Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

Indian Philosophy v2.c26.s14: XXIII Higher Wisdom and Lower Knowledge

Indian Philosophy v2.c26.s14

Language
English

XXIII Higher Wisdom and Lower Knowledge

v2.c26.s14.2

Parā vidyā is absolute truth. Its content is the oneness of Ātman and the sole reality thereof. If by means of the logical resources we try to describe the ultimate reality, we have perforce to employ myth and symbol. The Vedas give us the highest logical approximation to the truth. Empirical truth, or aparā vidyā, is not absolutely untrue. It is truth seen from the standpoint of the empirical consciousness.¹ The world extended in space and time and causality is not final, but is relative to the degree of our enlightenment. It is due to our partial vision, and to the extent to which our vision is partial its object is abstract. The higher monistic and the lower pluralistic views cannot be true in the same sense. Śaṁkara cuts the Gordian knot by attributing the latter to a fall from the lower.

v2.c26.s14.3

¹ Cp. Deussen : "Strictly viewed, this aparā vidyā is nothing but metaphysics in an empiric dress, i.e. vidyā as it appears considered from the standpoint of avidyā, the realism innate in us" (D.S.V., p. 100).

v2.c26.s14.4

Lower knowledge is not illusory or deceptive, but is only relative. If not, Śaṁkara’s elaborate and even passionate discussion of the lower knowledge will border on the grotesque. He admits that the lower knowledge leads us eventually to the higher wisdom. "This scriptural account of creation admitted by avidyā . . . has, for its highest aim, the teachings that Brahman is the true self. This must not be forgotten."² Transcendental absolutism becomes when it passes through the mill of man’s mind an empirical theism, which is true until true knowledge arises, even as dream states are true until awakening occurs.³

v2.c26.s14.5

² D.S.V., p. 106.

v2.c26.s14.6

³ S.B., ii. I. 14.

v2.c26.s14.7

Avidyā, or finite thought, bears its witness to the real which transcends thought. It leads us to the conclusion that its truth is relative and that it cannot directly grasp the nature of reality.⁴ While the ordinary mystic strives to rise above differences and lose himself and the object of his quest in a cloud of unknowing, Śaṃkara presents to us certain philosophical difficulties, and tells us that these indicate the possibility of a superior insight to which all that is divine and dark to intellect is radiant. The Vedas, which are regarded as authoritative, contain, according to Śaṃkara, both higher wisdom and lower knowledge. They give descriptions of the one non-dual Brahman and the unreality of the pluralistic universe.

v2.c26.s14.8

⁴ Cp. Dr. McTaggart: "A mysticism which ignores the claims of the understanding would no doubt be doomed. None ever went about to break logic, but in the end logic broke him. But there is a mysticism which starts from the standpoint of the understanding and only departs from it in so far as that standpoint shows itself not to be ultimate, but to postulate something beyond itself. To transcend the lower is not to ignore it" (Hegelian Cosmology, p. 292). Spinoza draws a distinction between Ratio and Scientia Intuitiva. He believes in three kinds of knowledge: (1) That due to imagination which gives mere opinion. To it belong all inadequate and confused ideas. It is also the source of erroneous knowledge. (2) Reason which gives us common notions and the knowledge of science, which tries to "understand the agreements, differences and contrasts of things" (Ethics, vol. ii, p. 29, Scholium). While Imagination accounts for the content of the average uninstructed man's thinking, Reason is responsible for the

v2.c26.s14.9

We have, in Śaṃkara’s philosophy, three kinds of existence: (1) pāramārthika, or ultimate reality; (2) vyāvahārika, or empirical existence; and (3) prātibhāsika, or illusory existence. Brahman is of the first kind, the world of space-time-cause of the second, while imagined objects, like silver in the shell, are of the third kind.¹ Illusory existence has no universality about it. It arises on occasions. It has not any practical efficiency. The erroneous notion of apparent existence ceases when its substratum of experience is perceived; the mistake in respect to empirical existence ceases when its substratum of Brahman is realised. The empirical world possesses a higher degree of truth than the world of fiction and dreams. It is the world of souls, their environment and their Lord, but strictly speaking it is rooted in the one Brahman.² Let it be clearly understood that the empirical self and the empirical world are both of the same rank of reality. The external world is not an illusion due to the projection of the ideas of the empirical ego. There is an external world in space independent of the empirical self and its ideas. These two empirical spheres of selves and things stand in a causal relation to each other. What we as empirical egos find in the world, we ourselves as transcendental subjects have placed there.

v2.c26.s14.10

¹ Vedāntaparibhāṣā. In some later Advaita treatises this distinction is applied to the jīva also. In the Dṛgḍṛśyaviveka, it is said that the impersonal consciousness limited by the adjuncts is the real self; when it assigns to itself agency and activity and is limited by the senses and the antaḥkaraṇa, it is the empirical self; the apparent jīva believes that its dream body and consciousness all belong to it (S.L.S., i).

v2.c26.s14.11

² Cp. Ānandagiri on S.B. on Māṇḍūkya Up. Brahmaṇy eva jīvo jagad īśvaraś ceti sarvaṃ kālpanikaṃ sambhavati.

v2.c26.s14.12

systematic knowledge of the man of science. (3) Intuition involves the exercise of philosophic genius, artistic insight and creation. Its object is individual. However, Śaṃkara reminds us most among European thinkers of Plato. Both were great spiritual realists who synthesised the main tendencies of the past in their own thoughts. Both distinguished knowledge into two kinds, higher and lower, the former referring to the ultimate truth or the ideal good, the latter to the world of shadows. Admitting that reality lies far behind the surface appearances, both tell us that it can be grasped by a complete withdrawal of the soul into its own self. Both believe in intuition which gives us the transcendent vision of reality.

Cites (3)