Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

成唯識論演祕 6.550

成唯識論演祕 6.550

Language
Classical Chinese

6.550

此破外救。外救意云:色有壞苦於理,何違?故此難云:若有壞苦,豈唯迷彼,唯發非福?若不爾者,即違《瑜伽》迷世俗苦發非福義。復有欲界迷於壞苦發非福行相例之失,便違教理。若許爾者,復違聖教,上界唯是不動行招,故不得約三苦以分為二諦也。

This refutes the other's rejoinder. The intention of the other's rejoinder is: how does the presence of the suffering of change in the form realm contradict reason? Therefore this objection states: if it has the suffering of change, how could delusion regarding it only initiate non-merit? If this were not so, it would contradict the meaning in the Yogācārabhūmi that delusion regarding conventional suffering initiates non-merit. Moreover, there would be the fault of drawing an analogy with the desire realm's initiating non-meritorious volitions through delusion regarding the suffering of change, which would contradict both teaching and reason. If this were conceded, it would further contradict the sacred teachings, [which state that] the higher realms are brought about only by immovable volitions. Therefore, one must not divide the two truths on the basis of the three sufferings.

English (machine translation) (machine translation)

Translations (1)