Indian Philosophy v2.c26.s15: XXIV Śaṁkara's Theory and Some Western Views Compared
Indian Philosophy v2.c26.s15
- Language
- English
Contents
- v2.c26.s15.7 — 4 parts
XXIV Śaṁkara's Theory and Some Western Views Compared
v2.c26.s15.2
Śaṁkara's theory of knowledge is often compared with that of Kant.¹ While there are striking similarities, there are far-reaching differences. Like Kant, Śaṁkara formulates the problem of the possibility of knowledge—even knowledge of self—and puts it in the forefront of philosophical inquiry. Both of them look upon the world of experience as phenomenal, and trace the root of this limitation to the structure of the human mind. By an examination of man's cognitive mechanism, Kant arrives at the conclusion that it is impossible for man to have a knowledge of transcendent objects, for whatever becomes an object of knowledge is enveloped in the forms of space, time and the categories of the understanding, the chief of which is causality. The being of reality is not apprehended by us; what we grasp is an apprearance thereof. According to Śaṁkara, it is some monstrous deformity of our vision that makes us see what is really one as if it were many. Paradoxically enough, our logical activity forces on us a phenomenal world which for ever insinuates itself between us and the reality. Both Śaṁkara and Kant attempt to solve the question of the conditions of knowledge by the critical rather than the empirical method. Śaṁkara avoided the error of Kant, who sought not so much the logical implications of experience as the *a priori* conditions of experience, and thus asserted the reality of an extra-empirical world of things in themselves. Śaṁkara's object was to discover the immanent principle within experience, and not a world beyond it. Both, however, agree that if the logical intellect sets itself up as constitutive of reality, it forfeits its title to truth and becomes, as Kant says, a faculty of illusion. Śaṁkara and Kant repudiate mentalism. As against Descartes, who distinguishes between our knowledge of our own existence, which is immediate and indubitable, and that of external objects, which is only inferential and problematic, Kant contends that our knowledge of the external world is quite as direct and certain as our knowledge of self. He repudiates Berkeleyan subjectivism in the famous section on the "Refutation of Idealism" in the second edition of the Critique of Pure Reason. "The simple but empirically determined consciousness of my own existence proves the existence of external objects in space." But if by real we understand that which is thought of as existing independent of consciousness and out of all relation to any knowledge, then, according to Śaṁkara, neither the empirical self as we are acquainted with it nor the external world as it is known to us is real; and Kant says that all objects of experience are phenomena and not noumena.¹ If, on the other hand, we mean by the real dependable matter of experience, then both the empirical self and the external world are real, and the two stand on the same footing. The finite self and the world are real or unreal according to the meaning assigned to reality. While Kant believes in a plurality of things in themselves, Śaṁkara declares that there is only one fundamental reality. In this matter Śaṁkara is certainly more philosophical than Kant, who illegitimately imports the distinctions of the world into the region of things-in-themselves.
v2.c26.s15.3
¹ The mystic idealism of Plotinus is said to owe much of its content to Indian thought. We know that Plotinus accompanied the Emperor Gordian in his campaign in the East, and he may have then come into contact with the representatives of Indian idealism.
v2.c26.s15.4
¹ See Kant's Prolegomena. See 13, Remark II.
v2.c26.s15.5
Śaṁkara does not draw a hard-and-fast line of distinction between sense and understanding, as Kant does, nor does he believe that the principles of our intelligence have no power to represent concrete fact. According to Kant, the rhapsody of perceptions which is not knowledge is what is given to us; what we make of it by means of our categories, which add necessity and universality from outside, is knowledge. In Śaṁkara, there is no contrast between the mental construction and the presented fact. The two are adapted to each other. This is also the difference between Śaṁkara and Bradley. Śaṁkara would not say that in actual feeling we have the "that," and that thought rests on the vicious abstraction of separating the "what" from the "that," the result being that we are unable to recapture the "that" through mere ideal representation. Nor would Śaṁkara endorse the objection of Aristotle against Plato, that if the sensible is not the intelligible, then ideas cannot help us to understand the sensible world. The sensible, for Śaṁkara, is less than the intelligible, and the latter helps us to comprehend the former, though he believes that even the intelligible falls short of the real. He distinguishes the real from the sensible as well as the intelligible, and holds that the latter is a greater approximation to reality than the former.
v2.c26.s15.6
Sometimes Śaṁkara’s theory is compared with that of M. Bergson, which argues that there has been a growth of consciousness in man. The upward ascent from the amœba has been a long one. Many kinds of awareness or consciousness implicit in those beings have been suppressed in the development of man. We have paid an enormous price for being what we are. While our logical minds are useful for practical purposes, it is unreasonable to suppose that the whole of us is exhausted by what we are now. Even in this world we come across men of genius or insight, in whom the slumbering powers are stirred to life. Śaṁkara would not agree with Bergson’s view that the intellect breaks up the flow of life, that the unending dynamic process is reduced by intellect to a static or geometrical presentation. Intellect not only dissects reality, but attempts to reconstitute it. It is both analytic and synthetic in its functions. Thought displaces contingency by law. It does not merely sunder reality into parts, but holds these in the bonds of unity by means of space, time and causality. To the concrete life of experience our intellects are quite adequate. Nay, they are made for each other, practically the parallel manifestations of one process. If Śaṁkara regards intellect as not the highest mode of man’s consciousness, it is because the completed world of intellect still leaves us with a riddle. The completed world of logic is not the complete world of life and experience. That is why Śaṁkara does not regard it as final. For him—history, art, moral theory, and religion too; for all these assume the dualistic standpoint. Śaṁkara does not condemn the intellect on the ground that it employs analysis and abstraction. He accepts its concreteness and yet finds it to be unsatisfactory. When we pass from the simple elements to complex categories and arrive logically at the conception of a supreme personality (Īśvara), whose life is expressed in the universe, Śaṃkara feels that our logic has grown in concreteness. The triumph of thought is the triumph of the concrete, but the most concrete thought is abstract in the sense that it is incapable of apprehending reality as it is. The higher we think the better we know; yet even the highest thought is not complete truth. In pressing forward and upward in the quest of reality with the aid of intelligence, we reach a reality seemingly full, rich and profound, that of Īśvara, the only way in which Brahman can be envisaged at the level of finite thought. But Īśvara is not the highest Brahman, since the unity of God is not an intelligible one.
