History of Sanskrit Poetics c6.120
History of Sanskrit Poetics c6.120
- Language
- English
c6.120
15 Doṣas. This is an important topic in all works on Poetics. भामह (I. 12) states that, not being a poet does not entail adharma or disease or punishment, but to be a bad poet is declared by the wise to be death itself. Similarly, the काव्यादर्श (I. 7) observes that one should not make light of even an insignificant blemish in a poem and that even a handsome body may cause disgust (to the seer) on account of a single leprous spot. भरत speaks of ten doṣas (17. 88, GOS 16. 88, vol. II. p. 331). Vide p. 110 above. दण्डी and भामह speaking of ten and eleven doṣas respectively. But they make no scientific distinction between doṣas of पद, of वाक्य, of पदार्थ and वाक्यार्थ. This is done by वामन. This distinction of the doṣas of पद, वाक्य and अर्थ is accepted by मम्मट and other later writers. The doctrines of the ध्वन्यालोक that, in a composition in which rasa is to be evolved, औचित्य of various kinds has to be looked to (p. 178 ff) and that certain items that conflict (विरोधि) with the main rasa should be avoided (p. 199 ff), as they gave rise to the doṣas of rasa. Vide मम्मट VII for रसदोषs. मम्मट refers (10th उल्लास) to several doṣas of alaṅkāras and shows that they are included in the several doṣas discussed by him in the 7th उल्लास. One cannot avoid doṣas altogether but there are degrees in doṣas, the worst being rasadoṣas. The साहित्यदर्पण says (I. 2) ‘सर्वथा निर्दोषस्यान्तमसम्भवत् ।’. One has to remember the warning of कुमारिल ‘न चाप्यतीव कर्तव्यं दोषदृष्टिपरं मनः। दोषोपविद्यमानोपि तच्चिन्तानां प्रकाशते॥’ q. by अर्जुनवर्मदेव on अमरशतक verse 72 and by the व्यक्तिविवेक. On doṣas, vide Dr. Raghavan on ‘Śṛṅgāraprakāśa’ vol. I. pp. 216-257, Dr. Krishnamoorthy on ‘doctrine of doṣas’ in I. H. Q. vol. 20 pp. 217-232.
Cites (8)
- Sāhityadarpaṇa — Viśvanātha Kavirāja, Sanskrit
- Kāvyādarśa — Daṇḍin, Sanskrit
- Kāvyālaṅkāra — Bhāmaha, Sanskrit
- Amaruśataka — Amaru, Sanskrit
- Nāṭyaśāstra — Bharata, Sanskrit
- Kāvyaprakāśa — Mammaṭa & Alaṭa, Sanskrit
- Dhvanyāloka — Ānandavardhana, Sanskrit
- Vyaktiviveka — Mahimabhaṭṭa, Sanskrit