Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

Indian Philosophy v2.c26.s31: XL Ethics

Indian Philosophy v2.c26.s31

Language
English

Contents

XL Ethics

v2.c26.s31.1

Of all items of the universe, the human individual alone is the ethical subject. He knows that he has relations to the two worlds of the infinite and the finite. The operation of the infinite in the finite is not a mere poetic vision, but is the sober truth of philosophy. The infinite dwells in all finite, and man is conscious of this fact. Though he is bound up with an organism which is mechanically determined by the past, the infinite ideals of truth, beauty and goodness operate in him and enable him to choose and strive for their greater expression. It is because the infinite Brahman is revealed to a larger extent in human beings that they are entitled to ethical and logical activity.¹ So long as the individual strains after them and does not reach them, he is in bondage; the moment he reaches the infinite, the inner strain is relaxed and the freedom of joy fills his spirit. To realise Brahman is the end of all activities, for Brahman is not mere being or consciousness but also bliss (ānanda), and so is the object of all striving.² Brahmātmaikatva, or the realisation of the identity with the infinite reality, is the final end of life, "the proper food of every soul,"³ and the only supreme value. Until it is reached the finite soul is at unrest with itself. "Every one in all the three worlds strives for the sources of happiness and not for those of misery."⁴ All men seek the best, and, as Browning says, have

v2.c26.s31.2

¹ Prādhānyāt . . . karmajñānādhikāraḥ (S.B., Tait. Up., ii. 1).

v2.c26.s31.3

² Prayojanasūcanārtham ānandagrahaṇam (Śikhāmaṇi on Vedānta-paribhāṣā, Introduction).

v2.c26.s31.4

³ Phædrus, p. 247.

v2.c26.s31.5

⁴ Śataślokī, p. 15.

v2.c26.s31.6

All with a touch of nobleness despite
Their error, upward tending all though weak—
Like plants in mines which never saw the sun,
But dream of him, and guess where he may be,
And do their best to climb and get to him.

v2.c26.s31.7

The best fruits which we can pluck from the tree of life (saṁsāra) turn to ashes in our mouth. The greatest pleasure palls and even life in heaven (svarga) is evanescent. A mere act of goodness or enjoyment of a sweet melody or contemplative insight may, for the moment, seem to lift us out of the narrowness of our individuality, but it cannot give us permanent satisfaction. The only object that can give us permanent satisfaction is the experience of Brahman (brahmānubhava). It is the supreme state of joy and peace and the perfection of individual development.⁵ Unfortunately our trouble arises because we cling to the world, cherish faith in its phantoms and feel disappointed when the mocking semblances of finite satisfactions vanish even as we reach them. "The individual sinks down in sin and grief so long as he believes that his body is the Ātman, but when he realises that he is one with the self of all things, his grief ceases."¹ We cannot manipulate reality into accord with any ideal of our mind, but have only to recognise it. Philosophy with Śaṁkara is not the production of what *ought to be*, but is the apprehension of what *is*. A spiritual perception of the infinite as the real leads to peace and joy.

v2.c26.s31.8

⁵ "The essence of mokṣa or release is boundless joy and utter removal of pain. As it is perfectly clear that men always desire both, there is always a desire for release" (Saṁkṣepaśārīraka, i. 67). Cp. Spinoza: "All our happiness or unhappiness depends solely on the quality of the object on which our love is fixed. . . . But love towards an object eternal and infinite feeds the mind with a joy that is pure with no tinge of sadness" (De Intellectus Emendatione, pp. 9 and 10).

v2.c26.s31.9

¹ S.B. on Muṇḍ. Up., iii. I. 2.

v2.c26.s31.10

All ethical goods, bound up as they are with the world of distinctions, are valuable as means to the end. While self-realisation is the absolute good, ethical goods are only relatively so. The ethically "good" is what helps the realisation of the infinite, and the ethically "bad" is its opposite.