v2.c26.s15.7.1
Among Western thinkers Bradley comes nearest to Śaṃkara, though there are fundamental differences between the two. In the first part of his *Appearance and Reality* Bradley develops the doctrine of the limitations of human knowledge by an acute and penetrating criticism of the distinction of primary and secondary qualities, substance and attribute, qualities and relations. It is his considered conviction that thought can never do justice to reality. By sundering the "what" and the "that," it is incapable of reaching the goal, *i.e.* recapturing the secret of reality. According to Bradley, when we have, say, the sensation of blue colour, we have a *that* which is actually present and a *what*, or the peculiar quality by which it is distinguished. In immediate apprehension we are not conscious of the distinction between the two aspects. It is a "this-what," a process-content where the distinction of the "this" from the "what" does not enter into consciousness. In judgment we distinguish the two, the predicate from the subject, and attribute the former to the latter. This is true of all judgments. Life or reality is feeling in which the "that" and the "what" are inseparable, while logical reflection is always abstract in the sense that its very essence lies in the mental separation of the content from the process. Śaṃkara does not regard the separation of the *that* from the *what* as the essential defect of logic in the sense in which Bradley takes it;
v2.c26.s15.7.2
nor does he say that the reality which constitutes the subject of judgment is presented to us in the feeling fact itself. Granting that in knowledge the idea is not the psychical image, but an ideal content, granting also that the ideal content is referred in the judgment to the real world, Śaṁkara would say that the real which the ideal content tends to characterise is not the feeling experience of a private individual but the independent reality. Knowledge attempts to characterise by objective qualities, not any feeling or any extension of it, but the permanent reality out there, whatever may happen to me or my feeling. So long as we are investigating the nature of a private experience, we are engaged in a psychological quest and not a logical endeavour. The ambiguity due to Bradley's use of the word "feeling" is absent in Śaṁkara. He would, however, admit that the true subject of all judgment is reality as it is, and the predicate is a quality which we attribute to it, though it falls short of it. In this way subject and predicate correspond to reality and appearance. "In every judgment the genuine subject is reality, which goes beyond the predicate and of which the predicate is an adjective." Until the "what" coincides with the "that," we have not truth; when it coincides we have not thought. As Bradley says: "If you predicate what is different, you ascribe to the subject what it is not;
v2.c26.s15.7.3
and if you predicate what is not different, you say nothing at all." So long as we think, the predicate is less than the subject, the appearance less than reality. All judgment, according to Śaṁkara, is invalid, not because it separates the "that" from the "what," but because the predicate is other than the subject which is the reality. Without difference there is no thought; with difference there is no reality. Bradley believes that the real is the harmonious, and truth must therefore be a harmony. Self-completeness and consistency are the marks of reality. Śaṁkara adopts these in the evaluation of possible predicates. Space, time and cause, etc., are neither self-complete nor consistent. They are self-discrepant and stretch beyond themselves. From the stricter point of view of Śaṁkara, even harmonious truth is not reality. We cannot say that reality is a harmony, for the latter means a number of parts interrelated in a whole. This distinction of parts and whole is an empirical one, which we are attributing to the transcendental reality. Truth, as harmony, requires us to postulate an absolute experience of Īśvara, which includes all finite subjects and all finite objects in a systematic unity. Śaṃkara holds that as the unity we assume is an unintelligible one, it has also the mark of appearance or unreality. Bradley is clear on this point. In all our thought the " that " and the " what " fall out and are at strife. To restore the unity is an impossibility.
v2.c26.s15.7.4
Logic piously assumes that all aspects of the world belong to one whole, that the discrepancies are apparent, and that the predicates are all one with the subject, appearances one with reality. Bradley assumes that in the world of logic there is nothing so imperfect that it cannot be taken into reality with sufficient modification. But he does not clearly tell us what the extent of the modification is. When he says that no judgment can possibly be true so long as the subject of judgment is reality, he is perfectly logical, and Śaṃkara would endorse his view. Bradley observes: "The conclusion to which I am brought is that a relational way of thought—anyone that moves by the machinery of terms and relations—must give appearance and not truth. It is a makeshift, a device, a mere practical compromise, most necessary, but in the end most indefensible." From this it follows that even the representation of reality as a harmony is a " device, a practical compromise most necessary, but in the end most indefensible." For Śaṃkara, as for Bradley, the weakness of logic is in its assumption of the distinction between the knower and the known. All duality is mental.¹
v2.c26.s15.8
¹ Dvaitaṃ sarvam manas.
v2.c26.s15.9
The logic of Śaṃkara has in it elements of both agnosticism and mysticism. The absolute is the unattainable goal towards which the finite intellect strives, and when it reaches its consummation thought ceases to be what it is in our empirical life, and passes into a higher and more direct form of apprehension in which it and its object can no longer be distinguished. Logical dialectic helps us to overcome the errors into which thought of necessity falls. The inconsistencies and the incompleteness in which Śaṃkara's theory of knowledge is content to remain are not due to any defects in his reasoning, but are the inevitable imperfections of a philosophy which tries to go to the depth of things. For him knowledge is so vital and error so fatal that he will not admit anything as true unless it stands the scrutiny of logic.