The Classical Accounts of India c22.s2.19
The Classical Accounts of India c22.s2.19
- Language
- English
c22.s2.19
Several other statements of Diodorus are directly contradictory to those of Megasthenes. For example, Diodorus gives the extent of India from East to West as 28,000 stadia,⁸ whereas according to Megasthenes it was 16,000 stadia.⁹ Surely a difference of 75% in measurement between a book and what is supposed to be its epitome needs an explanation. Again, Diodorus says that the Indus is perhaps the largest of all rivers in the world after the Nile,¹⁰ whereas Arrian quotes Megasthenes to the effect that of the two, the Indus and the Ganges, the Ganges is much the larger.¹¹ In Fragment II of McCrindle there is a statement that the Nile and the Danube taken together are not equal even to the Indus, not to speak of the Ganges.¹² Surely, Fragments I and II cannot both be extracts from the *Indika* of Megasthenes, though, curiously enough, they are treated as such by Schwanbeck and McCrindle.
Cites (2)
- Ἰνδική — Λούκιος Φλάουιος Ἀρριανός, Ancient Greek
- Indus Civilisation