Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

The Beads from Taxila (MASI 65) c2.s1: Etched Carnelians and Agates

The Beads from Taxila (MASI 65) c2.s1

Language
English

Etched Carnelians and Agates

c2.s1.1

A curious technique in bead manufacture is shown in the etched carnelians and agates illustrated in Pl. I, Nos. 1 to 7, and Pl. II, Nos. 1 to 31. In these beads the pattern is put on artificially by applying a strong alkali and then heating. This method has been described by Mr. Mackay in the Journal of the Royal Asiatic Society (October, 1925, pp. 697-701), and although some doubt has been thrown on some of the details, beads similar to many of those illustrated can be made in that way.²

c2.s1.2

There are three varieties of technique used. By far the commonest is the method of putting the pattern as white lines on a red or black background. In this case the actual change in the material due to the addition of the alkali is so great that in a few cases, due to the unequal expansion, the white portion has flaked away, leaving grooves. This has led to the erroneous belief that the bead has been cut away and the white portion inlaid. Beads which have been produced by this technique, which I call the first process, have been made in India during many periods³ and may be made there still: certainly, very perfect and elaborate specimens have been made in Persia during the last fifty years. At Kish and Ur in Mesopotamia they are found from before 3000 B.C. At the former place they have only been discovered amongst the remains of the early period, but at Ur a specimen dated between 800 and 600 B.C. has been found. Numerous examples also come from Syria and Russia. Most of these it is difficult to date, but some of the Russian specimens are as early as 300 B.C., whilst others are as recent as 1300 A.D.

c2.s1.3

¹ For further particulars see “Classification and Nomenclature of Beads and Pendants” by Horace C. Beck, Archæologia, Vol. 77, also reprinted separately. Copies of this and other reprints can be obtained from H. C. Beck, Coates Farm, Fittleworth, Sussex.

c2.s1.4

² The process as practised at Sehwān in Sind until a generation ago, is described by the late Mr. N. G. Majumdar as follows: “Put half a chhatak of washing soda in 2 tolas of water, and allow it to dissolve in a cup. Take some soft twigs of kinar (=capparis aphylla, a bush which grows wild in Sind and South-western Punjab), and rub pieces of them in the liquid, bringing the liquid to the required consistency and refining it through a piece of linen. Mix cotton wool with potters’ clay and pound it in an iron or pottery vessel so as to make it soft like wax. Prepare a mould of this clay and put the carnelian to be decorated in it, leaving the face to be decorated exposed. Dry it in the sun. Then draw or write whatever is desired on the carnelian with a reed or steel pen, using the aforesaid liquid. Let it dry in the air. Then fire it between two layers of charcoal. Keep the mould under a lid for cooling. Then take out the carnelian from the mould and clean the soot from its body. The decoration by this time has become milky white, and is permanently etched on the carnelian.”—[J. M.]

c2.s1.5

³ For etched carnelian beads of the Chalcolithic Period at Mohenjo-daro, see Marshall, Mohenjo-daro and the Indus Civilization, pp. 509, 515-16, 583; H. C. Beck, “Etched Carnelian Beads” J. S. A., Vol. xiii, 4 (1933).

c2.s1.6

In the second process the pattern is made in black on a white ground. The method seems to be to whiten the whole surface with alkali, which is done to a great depth, sometimes through the whole thickness of the bead, and then by some process not at present known, to etch or paint a black line which only goes a few thousandths of an inch into the surface. Beads of this second process, although very much less common than those of the first process, have been found in various countries. The earliest comes from Ur, and although not definitely dated, was classed as belonging to the early period. A considerable number come from Syria and are undated, but I do not think they are much more recent than the Christian Era. One of the specimens from Taxila dates from the first century A.D.; the other is undated. I have found no evidence that this process has been carried out recently.

c2.s1.7

The third process, which I have only seen in one specimen, has a black line direct on the red surface of the carnelian. This specimen, which is dated to the first century A.D., comes from Taxila and is figured on Pl. I, No. 1.

c2.s1.8

In addition, a certain number of beads, both carnelian and agate, appear to have been treated with alkali over part or the whole of the surface without any attempt at making a pattern.

c2.s1.9

The beads of the first process found at Taxila bear no resemblance to the tabular beads with dots all round found so frequently in the megalithic tombs and middens in Southern India. This is rather surprising, as some of the glass and quartz beads show great resemblance. The earliest beads of this process from Kish and Ur are of tabular form with a heavy line round the surface near the edge, or in some cases U-shaped markings, also near the edge. There are no beads of that type among the selected specimens from Taxila, but amongst the beads which are said to have come from Taxila, in the Ridgeway collection now in the University Museum of Archæology and Ethnology at Cambridge, there are two beads of this type. The other etched beads in the same collection from Taxila exactly resemble some of those sent to me to report on, and I wonder whether these two beads (Pl. II, Nos. 30, 31) can have come from an early site at or near Taxila. What makes me think this likely is that, as mentioned before, one or two of the other beads from Taxila show great similarity to early Mesopotamian beads.¹

c2.s1.10

With the exception of these two beads of doubtful age, the etched beads from Taxila are spread over a period of some seven centuries, from the fifth century

c2.s1.11

¹ The beads referred to at Cambridge were purchased by me from local dealers some thirty years ago and presented to Sir William Ridgeway. Most of them had no doubt been obtained at Taxila, but the two beads in question may well have come from some older site.—[J.M.]

