Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

The Classical Accounts of India c17.3

The Classical Accounts of India c17.3

Language
English

c17.3

Various opinions have been expressed by modern scholars about the value and authenticity of the memoirs of Damis, which formed the basis of the work of Philostratus.⁴ Professor Bigg, writing in 1910, argued that the so-called memoirs of Damis never really existed and that Damis was really invented by Philostratus. Others have taken a more liberal view. They admit the existence of the memoirs of Davis, but regard him as an "arrant story-teller" who reproduced old popular stories and passed them on as witnessed by him.⁵ In any case there is little doubt that not much reliance can be placed on anything mentioned in the work of Philostratus so long as it is not corroborated by independent sources.