Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

Indian Philosophy v2.c26.s25: XXXIV The World of Nature

Indian Philosophy v2.c26.s25

Language
English

XXXIV The World of Nature

v2.c26.s25.2

Śaṃkara does not stop with a mere description of reality, but examines the realm of phenomena in the light of his theory, formulates the truth which inadequate conceptions contain, and arranges the various phenomena in the order of their varying approximations to truth. He attempts to show how each appearance endeavours to reveal the character of reality which is its ground. Since the inexhaustible Brahman stands at the root of all, continuously higher and higher expressions reveal themselves in the world.⁵ " As in the series of beings which descends from man to blades of grass, a successive diminution of knowledge, power and so on is observed—although they have all the common attribute of being animated—so in the ascending series, extending from man up to Hiraṇyagarbha, a gradually increasing manifestation of knowledge, power, etc., takes place.”¹ We can distinguish in the world of phenomena: (1) the Īśvara, the dispenser of retribution, (2) the extension of nature, the nāmarūpaprapañca, the name and form world which is the scene of retribution, and (3) the plurality of individual souls, subject to the limitations of individuality, which suffer retribution in each new existence for the works of the previous lives. The plurality of the world arises from the two factors of the enjoyer and the enjoyed, the actors and the stage. The material world is called kṣetra, since it is the environment where the individual souls can act, realising their desires and fruits of their past karma.² It is inorganic nature consisting of the five elements. Organic nature consists of souls that have entered into the elements and wander as plants, animals, men and gods.³ The world of saṁsāra consists of various orders of beings with different modes of existence and different worlds answering to conditions necessary for the fulfilment of the experiences of beings. These beings form a graduated scale where the lowest limit is constituted by those whose experiences are most limited and the highest being the gods of the supersensible realm.⁴

v2.c26.s25.3

⁵ Yady apy eka evātmā sarvabhūteṣu sthāvarajaṅgameṣu gūḍhas tathāpi cittopādhiviśeṣatāratamyād ātmanaḥ kūṭasthanityasyaikarūpasyāpy uttarottaram āviṣṭasya tāratamyam aiśvaryaśaktiviśeṣaiḥ śrūyate (S.B., i. I. 11).

v2.c26.s25.4

¹ S.B., i. 3. 30. Yathā hi prāṇitvāviśeṣe 'pi manuṣyādistambaparyanteṣu jñānaiśvaryādipratibandhaḥ pareṇa pareṇa bhūyān bhavan dṛśyate, tathā manuṣyādiṣv eva hiraṇyagarbhaparyanteṣu jñānaiśvaryābhivyaktir api pareṇa pareṇa bhūyasī bhavati. See also S.B., i. 1. 1.

v2.c26.s25.5

² Phalopabhogārtham . . . sarvaprāṇikarmaphalāśrayaḥ (S.B., Muṇḍ. Up., iii. 1. 1).

v2.c26.s25.6

³ The Vedic deities also belong to the cosmic process (S.B., i. 2. 17; i. 3. 33).

v2.c26.s25.7

⁴ S.B., i. 3. 10; S.B. on Bṛh. Up., i. 4. 10.

v2.c26.s25.8

The evolution of the universe obeys an order.⁵ From prakṛti, the element of objectivity, arises first ākāśa, the prius of space and matter. “The entire world springs from Īśvara, ākāśa being produced first, and later on the other elements in due succession.”⁶ ākāśa, one, infinite, imponderable, inert, all-pervasive, is the first product.⁷ It stands for both space and an exceedingly fine matter filling all space. However attenuated a substance ākāśa may be, it is yet of the same order as the elements of air, fire, water and earth. Thus Śaṁkara disputes the Buddhist view that ākāśa is a negative entity, the mere absence of hindrances.¹ He holds that the negative result is a consequence of its positive nature.² From ākāśa other subtle elements (sūkṣmabhūtas) arise in an ascending order.³ Following the account of the Upaniṣads,⁴ Śaṃkara declares that, from ākāśa, air arises. From air comes fire, from fire water, from water earth. Since these five elements are relatively more permanent than their modifications, they are figuratively called immortal, imperishable.⁵ Ākāśa has the quality of sound, air of impact and pressure, light of luminosity and heat, water of taste and earth of smell. The relation of the properties to the elements is one of seed to plant. The śabdatanmātra, or the sound-essence, gives rise to ākāśa, which, in its turn, produces the outer form of sound. The tanmātra or the essence, contains in it both the element and its property. We have seen also that there is a graduated scale of the elements. All of them seem to be contained in the ākāśa tanmātra. The whole world takes its rise from ākāśa or sound.

v2.c26.s25.9

⁵ S.B., ii. 1. 24-25.

v2.c26.s25.10

⁶ S.B., ii. 3. 7.

v2.c26.s25.11

⁷ S.B., i. 1. 22; i. 3. 41. See Chān. Up., iii. 14. 3; viii. 14.

v2.c26.s25.12

¹ Āvaraṇābhāva (S.B., ii. 2. 22).

v2.c26.s25.13

² Vastubhūtam.

v2.c26.s25.14

³ S.B., ii. 3. 8–13.

v2.c26.s25.15

⁴ Tait. Up., ii. 1; Chān. Up., vi. 2. 2–3.

v2.c26.s25.16

⁵ Chān. Up., iv. 3. 1; Bṛh. Up., i. 5. 22.