c2.s1.12

B

c2.s1.13

B.C. to the second century A.D. Of the specimens illustrated, those shown in Pl. I, No. 5, and Pl. II, Nos. 1 to 16, are from the Bhir Mound; those on Pl. I, Nos. 1, 2, 3, 4 and 6, and on Pl. II, Nos. 17 to 27, are from Sirkap; beads from Jaṇḍiāl are on Pl. I, No. 7, and Pl. II, No. 28, and a bead from the Dharmarājikā Stūpa is figured on Pl. II, No. 29.

c2.s1.14

All the beads from the Bhir Mound have been made by the first process. Nos. 1 to 3 and 5 and 6, Pl. II, are agate; Nos. 4 and 7 to 16 are carnelian. The carnelian varies very much in colour, some beads being almost as pale as chalcedony, whilst others are very dark.

c2.s1.15

A not infrequent form is a spherical bead with plain spots upon it. Two are from the Bhir Mound (Pl. II, Nos. 5, 16) and dated in the third century B.C.; a similar one from Sirkap (Pl. II, No. 26) is dated in the first century A.D. : whilst the only etched bead sent from the Dharmarājikā Stūpa is of this pattern and is referable to the second century A.D. or later.

c2.s1.16

Another simple device frequently used is one or more bands or "zones" etched round spherical or barrel beads (Pl. II, Nos. 3, 4, 12); these go back to the third to the fifth century B.C. If three parallel zones are etched round a spherical bead and the perforation is put through the middle zone, the bead becomes an "eye-bead" (Pl. II, Nos. 2, 19); those illustrated date from the third century B.C. and first century A.D., respectively. A more usual way of producing an "eye-bead" is by etching a series of rings, and sometimes adding a dot in the centre (Pl. II, Nos. 8, 24).

c2.s1.17

A design, common at Taxila but which I have not seen elsewhere, is made by etching a series of pentagons round a spherical or barrel bead. In the former case it virtually forms a dodecahedron, whilst in the latter case a zone band is usually etched at each end (Pl. II, Nos. 1, 7, 17, 18). The first two date from the third century B.C., the last two from the first century A.D.

c2.s1.18

A plain wave or chevron pattern is etched on a fifth century B.C. bead from the Bhir Mound (Pl. II, No. 10), and a similar pattern on a bead of the first century A.D. from Sirkap (Pl. II, No. 23); whilst a more elaborate pattern of a chevron combined with zones and spots (Pl. II, No. 9) comes from the Bhir Mound and is referable to the third century B.C.

c2.s1.19

Two beads from the same site, dated in the fourth century B.C., are interesting as they represent double axes (Pl. II, Nos. 14, 15).

c2.s1.20

A broken specimen has triangles etched on it (Pl. II, No. 13), whilst a small tabular bead (Pl. II, No. 11) has a square on each side. The best specimen of a tabular bead, however, is the cross bead (Pl. I, No. 5) which has on each side the device of a cross inside two squares; it dates from the third century B.C.

c2.s1.21

Amongst the beads from Sirkap, in addition to those already mentioned, are several of considerable interest. A striped bead (Pl. II, No. 21) has six short longitudinal lines etched along it, and appears to be a copy of a glass bead like these found in Europe in the third century A.D. A similar glass bead, but with red stripes, is shown on Pl. I, No. 26.

c2.s1.22

Another bead—an agate barrel—(Pl. II, No. 20) has the pattern put on in a very indefinite manner and only slight discolouration has taken place, which suggests some alteration in the technique. The spherical bead (Pl. I, No. 6) has two different shades of etching, the lines going round as zones being much whiter than the small lines crossing the central zoneband at an angle.

c2.s1.23

A large zone bead of peculiar colour (Pl. I, No. 3) is extremely like the etched zone beads now found in Tibet, though some of the latter are three times the size of the Taxila specimen. The date of the Tibetan specimens is not known, but they have considerable value locally. The Taxila specimen dates from the first century A.D.

c2.s1.24

The beads from Sirkap, in addition to the bead made by the third process, also include two, both of the first century A.D., made by the second process. One of these is a spherical bead with whitened surface and a number of black spots (Pl. II, No. 27), the other is a chevron bead in which the black is very intense and almost looks like an enamel (Pl. I, No. 2).

c2.s1.25

The only other etched bead that needs to be mentioned is a fragment from Janḍiāl (Pl. I, No. 7). This appears to be made by a variation of the second process. The material has been whitened right through to the perforation and then, instead of a black, a pale brown colouring matter seems to have been used, and the greater part of the surface has been coloured with it. This specimen is unfortunately not susceptible of being dated.

c2.s1.26

Amongst the carnelian and agate beads are a certain number which, although they have no regular pattern on them, appear to have been treated with an alkali. The button from the Bhir Mound (Pl. II, No. 32) seems to have been treated in this way; other specimens have only a portion of the surface turned white. In some cases, as with the collared barrel bead (Pl. II, No. 33) the whitening of the surface is accompanied by a number of flaws and may be the result of accidental burning.

c2.s1.27

This partial discolouration may possibly be due to the bead having been buried in very alkaline earth for a long period, but this hardly seems probable, since many very early beads show no signs of discolouration. A chemical test of such beads discloses a great deal of soda in the surface of the bead.

Linked texts (24)