Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

摩訶止觀 6.4

摩訶止觀 6.4

Language
Classical Chinese

6.4

稱「思惟」者,從解得名。初觀真淺猶有事障,後重慮真此惑即除,故名「思惟惑」也。數人云:「欲界為貪,上界名愛。」《成論》人難此語:「上界有味禪貪,下界有欲愛,愛、貪俱通,何意偏判?若言下界貪重,上界貪輕,貪輕可非貪耶?」此亦是一並,但佛有時對緣別說,假名無定,豈可一例?但令召得煩惱即須破除,何勞諍於貪、愛?譬如除糞,唯以却穢為先,分別非急。入道要在方便,名相傍耳。若欲委知,《毘曇》、《成論》備悉明之,可往彼尋。空假之觀,今所論也。

They are called '[delusions of] thought' because their name is derived from their resolution. When one first contemplates the true, it is shallow, and there are still obstacles regarding phenomena; later, when one re-reflects on the true, these delusions are eliminated; hence they are called 'delusions of thought'. Those of the Abhidharma school say: 'In the desire realm it is greed, while in the higher realms it is called attachment.' Those of the Tattvasiddhi school challenge this statement: 'In the higher realms there is greed that relishes dhyāna, and in the lower realm there is desire-attachment. Both attachment and greed apply to both; why make a one-sided distinction? If one says greed is heavy in the lower realm and light in the higher realms, can light greed be non-greed?' This is also an objection. However, the Buddha spoke differently depending on conditions; provisional designations are not fixed, so how could they be forced into a single rule? One need only name and identify the afflictions and then destroy them; why labor over disputes between greed and attachment? It is like removing dung: the only priority is to cast out the filth; making fine distinctions is not urgent. The essential point in entering the path lies in expedients; names and characteristics are secondary. If one wishes to know in detail, the Abhidharma and Tattvasiddhi explain it fully; one may look there. Contemplating emptiness and the provisional is what is discussed here.

English (machine translation) (machine translation)

Translations (1)