v2.c26.s25.17

The gross matter of the world (mahābhūtas) is made up of the varying combinations of these subtle rudiments (sūkṣmabhūtas).⁶ The gross substance ākāśa manifests sound, air manifests sound and pressure, fire these and in addition light and heat, water has the qualities of taste in addition to the others, and earth has the qualities of other substances and its own special quality of smell. Every object has the properties of sound, tangibility, form, taste and smell. While the subtle rudiments are forms, homogeneous and continuous, of matter without any atomicity of structure, the gross substances are composite, though they are also said to be continuous and devoid of atomic structure.⁷ give rise by modifications (pariṇāma) to different kinds of things. Matter is constantly undergoing change of state. Changes may also be induced from without. Śaṁkara speaks of a cosmic vibratory motion.¹ All these elements are non-intelligent (acetana), and cannot of themselves bring about their development. The immanence of God in them all is assumed.² If the activities of the different elements are sometimes traced to the different Vedic deities, it makes little difference, since the latter only symbolise the functions of Īśvara.

v2.c26.s25.18

⁶ In each gross substance all the five subtle elements are found, though in different proportions. Quintuplication (pañcīkaraṇa) is the name given to the process of the combination of the five subtle elements into the gross substances of the world. Śaṃkara does not speak of pañcīkaraṇa, which assumes great importance in later Advaita. See Vedāntasāra. He adopts the view of trivṛtkaraṇa, or the mingling of the three elements. This is also the view of Vācaspati.

v2.c26.s25.19

⁷ Atom or aṇu is in the Advaita Vedānta not an ultimate indivisible discrete constituent of matter, but is the smallest conceivable quantum of matter.

v2.c26.s25.20

¹ Sarvalokāparispandanam.

v2.c26.s25.21

² Parameśvara eva tena tenātmanāvatiṣṭhamāno 'bhidhyāyams taṁ taṁ vikāraṁ sṛjati (S.B., ii. 3. 13). Rāmānuja holds that God's saṁkalpa, or will, is not necessary on every occasion of change. It occurs only once before the rise of ākāśa.

v2.c26.s25.22

The order of creation is reversed in the case of dissolution.³ At the time of dissolution the earth becomes water again; water fire, fire air, air becomes ākāśa, and ākāśa re-enters Īśvara.

v2.c26.s25.23

³ See S.B., ii. 3. 14. Cp. Deussen: "This view is likely to throw some light on the scientific motive of the teaching of the gradual evolution and absorption of the elements, as to which we have no other information; the observation that solids dissolve in water, that water turns into steam through heat, that the flames of fire flicker out into the air, air according to the altitude rarefies more and more into empty space, might lead us to the gradual progression of the dissolution of the world, and, by inversion into its opposite, the creation of the world" (D.S.V., p. 237).

v2.c26.s25.24

The psychic organs like manas (inner organ) are assumed by Śaṁkara to be of like nature with the physical elements. The human organism, like other things, is composed of the three elements of earth, water and fire.⁴ Manas or the inner organ, prāṇa or the vital breath, and vāk or speech, correspond to earth, water and fire respectively.⁵ Śaṁkara is aware that they are sometimes regarded as different in kind from the physical elements and produced before or after them. In any case they, as well as the elements, are in themselves lifeless and are produced as means to ends. Inorganic nature is parārtha, i.e. serves a purpose which lies beyond it.⁶ There is uniformity of nature in the inorganic world.⁷

v2.c26.s25.25

⁴ Chān. Up., vi. 2. 2-3.

v2.c26.s25.26

⁵ S.B., ii. 4. 20; iii. 1. 2.

v2.c26.s25.27

⁶ S.B.G., xiii. 22.

v2.c26.s25.28

⁷ S.B., Tait. Up., ii. 8.

v2.c26.s25.29

When we pass to organic nature, a new principle comes before us, the power of life immanent in certain things, by which they are able to realise a state of greater perfection, the power of realising an ideal. A stone does not live, since it has no tendency to become perfect, no inward inclination or strength to turn itself into a pillar or a statue. A plant, however, lives. If placed in suitable conditions, it has the power to grow, put forth leaf and blossom, flower and fruit. The animal, again, is capable of a fuller life than the plant. It sees, hears and feels, and also knows vaguely what it is about. Not only does it thrive in favourable conditions, but it goes out to find those conditions. It moves on purpose, while the plant does not. The human being lives a much higher life. He is what Śaṁkara calls a vyutpannacitta, a reflective being, with understanding and will. He has the growing power of the plant, the moving and the sensing powers of the animal, as well as the power to pierce behind the veil, discriminate the eternal from the non-eternal, and choose between good and evil. Men who realise their ambition are the gods. Thus under organic nature we find four classes of beings, gods, men, animals and plants.¹ In the spirit of the Upaniṣads, Śaṁkara admits that plants are places of enjoyment and possess living souls,² which have entered into them in consequence of impure deeds. Though they are insensible of enjoyment and suffering, they are said to be atoning for the deeds of their past existence. For Śaṁkara generally recognises three kinds of embodied souls, gods to whom is assigned a condition of infinite enjoyment, men whose lot is a mixed one of happiness and misery, and animals whose share is infinite suffering.³ In their embodied condition the souls exist together with the vital forces and subtle bodies, and, until they are liberated, these cling to them. The souls are said to be emanations from Brahman as the sparks are from fire; only they return into Brahman, while the sparks do not get back to fire.⁴

v2.c26.s25.30

¹ S.B., iii. i. 24.

v2.c26.s25.31

² Ibid.

v2.c26.s25.32

³ S.B., ii. i. 34.

v2.c26.s25.33

⁴ Muṇḍ. Up., ii. i. 1; Kauṣītaki, iii. 3. 4. 20; Bṛh., ii. i. 20. See S.B., iii. i. 20-21; Ait. Up., iii. 3. See also Chān. Up., vi. 2. 2.

Cites (7)