Pramāṇa · Search · About · API

Early Chauhan Dynasties c13.19

Early Chauhān Dynasties c13.19

Language
English

c13.19

A different view, no doubt, can also be held. According to Dr. R.C. Majumdar, and others who think likewise, it is unsafe to rely on a verse of the *Pṛthvīrājavijaya*, 'composed about four centuries after the events described', and to conclude on its basis that Durlabharāja ever reached Bengal.¹² He discounts also the evidential value of the verse from the Rādhanpur Plates, which recounts Vatsarāja's success in Gauḍa, by interpreting it a bit differently and saying that there being no evidence of any extensive territorial conquests by Vatsarāja, we should place the encounter between Vatsarāja and the Gauḍa in "the Doāb or its neighbourhood in a territory far away from Bengal." We disagree with him, because he has brushed aside evidence that is sound enough. The verse from the Rādhanpur Plates¹³ may not, as contended by Dr. Majumdar, necessarily mean that Vatsarāja advanced as far as Gauḍa. But that it means nothing else has to be conceded by every Sanskritist when he reads it along with the verse from the *Pṛthvīrājavijaya*, a *kāvya*, the comparison of which with old inscriptions proves without much possibility of cavil its immense value as a source of Chauhān history. So though it describes, as in the case of Durlabharāja I, events which happened four hundred years before its composition, it has every right to be believed, unless there is some good evidence to the contrary. And that no such evidence exists, or has at least been discovered so far might be stated without much fear of contradiction. Nor can we think of any special difficulty which could have prevented Vatsarāja and the Chauhāns from reaching Bengal. Vatsarāja's conquests were extensive enough. Dr. Majumdar would like us to believe that they were not so. According to the Gwālior inscription of Bhoja he forcibly carved out an empire (*sāmrājya*) for himself. The verse from the Rādhanpur Plates, the testimony of which Dr. Majumdar reinterprets in his own way, states actually that *he appropriated the fortune, not of the Gauḍa ruler, but the Gauḍa kingdom*; and this, we might remember, was nothing impossible, for once Vatsarāja overran the *Madhyadeśa*, as he actually did, no physical or political barrier barred his progress to Bengal. What Muhammad bin Bakhtyār achieved in 1197 and 1199 A.D., without any special backing and with ludicrous ease, could be achieved also by a ruler like Vatsarāja commanding the vast resources of Mālwā, Rājasthān and perhaps also the Uttar Pradesh.

Cites (1)