The Encyclopedia of Indian Philosophies v7.c42: Saṅgītiparyāya
The Encyclopedia of Indian Philosophies v7.c42
- Language
- English
Contents
- v7.c42.s1 I. Section of Ones — 3 parts
- v7.c42.s2 II. Section of Twos — 8 parts
- v7.c42.s3 III. Section of Threes — 21 parts
- v7.c42.s4 IV. Section of Fours — 51 parts
- v7.c42.s5 V. Section of Fives — 9 parts
- v7.c42.s6 VI. Section of Sixes — 25 parts
- v7.c42.s7 VII. Sets of Sevens — 14 parts
- v7.c42.s8 VIII. Section of Eights — 10 parts
- v7.c42.s9 IX. Section of Nines — 1 part
- v7.c42.s10 X. Section of Tens — 1 part
Saṅgītiparyāya
v7.c42.1
Summary by Christian Lindtner
v7.c42.2
The Saṅgītiparyāya (SGP) is a commentary, belonging to the Sarvāstivāda school, on the Saṅgītisūtra (SS), a sūtra which along with the Daśottarasūtra marks the earliest phase of Abhidharma in India. The SS is also extant in a Theravāda recension (Saṅgītisuttanta = Dīghanikāya xxxiii) and a Dharmaguptaka recension (only extant in Chinese). These three recensions differ in a number of details.
v7.c42.3
Apart from a few Sanskrit fragments the SGP is only available in a Chinese version done by the famous Hsüan-tsang. According to Chinese tradition SGP is a work of Śāriputra whereas Yaśomitra and Bu-ston ascribe its authorship to Mahākauṣṭhila. Along with the Dharmaskandha (which it often quotes) and the Prajñaptiśāstra (which is later than the SGP) it comprises the earliest stage of Sarvāstivāda Abhidharma.
v7.c42.4
The Chinese text is Taisho (=“T”) 1536. Both SS and SGP have been edited and translated into German by Valentine Stache-Rosen. References in the summary below to this work are indicated by “E”. Brief summaries of the work exist by J. Takakusu and S.C. Banerjee.
v7.c42.5
Since the SGP usually follows the SS very closely in its structure and contents—it consists of ten sections (nipāta) dealing with 203 sets of different dharmas—the best way to treat it will be to provide a synopsis of these chapters and categories with an abbreviated paraphrase of the philosophically interesting parts of the commentary.
v7.c42.6
Like most other Abhidharma works the SGP has little to offer from a purely philosophical point of view. What it offers is a sort of “soteriological ontology”, i.e. it deals with basic ethical and religious values from a psychological point of view. If the factors of existence are not related to this concern they are of no interest to our authors. On the other hand SS (and SGP) is of considerable historical interest. Along with the Daśottarasūtra the SS, as said, is an attempt to summarize all the fundamental concepts of Buddhist tradition. In retrospect its manner of arrangement appears archaic and superficial. It is mechanical without any deeper formative principle. Nevertheless the abundance of materials collected here provided later attempts at systematization with an indispensable background and inventory. The SGP in particular is not only the most extensive commentary extant on the SS but a mine of information about early Sarvāstivāda exegesis. To compare it closely with the corresponding Theravāda SS exegesis as found above all in Buddhaghoṣa's Sumangalavilāsinī would throw interesting light on the individual development of these two early Buddhist schools.
v7.c42.7
When commenting upon the SS the SGP sometimes merely gives brief or stereotypical definitions, sometimes it refers to or quotes other sources (mainly the Dharmaskandha or old sūtras) and sometimes it gives very thorough treatments.
I. Section of Ones
v7.c42.s1.1
(T367a1-369b9; E45-49) 1. All living beings subsist on nutriment of which there are four kinds: (i) edible, gross and fine, (ii) contact, (iii) representative cognition, and (iv) consciousness. All four are conditioned, impermanent, perishable, subject to change, produced by causes, invisible, impure and neither imperfect nor perfect. The rest of this section involves a long discussion of various subdivisions and peculiarities in regard to these four kinds.
v7.c42.s1.2
2. All living beings subsist on conditionings. They are likewise conditioned, impermanent, etc. Moreover they are material, independent of mind and neutral. Again various subdivisions, etc.
v7.c42.s1.3
3. Not being careless in regard to good factors.
II. Section of Twos
v7.c42.s2.1
(T369b10-376a28; E49-63) There are 27 sets of twos:
v7.c42.s2.2
1. Name (nāma), or spirit, and form (rūpa), or matter. The former comprises the four immaterial aggregates, space, calculated cessation and uncalculated cessation; the latter comprises the four elements and material forms derived from them.