v2.c26.s31.11.1

Right action is what embodies truth, and wrong that which embodies untruth.² Whatever leads to a better future existence is good, and what brings about a worse form of existence evil. The individual tries to make good his infinite nature and become more and more godlike. In the empirical world, Īśvara is the highest reality and the world is his creation. The believer in God should love the whole universe, which is a product of God. True peace and excellence lie not in self-assertion, not in individual striving for one's own good, but in offering oneself as a contribution to the true being of the universe. Egoism is the greatest evil, and love and compassion are the greatest good. By identifying ourselves with the social good, we truly gain our real ends. Every individual must subdue his senses, which make for self-assertion; pride must give place to humility, resentment to forgiveness, narrow attachment to family to universal benevolence. It is not so much the deed that is valuable as the will to suppress one's selfish will and assert the will of society. Duties are the opportunities afforded to man to sink his separate self and grow out into the world. Śaṁkara accepts the standards of his age and exhorts us to avoid the sins forbidden by the śāstras. The study of the Veda, sacrifices, gifts, penances and fasts are a means of knowledge.¹ They strengthen character, purify the spirit and deepen insight.

v2.c26.s31.11.2

Though rare spirits might grasp the truth at once, for the ordinary man time and effort are needed. Fulfilment of the daily obligations of life and the demands of household piety,² produce a frame of mind favourable to realisation.³ Vedic rituals, when scrupulously observed, lead to abhyudaya (literally ascent or progress in the scale of saṁsāra), and not to niḥśreyasa or salvation.⁴ While spiritual insight into the nature of ultimate reality has for its result mokṣa, the worship of God in this or that form leads to a variety of effects, though all these are confined to the world of saṁsāra.⁵ They help us to escape from selfish desire, hatred and dullness, and attain calm, peace and patience in suffering. Devout meditation is a means of knowledge. Bhakti aids jñāna. True wisdom is won only by those whose minds are prepared by a rigorous discipline. It is not a question of pouring into the mind some kind of knowledge of which it is destitute. Truth is in the centre of the soul. To let it shine, the mind has to be turned from the perishing world. Our understanding must be made transparent like the glass of the lamp through which shines the light within. "Though the Ātman is at all times and in all things, it does not shine in all things. It shines only through understanding, just as reflection appears only in polished surfaces."⁶ Śaṁkara attaches great importance to philosophical wisdom, which can be attained only through a practice of virtue.

v2.c26.s31.11.3

While jñāna leads to release, other means help its attainment indirectly.⁷ "The desire to know Brahman springs only in the person whose mind is pure, who is free from desires, and who, free from deeds done in this birth or in previous ones, becomes disgusted with the external ephemeral medley of ends and means.”¹ Śaṁkara accepts the principle of the yoga practice, which has for its chief end samādhi, what Śaṁkara calls saṁrādhana or complete satisfaction, which consists in withdrawing the senses from everything external and concentrating them on one’s own nature. The Advaita accepts the yogic distinctions of yama, niyama, etc., as the outer means (bahiraṅgasādhanas) and dhāraṇa and dhyāna as the inner means (antaraṅgasādhanas).² The inner requirements are also stated to be the discrimination between the eternal and the non-eternal, detachment from all selfish endeavours for earthly or heavenly good, the development of the virtues of tranquillity (śama), restraint (dama), renunciation (uparati), resignation (titikṣā), concentration (samādhi) and steadfastness of mind (śraddhā), and lastly an intense desire for freedom. These bring about the rise of true knowledge.³

v2.c26.s31.12

² Cp. "Everyone that doeth evil hateth the light" (St. John iii. 19).

v2.c26.s31.13

¹ Bṛh. Up., iv. 4. 22.

v2.c26.s31.14

² S.B., iii. 4. 26.

v2.c26.s31.15

³ iv. I. 4.

v2.c26.s31.16

⁴ S.B. on Muṇḍ. Up., Introduction.

v2.c26.s31.17

⁵ S.B., i. I. 24. See also iii. 2. 21.

v2.c26.s31.18

⁶ Sadāsarvagato 'py ātmā, na sarvatrāvabhāsate. Buddhyāvevāvabhāseta, svaccheṣu pratibimbavat. (Ātmabodha, p. 17.)

