Dighanikaya 30: 7. Lakkhaṇasuttavaṇṇanā
Sumaṅgalavilāsinī 30
- Language
- Pāli
7. Lakkhaṇasuttavaṇṇanā
30.p1
Dvattiṃsamahāpurisalakkhaṇavaṇṇanā
Explanation of the Thirty-Two Marks of a Great Man
30.199
Evaṃ me sutanti lakkhaṇasuttaṃ. Tatrāyamanuttānapadavaṇṇanā. Dvattiṃsimānīti dvattiṃsa imāni. Mahāpurisalakkhaṇānīti mahāpurisabyañjanāni mahāpurisanimittāni ‘‘ayaṃ mahāpuriso’’ti sañjānanakāraṇāni. ‘‘Yehi samannāgatassa mahāpurisassā’’tiādi mahāpadāne vitthāritanayeneva veditabbaṃ.
'Thus have I heard' introduces the Lakkhaṇa Sutta. Therein, this is the explanation of the obscure words. 'These thirty-two' means thirty-two in number. 'Marks of a great man' means characteristics of a great man, signs of a great man, the reasons for recognizing, 'This is a great man.' 'Endowed with which, for a great man,' and so forth, should be understood precisely in the manner elaborated in the Mahāpadāna [Sutta].
30.199_2
‘‘Bāhirakāpi isayo dhārenti, no ca kho jānanti ‘imassa kammassa katattā imaṃ lakkhaṇaṃ paṭilabhatī’ti’’ kasmā āha? Aṭṭhuppattiyā anurūpattā. Idañhi suttaṃ saaṭṭhuppattikaṃ. Sā panassa aṭṭhuppatti kattha samuṭṭhitā? Antogāme manussānaṃ antare. Tadā kira sāvatthivāsino attano attano gehesu ca gehadvāresu ca santhāgārādīsu ca nisīditvā kathaṃ samuṭṭhāpesuṃ – ‘‘bhagavato asītianubyañjanāni byāmappabhā dvattiṃsamahāpurisalakkhaṇāni, yehi ca bhagavato kāyo, sabbaphāliphullo viya pāricchattako, vikasitamiva kamalavanaṃ, nānāratanavicittaṃ viya suvaṇṇatoraṇaṃ, tārāmaricivirocamiva gaganatalaṃ, ito cito ca vidhāvamānā vipphandamānā chabbaṇṇarasmiyo muñcanto ativiya sobhati. Bhagavato ca iminā nāma kammena idaṃ lakkhaṇaṃ nibbattanti kathitaṃ natthi, yāguuḷuṅkamattampi pana kaṭacchubhattamattaṃ vā pubbe dinnapaccayā evaṃ uppajjatīti bhagavatā vuttaṃ. Kiṃ nu kho satthā kammaṃ akāsi, yenassa imāni lakkhaṇāni nibbattantī’’ti.
Why did he say: 'Even outside seers remember them, yet they do not know: “Due to having done this action, one obtains this mark”'? Because it was appropriate to the occasion of the discourse. For this discourse has an occasion. Where did that occasion arise? In the village among the people. At that time, it is said, the residents of Sāvatthī, having sat down in their respective houses, at house doors, in meeting halls, and so forth, raised a topic of conversation: 'The Blessed One possesses the eighty minor marks, a fathom-wide aura, and the thirty-two marks of a great man, by which the Blessed One's body shines exceedingly, like a coral tree in full bloom, like a blossoming lotus grove, like a golden archway adorned with various jewels, like the vault of the sky gleaming with the rays of stars, emitting six-colored rays running and darting here and there. And it has not been declared by the Blessed One: “Due to this specific deed, this mark was produced”; yet it was stated by the Blessed One that even a mere ladle of gruel or a mere spoon of food previously given as a condition arises like this. What deed did the Teacher do by which these marks were produced for him?'
30.199_3
Athāyasmā ānando antogāme caranto imaṃ kathāsallāpaṃ sutvā katabhattakicco vihāraṃ āgantvā satthu vattaṃ katvā vanditvā ṭhito ‘‘mayā, bhante, antogāme ekā kathā sutā’’ti āha. Tato bhagavatā ‘‘kiṃ te, ānanda, suta’’nti vutte sabbaṃ ārocesi. Satthā therassa vacanaṃ sutvā parivāretvā nisinne bhikkhū āmantetvā ‘‘dvattiṃsimāni, bhikkhave, mahāpurisassa mahāpurisalakkhaṇānī’’ti paṭipāṭiyā lakkhaṇāni dassetvā yena kammena yaṃ nibbattaṃ, tassa dassanatthaṃ evamāha.
Then the venerable Ānanda, walking inside the village and hearing this conversation, finished his meal duties, came to the monastery, performed the duties toward the Teacher, paid homage, and while standing there said: "Venerable sir, I heard a conversation inside the village." Then, when the Blessed One asked, "Ānanda, what did you hear?", he reported everything. The Teacher, having heard the Elder's words, addressed the bhikkhus seated around him, showed the marks in order, saying, "Bhikkhus, there are these thirty-two marks of a Great Man belonging to a Great Man," and spoke thus in order to show what [mark] was produced by what kamma.
30.199_4
Suppatiṭṭhitapādatālakkhaṇavaṇṇanā
Commentary on the Mark of Having Well-Planted Feet
30.201
Purimaṃ jātintiādīsu pubbe nivutthakkhandhā jātavasena ‘‘jātī’’ti vuttā. Tathā bhavanavasena ‘‘bhavo’’ti, nivutthavasena ālayaṭṭhena vā ‘‘niketo’’ti. Tiṇṇampi padānaṃ pubbe nivutthakkhandhasantāne ṭhitoti attho. Idāni yasmā taṃ khandhasantānaṃ devalokādīsupi vattati. Lakkhaṇanibbattanasamatthaṃ pana kusalakammaṃ tattha na sukaraṃ, manussabhūtasseva sukaraṃ. Tasmā yathābhūtena yaṃ kammaṃ kataṃ, taṃ dassento pubbe manussabhūto samānoti āha. Akāraṇaṃ vā etaṃ. Hatthiassamigamahiṃsavānarādibhūtopi mahāpuriso pāramiyo pūretiyeva. Yasmā pana evarūpe attabhāve ṭhitena katakammaṃ na sakkā sukhena dīpetuṃ, manussabhāve ṭhitena katakammaṃ pana sakkā sukhena dīpetuṃ. Tasmā ‘‘pubbe manussabhūto samāno’’ti āha.
In the words, "a previous life" and so forth, the aggregates inhabited previously are called a "birth" on account of rebirth. So too they are a "becoming" on account of existing, or an "abode" on account of being inhabited, or in the sense of a dwelling. The meaning of all three words is: established in the continuity of aggregates inhabited previously. Now, because that continuity of aggregates also proceeds in the deva worlds and the like, but wholesome kamma capable of producing a mark is not easily done there, and is only easily done by one who has become a human being—therefore, showing what kamma was done according to what he had become, he said: "having previously been a human being." Or this is without special purpose: even when having become an elephant, a horse, a deer, a buffalo, a monkey, or the like, the Great Man certainly fulfills the perfections. But because kamma done while established in such a physical existence cannot easily be explained, whereas kamma done while established in a human state can easily be explained, he therefore said: "having previously been a human being."
30.201_2
Daḷhasamādānoti thiragahaṇo. Kusalesu dhammesūti dasakusalakammapathesu. Avatthitasamādānoti niccalagahaṇo anivattitagahaṇo. Mahāsattassa hi akusalakammato aggiṃ patvā kukkuṭapattaṃ viya cittaṃ paṭikuṭati, kusalaṃ patvā vitānaṃ viya pasāriyati. Tasmā daḷhasamādāno hoti avatthitasamādāno. Na sakkā kenaci samaṇena vā brāhmaṇena vā devena vā mārena vā brahmunā vā kusalasamādānaṃ vissajjāpetuṃ.
