Indian Philosophy v2.c24.s26: Prakṛti
Indian Philosophy v2.c24.s26
- Language
- English
Prakṛti
v2.c24.s26.1
The Sāṁkhya attempts an explanation of nature as an immense complexity of elements which is ever changing. The hierarchy of forms from physical matter, which is itself a product of submaterial elements, is represented as an unfolding of the resources of nature. If all effects are latent in their causes, and if infinite regress is to be avoided, there must be an uncaused cause. From the principle of causality it is deduced that the ultimate basis of the empirical universe is the unmanifested (avyaktam) prakṛti. The Sāṁkhya Kārikā argues for the existence of prakṛti on the following grounds ¹: (1) Individual things are limited in magnitude. Whatever is limited is dependent on something external to itself. The finite as finite, therefore, cannot be the source of the universe. (2) All individual things possess certain pervasive characteristics, thus implying a common source from which they all issue. The Sāṁkhya does not believe that the different elements are completely distinct from one another. (3) There is an active principle manifesting itself in the development of things. Evolution implies a principle which cannot be equated with any one of its stages. It is something larger than its products, though immanent in them. (4) The effect differs from the cause, and we cannot, therefore, say that the finite and conditioned world is its own cause. (5) There is the obvious unity of the universe, suggesting a single cause. The Sāṁkhya assumes the continuity of the world from the lowest to the highest. The products evolve and dissolve in a definite order. The world is said to be the pariṇāma, or transformation, of prakṛti, which is its cause. Everything is the effect of a producing cause; for from nothing nothing comes. If less should be contained in the cause than in the effect, then this excess would have to be produced by nothing. It follows that the cause must contain more reality than, or at least as much reality as, the effect. The natural light of reason, to use Descartes's words, tells us that the ultimate cause must contain eminently all the reality, meaning and value of the effect. Nothing can be evolved which is not in kind originally involved.¹ While every effect is caused, prakṛti has no cause,² but is the cause of all effects, from which it is inferred.³ It is called pradhāna, since all effects are founded on it,⁴ Brahmā, or that which grows,⁵ māyā, or that which measures or limits. It is the primary form of being from which different orders of existences issue. The Sāṃkhya recognises the impossibility of deducing puruṣa or the self, from prakṛti or the not-self.
v2.c24.s26.2
¹ 15 and 16
v2.c24.s26.3
¹ Cp. with this Descartes's distinction of eminent and formal causes.
v2.c24.s26.4
² S.P.S., i. 67.
v2.c24.s26.5
³ S.P.S., i. 110, 136.
v2.c24.s26.6
⁴ Pradhīyate (S.P.B., i. 125). Lokācārya writes that it is called prakṛti, since it is the source of all change, avidyā, since it is opposed to all knowledge, māyā, since it is the cause of the varied creation. Prakṛtir ity ucyate vikārotpādakatvāt, avidyā jñānavirodhitvāt, māyā vicitrasṛṣṭikaratvāt (Tattvatraya, p. 48). Plato had a similar idea of a universal invisible source of all material forms. See Timæus, p. 24.
v2.c24.s26.7
⁵ B.G., xiv. 3.
v2.c24.s26.8
The products are caused, while prakṛti is uncaused; the products are dependent, while prakṛti is independent; the products are many in number, limited in space and time, while prakṛti is one, all-pervading and eternal.⁶ The products are the signs from which we infer the source. Prakṛti can never perish, and so it could never have been created. An intelligent principle cannot be the material out of which the inanimate world is formed, for spirit cannot be transformed into matter. Besides, agency belongs not to the puruṣa or the soul, but to the ahaṃkāra or self-sense, which is itself a product.⁷
v2.c24.s26.9
⁶ S.K., 10; S.P.S., i. 124. See also Y.B., iv. 12; S.P.B., i. 76.
v2.c24.s26.10
⁷ S.P.S., vi. 54.