v2.c26.s31.19

⁷ S.B., iv. I. I; S.B. on Tait. Up., i. 3. Plato recommends for philosophers the pursuit of wisdom, which has for its final fruit the vision of the idea of the Good, and for others true opinion, which is limited to one's station and its duties. See Phædo and Republic. Similarly, Aristotle recommends for the ordinary men "moral virtues," which are emphatically "human affairs," and for those who aim at immortality the exercise of reason, "which apprehends things noble and divine" (Nichomachean Ethics, x. 8).

v2.c26.s31.20

¹ S.B., Kena Up., Introduction. See also S.B., Chān. Up., Introduction, and viii. 5. 1; Bṛh. Up., iv. 4. 22; Kaṭha, i. 2. 15.

v2.c26.s31.21

² The Vedāntic śravaṇa and manana answer to dhāraṇa, nididhyāsana to dhyāna, and darśana to samādhi.

v2.c26.s31.22

³ S.B., iii. 4. 27.

v2.c26.s31.23

A thinker who is reaching forward to a larger conception of truth does not break entirely from the common beliefs of his age. Though the efficacy of caste institutions has ceased to be vital for Śaṁkara, he allows room for belief in it. The traditional theory that birth in a particular caste is not a matter of chance, but is the necessary consequence of conduct in a former existence, inclines Śaṁkara to accept the claim of the upper classes, gods and ṛṣis, for the exclusive right to study the Veda.⁴ While Śaṁkara holds that any man of any caste can attain the highest knowledge,⁵ he allows that those who follow the Brahminical rule of life should observe the obligations of caste and the stages of life. While the Brahmin may study the Veda and acquire wisdom, others may resort to worship and the like and attain the same goal of brahmajñāna.¹ It is difficult to find support in Śaṃkara for the claim that only through the study of the Veda can one acquire a knowledge of Brahman. As in his philosophy, so in his views of Hindu dharma, Śaṃkara tries to reconcile conflicting claims. By throwing open the highest knowledge or brahmajñāna to all who bear the human face divine (puruṣamātra), irrespective of caste or creed, he shows his fundamental humanity and his firm adherence to the logical implications of his Advaita philosophy. But he concedes to the Brahminical faith that the Śūdras, like Vidura, who attained the highest wisdom, did so as a result of their past conduct. If a Śūdra has capacity to understand the truth now, we may take it that he has studied the Veda in a previous life. Thus Śaṃkara undermined the belief of the exclusive right of the upper classes to salvation. He was willing to regard all who possess spiritual insight as his gurus, whether they were Brahmins or pariahs. " He who has learned to look upon the phenomenal world in the light of non-dualism is my true teacher, be he a caṇḍāla (pariah) or a dvija (twice-born). This is my conviction."²

v2.c26.s31.24

⁴ The cases of Jānaśruti (Chān., iv. 1. 2), who was called a Śūdra by Raikva, who, however, taught him the Vedas, and Satyakāma Jābāla, are explained away on the ground that so long as a Śūdra is not raised to a higher caste in the path of saṁsāra, he is not entitled to the saving knowledge.

v2.c26.s31.25

⁵ S.B., iii. 4. 38.

v2.c26.s31.26

¹ Puruṣamātrasambandhibhir japopavāsadevatārādhanādibhir dharma-viśeṣair anugraho vidyāyās sambhavati.

v2.c26.s31.27

² Manīṣapañcaka. See also Kaupīnapañcaka, pp. 3 and 5.