"Of firm undertaking" means having a steadfast grasp. "In wholesome qualities" means in the ten courses of wholesome action. "Of unswerving undertaking" means of motionless grasp, of unretracted grasp. For the Great Being's mind shrinks away from unwholesome kamma like a chicken's feather when it reaches fire, but when it reaches the wholesome, it spreads out like a canopy. Therefore he is of firm undertaking, of unswerving undertaking. No ascetic, brahmin, deva, Māra, or Brahmā can cause him to give up his undertaking of the wholesome.
30.201_3
Tatrimāni vatthūni – pubbe kira mahāpuriso kalandakayoniyaṃ nibbatti. Atha deve vuṭṭhe ogho āgantvā kulāvakaṃ gahetvā samuddameva pavesesi. Mahāpuriso ‘‘puttake nīharissāmī’’ti naṅguṭṭhaṃ temetvā temetvā samuddato udakaṃ bahi khipi. Sattame divase sakko āvajjitvā tattha āgamma ‘‘kiṃ karosī’’ti pucchi? So tassa ārocesi. Sakko mahāsamuddato udakassa dunnīharaṇīyabhāvaṃ kathesi. Bodhisatto tādisena kusītena saddhiṃ kathetumpi na vaṭṭati. ‘‘Mā idha tiṭṭhā’’ti apasāresi. Sakko ‘‘anomapurisena gahitagahaṇaṃ na sakkā vissajjāpetu’’nti tuṭṭho tassa puttake ānetvā adāsi. Mahājanakakālepi mahāsamuddaṃ taramāno ‘‘kasmā mahāsamuddaṃ tarasī’’ti devatāya puṭṭho ‘‘pāraṃ gantvā kulasantake raṭṭhe rajjaṃ gahetvā dānaṃ dātuṃ tarāmī’’ti āha. Tato devatāya – ‘‘ayaṃ mahāsamuddo gambhīro ceva puthulo ca, kadā naṃ tarissatī’’ti vutte so āha ‘‘taveso mahāsamuddasadiso, mayhaṃ pana ajjhāsayaṃ āgamma khuddakamātikā viya khāyati. Tvaṃyeva maṃ dakkhissasi samuddaṃ taritvā samuddapārato dhanaṃ āharitvā kulasantakaṃ rajjaṃ gahetvā dānaṃ dadamāna’’nti. Devatā ‘‘anomapurisena gahitagahaṇaṃ na sakkā vissajjāpetu’’nti bodhisattaṃ āliṅgetvā haritvā uyyāne nipajjāpesi. So chattaṃ ussāpetvā divase divase pañcasatasahassapariccāgaṃ katvā aparabhāge nikkhamma pabbajito. Evaṃ mahāsatto na sakkā kenaci samaṇena vā…pe… brahmunā vā kusalasamādānaṃ vissajjāpetuṃ. Tena vuttaṃ – ‘‘daḷhasamādāno ahosi kusalesu dhammesu avatthitasamādāno’’ti.
In this matter there are these stories: In the past, it is said, the Great Man was reborn in the womb of a squirrel. Then, when it rained, a flood came and took the nest and carried it into the great ocean. The Great Man, thinking, "I will rescue my young ones," dipped his tail again and again and threw water out of the ocean. On the seventh day, Sakka reflected, came there, and asked, "What are you doing?" He told him. Sakka spoke of the impossibility of taking water out of the great ocean. The Bodhisatta [thought] that it was not proper even to speak with such a lazy person, and drove him away, saying, "Do not stand here!" Sakka, thinking, "What has been grasped by this noble man cannot be caused to be given up," was pleased, brought his young ones, and gave them to him. In the time of Mahājanaka as well, while crossing the great ocean, when asked by a deity, "Why are you crossing the great ocean?", he said: "Having gone to the other shore, taking the kingdom belonging to my family, I cross so that I may give gifts." Then, when the deity said, "This great ocean is both deep and vast; when will you cross it?", he replied: "It looks like a great ocean to you, but because of my resolve, it appears like a little ditch. You yourself will see me crossing the ocean, bringing wealth from the far side of the ocean, taking the kingdom belonging to my family, and giving gifts." The deity, thinking, "What has been grasped by this noble man cannot be caused to be given up," embraced the Bodhisatta, carried him, and laid him down in a royal park. He raised the parasol, gave five hundred thousand every day, and at a later time went forth and became an ascetic. Thus, no ascetic or… pe… Brahmā could cause the Great Being to give up his undertaking of the wholesome. Hence it was said: "he was of firm undertaking in wholesome qualities, of unswerving undertaking."
30.201_4
Idāni yesu kusalesu dhammesu avatthitasamādāno ahosi, te dassetuṃ kāyasucaritetiādimāha. Dānasaṃvibhāgeti ettha ca dānameva diyyanavasena dānaṃ, saṃvibhāgakaraṇavasena saṃvibhāgo. Sīlasamādāneti pañcasīladasasīlacatupārisuddhisīlapūraṇakāle. Uposathūpavāseti cātuddasikādibhedassa uposathassa upavasanakāle. Matteyyatāyāti mātukātabbavatte. Sesapadesupi eseva nayo. Aññataraññataresu cāti aññesu ca evarūpesu. Adhikusalesūti ettha atthi kusalā, atthi adhikusalā. Sabbepi kāmāvacarā kusalā kusalā nāma, rūpāvacarā adhikusalā. Ubhopi te kusalā nāma, arūpāvacarā adhikusalā. Sabbepi te kusalā nāma, sāvakapāramīpaṭilābhapaccayā kusalā adhikusalā nāma. Tepi kusalā nāma, paccekabodhipaṭilābhapaccayā kusalā adhikusalā. Tepi kusalā nāma, sabbaññutaññāṇappaṭilābhapaccayā pana kusalā idha ‘‘adhikusalā’’ti adhippetā. Tesu adhikusalesu dhammesu daḷhasamādāno ahosi avatthitasamādāno.
Now, in order to show those wholesome states in which he had unwavering undertaking, he said: 'in bodily good conduct', and so forth. Here, 'in giving and sharing' (dānasaṃvibhāge): 'giving' (dāna) itself is giving in the sense of bestowing, while 'sharing' (saṃvibhāga) is in the sense of dividing equally. 'In undertaking virtue' (sīlasamādāne): at the time of fulfilling the five precepts, the ten precepts, and the fourfold morality of purification. 'In observing the uposatha' (uposathūpavāse): at the time of observing the uposatha consisting of the fourteenth day and so on. 'In filial duty toward one's mother' (matteyyatāya): in the duties that should be performed toward one's mother. In the remaining words, this is also the method. 'And in various other [wholesome states]' (aññataraññataresu ca): and in others of such a nature. 'In higher wholesome states' (adhikusalesu): herein, there are wholesome states, and there are higher wholesome states. All wholesome states of the sense sphere are called wholesome; those of the fine-material sphere are higher wholesome states. Both of those are called wholesome; those of the immaterial sphere are higher wholesome states. All of those are called wholesome; wholesome states that are conditions for attaining the perfections of a disciple are called higher wholesome states. Those too are called wholesome; wholesome states that are conditions for attaining individual awakening are higher wholesome states. Those too are called wholesome; but wholesome states that are conditions for attaining the knowledge of omniscience are intended here as 'higher wholesome states'. In those higher wholesome states he was one of firm undertaking, one of unwavering undertaking.