v2.c24.s26.11
The difficulty that prakṛti is not perceived is not of much moment. There are ever so many things which are accepted as real, though they are not open to perception. Perception cannot succeed with regard to objects too near or too remote. Defects of senses or manas, obstruction of another object, or presence of more attractive stimuli, render perception useless. The fineness of prakṛti renders it imperceptible.⁸ Vyāsa describes prakṛti as "that which never is nor is not, that which exists and does not exist, that in which there is no non-existence, the unmanifested, without any specific mark, the central background of all.”¹ If what serves the ends of self is the existent, then prakṛti is non-existent, though it is not non-existent as a square circle. Again, nothing that exists can be destroyed, and the products exist in prakṛti, though in an unmanifested state. In it all determinate existence is implicit. The different guṇas do not annul themselves, but are in a state of equipoise, which is not inactivity but a kind of tension. Prakṛti is not so much being as force. As the equilibrium of the three guṇas,² it is the ground of all modifications, physical and psychical. It is pure potentiality.³ We do not know the real nature of prakṛti or the guṇas, since our knowledge is confined to phenomena.⁴ It is devoid of sound and touch,⁵ practically the limit beyond which we cannot go. It is empirically an abstraction, a mere name.⁶ But it must be assumed to exist as the prius of all creation.⁷
v2.c24.s26.12
⁸ S.K., 8.
v2.c24.s26.13
¹ Niḥsattāsattam niḥsadasan nirasad avyaktam aliṅgam pradhānam (Y.B, ii. 19; S.P.B., i. 61).
v2.c24.s26.14
² Sāmyāvastha (S.P.B., i. 61).
v2.c24.s26.15
³ Cp. R.V., x. 92.
v2.c24.s26.16
⁴ Vyāsa quotes a verse from the Ṣaṣṭitantra to the effect:
v2.c24.s26.17
⁵ S.P.B., i. 128; Viṣṇu Purāṇa, i. 2. 20-21.
v2.c24.s26.18
⁶ Saṁjñāmātram (S.P.B., i. 68).
v2.c24.s26.19
⁷ Pra = before, kṛti = creation, or pra = forth, kṛ = to make.
v2.c24.s26.20
The Sāṁkhya description of the world in terms of one homogeneous substance, of which all things are but different configurations resulting from the different combinations of its ultimate constituents, has some resemblance to the materialist theory. Both the Sāṁkhya and materialism attempt to attain a more rational conception of the universe than the somewhat chaotic view which surface appearances leave on our minds. Both of them assert the ultimate reality of a primary substance which they regard as eternal, indestructible and ubiquitous. The multiplicity of heterogeneous things which we come across in our ordinary experience is traced to this single substance. But the prakṛti of the Sāṁkhya cannot be compared with matter pure and simple. The Sāṁkhya thinkers are aware of the incapacity of prakṛti
v2.c24.s26.21
Guṇānāṁ paramaṁ rūpaṁ na dṛṣṭipathaṁ ṛcchati
Yat tu dṛṣṭipathaṁ prāptaṁ tan māyeva sutucchakam.
v2.c24.s26.22
Vācaspati, commenting on it, observes that prakṛti is not māyā, but is like māyā, māyeva tu māyā.
v2.c24.s26.23
to produce puruṣa as well as the incapacity of puruṣa to produce prakṛti. They admit, while the materialists do not, that the evolution of prakṛti is purposive, " an arch where through gleams the untravelled world." The prakṛti of the Sāṃkhya is not a material substance, nor is it a conscious entity, since puruṣa is carefully distinguished from it. It gives rise not only to the five elements of the material universe, but also to the psychical. It is the basis of all objective existence. The Sāṃkhya arrives at the conception, not from the side of science, but from that of metaphysics. The real in its fulness is distinguished into the unchanging subject, and the changing object and prakṛti is the basis of the latter, the world of becoming. It is the symbol of the never-resting, active world stress. It goes on acting unconsciously, without regard to any thought-out plan, working for ends which it does not understand.
Cites (7)
- Yogabhāṣya — Vyāsa & Patañjali (author of the Yogasūtra), Sanskrit
- Sāṃkhyakārikā — Īśvarakṛṣṇa, Sanskrit
- Viṣṇupurāṇa — Sanskrit
- Ṛgvedasaṃhitā — Sanskrit
- Bhagavadgītā — Vyāsa, Sanskrit
- Sāṃkhyapravacanabhāṣya — Vijñānabhikṣu 1550, Sanskrit
- Tattvatraya — Piḷḷai Lokācārya, Tamil