v7.c42.s2.3
2. Ignorance—see III.3—and desire for existence, i.e. longing, craving, etc., for the material and immaterial elements.
v7.c42.s2.4
3. (Wrong) view about existence and about nonexistence. The former consists in believing the ego and the world to be permanent, the latter in believing in their annihilation.
v7.c42.s2.5
4. Shamelessness and disregard.
v7.c42.s2.6
5. Shame and consideration.
v7.c42.s2.7
6. Sulkiness and indulging in bad company.
v7.c42.s2.8
7. Suavity and being in good company.
8. Skill in (discerning the five) offences and skill in desisting from these offences. The five offences are named as (i) adultery, (ii) leaving the order, (iii) natural falling, (iv) falling and (v) wickedness.
9. Skill in (discerning the eight kinds of) meditative attainment and skill in desisting from these attainments.
10. Skill in (discerning thirteen different) elements and skill in reflecting upon them. A monk understands that there are eighteen elements, six elements, etc., and reflects upon their being impermanent, frustrating, empty and without self.
11. Rightness and mildness.
12. Patience and good disposition.
13. Courtesy and munificence.
14. Mindfulness and comprehension.
15. The power of calculation and the power of spiritual practice.
16. Unguardedness of one’s faculties and intemperance in diet.
17. Guardedness of one’s senses and temperance in diet.
18. Moral disaster and theoretical disaster.
19. Failure in morality and failure in theory.
20. Moral accomplishment and theoretical accomplishment. (The opposite of II, 18)
21. Purity in morality and purity in theory. (See 19 and 20)
22. Purity in theory and thorough exertion of one having such a theory.
23. Agitation over (four) agitating circumstances and thorough exertion of one being thus agitated.
24. Discontent toward good factors and perseverance in exertion.
25. Peace and insight. These two are inseparable.
26. Knowledge—see III.50—and liberation. Each is of three kinds.
27. Cognition of destruction and cognition of nonorigination.
III. Section of Threes
v7.c42.s3.1
(T376a29-391b10; E63-93) There are fifty sets of threes:
1. Roots of bad things, viz., (i) greed, (ii) hatred and (iii) delusion. “Delusion” is ignorance, e.g., of the past, the future, of karma, of the three jewels, of the four truths, etc.
2. Roots of good things, viz., (i) absence of greed, (ii) sympathy and (iii) understanding.
3. Bad initial thought of (i) sensual pleasures, (ii) malice and (iii) violence.
4. Good initial thought of (i) renunciation, (ii) absence of malice and (iii) nonviolence.
5. Bad conduct of (i) body, (ii) word and (iii) mind.
v7.c42.s3.2
6. Good conduct of (i) body, (ii) word and (iii) mind.
7. Elements of (i) sensual pleasures, (ii) malice and (iii) violence.
8. Elements of (i) renunciation, (ii) absence of malice and (iii) nonviolence.
9. Elements of (i) sensual pleasures, (ii) material form and (iii) immateriality.
10. Elements of (i) material form, (ii) immateriality and (iii) cessation.
11. Periods, viz., (i) the past, (ii) the future and (iii) the present.
12. Subjects of debate belonging to (i) the past, (ii) the future or (iii) the present.
13. Classification of matter as (i) visible and resisting, (ii) invisible and resisting, and (iii) invisible and unresisting.
14. Conditionings taking form as (i) body, (ii) word and (iii) mind.
15. Awarenesses like (i) an open sore, (ii) lightning and (iii) a diamond.
16. Persons of (i) stooping wisdom, (ii) wisdom like a pouched garment or (iii) comprehensive wisdom.
17. Senior by (i) birth or rank, (ii) common consent or convention and (iii) character (dharma).
18. Groups (i) determined as falsehood, (ii) determined as righteousness and (iii) undetermined.
19. Grounds of reproof based on (i) something seen, (ii) something heard or on (iii) suspicion.
20. A Tathāgata does not have to conceal any impure conduct in (i) body, (ii) words or (iii) thought.
21. Desire for (i) sensual pleasures, (ii) form or (iii) formlessness.
22. Desire for (i) material form, (ii) immateriality or (iii) extinction.
23. Intoxicants (lit. "outflows" (āsrava)) of (i) pleasures, (ii) existence and (iii) ignorance.
24. Longing for (i) pleasures, (ii) existence and (iii) a religious life.
25. Existence as (i) the existence of sensual pleasures, (ii) the existence of material form and (iii) immaterial existence.