30.201_5
Kaṭattā upacitattāti ettha sakimpi kataṃ katameva, abhiṇhakaraṇena pana upacitaṃ hoti. Ussannattāti piṇḍīkataṃ rāsīkataṃ kammaṃ ussannanti vuccati. Tasmā ‘‘ussannattā’’ti vadanto mayā katakammassa cakkavāḷaṃ atisambādhaṃ, bhavaggaṃ atinīcaṃ, evaṃ me ussannaṃ kammanti dasseti. Vipulattāti appamāṇattā. Iminā ‘‘anantaṃ aparimāṇaṃ mayā kataṃ kamma’’nti dasseti. Adhiggaṇhātīti adhibhavati, aññehi devehi atirekaṃ labhatīti attho. Paṭilabhatīti adhigacchati.
'Because of having done, because of having accumulated' (kaṭattā upacitattā): herein, what is done even once is indeed done; however, through repeated performance it is accumulated. 'Because of abundance' (ussannattā): kamma that has been grouped together, made into a heap, is called abundant. Therefore, saying 'because of abundance', he indicates: 'For the kamma done by me, the world system is too narrow, the peak of existence is too low; thus is my kamma abundant.' 'Because of vastness' (vipulattā): because of being immeasurable. By this he shows: 'Endless, boundless is the kamma done by me.' 'He surpasses' (adhiggaṇhāti): he overcomes; the meaning is that he obtains more than other devas. 'He obtains' (paṭilabhati): he acquires.
30.201_6
Sabbāvantehi pādatalehīti idaṃ ‘‘samaṃ pādaṃ bhūmiyaṃ nikkhipatī’’ti etassa vitthāravacanaṃ. Tattha sabbāvantehīti sabbapadesavantehi, na ekena padesena paṭhamaṃ phusati, na ekena pacchā, sabbeheva pādatalehi samaṃ phusati, samaṃ uddharati. Sacepi hi tathāgato ‘‘anekasataporisaṃ narakaṃ akkamissāmī’’ti pādaṃ abhinīharati. Tāvadeva ninnaṭṭhānaṃ vātapūritā viya kammārabhastā unnamitvā pathavisamaṃ hoti. Unnataṭṭhānampi anto pavisati. ‘‘Dūre akkamissāmī’’ti abhinīharantassa sineruppamāṇopi pabbato suseditavettaṅkuro viya onamitvā pādasamīpaṃ āgacchati. Tathā hissa yamakapāṭihāriyaṃ katvā ‘‘yugandharapabbataṃ akkamissāmī’’ti pāde abhinīhaṭe pabbato onamitvā pādasamīpaṃ āgato. Sopi taṃ akkamitvā dutiyapādena tāvatiṃsabhavanaṃ akkami. Na hi cakkalakkhaṇena patiṭṭhātabbaṭṭhānaṃ visamaṃ bhavituṃ sakkoti. Khāṇu vā kaṇṭako vā sakkharā vā kathalā vā uccārapassāvakheḷasiṅghāṇikādīni vā purimataraṃ vā apagacchanti, tattha tattheva vā pathaviṃ pavisanti. Tathāgatassa hi sīlatejena puññatejena dhammatejena dasannaṃ pāramīnaṃ ānubhāvena ayaṃ mahāpathavī sammā mudupupphābhikiṇṇā hoti.
'With the entire soles of his feet' (sabbāvantehi pādatalehi): this is an elaboration of 'he places his foot evenly on the ground'. There, 'with the entire' (sabbāvantehi): with all parts; he does not touch first with one part, nor later with another; with the entire soles of his feet he touches evenly, lifts evenly. Even if the Tathāgata extends his foot, thinking: 'I will step across an abyss many hundred men deep', right then the low place rises up like a smith's bellows filled with air and becomes level with the earth. The high place also sinks inward. When he extends [his foot], thinking: 'I will step far', even a mountain the size of Sineru bends down like a well-steamed shoot of cane and comes near his foot. For thus, having performed the Twin Miracle, when he extended his feet, thinking: 'I will step on Mount Yugandhara', the mountain bent down and came near his foot. Having stepped on it, he stepped with his second foot on the realm of the Tāvatiṃsa devas. Indeed, a place to be trodden upon by the mark of the wheel cannot be uneven. A stump, or a thorn, or gravel, or potsherds, or excrement, urine, saliva, snot, and so forth, either recede beforehand or sink into the earth right then and there. For through the power of virtue, the power of merit, the power of the Dhamma, and through the majesty of the ten perfections of the Tathāgata, this great earth is completely strewn with soft flowers.
30.202
Sāgarapariyantanti sāgarasīmaṃ. Na hi tassa rajjaṃ karontassa antarā rukkho vā pabbato vā nadī vā sīmā hoti mahāsamuddova sīmā. Tena vuttaṃ ‘‘sāgarapariyanta’’nti. Akhilamanimittamakaṇṭakanti niccoraṃ. Corā hi kharasamphassaṭṭhena khilā, upaddavapaccayaṭṭhena nimittā, vijjhanaṭṭhena kaṇṭakāti vuccanti. Iddhanti samiddhaṃ. Phītanti sabbasampattiphāliphullaṃ. Khemanti nibbhayaṃ. Sivanti nirupaddavaṃ. Nirabbudanti abbudavirahitaṃ, gumbaṃ gumbaṃ hutvā carantehi corehi virahitanti attho. Akkhambhiyoti avikkhambhanīyo. Na naṃ koci ṭhānato cāletuṃ sakkoti. Paccatthikenāti paṭipakkhaṃ icchantena. Paccāmittenāti paṭiviruddhena amittena. Ubhayampetaṃ sapattavevacanaṃ. Abbhantarehīti anto uṭṭhitehi rāgādīhi.
'Bounded by the ocean' (sāgarapariyantaṃ): having the ocean as its border. For when he exercises kingship, no tree, mountain, or river in between is the border; only the great ocean is the border. Therefore it is said: 'bounded by the ocean'. 'Free from barrenness, free from ill omens, free from thorns' (akhilamanimittamakaṇṭakaṃ): free from thieves. For thieves are called 'barren' (khila) in the sense of harsh contact, 'ill omens' (nimitta) in the sense of causing misfortune, and 'thorns' (kaṇṭaka) in the sense of piercing. 'Prosperous' (iddhaṃ): successful. 'Flourishing' (phītaṃ): blossomed and bloomed with all prosperity. 'Secure' (khemaṃ): free from fear. 'Auspicious' (sivaṃ): free from danger. 'Free from distress' (nirabbudaṃ): without tumors; the meaning is, free from thieves wandering in gangs. 'Unshakable' (akkhambhiyo): impossible to be shaken off. No one can move him from his position. 'By an opponent' (paccatthikena): by one desiring opposition. 'By an enemy' (paccāmittenā): by a hostile enemy. Both of these are synonyms for an adversary. 'By internal [ones]' (abbhantarehi): by lust and so on arisen within.
30.202_2
Bāhirehīti samaṇādīhi. Tathā hi naṃ bāhirā devadattakokālikādayo samaṇāpi soṇadaṇḍakūṭadaṇḍādayo brāhmaṇāpi sakkasadisā devatāpi satta vassāni anubandhamāno māropi bakādayo brahmānopi vikkhambhetuṃ nāsakkhiṃsu.
'By external [ones]' (bāhirehi): by recluses and so forth. For neither external recluses such as Devadatta and Kokālika, nor brāhmaṇas such as Soṇadaṇḍa and Kūṭadaṇḍa, nor devatās equal to Sakka, nor Māra pursuing him for seven years, nor brahmas such as Baka were able to shake him.
30.202_3
Ettāvatā bhagavatā kammañca kammasarikkhakañca lakkhaṇañca lakkhaṇānisaṃso ca vutto hoti. Kammaṃ nāma satasahassakappādhikāni cattāri asaṅkhyeyyāni daḷhavīriyena hutvā kataṃ kammaṃ. Kammasarikkhakaṃ nāma daḷhena hutvā katabhāvaṃ sadevako loko jānātūti suppatiṭṭhitapādamahāpurisalakkhaṇaṃ. Lakkhaṇaṃ nāma suppatiṭṭhitapādatā. Lakkhaṇānisaṃso nāma paccatthikehi avikkhambhanīyatā.
