Mathematics in Ancient and Medieval India c5.s11: Symbol for Minus Sign
Mathematics in Ancient and Medieval India c5.s11
- Language
- English
Symbol for Minus Sign
c5.s11.1
In the *Bakhśālī Ms*, the modern plus sign ( + ) has been used to represent minus sign. Bhāskara I has made use of a little circle ( • ) on the right of the numbers to be subtracted. For example,
c5.s11.2
( ½ ) - ( ⅙ ) is written as ½ ⅙•
c5.s11.3
The plus sign, to denote negative sign, is also used in Jaina work *Dhavalā*, a commentary on the *Ṣaṭkaṇḍāgama* (vol. 10, p. 151). The first letter *ri* of the word *rina* was written in Brāhmī script as [Figure:]. Perhaps the sign [Figure:] was changed later into + to denote negative sign. But how little circle for negative sign came to be used, is not known. Another manuscript,¹ a commentary on the *Pāṭīgaṇita* of *Śrīdhara*, available at Kashmir, has used the + symbol for the minus sign. The symbol + is generally used after the number affected, but sometimes it was also used before the number affected. Thus, - 3 is written as 3 +, and sometimes as + 3.
c5.s11.4
¹ Ed. by K. S. Shukla, Lucknow, 1959.
c5.s11.5
This Kashmirian manuscript has used dot ( . ) as well as ( o ) for zero. The dot symbol was also found to have been used in the *Bakhśālī Ms.*² (c. 400 A. D.). The dot as a symbol for zero is found to be more ancient than the small circle, and this shows that the mathematicians of north-west region of India had not yet given up the use of dot, the alternative symbol for zero.
c5.s11.6
² The absence of the use of a small circle as a symbol for zero testifies that it is a much older work than the present commentary.
c5.s11.7
*Rule of Three and its Inverse, Five, Seven, etc,*
c5.s11.8
The term used in ancient India for rule of three is *trairāśika*, for three things were involved in the problems. It has appeared in the *Bakhshālī Ms.* (400 A. D.), *Āryabhaṭīya* of Āryabhaṭa I and in all other later mathematical works.¹ The method gives the solution of the problem like : if p yields f, what will i yield ? where p = *pramāṇa* (argument), f = *phala* (fruit) and i = *icchā* (requisition). According to Śrīdhara, the *pramāṇa* and *icchā*, which are of the same demominations should be set down in the first and last places; the *phala* which is of different denominations, be set down in the middle as follows :
c5.s11.9
¹ *Āryabhaṭīya*, ii, 26; *Brahmasphuṭa-Siddhānta*, xii. 10, *Gaṇitasārasaṃgraha*, v. 2 (i); *Mahāsiddhānta*, xv. 24–25; *Gaṇitatilaka*, v. 86, p-68; *Siddhānta Śekhara*, xiii, 14; *Gaṇitakumudī* I, v. 60, p. 47; *Pāṭīsāra* of Muniśvara, v. 83.
c5.s11.10
| p | f | i |
c5.s11.11
For required result the middle quantity is to be multiplied by the last quantity and divided by the first quantity. i.e. required result = (f)/p
c5.s11.12
*Example* "A certain lame person goes to a distance of ⅛ of a yojana in ⅕ of a day. Say in how much time will he go to a distance of 100 yojanas ?".² Here p = ⅛ of a yojana. f = ⅕ of a day. i = 100 yojanas.
c5.s11.13
² *Gaṇitasārasaṃgraha*, v. 3, 4; *Gaṇitatilaka* v. 93, p. 72; *Pāṭīgaṇita*, Ex. 30, p. 24 (Eng. tr.)