26. Obfuscation (tamas) concerning (i) the past, (ii) the future and (iii) the present.
27. Fear of (i) disease, (ii) old age and (iii) death.
28. Feelings may be (i) satisfying, (ii) frustrating or (iii) neither satisfying nor frustrating.
29. Frustrations (i) consisting in pain, (ii) due to the conditioning or (iii) due to change.
30. Kinds of conceit: (i) "I am better than ...," (ii) "I am equal to ..." and (iii) "I am inferior to ..."
31. The fire of (i) attachment, (ii) hatred and (iii) delusion.
v7.c42.s3.3
32. The fire (i) of being worthy of offerings, (ii) of a householder and (iii) of a good receiver of gifts.
v7.c42.s3.4
33. Occasions for good action are provided by (i) giving, (ii) following moral precepts and (iii) spiritual practice.
v7.c42.s3.5
34. Three kinds of rebirth in pleasure.
v7.c42.s3.6
35. Three kinds of rebirth in satisfaction.
v7.c42.s3.7
36. Wisdom derived from (i) traditional learning, (ii) reasoning or (iii) personal realization.
v7.c42.s3.8
37. Wisdom of (i) a pupil, (ii) a perfected being or adept and (iii) one who is neither a pupil nor an adept.
v7.c42.s3.9
38. The faculty (i) of coming to know the unknown, (ii) of knowing and (iii) of having fully understood.
v7.c42.s3.10
39. The eye of (i) flesh, (ii) the divine eye and (iii) of wisdom.
v7.c42.s3.11
40. The weapon of (i) learning, (ii) seclusion and (iii) wisdom.
v7.c42.s3.12
41. Training as to (i) morality, (ii) awareness and (iii) wisdom.
v7.c42.s3.13
42. Practice of (i) morality, (ii) concentration and (iii) wisdom.
v7.c42.s3.14
43. States that are (i) divine, (ii) sublime (*brahma*) or (iii) noble (*ārya*). They are (i) the four meditational states, (ii) the four boundless things, viz., love, compassion, sympathy and equanimity and (iii) the four applications of mindfulness (see IV.1), the four right exertions (see IV.2), the four bases of supernatural power (see IV.3), the five faculties (see V.20), the five powers (see V.22), the seven factors of enlightenment (see VII.1) and the noble eightfold path (see VIII.1).
v7.c42.s3.15
44. Concentration (i) with initial and sustained thought, (ii) without initial and only with sustained thought, and (iii) without initial or sustained thought.
v7.c42.s3.16
45. The wonder of (i) supernatural powers, (ii) mind-reading and (iii) teaching.
v7.c42.s3.17
46. Purity of (i) body, (ii) word and (iii) mind.
v7.c42.s3.18
47. Sagacity in (i) body, (ii) word and (iii) mind.
v7.c42.s3.19
48. Supremacy of (i) the world, (ii) oneself and (iii) the doctrine (*dharma*).
v7.c42.s3.20
49. The superiority of one’s (i) course, (ii) knowledge and (iii) liberation.
v7.c42.s3.21
50. The nonlearners’ knowledge manifesting itself in cognition of (i) former lives, (ii) decease and rebirth and (iii) destruction of intoxicants.
IV. Section of Fours
v7.c42.s4.1
(T391b11-411c12; E93-130) There are fifty groups each consisting of four items:
v7.c42.s4.2
1. Application of mindfulness as to (i) the body, (ii) feelings, (iii) thought and (iv) concepts.
v7.c42.s4.3
2. Right exertion to (i) get rid of evil things, (ii) prevent evil things, (iii) engender good things and (iv) maintain and enhance good things.
v7.c42.s4.4
3. The four bases of supernatural power are motivated by (i) interest, (ii) energy, (iii) awareness and (iv) deliberation.
v7.c42.s4.5
4. The four stages of meditation. In the first, where the monk is free from desire and unwholesome thoughts, he experiences a solitary delight accompanied by initial and sustained thought, etc. (The well-known canonical phrases are given.)
v7.c42.s4.6
5. The four noble truths, i.e. the truth of (i) frustration, (ii) its origin, (iii) its cessation and (iv) the way to achieve its cessation.
v7.c42.s4.7
6. The identification of (i) small, (ii) big, (iii) the boundless and (iv) nothing.
v7.c42.s4.8
7. Four boundless states, viz., (i) love, (ii) compassion, (iii) sympathy and (iv) equanimity.
v7.c42.s4.9
8. Four immaterial states, viz., the sphere of (i) spatial infinitude, (ii) infinitude of consciousness, (iii) nothingness and (iv) neither identification nor no identification.
v7.c42.s4.10
9. The four-fold traditional practice of a monk means that he is satisfied with any (i) robes, (ii) alms, (iii) bed and seat that he may get, and that (iv) he applies himself to abandonment and spiritual practice.