v2.c26.s31.28

The rules of āśramas or stages of life are insisted on. To gain salvation, one need not become a saññyāsin. In the Bṛhadāraṇyaka and the Chāndogya Upaniṣads, gṛhasthas, or householders, acquired and taught brahmavidyā. Saññyāsins, however, are best entitled to it, since it is easier for them to acquire it than for others, since they are not called upon to undertake active worship, household duties or vedic rites. Śaṃkara insists that those who follow the āśrama rules must become saññyāsins before they attain release, though there is no such obligation for those who do not adhere to the āśrama rules. The saññyāsins are grounded in Brahman (brahmasaṃsthā). "Such a state is impossible for those belonging to the three other stages of life, as scripture declares that they suffer loss through the non-performance of the works enjoined on their stage of life, while the saññyāsin can suffer no loss owing to non-performance."³ Again, "Although jñāna is permitted to all in any order of life, it is only that possessed by a saññyāsin that leads to freedom and not that combined with karma.”¹ Śaṁkara felt in the practical religion of the Hindus the want of discipline and a common standard, and so rearranged the ascetic orders and thus tried to obtain for Hinduism the disciplinary advantages of the Buddhist organisation.² Obsessed by the lesson which the Buddhistic admission of women in the body of ordained ascetics had taught, Śaṁkara excluded women from his monasteries, which were mainly intended as seats of learning and asylums for those who courted poverty, austere purity of life and freedom from the thraldom of the world. Śaṁkara ignored caste distinctions in the monastic order he founded.

v2.c26.s31.29

³ S.B., iii. 4. 20.

v2.c26.s31.30

¹ S.B., Introduction to Muṇḍaka Up. Saññyāsaniṣthaiva brahmavidyā mokṣasādhanam na karmasahitet.

v2.c26.s31.31

² Vidyāraṇya distinguishes vividiṣāsaññyāsa or the renunciation of the seeker from the vidvatsaññyāsa or the renunciation of the saved; while the first is optional, the second eventually follows the attainment of vidyā. The first, if adopted, is to be carried out in the orthodox way; the second has no regulations binding it. See Jivanmuktiviveka.

v2.c26.s31.32

The rules of varṇāśrama are binding on the Hindus, since they express the higher mind of the community. These are not to be regarded as externally imposed on the individuals who do not exist simply for the community. The moral value of the individual does not depend entirely on his contribution to the community. Man is not like a piece of clay to be moulded from outside. He has to be persuaded from within. The śāstras do not compel a man to do this or that, but simply remind men of the collective experience of the race.³ Apart from general principles, conventions alter from place to place.⁴ Moral life deepens as we progress higher and higher.⁵ Customary morality is something which is ever growing. The Vedic rule of life is not an indispensable aid to wisdom. Even those who are not entitled to it attained the highest goal. The poor and the outcast may by prayer and worship, fasting and sacrifice, attain the goal through the grace of God.⁶

v2.c26.s31.33

³ Jñāpakaṁ hi śāstraṁ, na kārakam. See also S.B., Bṛh. Up., ii. 1. 20.

v2.c26.s31.34

⁴ S.B., i. 1. 4.

v2.c26.s31.35

⁵ Ibid.

v2.c26.s31.36

⁶ S.B., iii. 4. 36-39.

v2.c26.s31.37

He who realises the goal is the true Brahmin, the knower of Brahman. The way in which he lives is described by Śaṁkara, who quotes the following passage :—

v2.c26.s31.38

Whom no one knows as high nor lowly born,
No one as erudite, nor yet not erudite,
No one as of good deeds, nor of evil deeds,
He is a Brāhmaṇa in very truth.
Given up to hidden duties well fulfilled,
In secrecy let all his life be spent;
As he were blind and deaf, of sense bereft,
Thus let the truly wise pass through the world.¹

v2.c26.s31.39

¹ Yaṁ na santam na cāsantam, nāśrutam na bahuśrutam Na suvṛttaṁ na durvṛttaṁ veda kaścit sa brāhmaṇaḥ. Gūḍhadharmāśrito vidvān ajñātacaritaṁ caret Andhavaj jaḍavac cāpi mūkavac ca mahīṁ caret. (S.B., iii. 4. 50; D.S.V., p. 144.)

v2.c26.s31.40

It is life in the spirit full of meekness and peace, holiness and joy, and not sinking into a state of contemplative inertia. His activities do not bind him. His karma is not karma in the ordinary sense.² While some liberated undertake the minimum activity for sustaining life (jīvanamātrārtham), others throw themselves into the work of the world (loka-saṁgrahārtham).³ This activity of the liberated is not centred in the individualistic standpoint⁴ and so is not to be regarded as binding the individual to the circuit.⁵ The freed souls, who save themselves by their effort, save the world by their example.

