Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

The Classical Accounts of India c22.s2.25

The Classical Accounts of India c22.s2.25

Language
English

c22.s2.25

Now para 49 deals with the seventh caste, the members of which held the chief offices of State. As the next three paras, 50-52, describe the officers, it has been presumed—although the name of Megasthenes does not appear, even once, anywhere in these paras,—that they were taken from his *Indika*. But, as stated above, Strabo's description of the third caste, namely, shepherds and hunters, based on Megasthenes, is similarly followed immediately by a long account of elephants and other animals, which, as Strabo himself says (p. 266), was based on “both Megasthenes and others”. It is, therefore, unsafe to take this supplementary note on the seventh caste also as based on the *Indika* of Megasthenes. It is true that Strabo does not make any similar statement that it was derived from others. But there was no occasion for it. In the case of paras 42-45, they were really a digression, coming between two parts of a statement derived from Megasthenes; but para 49 having concluded that statement, the paras that follow, not being a digression in any way, needed no such comment or explanation. Further, Strabo's statement that in his account of the hunters, i.e. the third caste, he mentioned what both Megasthenes and others have said (p. 266), makes it doubtful whether the details of each caste are wholly derived from Megasthenes. Attention may be drawn in this connection to substantial difference in details given by Strabo and Diodorus of the second, fourth, and sixth castes. These differences are of such a nature that it is difficult to hold that both derived their information from Megasthenes alone.

Cites (1)