v7.c42.s4.11
10. The four fruits of monkhood consist in (i) entering upon the stream, (ii) returning only once, (iii) returning no more and (iv) finally becoming a perfected being.
v7.c42.s4.12
11. The four signs of entering upon the stream are (i) the company of good people, (ii) listening to the true dharma, (iii) proper attention and (iv) behavior in conformity to Buddhism.
v7.c42.s4.13
12. One who has entered upon the stream firmly believes in (i) the Buddha, (ii) the dharma and (iii) the order. Moreover, (iv) he lives a pure life.
v7.c42.s4.14
13. Understanding of (i) the dharma, (ii) consequences, (iii) the awarenesses of others and (iv) convention.
v7.c42.s4.15
14. Understanding of (i) frustration, (ii) its origin, (iii) its extinction and (iv) the way of this.
v7.c42.s4.16
15. The powers of (i) faith, (ii) energy, (iii) concentration and (iv) wisdom.
v7.c42.s4.17
16. The support of (i) wisdom, (ii) truth, (iii) renunciation and (iv) inner peace.
v7.c42.s4.18
17. The main portions of Buddhism (dharmaskandha) are (i) a moral precepts, (ii) concentration, (iii) wisdom and (iv) liberation.
v7.c42.s4.19
18. Four attitudes to things, viz., deliberately to (i) use, (ii) endure, (iii) avoid or (iv) get rid of them.
v7.c42.s4.20
19. Four items of Buddhism, viz., (i) noncovetousness, (ii) absence of malice, (iii) right mindfulness and (iv) right concentration.
v7.c42.s4.21
20. Things to be realized by means of one's (i) body, (ii) recollection, (iii) vision or (iv) wisdom.
v7.c42.s4.22
21. One's course may be difficult and result in (i) knowledge slowly acquired or (ii) quickly acquired, or it may be easy and result in (iii) knowledge slowly acquired or (iv) quickly acquired.
v7.c42.s4.23
22. Otherwise one's course may imply (i) want of endurance, (ii) self-control, (iii) endurance or (iv) equanimity.
v7.c42.s4.24
23. Careful development of concentration contributes to (i) a pleasant life here and now, (ii) intuition, (iii) analytical wisdom and (iv) extinction of intoxicants.
v7.c42.s4.25
24. Actions may be (i) bad, (ii) good, (iii) bad and good or (iv) neither bad nor good.
v7.c42.s4.26
25. An attitude to the dharma may be (i) satisfying now but frustrating later, (ii) frustrating now but satisfying later, (iii) frustrating now and frustrating later or (iv) satisfying now and satisfying later.
v7.c42.s4.27
26. Bondage in the form of (i) sensual pleasure, (ii) existence, (iii) (wrong) views or (iv) ignorance.
v7.c42.s4.28
27. Separation from the bondage of (i) sensual pleasure, (ii) existence, (iii) (wrong) views or (iv) ignorance.
v7.c42.s4.29
28. Four floods, viz., that of (i) sensual pleasure, (ii) existence, (iii) (wrong) views and (iv) ignorance.
v7.c42.s4.30
29. Clinging to (i) sensual pleasure, (ii) (wrong) views, (iii) moral precepts and rituals and (iv) beliefs in a self.
v7.c42.s4.31
30. Four knots, viz., (i) desire, (ii) malice, (iii) clinging to precepts and rituals and (iv) confidence in and clinging to "the idea that something is true".
v7.c42.s4.32
31. Four elements, viz., (i) earth, (ii) water, (iii) fire and (iv) wind.
v7.c42.s4.33
32. Four kinds of nourishment. viz., (i) gross and fine food, (ii) touch, (iii) representative cognition and (iv) consciousness.
v7.c42.s4.34
33. Four stations of consciousness, viz., (i) matter, (ii) feelings, (iii) identifications and (iv) conditionings.
v7.c42.s4.35
34. Four sources of desire, viz., (i) robes, (ii) alms, (iii) lodging and (iv) existence and nonexistence.
v7.c42.s4.36
35. Four wrong courses conditioned by (i) excitement, (ii) hatred, (iii) delusion or (iv) fear.
v7.c42.s4.37
36. A question may be answered either (i) directly, (ii) with qualifications, (iii) after further interrogation or (iv) it may be left open.
v7.c42.s4.38
37. A gift may be pure on the part of (i) the donator, not the receiver, (ii) the receiver, not the donator, (iii) neither the donator nor the receiver or (iv) the donator as well as the receiver.
v7.c42.s4.39
38. The four grounds of conciliation are (i) liberality, (ii) kindly speech, (iii) helpfulness and (iv) a feeling of common good.
