俱舍論頌疏論本 20.23
俱舍論頌疏論本 20.23
- Language
- Classical Chinese
20.23
釋曰:前三句經部破,第四句有宗答。何礙用云何者,此用字兩度言之,一何礙用、二用云何。何礙用者,經部破云:汝說三世法體常有,應一切時能起作用,何法礙用,時有時無?用云何者,汝說法體由作用故三世有別,又此作用,云何得說為去來今?且作用中而得更立有餘作用,用上有用,便致無窮。
The explanation says: The first three lines are the Sautrāntika refutation; the fourth line is the Sarvāstivāda response. As for "What obstructs function? How is there function?": the word "function" is spoken twice: first, "what obstructs function?"; second, "how is there function?" As for "what obstructs function?": the Sautrāntika refutes them, saying: You state that the entities of dharmas in the three time-periods are permanently existent; then at all times they should be able to produce function; what dharma obstructs function so that it sometimes exists and sometimes does not? As for "how is there function?": you state that because of function, the entities of dharmas are distinguished into three time-periods; moreover, regarding this function, how can it be spoken of as past, future, and present? And within function, can yet another function be further posited? A function upon a function would then lead to an infinite regress.
Translations (1)
- English (machine translation) — English, machine translation