To this extent, kamma, that which resembles kamma, the mark, and the benefit of the mark have been stated by the Blessed One. 'Kamma' is the kamma done with firm energy over four incalculable periods and a hundred thousand aeons. 'That which resembles kamma' is the mark of a great man having well-planted feet, so that the world with its devas may know the fact of its having been done firmly. 'The mark' is the quality of having well-planted feet. 'The benefit of the mark' is the unshakability by opponents.
30.203
Tatthetaṃ vuccatīti tattha vutte kammādibhede aparampi idaṃ vuccati, gāthābandhaṃ sandhāya vuttaṃ. Etā pana gāthā porāṇakattherā ‘‘ānandattherena ṭhapitā vaṇṇanāgāthā’’ti vatvā gatā. Aparabhāge therā ‘‘ekapadiko atthuddhāro’’ti āhaṃsu.
'Here this is said' (tatthetaṃ vuccati): in that matter, another statement is made regarding the division of kamma and so forth that has been spoken of; this is said with reference to the composition of verses. Now, the elder monks of old passed this down, saying: 'These are verses of praise established by the Elder Ānanda.' In a later period, the elders said: 'It is an extraction of the meaning word by word.'
30.203_2
Tattha sacceti vacīsacce. Dhammeti dasakusalakammapathadhamme. Dameti indriyadamane. Saṃyameti sīlasaṃyame. ‘‘Soceyyasīlālayuposathesu cā’’ti ettha kāyasoceyyādi tividhaṃ soceyyaṃ. Ālayabhūtaṃ sīlameva sīlālayo. Uposathakammaṃ uposatho. Ahiṃsāyāti avihiṃsāya. Samattamācarīti sakalaṃ acari.
Herein, 'in truth' (sacce): in truthfulness of speech. 'In Dhamma' (dhamme): in the Dhamma of the ten wholesome courses of action. 'In restraint' (dame): in the restraint of the faculties. 'In self-control' (saṃyame): in the self-control of virtue. In 'and in purity, the domain of virtue, and the uposatha' (soceyyasīlālayuposathesu ca): here, threefold purity such as bodily purity. 'The domain of virtue' (sīlālaya) is just virtue which has become a dwelling. 'Uposatha' is the practice of the uposatha. 'In non-violence' (ahiṃsāya): in harmlessness. 'He practiced entirely' (samattamācarī): he practiced completely.
30.203_3
Anvabhīti anubhavi. Veyyañjanikāti lakkhaṇapāṭhakā. Parābhibhūti pare abhibhavanasamattho. Sattubhīti sapattehi akkhambhiyo hoti.
'He experienced' (anvabhī): he experienced (anubhavi). 'Experts in physical marks' (veyyañjanikā): readers of marks. 'Overcoming others' (parābhibhū): capable of overcoming others. 'By enemies' (sattubhī): he is unshakable by adversaries.
30.203_4
Na so gacchati jātu khambhananti so ekaṃseneva aggapuggalo vikkhambhetabbataṃ na gacchati. Esā hi tassa dhammatāti tassa hi esā dhammatā ayaṃ sabhāvo.
‘He never undergoes hindrance’ means that he, the supreme individual, certainly does not undergo suppression. ‘For this is his nature’: for this is his nature, this natural state.
30.203_5
Pādatalacakkalakkhaṇavaṇṇanā
Commentary on the Mark of the Wheels on the Soles of the Feet
30.204
Ubbegauttāsabhayanti ubbegabhayañceva uttāsabhayañca. Tattha corato vā rājato vā paccatthikato vā vilopanabandhanādinissayaṃ bhayaṃ ubbego nāma, taṃmuhuttikaṃ caṇḍahatthiassādīni vā ahiyakkhādayo vā paṭicca lomahaṃsanakaraṃ bhayaṃ uttāsabhayaṃ nāma. Taṃ sabbaṃ apanuditā vūpasametā. Saṃvidhātāti saṃvidahitā. Kathaṃ saṃvidahati? Aṭaviyaṃ sāsaṅkaṭṭhānesu dānasālaṃ kāretvā tattha āgate bhojetvā manusse datvā ativāheti, taṃ ṭhānaṃ pavisituṃ asakkontānaṃ manusse pesetvā paveseti. Nagarādīsupi tesu tesu ṭhānesu ārakkhaṃ ṭhapeti, evaṃ saṃvidahati. Saparivārañca dānaṃ adāsīti annaṃ pānanti dasavidhaṃ dānavatthuṃ.
‘Agitation, alarm, and fear’ means both the fear of agitation and the fear of alarm. In this context, fear rooted in plunder, imprisonment, and so forth caused by a thief, a king, or an enemy is called ‘agitation’; fear that causes goosebumps on account of savage elephants, horses, and so on, or serpents, yakkhas, and so forth in a given moment is called ‘fear of alarm’. He was one who dispelled and calmed all of that. ‘An organizer’: one who makes arrangements. How did he make arrangements? Having built a hall for giving in dangerous places in the wilderness, having fed those who arrived there, he had people conduct them through safely; he dispatched people to let in those unable to enter that place. In cities and elsewhere, too, he stationed guards in various places; thus he made arrangements. ‘And gave gifts with their accompaniments’ refers to the ten kinds of gift items, such as food and drink.
30.204_2
Tattha annanti yāgubhattaṃ. Taṃ dadanto na dvāre ṭhapetvā adāsi, atha kho antonivesane haritupalittaṭṭhāne lājā ceva pupphāni ca vikiritvā āsanaṃ paññapetvā vitānaṃ bandhitvā gandhadhūmādīhi sakkāraṃ katvā bhikkhusaṅghaṃ nisīdāpetvā yāguṃ adāsi. Yāguṃ dento ca sabyañjanaṃ adāsi. Yāgupānāvasāne pāde dhovitvā telena makkhetvā nānappakārakaṃ anantaṃ khajjakaṃ datvā pariyosāne anekasūpaṃ anekabyañjanaṃ paṇītabhojanaṃ adāsi. Pānaṃ dento ambapānādiaṭṭhavidhaṃ pānaṃ adāsi, tampi yāgubhattaṃ datvā. Vatthaṃ dento na suddhavatthameva adāsi, ekapaṭṭadupaṭṭādipahonakaṃ pana datvā sucimpi adāsi, suttampi adāsi, suttaṃ vaṭṭesi, sūcikammakaraṇaṭṭhāne bhikkhūnaṃ āsanāni, yāgubhattaṃ, pādamakkhanaṃ, piṭṭhimakkhanaṃ, rajanaṃ, paṇḍupalāsaṃ, rajanadoṇikaṃ, antamaso cīvararajanakaṃ kappiyakārakampi adāsi.
Therein, ‘food’ means rice porridge and boiled rice. Giving that, he did not give it having placed it at the door; rather, having sprinkled popped grain and flowers inside the residence in a place smeared with green [cow dung], having prepared seats, having fastened a canopy, having paid honour with perfumes, incenses, and so on, having seated the Saṅgha of bhikkhus, he gave rice porridge. And while giving rice porridge, he gave it with condiments. At the conclusion of drinking the rice porridge, having washed their feet, having anointed them with oil, having given boundless hard food of various kinds, in the end he gave refined soft food with many soups and many curries. Giving drink, he gave eight kinds of drinks, such as mango juice, and that too after giving rice porridge and boiled rice. Giving cloth, he did not give merely plain cloth; rather, having given what was sufficient for a single-fold or double-fold [robe] and so on, he gave a needle, gave thread, spun thread, and in the place where the needlework was done he gave seats for the bhikkhus, rice porridge and boiled rice, foot-ointment, back-ointment, dye, dry leaves, a dye-trough, and even a robe-dyer and an attendant who makes things allowable.