v7.c42.s4.40
39. Four ways of birth, viz., (i) oviparous creation, (ii) viviparous, (iii) moisture-sprung and (iv) spontaneous.
v7.c42.s4.41
40. One may obtain a body that can be destroyed (i) by oneself, not by others, (ii) by others, not by oneself, (iii) by oneself and by others or (iv) neither by oneself nor by others.
v7.c42.s4.42
41. An individual person may (i) follow the stream, (ii) go against the stream, (iii) rest in himself or (iv) have gone to the further shore.
v7.c42.s4.43
42. An individual person may be concerned with (i) his own good, not that of others, (ii) that of others, not his own, (iii) neither his own nor that of others or (iv) his own as well as that of others.
v7.c42.s4.44
43. An individual person may (i) live in the dark and end in the dark, (ii) live in the dark and end in light, (iii) live in light but end in the dark, or (iv) live in light and end in light.
v7.c42.s4.45
44. An individual person may torment (i) himself, (ii) others, (iii) neither himself nor others or (iv) himself as well as others.
v7.c42.s4.46
45. There are four kinds of bad verbal behavior, viz., (i) to tell a lie, (ii) slander, (iii) rudeness and (iv) silly talk.
v7.c42.s4.47
46. The four kinds of good verbal behavior consist in abstaining from (i) lies, (ii) slander, (iii) rudeness and (iv) nonsense.
v7.c42.s4.48
47. Four ignoble modes of speech, viz., claiming to have (i) seen what one has not seen, (ii) heard what one has not heard, (iii) considered what one has not considered and (iv) understood what one has not understood.
v7.c42.s4.49
48. Four decent modes of speech, viz., admitting not to have (i) seen what one has not seen, (ii) heard what one has not heard, (iii) considered what one has not considered and (iv) understood what one has not understood.
v7.c42.s4.50
49. Four ignoble modes of speech, viz., claiming not to have (i) seen what one has seen, (ii) heard what one has heard, (iii) considered what one has considered and (iv) understood what one has understood.
v7.c42.s4.51
50. Four other decent modes of speech, viz., admitting to have (i) seen what one has seen, (ii) heard what one has heard, (iii) considered what one has considered and (iv) understood what one has understood.
V. Section of Fives
v7.c42.s5.1
(T411c13-428c15; E130-159) There are twentyfive groups each of five items:
v7.c42.s5.2
1. Five aggregates, viz., (i) the body, (ii) feelings, (iii) identifications, (iv) conditionings and (v) consciousness.
v7.c42.s5.3
2. Five groups of grasping: as above.
3. Five sensous constituents, viz., those objects that may be discerned by means of (i) the eyes, (ii) the ears, (iii) the nose, (iv) the tongue or (v) the body.
4. Selfishness in regard to one’s (i) lodging, (ii) supporting family, (iii) beauty, (iv) gain and (v) the *dharma*.
5. Five kinds of rebirth, viz., (i) in hell, (ii) as an animal, (iii) as a hungry ghost, (iv) as a human being or (v) as a god.
6. Five obstructions in the form of (i) longing for sensual pleasures, (ii) ill-will, (iii) torpor, (iv) worry and (v) wavering.
7. Barrenness of mind consists in a monk’s lack of belief in (i) the Buddha, (ii) the teaching, (iii) the instruction, (iv) the obligations and (v) the authoritative masters.
8. The five bondages of the mind are, briefly stated, a monk’s (i) passion for one’s own person, (ii) passion for pleasure, (iii) passion for company, (iv) lack of interest in listening to the *dharma* and (v) his being satisfied by having made a minor spiritual progress.
9. Five fetters belonging to the lower world, viz., (i) longing for pleasure, (ii) malice, (iii) belief in one’s own ego, (iv) clinging to precepts and rituals and (v) wavering.
10. Five fetters belonging to the upper world, viz., (i) attachment to matter (or form), (ii) attachment to immateriality (or formlessness), (iii) excitedness, (iv) pride and (v) ignorance.
11. Five disadvantages of being impatient, viz., one becomes (i) violent, (ii) unhappy and (iii) unpopular, and one gets a bad (iv) reputation and (v) rebirth.
12. Five advantages of being patient: one is not (i) violent, (ii) unhappy or (iii) unpopular, but gets a good (iv) reputation and (v) rebirth.
13. The loss of one’s (i) relatives, (ii) possessions, (iii) good health, (iv) good morals and of one’s (v) opinions.
14. The blessing of having (i) relatives, etc., as above.
15. An admonition may be (i) at the right or wrong time, (ii) true or false, (ii) useful or not useful, (iv) mild or rude or (v) compassionate or full of hate.
