Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

俱舍論記 9.17

俱舍論記 9.17

Language
Classical Chinese

9.17

「謂死有前至中闕具三」者,初即正答前問,次總明有體四位不同。若欲、色二界有色有情具足四有,若無色界唯闕中有具餘三有。言結生者,結謂結續,即不斷義。又《婆沙》一百九十二云「如說四有,謂本有、死有、中有、生有。有聲目多義,如前廣說。此中有聲,說屬眾同分,有情數五蘊名有。云何本有?答:除生分、死分,諸蘊中間諸有。此則一期五蘊、四蘊為性。問:何故此有說名本有?答:此是前時所造業生,故名本有。問:若爾,餘有亦本有,皆前時所造業所生故。答:若是前時所造業生,麁顯易覺明了現見者,說名本有。餘雖前時所造業生,而微隱難覺非明了現見,是以不說。云何死有?答:死分諸蘊,則命終時五蘊、四蘊為性。云何中有?答:除死分、生分、諸蘊中間諸有,則二有中間五蘊為性。問:何故此有說名中有?答:此於二有中間生故,名中有。問:若爾,餘有亦是中有,皆於二有中間生故。答:若於二有中間生,非趣所攝者,名中有。餘雖二有中間生,而是趣攝,不名中有。云何生有?答:生分諸蘊,則結生時五蘊、四蘊為性。」廣如彼釋。

Regarding "That is, before the existence at death ... in the intermediate, it lacks [one] and is complete with three": the first part directly answers the previous question; next, it generally clarifies that the entity of existence differs across four phases. If it is in the desire or form realms, a sentient being possessed of form is fully endowed with the four existences; if in the formless realm, it lacks only the intermediate existence and is endowed with the remaining three existences. As for "taking rebirth" (pratisaṃdhi), "taking" means joining and continuing, which signifies non-interruption. Furthermore, Mahāvibhāṣā 192 says: "As it says, there are four existences: namely, basic existence (pūrvakāla-bhava), death existence (maraṇa-bhava), intermediate existence (antarā-bhava), and rebirth existence (upapatti-bhava). The word 'existence' (bhava) denotes many meanings, as explained extensively before. Here, the word 'existence' speaks of what belongs to the same class of beings (nikāya-sabhāga); the five skandhas of sentient beings are called 'existence.' What is basic existence? Answer: Excluding the portions of birth and death, it is the existences between those skandhas. This has as its nature the five skandhas or four skandhas of a single life span. Question: Why is this existence called 'basic existence'? Answer: This is born from karma created in a previous time; therefore it is called basic existence. Question: If so, the other existences would also be basic existences, since all are born from karma created in a previous time. Answer: If it is born of karma created in a previous time, and is coarse, manifest, easily perceived, clear, and visible to the senses, it is called basic existence. Although the others are born of karma created in a previous time, they are subtle, concealed, difficult to perceive, and not clearly visible, so they are not so designated. What is death existence? Answer: The skandhas of the portion of death; that is, it has as its nature the five skandhas or four skandhas at the time of the end of life. What is intermediate existence? Answer: Excluding the portions of death and birth, it is the existences between those skandhas; that is, it has as its nature the five skandhas between the two existences. Question: Why is this existence called 'intermediate existence'? Answer: Because this arises between two existences, it is called intermediate existence. Question: If so, the other existences would also be intermediate existences, since all arise between two existences. Answer: If it arises between two existences and is not included within a rebirth destiny (gati), it is called intermediate existence. Although the others arise between two existences, they are included within a destiny, so they are not called intermediate existences. What is rebirth existence? Answer: The skandhas of the portion of birth; that is, it has as its nature the five skandhas or four skandhas at the time of taking rebirth." It is explained extensively as in that text.

English (machine translation) (machine translation)

Translations (1)

Linked texts (1)