Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

The Classical Accounts of India c22.s2.31

The Classical Accounts of India c22.s2.31

Language
English

c22.s2.31

Pliny also says, with reference to Megasthenes and Dionysius, that “it is not worth while to study their accounts with care, so conflicting are they and incredible”.¹⁷ Schwanbeck’s comments on these observations are interesting. He says : “The fact is they find fault with only two parts of the narrative of Megasthenes,—the one in which he writes of the fabulous races of India, and the other where he gives an account of Herakles and the Indian Dionysus; although it so happens that on other matters also they regarded the account given by others as true, rather than that of Megasthenes.”¹⁸ The first part of this comment is unwarranted, and is contradicted by the last part.