Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

Bharatiya Jyotihshastra (History of Indian Astronomy), translated by R. V. Vaidya v1.c6.s5.t2: The Time of Kṛttikādi system

Bhāratīya Jyotiḥśāstra (History of Indian Astronomy), translated by R. V. Vaidya v1.c6.s5.t2

Language
English

The Time of Kṛttikādi system

v1.c6.s5.t2.1

The list of nakṣatras mentioned in the Vedas begins with Kṛttikās. The equinox used to occur in the 4th quarter of Bharaṇī division in the Vedāṅga Jyotiṣa age. It must have been in Kṛttikās before that time; and assuming that the nakṣatra-list commenced from Kṛttikās, Bentley and other European scholars have found 15th century B.C. as the time when the equinox used to take place in Kṛttikās; but this is erroneous. The mistake which was committed in the case of Vedāṅga Jyotiṣa has been committed in this case also. The tropical longitude of Kṛttikās must have been zero in the age when equinox used to coincide with this asterism. Its sāyana longitude in 1850 A.D. was 57° 54'. Hence, the time of equinox being in Kṛttikās comes to be (57° 54' × 72) i.e. 4170 yrs—1850=2320 B.C. The scholar Bayo has found out the time of Kṛttikādi system as prevailing amongst the Chinese to be about 2357 B.C.* and he must have found the time by adopting the same system of calculation as followed by the author. He has not read Bayo's original articles; but it is surprising to see that Bayo has not followed the system in the case of Hindus which he has done in the case of the Chinese-nakṣatra system.

v1.c6.s5.t2.2

According to Weber, the time of Kṛttikā being first nakṣatra comes to be somewhere between 2780 to 1820 B.C. Dr. Thibhaut has a fairly good knowledge of Indian astronomy. His opinion about this point has recently been published. The gist of his arguments is as follows:—There is no support to show that Kṛttikās were regarded as the first nakṣatra because equinox used to occur in that nakṣatra. We do not come across any description in the Vedic literature about planetary positions signifying a time prior to the one given by the solstitial positions described by Vedāṅga Jyotiṣa. The statement of winter solstice occurring in the beginning of Dhaniṣṭhā nakṣatra is very ambiguous; because the stars in the nakṣatra division** occupied by the sun is never visible; it can not be said with certainty at which point of the ecliptic the sun must have been for the occurrence of the winter solstice given by Vedāṅga Jyotiṣa. Hence, the time calculated by the above method is liable to be mistaken even by 1000 years.

v1.c6.s5.t2.3

The Europeans have not even now understood the quotation from Śatapatha Brāhmaṇa given above. The Pleiades are seen above the horizon for about 10 or 11 months during the year; and when they used to rise exactly in the east, this eastern rise could be seen from any place on the earth then; and there is nothing to be doubted about this. If there would have been an error of 1 degree in ascertaining the exact astronomical east, that in the calculated time would not be more than 200 years. In short, the reason why Kṛttikās used to be reckoned as the 1st nakṣatra was their rising in the exact East. The time for this event was about 3000 B.S. without doubt.