16. It is an impossibility that a pious monk (i) kills, (ii) steals, (iii) has sexual intercourse, (iv) tells a lie or (v) enjoys what does not belong to him.
17. There are five virtues of a monk exerting himself, (i) faith, (ii) honesty, (iii) good health, (iv) manly vigor and (v) wisdom.
18. Five identifications that lead to emancipation, viz., that of (i) impermanence, (ii) the impermanent being painful, (iii) there being no self, (iv) food being repugnant and that of (v) death.
19. There are five bases of emancipation, (i) hearing the *dharma* taught by the teacher, (ii) reciting it, (iii) preaching it oneself, (iv) pondering over it or (v) understanding it.
v7.c42.s5.4
20. Five faculties, as IV. 15 (q.v.) adding mindfulness as the third.
v7.c42.s5.5
21. Five other faculties, viz., that of (i) satisfaction, (ii) frustration, (iii) joy, (iv) distress and (v) equanimity.
v7.c42.s5.6
22. Five powers, as in V. 20.
v7.c42.s5.7
23. The five kinds of nonreturners are those who pass into final extinction (i) in an intermediate state of existence, (ii) after having been reborn, (iii) with effort, (iv) without effort and (v) those who are going upwards to Akaniṣṭhas in the stream.
v7.c42.s5.8
24. There are five kinds of gods having pure abodes, viz., (i) the Avṛhas, (ii) the Atapas, (iii) the Sudṛśas, (iv) the Sudarśanas and (v) the Akaniṣṭhas.
v7.c42.s5.9
25. There are five basic elements tending to deliverance, viz., to put it briefly, giving up (i) sensual pleasures, (ii) malice and non-malice, (iii) violence and nonviolence, (iv) form and formlessness and (v) individuality and extinction of individuality.
VI. Section of Sixes
v7.c42.s6.1
(T428c16-435a3; E160-175) There are twentyfour groups each of six items:
v7.c42.s6.2
1. The internal sense-bases of contact, viz., (i) eyes, (ii) ears, (iii) nose, (iv) tongue, (v) body and (vi) mind.
v7.c42.s6.3
2. The external sense-bases of contact, viz., (i) visible matter, (ii) sounds, (iii) smell, (iv) taste, (v) the tangible and (vi) concepts.
v7.c42.s6.4
3. The six kinds of consciousness depend on (i) the eyes, (ii) the ears, (iii) the nose, (iv) the tongue, (v) the (skin of the) body and on (vi) the mind.
v7.c42.s6.5
4. The six kinds of contact depend on (i) the eyes, etc., as above.
v7.c42.s6.6
5. The six kinds of feeling arise from contact with (i) the eyes, etc., as above.
v7.c42.s6.7
6. The six kinds of identification arise from contact with (i) the eyes, etc., as above.
v7.c42.s6.8
7. The six kinds of volition arise from contact with (i) the eyes, etc., as above.
v7.c42.s6.9
8. The six kinds of desire arise from contact with (i) the eyes, etc., as above.
v7.c42.s6.10
9. It is disadvantageous to show disrespect to (i) the Buddha, (ii) the *dharma*, (iii) the order, (iv) the training precepts, and it is disadvantageous to be (v) sulky or (vi) have bad friends.
v7.c42.s6.11
10. It is advantageous to show respect to (i) the Buddha, (ii) the *dharma*, (iii) the order, and it is advantageous to be (v) affable and (vi) have good friends.
v7.c42.s6.12
11. The six ponderings involving contentedness are concerned with (i) visible forms, (ii) sounds, (iii) odors, (iv) tastes, (v) tangibles and (vi) concepts.
v7.c42.s6.13
12. The six ponderings involving depression are concerned with (i) visible forms, etc., as above.
v7.c42.s6.14
13. The six ponderings involving equanimity are concerned with (i) visible forms, etc., as above.
v7.c42.s6.15
14. The six attitudes of perseverance are expressed in a monk’s equanimity and mindfulness towards (i) visible forms, etc., as above.
v7.c42.s6.16
15. The six elements are (i) earth, (ii) water, (iii) fire, (iv) wind, (v) space and (vi) consciousness.
v7.c42.s6.17
16. The six factors leading to liberation are expressed in a monk’s getting rid of (i) malevolence, (ii) injury, (iii) disgust, (iv) longing for pleasure, (v) consciousness following outward signs, and (vi) belief in an ego.
v7.c42.s6.18
17. The six roots of contention are expressed in a monk’s being (i) angry and grudging, (ii) unfair and hypocritical, (iii) envious and mean, (iv) deceitful and crafty, (v) full of wrong and false views, and (vi) tenaciously attached to his own persuasions.