c5.s11.14
As per direction in the rule, we write
c5.s11.15
| ⅛ | ⅓ | 100 |
c5.s11.16
required result = (1/3 × 100)/(1/8) &= 266 \ 2/3 days / &= 8 months and 26 2/3 days
c5.s11.17
In the Renaissance period, this rule was highly appreciated to solve commercial problems by Widman (1489 A. D.). Tonstall (1522 A. D.), Gamma Frisius (1540 A. D.), Recorde (c. 1542 A. D.) etc. Recorde calls this rule, ‘the rule of proportion’, sometimes ‘Golden Rule’ for its excellency in arithmetical computation.¹
c5.s11.18
¹ Smith, D. E. *History of Mathematics*, Dover Publication, 2, p. 484.
c5.s11.19
For inverse rule of three² (*vyasta-trairāśika*), there is change in the units of measurment. The required result in this case is obtained when the middle quantity is multiplied by the first quantity and divided by the last quantity i.e. (f)/i. Al-Bīrūnī wrote a treatise, *Fi raśikat al-hind* (‘rule of three or more terms of the Hindus’). In his *India* (1, p. 313), he has used an example of *vyasta-trairāśika* (Inverse Rule of Three). The rule was known to the Arabs from the eighth century onward. It is quite likely that the rule went to Europe through the Arabs where it was known later as ‘the Golden Rule’.
c5.s11.20
² *Brāhmasphuṭasiddhānta*, xii, 11,
c5.s11.21
The rule of five, the rule of seven, the rule of nine etc. were so named, for there are five, seven, and nine terms etc. involved in the problems. By these rules, the problems of principal and interest, prices of various types of gold, calculation of charges for carring weights to a distance, barter of commodities, sale of living things etc. are solved. The two sides referred to in these rules are known as *pramāṇarāśi-pakṣa* (the argument side), and *icchārāśi-pakṣa* (the requisition side). After placing the given numbers in these two sides, the fruit has to be transposed from one side to the other and then denominator of two sides are interchanged in like manner and each side is multiplied. The required result is obtained when the side with larger quantities is divided by the side with smaller quantities. This can be clarified from the following example.¹
c5.s11.22
¹ *Gaṇitasārasaṃgraha* v. 34; *Gaṇitatilaka*, v. 99, p. 76; *Gaṇita-Kaumudī*, I, lines 6-9, p. 51; Similar examples appeared in Bhāskara I's commentary on the *Āryabhaṭīya*, ii, 26-27.
c5.s11.23
*Example.* "If 1½ be the interest on 100½ for one-third of a month, what will be the interest on 60¼ for 7½ months?"
c5.s11.24
Here, the two sides may be written as,
c5.s11.25
| *pramāṇarāśi* *pakṣa* (a) | *icchārāśi* *pakṣa* (b) |
| 100½ or 201/2 | 60¼ or 241/4 |
| ⅓ | 15/2 |
| 1½ or 3/2 | 0 |
c5.s11.26
The symbol 0 is written for the desired quantity. In the *Pāṭīsāra* (v. 88-92) of Muniśvara¹ the place for desired quantity is left vacant. Next, the fruit is transposed and denominators are interchanged as follows :
c5.s11.27
¹ Manuscript in the Govt. Sanskrit College Library, Benaras.
c5.s11.29
The required result $=(241 × 2 × 15 × 3 × 3)/(201 × 4 × 1 × 2 × 2) = 20 125/536$
Cites (9)
- Brāhmasphuṭasiddhānta — Brahmagupta, Sanskrit
- Āryabhaṭīya — Āryabhaṭa, Sanskrit
- Gaṇitasārasaṅgraha — Mahāvīra (mathematician), Sanskrit
- Gaṇitakaumudī — Nārāyaṇa Paṇḍita (mathematician), Sanskrit
- Dhavalā — Śaurasenī Prakrit
- Siddhāntaśekhara — Śrīpati, Sanskrit
- Mahāsiddhānta (Āryasiddhānta) — Āryabhaṭa II, Sanskrit
- Gaṇitatilaka — Śrīpati, Sanskrit
- Pāṭīgaṇita — Śrīdhara (mathematician), Sanskrit