30.204_3
Yānanti upāhanaṃ. Taṃ dadantopi upāhanatthavikaṃ upāhanadaṇḍakaṃ makkhanatelaṃ heṭṭhā vuttāni ca annādīni tasseva parivāraṃ katvā adāsi. Mālaṃ dentopi na suddhamālameva adāsi, atha kho naṃ gandhehi missetvā heṭṭhimāni cattāri tasseva parivāraṃ katvā adāsi. Bodhicetiyaāsanapotthakādipūjanatthāya ceva cetiyagharadhūpanatthāya ca gandhaṃ dentopi na suddhagandhameva adāsi, gandhapisanakanisadāya ceva pakkhipanakabhājanena ca saddhiṃ heṭṭhimāni pañca tassa parivāraṃ katvā adāsi. Cetiyapūjādīnaṃ atthāya haritālamanosilācīnapiṭṭhādivilepanaṃ dentopi na suddhavilepanameva adāsi, vilepanabhājanena saddhiṃ heṭṭhimāni cha tassa parivāraṃ katvā adāsi. Seyyāti mañcapīṭhaṃ. Taṃ dentopi na suddhakameva adāsi, kojavakambalapaccattharaṇamañcappaṭipādakehi saddhiṃ antamaso maṅgulasodhanadaṇḍakaṃ heṭṭhimāni ca satta tassa parivāraṃ katvā adāsi. Āvasathaṃ dentopi na gehamattameva adāsi, atha kho naṃ mālākammalatākammapaṭimaṇḍitaṃ supaññattaṃ mañcapīṭhaṃ kāretvā heṭṭhimāni aṭṭha tassa parivāraṃ katvā adāsi. Padīpeyyanti padīpatelaṃ. Taṃ dento cetiyaṅgaṇe bodhiyaṅgaṇe dhammassavanagge vasanagehe potthakavācanaṭṭhāne iminā dīpaṃ jālāpethāti na suddhatelameva adāsi, vaṭṭi kapallakatelabhājanādīhi saddhiṃ heṭṭhimāni nava tassa parivāraṃ katvā adāsi. Suvibhattantarānīti suvibhattaantarāni.
‘A vehicle’ means footwear. Giving that as well, he gave a footwear bag, a footwear stick, anointing oil, and the aforementioned items such as food, making them the accompaniments to that very thing. Giving a garland, too, he did not give merely a plain garland; rather, having mixed it with perfumes, he gave the four preceding [items] making them the accompaniments to that very thing. Giving perfume to worship the Bodhi tree, cetiya, seat, manuscripts, and so forth, and to fumigate cetiya houses, he did not give merely plain perfume; he gave the five preceding [items] together with a grindstone for perfume and a storage vessel, making them its accompaniments. Giving ointments such as yellow orpiment, red arsenic, and Chinese vermilion for the purpose of worshiping cetiyas and so forth, he did not give merely plain ointment; he gave the six preceding [items] together with an ointment container, making them its accompaniments. ‘A bed’ means a couch and a chair. Giving that, too, he did not give it merely plain; he gave the seven preceding [items] together with a fleecy counterpane, a woollen blanket, a mattress, bed supports, and even a scraper to remove dirt, making them its accompaniments. Giving a dwelling, too, he did not give merely a house; rather, having made it adorned with floral work and creeper patterns and well-furnished with couches and chairs, he gave the eight preceding [items] making them its accompaniments. ‘Accessories for lamps’ means lamp oil. Giving that, with the thought: ‘Light lamps with this in the cetiya compound, the Bodhi tree compound, the Dhamma preaching hall, the living quarters, and the place of reading manuscripts,’ he did not give merely plain oil; he gave the nine preceding [items] together with wicks, small saucers, oil vessels, and so forth, making them its accompaniments. ‘With well-proportioned spaces’ means with well-divided intervals.
30.204_4
Rājānoti abhisittā. Bhogiyāti bhojakā kumārāti rājakumārā. Idha kammaṃ nāma saparivāraṃ dānaṃ. Kammasarikkhakaṃ nāma saparivāraṃ katvā dānaṃ adāsīti iminā kāraṇena sadevako loko jānātūti nibbattaṃ cakkalakkhaṇaṃ. Lakkhaṇaṃ nāma tadeva cakkalakkhaṇaṃ. Ānisaṃso mahāparivāratā.
‘Kings’ means anointed monarchs. ‘Lords’ means rulers; ‘princes’ means royal princes. Here, ‘kamma’ means the gift given with accompaniments. ‘Resembling the kamma’ means that the wheel mark arose so that the world with its devas would know that it was on this ground that he gave the gift having made it with accompaniments. ‘Mark’ means that very wheel mark. The benefit is the state of having a large retinue.
30.205
Tatthetaṃ vuccatīti imā tadatthaparidīpanā gāthā vuccanti. Duvidhā hi gāthā honti – tadatthaparidīpanā ca visesatthaparidīpanā ca. Tattha pāḷiāgatameva atthaṃ paridīpanā tadatthaparidīpanā nāma. Pāḷiyaṃ anāgataṃ paridīpanā visesatthaparidīpanā nāma. Imā pana tadatthaparidīpanā. Tattha pureti pubbe. Puratthāti tasseva vevacanaṃ. Purimāsu jātīsūti imissā jātiyā pubbekatakammapaṭikkhepadīpanaṃ. Ubbegauttāsabhayāpanūdanoti ubbegabhayassa ca uttāsabhayassa ca apanūdano. Ussukoti adhimutto.
‘Therein this is said’ means that these verses elucidating that meaning are spoken. For verses are of two kinds: those elucidating that meaning and those elucidating a special meaning. Therein, those elucidating only the meaning found in the Pāli text are called ‘those elucidating that meaning’. Those elucidating what is not found in the Pāli text are called ‘those elucidating a special meaning’. These, however, are those elucidating that meaning. Therein, ‘in former times’ means in the past. ‘Formerly’ is a synonym for that very term. ‘In previous births’ shows the rejection of kamma performed before this birth. ‘Dispeller of agitation, alarm, and fear’ means one who dispels both the fear of agitation and the fear of alarm. ‘Eager’ means dedicated.
30.205_2
Satapuññalakkhaṇanti satena satena puññakammena nibbattaṃ ekekaṃ lakkhaṇaṃ. Evaṃ sante yo koci buddho bhaveyyāti na rocayiṃsu, anantesu pana cakkavāḷesu sabbe sattā ekekaṃ kammaṃ satakkhattuṃ kareyyuṃ, ettakehi janehi kataṃ kammaṃ bodhisatto ekova ekekaṃ sataguṇaṃ katvā nibbatto. Tasmā ‘‘satapuññalakkhaṇo’’ti imamatthaṃ rocayiṃsu. Manussāsurasakkarakkhasāti manussā ca asurā ca sakkā ca rakkhasā ca.
‘Mark of a hundred merits’ means each mark is produced by a hundred meritorious deeds each. If this were the case, anyone could become a Buddha; therefore, they did not accept this. But if all beings in the infinite world systems were each to perform a deed a hundred times, the Bodhisatta alone was reborn having performed a deed done by so many people a hundred times over. Therefore, they accepted this meaning: ‘the mark of a hundred merits’. ‘Human beings, asuras, sakkas, and rakkhasas’ means human beings, asuras, sakkas, and rakkhasas.