v7.c42.s6.19
18. The six principles of fraternal living consist in a monk’s showing kindness (i) in deeds, (ii) in speech, (iii) in thoughts and in (iv) sharing gifts that one has received, (v) practising good morals and (vi) living according to orthodox views.
v7.c42.s6.20
19. The six higher faculties consist in (i) supernatural power, (ii) divine audition, (iii) reading the thoughts of others, (iv) knowing one’s previous incarnations, (v) knowing decease and rebirth and (vi) knowing the destruction of evil influences.
v7.c42.s6.21
20. The six identifications contributing to knowledge refer to one’s understanding of (i) impermanence, (ii) impermanence as frustrating, (iii) lack of self as frustrating, (iv) food as disgusting, (v) the entire world as lacking delight, and (vi) death.
v7.c42.s6.22
21. The six things to be recollected are (i) the Buddha, (ii) the dharma, (iii) the order, (iv) the moral precepts, (v) renunciation and (vi) the gods.
v7.c42.s6.23
22. The six superiorities consist in (i) seeing, (ii) listening, (iii) gain, (iv) discipline, (v) serving and (vi) recollecting.
v7.c42.s6.24
23. There are six kinds of longing for (i) matter, (ii) sounds, (iii) smell, (iv) taste, (v) tangibles and (vi) concepts.
v7.c42.s6.25
24. There are six modes of heredity: (i) a person of bad descent doing bad things, (ii) a person of bad descent doing good things, (iii) a bad person creating extinction that is neither bad nor good, (iv) a good person creating bad things, (v) a good person creating good things, and (vi) a good person creating extinction that is neither bad nor good.
VII. Sets of Sevens
v7.c42.s7.1
(T435a4-440c22; E175-187) There are thirteen groups each of seven items:
v7.c42.s7.2
1. The factors of enlightenment, viz., (i) mindfulness, (ii) analysis of the doctrine, (iii) energy, (iv) joy, (v) serenity, (vi) concentration and (vii) equanimity.
v7.c42.s7.3
2. There are seven kinds of persons, viz., (i) the follower of confidence, (ii) the follower of the *dharma*, (iii) the one freed by confidence, (iv) the one who has won the right view, (v) one who has bodily testimony, (vi) one freed by insight, and (vii) one freed in both ways.
v7.c42.s7.4
3. The seven requisites of concentration are: correct (i) view, (ii) resolve, (iii) speech, (iv) action, (v) way of life, (vi) effort and (vii) mindfulness.
v7.c42.s7.5
4. The seven treasures are: (i) faith, (ii) good morals, (iii) bashfulness, (iv) modesty, (v) learning, (vi) renunciation and (vii) wisdom.
v7.c42.s7.6
5. The seven powers are those of (i) faith, (ii) energy, (iii) bashfulness, (iv) modesty, (v) mindfulness, (vi) concentration and (vii) wisdom.
v7.c42.s7.7
6. There are seven bad qualities, viz., (i) want of faith, (ii) unconscientiousness, (iii) indiscretion, (iv) want of learning, (v) slackness, (vi) muddleheadedness and (vii) lack of wisdom.
v7.c42.s7.8
7. There are seven good qualities, viz., (i) faith, (ii) shame, (iii) modesty, (iv) energy, (v) mindfulness, (vi) concentration and (vii) wisdom.
v7.c42.s7.9
8. The seven bad qualities are: not to know (i) the *dharma*, (ii) the meaning of what is said, (iii) the right time, (iv) the right measure, (v) oneself, (vi) the audience, and not to know (vii) whether a person is eminent or mean.
v7.c42.s7.10
9. The seven good qualities are: to know (i) the *dharma*, etc., as above.
v7.c42.s7.11
10. There are seven states of consciousness, viz., physical beings (i) diverse in body and in identification, (ii) diverse in body but uniform in identification, (iii) uniform in body but diverse in identification, and (iv) uniform in body and uniform in identification. Moreover there are immaterial beings who dwell in the realm of (v) infinite space, (vi) infinite consciousness, or (vii) nothingness.
v7.c42.s7.12
11. The seven kinds of latent dispositions are (i) sensual passion, (ii) enmity, (iii) lust for rebirth, (iv) conceit, (v) ignorance, (vi) false opinion, and (vii) doubt.
v7.c42.s7.13
12. The seven faultless attitudes are, to put it briefly, to have (i) faith, (ii) good morals, (iii) good friends. Moreover, (iv) to enjoy solitude and to have (v) energy, (vi) mindfulness and (vii) wisdom.
v7.c42.s7.14
13. There are seven ways for the settlement of cases: (i) by confronting both parties, (ii) when the accused is a victim of amnesia, (iii) when the prosecuted has regained his sanity, (iv) by checking the character of the prosecuted, (v) on majority vote, (vi) confession of guilt, or (vii) by “covering with grass”, i.e. by reaching a compromise.
