Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

The Classical Accounts of India c22.s2.33

The Classical Accounts of India c22.s2.33

Language
English

c22.s2.33

“The relative veracity of Megasthenes, then, cannot be questioned, for he related truthfully both what he actually saw, and what was told him by others.”¹⁹ In support of this Schwanbeck has cited the passage in Arrian’s *Indika* (above, p. 231), in which Megasthenes is referred to as a man of approved character. It is, however, curious that Schwanbeck does not refer to the views of Arrian, quoted above,²⁰ in which he clearly says that no true account of India beyond the Hyphasis is known, since the account of Megasthenes is absolutely unreliable; and he supports this by mentioning the latter’s description of the river Silas. Again, referring to the statement of Megasthenes ‘that the Indian tribes number in all 118,’ Arrian makes the very apposite comment : “I am at a loss to conjecture how he arrived at it, for the greater part of India he did not visit, nor is mutual intercourse maintained between all the tribes.”²¹ Again Arrian says : “Megasthenes avers that the tradition about (gold-digging) ants is strictly true,” and very correctly observes: “Megasthenes writes what he had heard from hearsay.”²² Megasthenes may certainly be excused, as Schwanbeck has argued, for recording “truthfully both what he actually saw, and what was told him by others.” But when Megasthenes does not evidently distinguish between the two, and ‘avers as strictly true’ what he merely ‘heard’ from others, we may certainly be sceptical about the real value of his accounts. Besides, it is obvious from the way in which he has recorded the most unnatural phenomena and incredible tales about men and animals, without any comment, that he did not possess a very high degree of critical judgment such as we find, for example, in the writings of Arrian and Strabo. It is to be seriously considered how far we can place absolute reliance on the statements of such an uncritical man, even if they were based on his own observations. This particularly applies to his description of social manners which would be in any case difficult for a foreigner to comprehend rightly even if he had a higher degree of critical ability than Megasthenes possessed. His description of the seven castes, which are unknown to Indian literature or tradition, may be cited as an example, where, on a few basic facts, he has reared up a scheme which is mostly inaccurate and misleading. On the whole, time has surely come when we must make a re-assessment