30.205_3
Āyatapaṇhitāditilakkhaṇavaṇṇanā
Commentary on the Three Marks Beginning with Having Long Heels
30.206
Antarāti paṭisandhito sarasacutiyā antare. Idha kammaṃ nāma pāṇātipātā virati. Kammasarikkhakaṃ nāma pāṇātipātaṃ karonto padasaddasavanabhayā aggaggapādehi akkamantā gantvā paraṃ pātenti. Atha te iminā kāraṇena tesaṃ taṃ kammaṃ jano jānātūti antovaṅkapādā vā bahivaṅkapādā vā ukkuṭikapādā vā aggakoṇḍā vā paṇhikoṇḍā vā bhavanti. Aggapādehi gantvā parassa amāritabhāvaṃ pana tathāgatassa sadevako loko iminā kāraṇena jānātūti āyatapaṇhi mahāpurisalakkhaṇaṃ nibbattati. Tathā paraṃ ghātentā unnatakāyena gacchantā aññe passissantīti onatā gantvā paraṃ ghātenti. Atha te evamime gantvā paraṃ ghātayiṃsūti nesaṃ taṃ kammaṃ iminā kāraṇena paro jānātūti khujjā vā vāmanā vā pīṭhasappi vā bhavanti. Tathāgatassa pana evaṃ gantvā paresaṃ aghātitabhāvaṃ iminā kāraṇena sadevako loko jānātūti brahmujugattamahāpurisalakkhaṇaṃ nibbattati. Tathā paraṃ ghātentā āvudhaṃ vā muggaraṃ vā gaṇhitvā muṭṭhikatahatthā paraṃ ghātenti. Te evaṃ tesaṃ parassa ghātitabhāvaṃ iminā kāraṇena jano jānātūti rassaṅgulī vā rassahatthā vā vaṅkaṅgulī vā phaṇahatthakā vā bhavanti. Tathāgatassa pana evaṃ paresaṃ aghātitabhāvaṃ sadevako loko iminā kāraṇena jānātūti dīghaṅgulimahāpurisalakkhaṇaṃ nibbattati. Idamettha kammasarikkhakaṃ. Idameva pana lakkhaṇattayaṃ lakkhaṇaṃ nāma. Dīghāyukabhāvo lakkhaṇānisaṃso.
"In the interval" means in the interval between rebirth-linking and natural death. Here, the kamma is abstention from taking life. That which resembles the kamma is as follows: when committing the taking of life, fearing the sound of footsteps, they walk stepping with the tips of their feet and strike down the other. Then, by this reason, so that people may know that kamma of theirs, they become bent inward in the feet, or bent outward in the feet, or squatting in the feet, or club-footed in the front, or club-footed in the heels. But so that the world with its devas may know by this reason that the Tathāgata did not kill another while walking on tiptoes, the mark of a Great Man having projecting heels is produced. Likewise, when slaying another, thinking that others will see them if they walk with their bodies held high, they bend down and slay the other. Then, by this reason, so that another may know that kamma of theirs—that they walked thus and slew another—they become hunchbacked, or dwarfed, or cripples on a stool. But so that the world with its devas may know by this reason that the Tathāgata did not slay others by walking thus, the mark of a Great Man having a body as straight as Brahmā's is produced. Likewise, when slaying another, taking a weapon or a club, they slay the other with hands made into fists. By this reason, so that people may know that slaying of another by them in this way, they have short fingers, or short hands, or crooked fingers, or hands like a snake's hood. But so that the world with its devas may know by this reason that the Tathāgata did not slay others in this way, the mark of a Great Man having long fingers is produced. This is what resembles the kamma here. And this triad of marks is the mark itself; the state of having a long lifespan is the benefit of the mark.
30.207
Maraṇavadhabhayattanoti ettha maraṇasaṅkhāto vadho maraṇavadho, maraṇavadhato bhayaṃ maraṇavadhabhayaṃ, taṃ attano jānitvā. Paṭivirato paraṃmāraṇāyāti yathā mayhaṃ maraṇato bhayaṃ mama jīvitaṃ piyaṃ, evaṃ paresampīti ñatvā paraṃ māraṇato paṭivirato ahosi. Sucaritenāti suciṇṇena. Saggamagamāti saggaṃ gato.
"Maraṇavadhabhayattano": here, slaying consisting of death is "death-slaying"; fear of death-slaying is "fear of death-slaying"; knowing that of oneself. "Paṭivirato paraṃmāraṇāya": just as I fear death and cherish my life, so too do others—having understood thus, he abstained from killing others. "Sucaritena": by well-conducted action. "Saggamagamā": he went to heaven.
30.207_2
Caviya punaridhāgatoti cavitvā puna idhāgato. Dīghapāsaṇhikoti dīghapaṇhiko. Brahmāva sujūti brahmā viya suṭṭhu uju.
"Caviya punaridhāgato": having passed away, he came here again. "Dīghapāsaṇhiko": having long heels. "Brahmāva sujū": very straight like a Brahmā.
30.207_3
Subhujoti sundarabhujo. Susūti mahallakakālepi taruṇarūpo. Susaṇṭhitoti susaṇṭhānasampanno. Mudutalunaṅguliyassāti mudū ca talunā ca aṅguliyo assa. Tībhīti tīhi. Purisavaraggalakkhaṇehīti purisavarassa aggalakkhaṇehi. Cirayapanāyāti ciraṃ yāpanāya, dīghāyukabhāvāya.
"Subhujo": having beautiful arms. "Susū": youthful in appearance even in old age. "Susaṇṭhito": endowed with a fine bodily form. "Mudutalunaṅguliyassa": of him whose fingers are soft and tender. "Tībhī": by three. "Purisavaraggalakkhaṇehi": by the foremost marks of an excellent man. "Cirayapanāya": for long endurance, for longevity.
30.207_4
Ciraṃ yapetīti ciraṃ yāpeti. Cirataraṃ pabbajati yadi tatoti tato cirataraṃ yāpeti, yadi pabbajatīti attho. Yāpayati ca vasiddhibhāvanāyāti vasippatto hutvā iddhibhāvanāya yāpeti.
"Ciraṃ yapeti": he endures long. "Cirataraṃ pabbajati yadi tato": he endures longer still than that if he goes forth, this is the meaning. "Yāpayati ca vasiddhibhāvanāya": having attained mastery, he endures by the development of psychic power.
30.207_5
Sattussadatālakkhaṇavaṇṇanā
Explanation of the Mark of Having Seven Prominences
30.208
Rasitānanti rasasampannānaṃ. ‘‘Khādanīyāna’’ntiādīsu khādanīyāni nāma piṭṭhakhajjakādīni. Bhojanīyānīti pañca bhojanāni. Sāyanīyānīti sāyitabbāni sappinavanītādīni. Lehanīyānīti nillehitabbāni piṭṭhapāyāsādīni. Pānānīti aṭṭha pānakāni.
"Rasitānaṃ": of tasty things. In the passage beginning with "khādanīyānaṃ": "chewable foods" means flour cakes and the like. "Staple foods" means the five staple foods. "Savory foods" means foods to be tasted, such as ghee, butter, and so forth. "Lickable foods" means foods to be licked, such as confection-puddings and so forth. "Drinks" means the eight kinds of drinks.
30.208_2
Idha kammaṃ nāma kappasatasahassādhikāni cattāri asaṅkhyeyyāni dinnaṃ idaṃ paṇītabhojanadānaṃ. Kammasarikkhakaṃ nāma lūkhabhojane kucchigate lohitaṃ sussati, maṃsaṃ milāyati. Tasmā lūkhadāyakā sattā iminā kāraṇena nesaṃ lūkhabhojanassa dinnabhāvaṃ jano jānātūti appamaṃsā appalohitā manussapetā viya dullabhannapānā bhavanti. Paṇītabhojane pana kucchigate maṃsalohitaṃ vaḍḍhati, paripuṇṇakāyā pāsādikā abhirūpadassanā honti. Tasmā tathāgatassa dīgharattaṃ paṇītabhojanadāyakattaṃ sadevako loko iminā kāraṇena jānātūti sattussadamahāpurisalakkhaṇaṃ nibbattati. Lakkhaṇaṃ nāma sattussadalakkhaṇameva. Paṇītalābhitā ānisaṃso.