VIII. Section of Eights
v7.c42.s8.1
(T440c23-445b14; E187-199) There are ten groups each of eight items:
v7.c42.s8.2
1. Eight factors of the noble way, viz., the correct (i) view, (ii) intention, (iii) speech, (iv) action, (v) livelihood, (vi) effort, (vii) mindfulness and (viii) concentration.
v7.c42.s8.3
2. The eight persons are those who have (i) entered the stream, (ii) work for the fruit of stream-entry, those who are (iii) once-returners, (iv) work for the fruit of a once-returner, those who are (v) never-returners, (vi) work for the fruit of a never-returner, and those who are (vii) perfected beings, and those who (viii) work for the fruit of a perfected being.
v7.c42.s8.4
3. There are eight ways of giving gifts: (i) disrespectfully, (ii) from fear, (iii) from gratitude, (iv) in the hope of getting something in return in the future, (v) to follow up the family tradition, (vi) for fame, (vii) to be reborn in heaven, or (viii) to adorn and prepare one's mind for the highest good.
v7.c42.s8.5
4. The eight instances of sloth occur, to put it briefly, when a monk (i) has done a little but is too lazy to do more, (ii) has done something but is too lazy to do more, (iii) has done his work but is too tired to do more, (iv) is too lazy to work the next day, (v) is too tired to continue his journey the same day, (vi) is too tired to continue his journey the next day, (vii) is too ill to work hard, or (viii) has recovered from his illness but still is too lazy to do his work.
v7.c42.s8.6
5. The eight instances of hard work: the opposite of the above.
v7.c42.s8.7
6. Meritorious deeds result in good rebirth as (i) a wealthy person or as a god, be it a (ii) Mahārājika, (iii) a Trāyastrimśa, (iv) a Yama, (v) a Tuṣita, (vi) a Nirmāṇarati, (vii) a Paranirmitavaśavarti, or (viii) a Brahmakāyika god.
v7.c42.s8.8
7. The eight assemblies consists of (i) nobles, (ii) brahmins, (iii) householders, (iv) ascetics, (v) Caturmahārājakāyika gods, (vi) Trāyastrimśa gods, (vii) Māras and (viii) Brahmās.
v7.c42.s8.9
8. There are eight guiding principles in society, viz., (i) gain, (ii) loss, (iii) blame, (iv) praise, (v) fame, (vi) disgrace, (vii) frustration and (viii) satisfaction.
v7.c42.s8.10
9. The eight liberations are described at length in the usual cliche, see e.g., *Dīghanikāya* III, p. 261.
10. The eight positions of mastery are also described at length in the standard cliche, see e.g., *Dīghanikāya* III, p. 260.
IX. Section of Nines
v7.c42.s9.1
(T445b15-447a17; E199-203) There are two groups each of nine items:
1. The nine fetters, viz., (i) attraction, (ii) repugnance, (iii) seven kinds of conceit, (iv) ignorance, (v) dogmatism, (vi) clinging, (vii) wavering, (viii) envy and (ix) selfishness.
2. Of the nine abodes of beings (i)-(iv) and (vi)-(viii) are the same as the seven stations of consciousness, see VII (x), above. But there are also (v) material beings without any perception, and (ix) immaterial beings who have reached the realm of neither-identification-nor-nonidentification.
X. Section of Tens
v7.c42.s10.1
(T447a18-453b19; E203-206) Finally there are two groups each of ten items:
1. Ten foundations of meditational totalization, viz., (i) earth, (ii) water, (iii) fire, (iv) air, (v) blue, (vi) yellow, (vii) red, (viii) white, (ix) endless space, and (x) endless consciousness.
2. Ten virtues in need of no further training, viz., a correct (i) view, (ii) intention, (iii) speech, (iv) action, (v) livelihood, (vi) effort, (vii) mindfulness, (viii) concentration, (ix) emancipation and (x) wisdom.
Cites (8)
- Saṅgītiparyāya — Classical Chinese
- Saṅgītisutta — Pāli
- Nibbānasutta — Pāli
- Dīghanikāya — Pāli
- Prajñaptiśāstra — Sanskrit
- Daśottarasūtra — Sanskrit
- Sangītisūtra — Sanskrit
- Dharmaskandha — Sanskrit