v2.c26.s31.41

² Viduṣaḥ kriyamāṇaṁ api karma paramārthato'karmeva (S.B.G., iv. 20).

v2.c26.s31.42

³ S.B.G., iv. 19.

v2.c26.s31.43

⁴ S.B., iv. 1. 13.

v2.c26.s31.44

⁵ "He who, when awake, is as though in a sound sleep, and sees not duality, or, if seeing it, regards it as non-duality, who, though acting, is free from the results of actions, he, and he alone, is without doubt the knower of self" (Upadeśasāhasrī, p. 45). "He who, whether active or at rest, links not his ego with his act and allows not his mind to be affected, is said to be the real jīvanmukta." "He who, though deep in intercourse with all things, is ever as cool and unconcerned as in attending to another's business, full of peace and contentment, is said to be the real jīvanmukta." Rāma asks Vasiṣṭha: "Tell me which of the two is better than the other, he who is ever at rest though mixing in the world, even like one awakened from a prolonged trance, or he who rises to and remains in trance in some solitary corner?" And his guru Vasiṣṭha replies: "Trance is only that internal calm which comes of looking upon this world and the guṇas which create it as all not-self. Having gained this pleasant calm within from the conviction 'I have no touch with the objective,' the yogin may remain in the world or shut himself up in meditation. Both, O Rāma, are equally good if the fire of desire is entirely cooled down within" (Yogavāsiṣṭha, quoted in Jīvanmuktiviveka, i and iv).

v2.c26.s31.45

While Vedic injunctions and moral rules are necessary for those involved in the circle of saṃsāra, they lose their point for the soul who leaves behind the whole sphere of desire and turns back on the differences of saṃsāra.¹ The question is raised whether the released soul can do what he will. Śaṃkara answers that, since selfish attachment that moves to action is absent in the case of the released soul, he does not act at all.² Action which arises from avidyā cannot coexist with a true knowledge of spirit.³ While such explanations seem to deny all action whatsoever to the released soul, there are other passages in Śaṃkara which make out that the released soul, free from all selfish desire, acts in a disinterested way.⁴ Evil action is psychologically impossible for him. Freedom from moral laws is mentioned as a glorification, alaṃkāra or ornament of the state of liberation and not an invitation to violate the moral laws. In no case is it to be regarded as encouraging the neglect of morality. The freed soul is lifted up into such a relationship with the absolute spirit that it is impossible for him to sin. He has verily died to sin. Śaṃkara’s attitude is not to be confused with that taken sometimes by the Antinomians in the Christian Church. While it is true that the freed soul “has no longer any object to aim at, since he has achieved all,”⁵ still he works for the welfare of the world. Besides, while Śaṃkara holds that moral obligation has no meaning for the freed soul, he does not say that the moral virtues are abandoned by him.⁶ Moral perfection leads to the death, not of morality, but of moralistic individualism. Rules of conduct have their force so long as we are struggling upward, working out the beast in us. They help to keep us straight when there is danger of our going wrong. As rules of murder, theft and the like do not worry the civilised man, so the spiritual man is not concerned with the conventional rules of morality.

v2.c26.s31.46

¹ Cp. Nistraiguṇye pathi vicaratāṃ ko vidhiḥ ko niṣedhaḥ ?

v2.c26.s31.47

² Na ca niyogābhāvāt saṃyagdarśino yatheṣṭaceṣṭāprasaṅgaḥ . . . sarvatrābhimānasyaiya pravartakatvāt, abhimānābhāvāc ca saṃyagdarśinaḥ (S.B., ii. 3. 48).

v2.c26.s31.48

³ See S.B., Introduction to Tait. Up.

v2.c26.s31.49

⁴ S.B.G., iv. 21.

v2.c26.s31.50

⁵ Introduction to S.B.G., v.

v2.c26.s31.51

⁶ Sureśvara says: ‘To the person in whom the realisation of the supreme arises, non-hatred and other qualities will be a habit requiring no effort; they are no longer virtues to be acquired by conscious exertion’ (Naiṣkarmyasiddhi, iv. 69).

Cites (19)