seeking to expand their power and territories through aggression and alliance. We detect here the beginning of states, as opposed to the village or regional political structures that existed in the Vedic period.

c5.s2.t2.11

The military capability of the kings assured a relatively efficient and safe network of roads and waterways, a necessary prerequisite for maintaining a central government and for administering a large territory. The facility of travel also enabled religious mendicants to travel freely over a large region and to disseminate new ideas and customs. It also enabled a merchant class to flourish. Merchants established the first professional organizations in India. Merchant guilds had their own laws and government, which were respected by the civil authority. Trade was also facilitated by the creation of money; the first coins of India go back to the late sixth century B.C.E.¹⁹

c5.s2.t2.12

¹⁹ It is a matter of controversy whether writing was used during this period. See Ghosh 1973, 27; Gombrich 1988, 53.

c5.s2.t2.13

Cities and courts of kings attracted nobles, priests, philosophers, and leaders of religious sects. The breakdown of the strict family and kinship networks that urban life entailed and the resultant freedom for individual initiatives clearly encouraged both ideological and practical challenges to traditional Brāhmaṇism. The many religious movements that arose about this time were primarily urban in nature. Speaking of Buddhism, one of the most successful of such movements, Gombrich (1988, 50) says:

c5.s2.t2.14

The most obvious difference from the [Vedic] society . . . is that that was entirely rural, a village-based society, whereas the Buddha spent much of his time in cities. Max Weber aptly begins his account of Buddhism with these words: “Like Jainism, but even more clearly, Buddhism presents itself as the product of the time of urban development, of urban kingship and the city nobles.”²⁰ The Buddha talked to kings, Pasenadi of Kosala, Bimbisāra and his son Ajātasattu of Magadha, who ruled quite sizeable territories from their urban capitals.

c5.s2.t2.15

²⁰ Max Weber, *The Religion of India*, trans. and ed. Hans H. Gerth and Don Martindale (New York: The Free Press, 1958), 204.

c5.s2.t2.16

Cities, kings, and the merchant class contributed to the rise of individualism, a factor extremely significant for our study. Dumont (1960), as we have remarked, has argued that Vedic thought lacked the concept of the individual; it was the group that gave the individual conceptual reality. Caste ideology stressed the centrality of the group at the expense of the individual. Even though Dumont’s dichotomy between the lack of the individual in the world and the centrality of the individual in the renunciation of the world may not present a totally accurate picture of the individual in Indian history, nevertheless he is right in pointing out the marginal status of the individual in the mainstream of Vedic thought. The factors that contributed to the discovery of the individual as a central concept in religious and social thought both within and outside the institution of world renunciation, however, were the emergence of kingship and urban culture. The king, of course, was the supreme individual in society. That he belonged to the noble class was pure theory; he was not just another member of a group. There was no one like him in his kingdom. Ambition, strategy, and intrigue all played a role in a man's becoming a king and in expanding his realm. Even patricide appears to have been committed by impatient royal heirs. A similar individualistic mentality may have been prevalent among merchants, whose success depended less on following an inherited and ritualized pattern of behavior than on initiative and enterprise.

c5.s2.t2.17

The individualistic spirit permitted the creation of the first voluntary religious organizations in India. The Buddhist and Jain monastic orders are the earliest available examples of such organizations. People entered them because they wanted to, because they had taken a personal decision regarding how they wanted to live their lives. They were not following a set pattern for correct living ritualized in life-cycle ceremonies. They exercised the same individual initiative at the religious level that kings and merchants exercised in the political and economic fields. The freedom to choose that was encouraged by the new urban environment, we shall see, is at the heart of both the challenges to the Vedic religious ideal and the theology of the *āśrama* system.

Cites (2)