Here, "kamma" means this gift of choice food given over four incalculable periods and a hundred thousand aeons. "Resemblance to the kamma" means: when coarse food enters the belly, the blood dries up and the flesh withers. Therefore, beings who give coarse food—so that people may know by this reason that they gave coarse food—become with little flesh and little blood, like human ghosts, hard to find food and drink for. But when choice food enters the belly, flesh and blood increase, and their bodies are full, pleasing, and handsome to behold. Therefore, so that the world with its devas may know by this reason that the Tathāgata was a giver of choice food for a long time, the mark of a great man consisting of seven prominences is produced. The mark itself is the mark of seven prominences. The benefit is the receiving of choice things.
30.209
Khajjabhojjamathaleyyasāyitanti khajjakañca bhojanañca lehanīyañca sāyanīyañca. Uttamaggarasadāyakoti uttamo aggarasadāyako, uttamānaṃ vā aggarasānaṃ dāyako.
"Khajjabhojjamathaleyyasāyitaṃ": chewable food, staple food, lickable food, and savory food. "Uttamaggarasadāyako": a supreme giver of foremost flavors, or a giver of supreme, foremost flavors.
30.209_2
Satta cussadeti satta ca ussade. Tadatthajotakanti khajjabhojjādijotakaṃ, tesaṃ lābhasaṃvattanikanti attho. Pabbajampi cāti pabbajamānopi ca. Tadādhigacchatīti taṃ adhigacchati. Lābhiruttamanti lābhi uttamaṃ.
"Satta cussade": and seven prominences. "Tadatthajotakaṃ": illuminating the chewable, staple foods, and so forth; meaning it is conducive to the acquisition of these things. "Pabbajampi cā": even when going forth. "Tadādhigacchati": he attains that. "Lābhiruttamaṃ": he receives the supreme.
30.209_3
Karacaraṇādilakkhaṇavaṇṇanā
Explanation of the Marks of the Hands and Feet, etc.
30.210
Dānenātiādīsu ekacco dāneneva saṅgaṇhitabbo hoti, taṃ dānena saṅgahesi. Pabbajitānaṃ pabbajitaparikkhāraṃ, gihīnaṃ gihiparikkhāraṃ adāsi.
In the passage beginning with "dānena": one person is to be won over by giving alone; he won that person over by giving. He gave the requisites of an ascetic to ascetics, and the requisites of a householder to householders.
30.210_2
Peyyavajjenāti ekacco hi ‘‘ayaṃ dātabbaṃ nāma deti, ekena pana vacanena sabbaṃ makkhetvā nāseti, kiṃ etassa dāna’’nti vattā hoti. Ekacco ‘‘ayaṃ kiñcāpi dānaṃ na deti, kathento pana telena viya makkheti. Eso detu vā mā vā, vacanameva tassa sahassaṃ agghatī’’ti vattā hoti. Evarūpo puggalo dānaṃ na paccāsīsati, piyavacanameva paccāsīsati. Taṃ piyavacanena saṅgahesi.
"Peyyavajjena": for one person says: "This person indeed gives what should be given, but with a single word he smears and ruins it all—what good is his giving?" Another says: "Even though this person gives no gift, when he speaks he soothes as if with oil. Whether he gives or not, his word alone is worth a thousand." Such a person does not expect a gift; he expects only kind speech. He won that person over by kind speech.
30.210_3
Atthacariyāyāti atthasaṃvaḍḍhanakathāya. Ekacco hi neva dānaṃ, na piyavacanaṃ paccāsīsati. Attano hitakathaṃ vaḍḍhitakathameva paccāsīsati. Evarūpaṃ puggalaṃ ‘‘idaṃ te kātabbaṃ, idaṃ te na kātabbaṃ. Evarūpo puggalo sevitabbo, evarūpo puggalo na sevitabbo’’ti evaṃ atthacariyāya saṅgahesi.
"Atthacariyāya": through speech that promotes well-being. For one person expects neither a gift nor kind speech; he expects only talk of his own benefit, talk of his growth. He won such a person over through beneficial conduct thus: "This should be done by you; this should not be done by you. Such a person should be associated with; such a person should not be associated with."
30.210_4
Samānattatāyāti samānasukhadukkhabhāvena. Ekacco hi dānādīsu ekampi na paccāsīsati, ekāsane nisajjaṃ, ekapallaṅke sayanaṃ, ekato bhojananti evaṃ samānasukhadukkhataṃ paccāsīsati. Tattha jātiyā hīno bhogena adhiko dussaṅgaho hoti. Na hi sakkā tena saddhiṃ ekaparibhogo kātuṃ, tathā akariyamāne ca so kujjhati. Bhogena hīno jātiyā adhikopi dussaṅgaho hoti. So hi ‘‘ahaṃ jātimā’’ti bhogasampannena saddhiṃ ekaparibhogaṃ na icchati, tasmiṃ akariyamāne kujjhati. Ubhohipi hīno pana susaṅgaho hoti. Na hi so itarena saddhiṃ ekaparibhogaṃ icchati, na akariyamāne ca kujjhati. Ubhohi sadisopi susaṅgahoyeva. Bhikkhūsu dussīlo dussaṅgaho hoti. Na hi sakkā tena saddhiṃ ekaparibhogo kātuṃ, tathā akariyamāne ca kujjhati. Sīlavā susaṅgaho hoti. Sīlavā hi adīyamānepi akariyamānepi na kujjhati. Aññaṃ attanā saddhiṃ paribhogaṃ akarontampi na pāpakena cittena passati. Paribhogopi tena saddhiṃ sukaro hoti. Tasmā evarūpaṃ puggalaṃ evaṃ samānattatāya saṅgahesi.
"Samānattatāya": by equality in pleasure and pain. For one person expects none of these—gifts and so forth—but expects equality in pleasure and pain, such as sitting on the same seat, lying down on the same couch, and eating together. In that regard, one who is lower in birth but superior in wealth is difficult to win over. For it is not possible to share use with him, and when it is not done, he becomes angry. One who is lower in wealth but superior in birth is also difficult to win over. For thinking "I am of good birth," he does not wish to share use with one endowed with wealth, and when it is not done, he becomes angry. But one who is inferior in both is easy to win over. For he does not wish to share use with the other, nor does he become angry when it is not done. One who is equal in both is also easy to win over. Among monks, one who is immoral is difficult to win over. For it is not possible to share use with him, and when it is not done, he becomes angry. One of good virtue is easy to win over. For a virtuous one does not get angry even when nothing is given or done. Even when another does not share use with him, he does not look upon him with an evil mind. Moreover, sharing use with him is easy to do. Therefore, he won over such a person by such impartiality.
30.210_5
Susaṅgahitāssa hontīti susaṅgahitā assa honti. Detu vā mā vā detu, karotu vā mā vā karotu, susaṅgahitāva honti, na bhijjanti. ‘‘Yadāssa dātabbaṃ hoti, tadā deti. Idāni maññe natthi, tena na deti. Kiṃ mayaṃ dadamānameva upaṭṭhahāma? Adentaṃ akarontaṃ na upaṭṭhahāmā’’ti evaṃ cintenti.
"Susaṅgahitāssa honti": they are well won over by him. Whether he gives or does not give, whether he acts or does not act, they are well won over and do not fall away. They think thus: "When he has something to give, he gives. Now, we think, he has none, and therefore he does not give. Do we attend upon him only while he is giving? Would we not attend upon him when he gives nothing and does nothing?"
30.210_6
Idha kammaṃ nāma dīgharattaṃ kataṃ dānādisaṅgahakammaṃ. Kammasarikkhakaṃ nāma yo evaṃ asaṅgāhako hoti, so iminā kāraṇenassa asaṅgāhakabhāvaṃ jano jānātūti thaddhahatthapādo ceva hoti, visamaṭṭhitāvayavalakkhaṇo ca. Tathāgatassa pana dīgharattaṃ saṅgāhakabhāvaṃ sadevako loko iminā kāraṇena jānātūti imāni dve lakkhaṇāni nibbattanti. Lakkhaṇaṃ nāma idameva lakkhaṇadvayaṃ. Susaṅgahitaparijanatā ānisaṃso.
Here, action means the action of helping others, such as giving, done for a long time. Resemblance to the action means that whoever is not helpful in this way, so that people may know his unhelpful nature through this reason, has stiff hands and feet and unevenly set limbs. But so that the world with its devas may know the Tathāgata's nature of being helpful for a long time through this reason, these two marks arise. The mark itself is this pair of marks. Having a well-gathered retinue is the benefit.
30.211
Kariyāti karitvā. Cariyāti caritvā. Anavamatenāti anavaññātena. ‘‘Anapamodenā’’tipi pāṭho, na appamodena, na dīnena na gabbhitenāti attho.
"Kariyā" means having done. "Cariyā" means having conducted himself. "Anavamatenā" means without contempt. There is also the reading "anapamodena"; the meaning is: not without joy, not despondently, not arrogantly.
30.211_2
Caviyāti cavitvā. Atirucira suvaggu dassaneyyanti atirucirañca supāsādikaṃ suvaggu ca suṭṭhu chekaṃ dassaneyyañca daṭṭhabbayuttaṃ. Susu kumāroti suṭṭhu sukumāro.
"Caviyā" means having fallen [from there]. "Atirucira suvaggu dassaneyyaṃ" means exceedingly pleasing, inspiring great confidence, very melodious, highly skilled, and goodly to behold, worthy of being seen. "Susu kumāro" means a very tender youth.
30.211_3
Parijanassavoti parijano assavo vacanakaro. Vidheyyoti kattabbākattabbesu yathāruci vidhātabbo. Mahimanti mahiṃ imaṃ. Piyavadū hitasukhataṃ jigīsamānoti piyavado hutvā hitañca sukhañca pariyesamāno. Vacanapaṭikarassā bhippasannāti vacanapaṭikarā assa abhippasannā. Dhammānudhammanti dhammañca anudhammañca.
"Parijanassavo" means the retinue is obedient, carrying out his word. "Vidheyyo" means manageable, to be directed as he pleases in what should and should not be done. "Mahimaṃ" means this earth. "Piyavadū hitasukhataṃ jigīsamāno" means speaking kindly, seeking welfare and happiness. "Vacanapaṭikarassā bhippasannā" means carrying out his words, devoted to him. "Dhammānudhammaṃ" means the Dhamma and what conforms to the Dhamma.
30.211_4
Ussaṅkhapādādilakkhaṇavaṇṇanā
Explanation of the Mark of High-Raised Ankles and Others
30.212
Atthūpasaṃhitanti idhalokaparalokatthanissitaṃ. Dhammūpasaṃhitanti dasakusalakammapathanissitaṃ. Bahujanaṃ nidaṃsesīti bahujanassa nidaṃsanakathaṃ kathesi. Pāṇīnanti sattānaṃ. ‘‘Aggo’’tiādīni sabbāni aññamaññavevacanāni. Idha kammaṃ nāma dīgharattaṃ bhāsitā uddhaṅgamanīyā atthūpasaṃhitā vācā. Kammasarikkhakaṃ nāma yo evarūpaṃ uggatavācaṃ na bhāsati, so iminā kāraṇena uggatavācāya abhāsanaṃ jano jānātūti adhosaṅkhapādo ca hoti adhonatalomo ca. Tathāgatassa pana dīgharattaṃ evarūpāya uggatavācāya bhāsitabhāvaṃ sadevako loko iminā kāraṇena jānātūti ussaṅkhapādalakkhaṇañca uddhaggalomalakkhaṇañca nibbattati. Lakkhaṇaṃ nāma idameva lakkhaṇadvayaṃ. Uttamabhāvo ānisaṃso.
"Atthūpasaṃhitaṃ" means connected with benefit in this world and the world beyond. "Dhammūpasaṃhitaṃ" means connected with the ten courses of wholesome action. "Bahujanaṃ nidaṃsesī" means he spoke instructive talk to many people. "Pāṇīnaṃ" means of beings. The words beginning with "agga" are all synonyms of one another. Here, action means speech leading upward, connected with benefit, spoken for a long time. Resemblance to the action means that whoever does not speak such elevated speech, so that people may know his non-speaking of elevated speech through this reason, has low ankles and downward-bent body hairs. But so that the world with its devas may know the Tathāgata's speaking of such elevated speech for a long time through this reason, the mark of high-raised ankles and the mark of hairs standing erect arise. The mark itself is this pair of marks. Being supreme is the benefit.
30.213
Erayanti bhaṇanto. Bahujanaṃ nidaṃsayīti bahujanassa hitaṃ dasseti. Dhammayāganti dhammadānayaññaṃ.
"Erayaṃ" means uttering. "Bahujanaṃ nidaṃsayī" means he shows benefit to many people. "Dhammayāgaṃ" means the sacrifice of giving Dhamma.
30.213_2
Ubbhamuppatitalomavā sasoti so esa uddhaggatalomavā hoti. Pādagaṇṭhirahūti pādagopphakā ahesuṃ. Sādhusaṇṭhitāti suṭṭhu saṇṭhitā. Maṃsalohitācitāti maṃsena ca lohitena ca ācitā. Tacotthatāti tacena pariyonaddhā niguḷhā. Vajatīti gacchati. Anomanikkamoti anomavihārī seṭṭhavihārī.
"Ubbhamuppatitalomavā saso" means he has hairs that stand erect. "Pādagaṇṭhirahū" means his ankle-bones were [high]. "Sādhusaṇṭhitā" means well-placed. "Maṃsalohitācitā" means heaped over with flesh and blood. "Tacotthatā" means covered and concealed by skin. "Vajati" means goes. "Anomanikkamo" means one of elevated conduct, of supreme conduct.
30.213_3
Eṇijaṅghalakkhaṇavaṇṇanā
Explanation of the Mark of Antelope-like Calves
30.214
Sippaṃ vātiādīsu sippaṃ nāma dve sippāni – hīnañca sippaṃ, ukkaṭṭhañca sippaṃ. Hīnaṃ nāma sippaṃ naḷakārasippaṃ, kumbhakārasippaṃ pesakārasippaṃ nahāpitasippaṃ. Ukkaṭṭhaṃ nāma sippaṃ lekhā muddā gaṇanā. Vijjāti ahivijjādianekavidhā. Caraṇanti pañcasīlaṃ dasasīlaṃ pātimokkhasaṃvarasīlaṃ. Kammanti kammassakatājānanapaññā. Kilisseyyunti kilameyyuṃ. Antevāsikavattaṃ nāma dukkhaṃ, taṃ nesaṃ mā ciramahosīti cintesi.
In the passage beginning "sippaṃ vā": craft means two kinds of craft—inferior craft and superior craft. An inferior craft is reed-working, pottery, weaving, or barbering. A superior craft is writing, calculation, or arithmetic. "Vijjā" means the various sciences such as snake-charming. "Caraṇaṃ" means the five precepts, the ten precepts, or the restraint of the Pātimokkha. "Kammaṃ" means wisdom understanding the ownership of kamma. "Kilisseyyuṃ" means they would be weary. He thought: "The duties of a pupil are difficult; let this not last long for them."
First 52 of 111 passages. Read on
Translations (1)
- English (machine translation) — English, machine translation
Commentaries (2)
- Līnatthappakāsinī (Dīghanikāya-ṭīkā) — Dhammapāla, Pāli
- Sādhuvilāsinī — Ñāṇābhivaṃsa, Pāli
Linked texts (2)
- Dīghanikāya — Pāli
- Lakkhaṇasutta — Pāli